Sherlock: 10 Crazy Twists That Would Turn The Show Upside Down
Fandoms are like the oceans - the deeper you go, the darker they get - and in the case of the Sherlock fandom, the more we wait, the weirder our theories become.
If there's one thing that the Sherlock writers enjoy more than anything else, it's a mind-blowing plot twist to make their audience shout at the television, very loudly. Series 3 was no different, with Moffat and Gatiss revealing in the dying seconds of 'His Last Vow' that actually, Jim Moriarty, the lunatic himself, is alive and well. It's a cliffhanger that's left so many questions about the future of the show and generated a heap more hype to keep the fans talking about Sherlock, and the genius is that it's such a simple twist; it's literally the same one they pulled just a series prior, too. It certainly leaves the Sherlockians thinking. Fandoms are like the oceans - the deeper you go, the darker they get - and in the case of the Sherlock fandom, the more we wait, the weirder our theories become. Here are ten of the bizarrest, but actually vaguely plausible ideas that the fans have had since the end of Series 3, that would utterly revolutionise the show again.
10. Janine Is Moriarty's Sister
In the last couple of episodes, it seemed like we were seeing a more human side to the sociopathic Sherlock; he got himself a girlfriend, was going to propose to her and then, no, wait, it was all a plan to get into a criminal mastermind's office. But why would someone of Magnussen's magnitude hire Janine? She's just his PA, you might say. Well then why did he hint to John that he'd blackmailed her as well? Perhaps she has secrets, maybe of Sherlock, but perhaps of somebody else that we already know? Well, Jim Moriarty is another character who's Irish, dark-haired, dark-eyed and charismatic; he's also obsessed with Sherlock, and also utterly unsurprised and unemotional over his deceiving. If Janine was to be Moriarty's sister, it would mean that he had much more of a presence in Series 3 than we thought, not to mention the jibes that Sherlock could make to him about his relationship with her. It's a far-fetched idea, admittedly based on the fact that these are the only two Irish characters in the entire show, but it would certainly add fuel to the already-fiery relationship between Sherlock and his arch-nemesis.
9. Sherlock Poisoned Moriarty
Let's just assume for a second that Jim Moriarty really is dead, and that the end of Series 3 was just another villain using his image. Let's also assume that Sherlock didn't tell us the whole truth over how he faked his death... John asked Sherlock if Moriarty had touched anything when he visited Baker Street; Sherlock replied no. Just an apple. But that's not true, as he also offered him a cup of tea. If he'd have poisoned the tea, the line, "I am you," has more prominence; he asked Moriarty to look into his eyes, see his overly-dilated pupils, and realise that he's terminally ill. Moriarty then realised, knowing it was the tea - they're geniuses after all - and killed himself. But how did Sherlock fake the faking? He asked for Molly's help, didn't he? It's a wonderful theory, spiked only by its outlandishness. It's something that no one's really considered, and should it be true, we'd see Sherlock as a murderer long before 'His Last Vow'. It's a hell of a twist, but it's really too elaborate, surely?
8. Mycroft And Sherlock Aren't Really Related
It's a strange relationship for a pair of siblings to have; you can't tell if they despise each other, or actually admire one another. But what if the Holmes brothers aren't actually brothers at all? The evidence is staring us right in the face: Mark Gatiss looks absolutely nothing like Benedict Cumberbatch. On top of that, it's been established that Mrs Holmes is the cleverer one in their parents' relationship, and it would explain why they harbour such disdain for one another; if they remembered their mother's betrayal every time they looked the other one in the eyes, it would definitely answer a few questions. It's obviously not true though, and even if it was, it would never be addressed in the show. Part of the beauty of this relationship is that they're so different, yet two sides of the same coin: it might be hinted at that they're not actually related, but it would take the fun out to explicitly declare it.
7. Moriarty Knew Magnussen
Janine might well be related to Jim Moriarty (though she's probably not). But there are still some arrows that can be connected between the consultant criminal and the newspaper nutter. Magnussen knew about Redbeard. The only other people to know about Sherlock's childhood dog would be Sherlock himself, Mycroft and their parents. Oh, and Jim, who Mycroft told everything to when he was locked up. Moriarty went straight to a newspaper journalist when he wanted to bring Sherlock down; and whose newspaper would he most likely have used? It's wholly possible that even if they weren't strictly associates, Charles Augustus Magnussen was a member of Moriarty's network, feeding him information about Holmes. Whilst these links might never actually be addressed, it's certainly plausible. It would again, suggest much more that Moriarty was never actually gone if the new baddie was always actually the old baddie, but it's unlikely Moffat and co will mention the tabloid tycoon again, other than reference his death.
6. Tom Was A Sniper
Molly's bad history of boyfriends was mentioned by Sherlock; okay, she only actually had the one boyfriend, but he did turn out to be the most dangerous criminal mastermind that the planet had ever seen. Latest love Tom however certainly resembles the sniper that was waiting in the window for Sherlock to jump. It would be an ingenious plan, to dress up as Sherlock as to put him off figuring out who you are, and if you want to get closer to the man himself, do what the professionals do: it was a plan that worked wonders for Jim. Unfortunately, as neat as this theory is, there are as many reasons why it's not true as why it is. Tom comes across as a bit of an idiot; to paraquote Sherlock himself, are those really the actions of a criminal mastermind? Mycroft himself was standing right behind that particular sniper, ready to tell him to step down from his position, so he'd recognise him at least. Oh, and then there's the tiny detail that Tom and Molly actually split up. It may not have lasted, but it was, apparently, a normal relationship for poor Miss Hooper.
