Sherlock: 13 WTF Moments From The Abominable Bride

"I am glad you liked my potato."

By Christian Bone /

After the now regular two-year wait between series, Sherlock returned on New Year's Day - but this time with a difference. For this instalment, Sherlock and co returned to their roots and were back in Victorian London, a move which caused many a viewer to exclaim 'WTF' in itself. Fans were surely preparing themselves for an episode that stripped away the usual Sherlock thrills and trickery and took the Great Detective back to basics. Well, if they did, they made a very bad deduction. In fact, the special - with the wonderfully lurid title of The Abominable Bride - was probably the most mind-bending, twisty-turny episode of the series to-date, with time travel, dreamscapes and drug trips abound. Far from being faithful, you can imagine Arthur Conan Doyle's moustache would spin round and round if he ever saw this wacky adaptation of his work. Needless to say, SPOILERS are meat and drink to this article from this point on.

13. Dr Hooper

The first twenty-odd minutes of the special do actually play out much as you would expect, with the usual Sherlock suspects being reintroduced in Victorian times. Lestrade is a muttonchopped bobbie, Mary is a frustrated housewife with an itch for more, Mrs Hudson is still complaining that she's not their housekeeper. And then we're introduced to a Victorian-ised Molly Hooper - an original character to the show - who is entirely different from the regular version. Rather than a timid mortuary attendant who is infatuated with the detective, she is now a doctor, has an argumentative relationship with Sherlock and, oh yes, pretends to be a man. It's a tough call but she might also sport a better moustache than Watson. But then this wasn't the only eyebrow-raising reinvention of a Sherlock favourite...

12. A Bigger Role For Mycroft

When Sherlock began, the showmakers took liberties with the character of Sherlock's brother Mycroft by making him of slim build rather than the decidedly plumper version from the original stories. That said, there were heavy hints that Mycroft had suffered from weight problems in the past. Well, now we're back in the past and indeed Mycroft is, as he puts it, "increased." He still possesses his smarts, however, and even has a bet with Sherlock over how long he has left to live. Sherlockians might have anticipated that Moffat and Gatiss would portray a more traditional Mycroft this time around, but the sight of Mark Gatiss in a fat suit guzzling down plum puddings is not something you can prepare yourself for or forget in a hurry.

11. "I Am Glad You Liked My Potato."

Before watching the episode, another thing fans might have assumed that the Victorian setting would tone down would be the comic element of the series. Surely, moving the action to that notoriously stiff upper-lipped era would mean there wouldn't be any out-and-out comedy moments like the 'John's Stag' scene from The Sign of Three. Actually, a visit to Mycroft's club - which requires absolute silence - surprisingly results in another classic as John shows off his terrible sign language skills, calling the doorman ugly and miming the immortal line: "I am glad you liked my potato." While it is very funny, it's the sort of comedy that you would expect from Mr Bean or Leslie Nielsen in The Naked Gun rather than Sherlock, which earns it a place on this list.

10. "What Made You Like This?"

When staking out to catch the Abominable Bride at work, Holmes and Watson get a rare bit of quiet time where John finally asks his friend something that he has peculiarly never thought to ask before: what made Sherlock the way he is? While he probes Sherlock (oh, come on, we're grown-ups here) about it, he doesn't get any more of an answer than "I made me." This is something of a WTF moment because this question has been built up to in the preceding three quarters of an hour - in Sherlock's repeated talks of one's past haunting the present - but then is never referenced again after this scene. It is completely fair enough that Moffat and Gatiss would not want to properly explain Sherlock's origins but, having teased the answer throughout the episode, it ends up with it feeling like an abandoned plot thread.

9. Sir Digby Chicken Sherlock

If you've ever seen That Mitchell and Webb Look, the sketch show starring David Mitchell and Robert Webb, the shot when Sherlock is disorientated and storms out of the Carmichaels' house will have made you think of only one thing: Sir Digby Chicken Caesar. As played by Webb, Sir Digby Chicken Caesar is a drunken fantasist who also wears a deerstalker. This filming technique - an extreme close up on the face while the background is out of focus - is always used when Digby is on the run. This is a moment that will pass a lot of people by but any fan of Mitchell and Webb who is watching will be pulled out of the drama and instantly have the Sir Digby theme tune stuck in their heads. Come on everyone, "Duh-lun, duh-lun, duh-lun, dun, dun, dun..."

8. It Was All A Dream

When it was announced that the special would take place in Victorian times, fans devised theories about how it could fit into the series despite Moffat and Gatiss going on record saying that it would be a standalone episode, separate from the rest of the show. Naturally, this was a complete lie and around about the hour mark of the special it was revealed that the Victorian mystery had all taken place inside Sherlock's Mind Palace. Yep, it wasn't a standalone at all but rather an elaborate experiment of Sherlock's to deduce how Moriarty had come back from the dead. This was a twofold WTF moment as it was a jaw-dropping revelation that it was all an illusion, as well as the fact that such a reveal was made only two-thirds into the episode rather than at the climax. You really can't second-guess this show.

