Sherlock: 10 Worst Things Sherlock Holmes Ever Did
The times Sherlock was a total villain in his own show.
When you live life as a high-functioning sociopath, you're inevitably going to make some poor judgement calls when it comes to morality.
This doesn't inherently mean that those who lack a sense of empathy are bad people, just that they may struggle to comprehend how their actions affect others. If you insert some crime into the mix, then it generates a deadly cocktail of bad behaviour.
Sherlock was a great chance to re-insert the classic Arthur Conan Doyle under the microscope and analyse how his behaviour would work in a modern setting. It's safe to say that his volatile and borderline unsociable personality gave the series plenty of exciting yet dark moments.
Across the show's four seasons, viewers got the chance to see their favourite detective in action, solving crimes and mysteries alongside his ever-faithful number 2, John Watson. But, it wasn't all fun and games, as the titular character did some rather deplorable things that made him a little tough to love at times.
The following ten entries are the worst of the worst, as his deductive reasoning often forgot his humanity.
--
This list will contain spoilers.
10. Constantly Destroying 221B Baker Street
Being a landlady must be tough, but it's exponentially tougher when your resident is a wild, uncaring and dangerous detective prone to fits of boredom.
This is one aspect of Sherlock's life that can be increasingly tough to sit through, as his blatant disregard for Mrs Hudson's property is awkward at best and horrible at worst.
Sherlock did a great many things throughout the show's run to his iconic home of 221B Baker Street. For one, he was always inviting criminal activity thanks to his profession, allowing dangerous individuals to make their way there. This even led to the homestead being blown to smithereens in the show's final episode.
However, further from just the activity he brings into it, he's also partial to destroying it himself. The most egregious example of this came when he shot up the wall with a handgun, firing into a spray-painted smiley face on the wall. His excuse for this, well, he was "bored".
This must have been a justifiable reason to kick someone out, so it's a wonder that Mrs Hudson never did so.
9. Refusing To Wear Clothes To Buckingham Palace
The monarchy to many people is everything, but to others, it's hardly the be-all and end-all. Still, even those who couldn't care less about the royal family would have the common decency to put something on if taken to their home. In fact, walking into anyone's house sporting nothing but a bedsheet is rather atrocious behaviour.
During the episode "A Scandal In Belgravia", Sherlock and Watson are taken to the mighty British building to meet Mycroft and discuss a scandal involving a royal family member. Sherlock is tasked with uncovering this issue and retaining some highly sensitive information from the infamous Irene Adler.
Of course, he receives all of these instructions whilst sat in the palace essentially naked. While it did make for a highly amusing moment that may have paid some fan service to certain sides of the viewer base, it ultimately made Sherlock look like an incessant little brat.
To be fair, a lot of his charm comes from how childish and stubborn he is, so although his behaviour here was terrible, it wasn't off-brand for him.
8. Hurting Molly Time And Time Again
Molly Hooper was easily the unsung hero of the series. Her assistance at St Bart's Hospital was an essential piece of the show's puzzle, as, without her, many of the mysteries would not have been solved. But, she also played a unique role as the show's down-on-her-luck, awkward, relatable figure, who loved Sherlock. Sadly for her, this was unrequited.
Ever since she started on the show, it was clear that Molly had feelings for Sherlock, and he responded as anyone with a lack of emotional depth would by ignoring them. This did change a little after season two when he seemingly became aware of her feelings towards him, but it didn't stop him from continuing to hurt her. Still, she was able to bring a level of shame and confidence towards him as the series progressed.
Aside from his constant jabs, mocking her and generally treating her as beneath him, it got taken a step further in the final episode. Here, he called Molly and told her that he loved her, which the viewers knew wasn't true. In his defence, he was forced to do this, and he seemed pretty torn up about it, but after everything between them, seeing him lie to her was painful.
7. Ruining John's Proposal
It was clear that Sherlock was going to need to return to the world of the living at some point, and letting his dear friend John Watson know that he hadn't died after the incident with Moriarty was an important first step. Sadly, he rather butchered the timing, as by returning to life when he did, he inadvertently ruined Watson's proposal of marriage to Mary.
Imagine this, you lose your closest friend/ally and find yourself struggling to come to terms with it. Soon, you begin to accept that he's gone, and you try your hardest to move on with your life. Then you get thrown a lifeline as you fall in love and begin to work through your past. Eventually, you decide to propose, and just as you do, your "dead" friend reveals himself as alive and ruins it.
Sadly, this is what happened to John Watson, as during the third season's opening episode, Sherlock turned up to the restaurant where Watson was preparing to propose, dressed as a waiter and revealed himself to be alive after being gone for two whole years.
This one wasn't entirely his fault, as he wasn't to know John's plans for the evening. Still, he indirectly ruined what should have been a beautiful moment.
6. Indirectly Leading To Mary's Death
Sherlock's destruction of John's proposal to Mary was undoubtedly a roadblock, but eventually, the pair ended up getting hitched. Unfortunately, there was another twist in the pipelines, as it turns out Mary was not who she claimed to be, as she harboured a dark and dangerous life as a former assassin. That wasn't even the end of Watson's shocking heartbreak.