5. John Has Dreamt Up Everything As Escapism
John Watson is a man attracted to danger. His psychotherapist tells him to keep a blog. What if his blog is actually... all of this? It would explain how Sherlock is often, completely unbelievably bonkers, and high-octane. John could be dreaming of a best friend for himself, because he's so alone; the story picks up two years later with a new love interest - someone that he'd love to actually meet - and nothing's happened in between, and the story could just be a fabrication to please his shrink. Or, that's complete nonsense and an insult to the character. It would be an elaborate way to end the series, but it doesn't explain why he's usually the butt of jokes, why he's not actually the hero, and why he's writing a blog if the whole story is a blog: is this blogception or something? This may be the kind of story that John likes, but the truth is, he's living in it. It's a cop-out to think otherwise.
4. Sherlock Spent His Two Years Away High
Just as Steve Thompson had convinced us Sherlock Holmes was a loveable, childlike, vulnerable and hilarious man who just wants to be a hero, Steven Moffat smashed the illusion by turning him into a conniving murderer. Oh, and he's a heroin addict now: heroin addicts are cool. The clues to his drug-riddled past have always been there, but what if Sherlock was away for so long because he'd relapsed into his former lifestyle? Maybe Mycroft brought him home because he realised what was going on; we never actually saw him fight bad guys abroad either. It would not only explain why Moriarty's back - he wasn't dismantling his network at all - but it would allude to something Holmes himself mentioned: he solves cases as a substitute for drugs. He wasn't solving cases when he was away: he was tracking down terrorists. That's a bit of a nitpick, and though it's intriguing to wonder how often Sherlock turns to the drugs, and whether he'd do so when living on his own, heroin probably isn't the sole reason that he spent two years away. We heard some of the tales of him solving cases anyway, as Anderson was convinced that this he was still alive; it seems Sherlock chose life after all.
3. Moriarty Is The Third Holmes Brother
It was a throwaway line to many, but one that many Sherlock fans picked up on, in 'His Last Vow'. A member of the government asked Mycroft if he was sparing his brother's life for sentiment, only for Mycroft to reference the "other" one. Other brother? We know that the Holmes boys weren't too kind to Moriarty. And we know that he's the only other person in this whole universe that could be as clever as those two. Remember when Jim was taunting Sherlock about all the people that would miss him if he died? He said "Mummy and Daddy": not "Your mummy and daddy", but as if they were his parents too. Could you really blame them for putting that psychopath up for adoption? It's too obvious a route to go down, surely; it's the same conundrum that Doctor Who writers found themselves in over the Master, and that ended when the Doctor claimed, "You've been watching too many films." Rather like Mycroft and Sherlock not being related, or Janine being related to Jim, it's far too convenient a link to draw, simply to snatch some kind of affection from the audience that these characters have some kind of bond. Or as it's also known, Princess Leia Syndrome.
2. Kitty Riley Is Moriarty
What if Rich Brook was real? What if he really did die, and that the Moriarty who's coming back is actually the real Moriarty? What if that person, is Kitty Riley, the journalist who concocted the Rich Brook story? It would certainly please those who disliked Andrew Scott's mad portrayal. Firstly, Riley's flat is full of paintings, which is puts her in a better position to know about the Van Buurin Supernova; she also had the words "Make Believe" on her wall. Rich Brook (as we'll call him for distinction) wore a fox pin during the Crown Jewels trial; there's a fairytale called The Wolf and The Fox, which states, "The wolf had the fox with him, and whatsoever the wolf wished, that the fox was compelled to do, for he was the weaker." Is Kitty the wolf? And didn't the Moriarty in 'The Great Game' have a woman's handwriting? It's a brilliantly thought-out idea, but it's utterly bonkers; it would be the most outlandish, incredible plot-twist to pull off, and it would confuse just about anyone who didn't really pay that much attention to Riley. It would the boldest television move ever if they went with it, but they just... won't. Sorry.
1. John And Sherlock Really Are In Love
There is a large section of the fandom that "ship" "JohnLock". For any of you that haven't got a clue what that means, they believe that John and Sherlock should be a couple. They have a great chemistry: they get on particularly well, and they both seem slightly jealous of each other's partners to start with. John asks Sherlock if he has a partner very early on in their friendship, and everyone assumes they're an item. Why is John Watson so keen to shout down anyone who calls him gay? Maybe because he really does love Sherlock, and he's tired of being reminded of the everyday pain that they can never be together. Maybe he's living a lie, dreaming of a blissful life with just him and Holmes. Maybe you're sick of the constant jokes about it, and you wish that once and for all, someone would put an end to the suggestion that Sherlock and John are secretly in love. But it would be one hell of a final twist if they were, wouldn't it?