7. The Villains Are... Feminists

Despite that hugely shocking moment, The Abominable Bride didn't rest on its laurels for the next half hour and instead laid on another ridiculous moment - that the episode's real villains are in fact a group of militant suffragettes who are getting their revenge on the men who wronged them. While it might still be a contentious point to make the nowadays exonerated suffragettes the bad guys, what really makes this a ballsy move by Moffat and Gatiss is dressing them up in the infamous pointed hoods used by the Ku Klux Klan, visually suggesting they are on a par with that organisation. Of course, the episode is firmly on the side of the suffragettes as shown through its satirical look at Victorian sexism and Mycroft even saying "this is a war we must lose" but still, the image of feminists in the costume of the KKK is one that is always going to ruffle some feathers.

6. Moriarty Is The Bride

From the controversial to the downright bizarre. As it raced to its climax, The Abominable Bride got weirder and weirder. You had drug-induced dream states. Villainous feminists. All topped off with Moriarty in a wedding dress. Wait, what? No, this wasn't some steamy fan fiction where Sherlock and Moriarty get married but another hallucination of the detective's. As he is about to pull back the Bride's veil to reveal who he believes is the killer, unveiled instead is Moriarty who has been haunting his dreams. Apparently, he's the virus in his hardrive. Or something. Much like Molly with a moustache or an increased Mycroft, Moriarty in a bridal gown is something that will no doubt be imprinted on the minds of Sherlock fans for a long time to come.

5. Sherlock Vs The Undead

Having established that a lot of the episode was set in Sherlock's Mind Palace, all sense of reality was thrown out of the window for the show's final reel - resulting in this full-on horror moment that the show could never normally get away with. Yes, it's Sherlock meets The Walking Dead. Even in Series Two's horror-flavoured The Hounds of Baskerville we didn't see anything too traumatizing, just a big dog, but here a hundred-year old rotting corpse comes back to life and lunges at Sherlock. Depending on your point of view, this is either the show completely going off the rails and losing all sense of plot or the writers having a blast pulling the rug from under our feet.

4. The Falls

Teased throughout the episode, the climax of the Victorian element of the story took place at the fabled Reichenbach Falls, where Holmes and Moriarty had their final tangle before plummeting into the depths. Here, however, mega fanboys Moffat and Gatiss couldn't resist rewriting the tale and giving it a happy ending. Whereas Doyle had Watson sent away from the action, just as Holmes and Moriarty are fighting to the death the good doctor returns to protect his friend and send the evil professor comically tumbling into the water. It's hard to argue that this scene had any proper bearing on the plot, so watching it will either put a big beam on the face of hardcore fans or leave others scratching their heads.

3. Mycroft's Book

Throughout the scenes on the plane, Mycroft is acting peculiarly kind to Sherlock. Sure, his brother has just been exiled for killing a man, has taken an overdose and his nemesis has just returned from the grave, so you might expect him to show a modicum of empathy but this is Mycroft we're talking about, who is usually even less emotional than Sherlock. The most surprising moment happens after Sherlock tears up his list of what drugs he has taken - something which apparently harks back to a day in Sherlock's past. Once Sherlock and the others have left, Mycroft collects the pieces and files them away in a notebook which seems to be all about Sherlock. It even mentions his childhood dog Redbeard that Mycroft has chided Sherlock about before. It's a curious little scene that will surely be of importance once the show returns for Series Four. For now, though, we're lacking answers. Let the fan theories begin.

2. Moriarty IS Dead

Ever since Moriarty appeared on every TV screen in the country (in both the show and the real world) in Series Three finale His Last Vow, fans have been theorising left, right and centre over how he could have faked his death of shooting himself in the head. With Sherlock we didn't see him hit the ground but we positively saw blood pouring out the back of Moriarty's noggin. In The Abominable Bride, Sherlock dived into his Mind Palace to imagine himself solving a similar case from a hundred years ago and in doing so determines the truth about Moriarty - that he really is dead. There's no way you can come back from a bullet in the brain. However, he says he also knows what he's going to do next. Firstly, this is a WTF moment as it seems the series is going back on the promise of the last series that Moriarty is alive and, secondly, though Moriarty is dead it seems he is somehow still out to get Sherlock. Answers on a post card please.

1. The Whole Show Is The Dream?

After all these twists and shocks, the screen goes black, the music starts to play and then... they've got one more WTF moment up their sleeve. And it's a doozy. After revealing that the Victorian era was in modern Sherlock's imagination, the final scene presents it the other way around - the modern setting is the imaginings of Victorian Sherlock. This episode has been the only one set in the 'real world' and the rest of the show has been the dream. Most people will take this scene as a last little joke after all the times the rug has been pulled from beneath us in the past 90 minutes, but it is the final scene of the episode which suggests that it is the one that tells the truth. After all, it can't be explained away - why would modern Sherlock imagine this scene, it doesn't impact on solving the mystery? So it seems that the show we have loved for the past five years really is just a story made up by the original Sherlock. Mind (Palace) Blown. What did you think of The Abominable Bride? Leave your thoughts below!