The episode "The Six Thatchers" ended with a showdown in an aquarium, as Vivian Norbury - a disgruntled secretary responsible for the episode's shenanigans - pulled a gun on Sherlock and Mary. In response to this, Sherlock did what he does best and deciphered information from her, mocking her and attempting to destroy her confidence.
After this - as you might expect from someone wielding a gun - she took action and shot a round at him, which Mary jumped in front of. It was a shocking moment and made all the worse as Watson arrived on the scene to say goodbye to his loving wife.
Sherlock didn't fire the gun or intend for this to happen, but he caused it through his ego and over-confidence.
5. Acting Distant Towards His Sister
Now, it's important to state that Eurus Holmes had absolutely no right to do any of the things she did. In fact, killing your childhood best friend, trying to destroy your life and putting you in a Saw like puzzle is the furthest thing possible from a justifiable response to a brother's lack of attention. But that doesn't mean Sherlock was entirely in the right either.
It's made clear from the beginning of the show that Sherlock has no sentimental attachments to his family. His rivalry with Mycroft solidified that, and the way he seems ashamed of his parents added the extra icing to the cake. While it's understandable to have some residual irritancy with family, it appears that he genuinely pushed them away, and that's made most evident from his dynamic with Eurus, his sister.
The end of the final episode reveals that Eurus' had been letting out a cry for help the whole time and that all the awful things she had done were a ploy to get her brother to pay attention to her. While that doesn't excuse anything, it does act as a metaphor for how Sherlock's lack of care for those who raised and lived with him caused significant problems.
4. Using John As An Experiment
The relationship between Sherlock and Watson was the emotional core of the show. Seeing John become a part of Sherlock's world and changing him for the better was beautiful to see and took both characters in a fascinating direction. But, it wasn't all sunshine and rainbows for this pairing.
Aside from the constant tension and bickering between them, Sherlock often put Watson at extreme risk for "the greater good". The worst instance of this had to be what he did during the episode "The Hounds of Baskerville".
This episode was essentially Sherlock's soiree into horror, as it was full of tense, scary scenes. One of the most frightening had to be when John was locked in the laboratory with the titular hound. However, the reveal of what actually happened here was scary in a different way.
It turns out that the hound was a mere hallucination brought about by a drug. Sherlock revealed to John at the end of the episode that he had drugged him, caused him to hallucinate the beast and set up the entire encounter himself as an experiment.
Getting information is always important, but to drug and torture your supposed friend, that's just abhorrent.
3. Killing Charles Magnussen
This one is pretty self-explanatory, as while he certainly deserved to be taken down, killing this man in cold blood was a sudden and shocking act that proved the statement "I'm not a hero".
While it made perfect sense for Sherlock to use extreme force to end Magnussen's reign of terror, the lack of concern or remorse after killing him was terrifying.
The third season of Sherlock was a tough sell, as the show had lost its primary antagonist in Jim Moriarty and needed to bring in a whole new threat. Sherlock's writers did a decent job in this by generating the season's new overarching villain in the form of master blackmailer Charles Magnussen. But no one could have predicted how he'd be taken down.
After Sherlock and Watson came face to face with the villain and attempted to retrieve vital documents - some of which involved John and Mary - they found themselves backed into a corner. To get out of this, Sherlock took up a gun and shot Magnussen in the head at point-blank range.
It's true that, as the villain, he needed to be stopped. Still, seeing the protagonist commit murder was a particularly dark moment in Sherlock's life, especially as it didn't seem to affect him much afterwards.
2. Faking His Death
Talk about a compelling season cliff-hanger. The second season of Sherlock ended spectacularly, with the iconic scene that saw the titular character leap from a rooftop to ensure the lives of his friends and colleagues would continue. It only became better when you found out that he'd faked the whole thing and was still breathing. It was an extraordinary moment, but when you step back and examine it, it's more than a little dubious.
At the culmination of "The Reichenbach Fall", Sherlock and his arch-nemesis Moriarty found themselves at an impasse. Sherlock had the upper hand at first, only for the villain to shoot himself and tie Sherlock in a tough situation where he could either jump off the roof or allow his friends to be killed by assassins. But, as the brilliant detective often does, he found a way around it, as he'd predicted such a scenario and pre-orchestrated a clever fake death plan.
While faking suicide is terrible enough and illegal to an extreme point, the most egregious thing he did here was not clueing John in. Surely he could have trusted him enough to let him know the truth, especially as it took another two years before he finally revealed that he'd faked the whole thing.
1. Using Janine As A Means To An End
So, it turns out Molly wasn't the only one he lied to about loving, but this time it was his choice.
It's safe to say that Sherlock Holmes had some issues with people. Watching him navigate a social situation was often far more uncomfortable than the hideous crimes he was solving. Therefore it came as a massive shock to many when he began dating Janine, a woman he'd met at John and Mary's wedding.
At first, although it felt alien, the relationship seemed healthy. Janine brought out a side to Sherlock that viewers hadn't seen before, and it seemed to be changing him. But then, it was revealed that the entire relationship was a ploy from Sherlock to use Janine's position as Charles Magnussen's personal assistant to gain access to his office.
Viewers had seen Sherlock use people before, but to trick someone into believing you love them, gaslighting them and even going so far as to fake a proposal to them was next level sociopathy.
It's a wonder that he still made it out of this without enduring more immense consequences, as Janine's revenge - selling their story to newspapers - was sweet, but nothing too damning.