South Park: 5 Most Controversial Episodes Ever

By Deleted User 20210604 /

If you are a South Park fan then it is likely that you will be familiar with phrases such as €œWait, they did what this week?€ or €œThey are never going to get away with this one€. The cries of fans everywhere are echoed by the creators themselves, who have admitted €˜there are some South Park episodes where we€™re like €œOh man, how did we not get in trouble for that?€ South Park is known for its shocking plotlines and critical outlook on celebrities, religion, and politics. Although it seems no subject matter is out of bounds for Matt and Trey, there have certainly been a few episodes that have taken it to the very edge. And unsurprisingly complaints were made, celebrities moaned, and controversy ensued! But which episodes caused the most controversy? Well, let us delve into the jaw-dropping, eye-widening, close to the knuckle world of South Park controversy....

5. Proper Condom Use

Stan€™s parents catch him €˜milking€™ or masturbating Sparky the dog, and accuse the teachers at South Park Elementary of not teaching the children proper sex education. This leads to a bunch of sexually in-experienced teachers giving the children wrong information, resulting in the girls making the boys wear condoms at all times so that they don€™t catch any STDs, and also in Mr. Garrison placing a condom on a fake penis with his mouth. So to sum up: A group of fourth grade children purchasing condoms and masturbating their pet dogs, and a teacher demonstrating how to put a condom on to a kindergarten class using only his mouth. How could that possibly be considered controversial? This episode was one of the first South Park episodes to face issues in being aired. Its rating was increased and time-slot changed in Australia, and here in the UK Sky One actually refused to air the episode. Not to worry though, as Channel 4, MTV and Comedy Central have had no problems with airing the full uncensored episode. Few.

4. Super Best Friends

When David Blaine comes to South Park and starts a cult called €˜Blaintology€™ that takes the town by storm and sees its members drowning themselves in a mass suicide, a special group of super-heroes is required to stop Blaintology in its tracks. And who is this group? Why, it€™s a group of religious leaders known as Super Best Friends, consisting of Jesus, Buddha, Moses, Joseph Smith, Krishna, Laozi, Sea Man, and, a somewhat bolder choice by Matt and Trey, Muhammad. An episode that shows the dangers of both cults and religions (and not to mention an episode that includes an overtly fictional Sea Man in its list of religious figures) it would seem obvious that this episode was going to raise a few eyebrows. Surprisingly however this episode caused little uproar at the time of airing, perhaps because of lower viewing figures at the time which meant the episode went unnoticed. That isn€™t to say that there weren€™t complaints, just not enough to cause any real problems for the creators. So not only did they get away fairly scrape-free with mocking scientology, but more importantly they also got away with depicting Muhammad in this episode. But that didn€™t stop them from doing it again a few years later...

3. Cartoon Wars

It€™s a Muhammad controversy again, and this time they also sparked a feud in the world of animated comedy in the process. Cartoon Wars sees Cartman attempt to stop a Family Guy episode from airing because it just isn€™t funny! Oh, and because Family Guy are going to show an image of Muhammad and terrorist groups are threatening to attack America if it airs. But mainly just because it isn€™t funny. Unlike Super Best Friends, this episode was released following the Jyllands-Posten controversy of September 2005 which saw the Danish newspaper receive terrorist threats for including a cartoon of Muhammad, and as a result Comedy Central decided to censor the image of Muhammad in the episode proving just how much times had changed. The episode itself is being critical of the whole thing; as Meta-episodes go this really does top it! Released at a time when Family Guy was at its peak, gaining an average viewership of 8 million (a number South Park could only dream of, averaging around 4 million in earlier seasons and only 2 million currently), you might say it was fairly brave of the creators to mock a show that was more successful than theirs. Yet according to Matt and Trey the creators of The Simpsons and King of the Hill both sent kind messages of agreement following this episode being aired, so it seems they aren€™t alone in their opinion. If you€™re a family guy fan and you don€™t want the show being ruined for you, do NOT watch this episode. You will never look at the cutaway segments in the same way again. Or at Manatees either...

2. Trapped In The Closet

Leaving Muhammad behind for a moment and returning swiftly to Scientology, Trapped in the Closet sees Stan join the Church of Scientology and become the reincarnation or €œsecond coming€ of Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard, which leads to famous scientologists John Travolta and Tom Cruise locking themselves in Stan€™s closet. Given the obvious homosexual connotations that come from Tom Cruise being unable to come out of the closet, and given the blatant mockery of Cruise€™s religion, it didn€™t come as a big surprise that Cruise kicked up a fuss. He reportedly refused to promote Mission Impossible III if the episode aired, and with both Paramount Pictures and Comedy Central being owned by parent company Viacom this was certainly problematic, although not enough so to persuade Matt and Trey to pull any punches. Cruise wasn€™t the only celebrity that threw a tantrum. Isaac Hayes, the voice of Chef, was also unhappy with the episode, and left the show as a result of this. But did the reaction stop them from mocking Tom Cruise again? Like the image of Muhammad, nothing is off limits for Matt and Trey, as was discovered in the most controversial South Park episode of all time. Click next to discover which episode we rated the most controversial.

1. 200/201

And last but in no way least, the most controversial episode of South Park, the episode that rattled the most feathers, the episode that really got the creators in Tom Cruise€™s bad books. It is, of course, the 200th episode two-part special, 200 and 201. After Stan offends Tom Cruise by calling him a fudge-packer (even though he is literally packing fudge at the time), 200 pissed-off celebrities decide to file a lawsuit against the town. Stan tries to apologise, but Tom Cruise says the only way they will stop the lawsuit is if the town can get him and the other celebrities Muhammad, as they want his €˜goo€™ which they believe makes him immune to mockery. So in part one the creators managed again to mock Tom Cruise, and they proposed to show a depiction of Muhammad in part two. Revolution Muslim got involved following 200, warning the creators that they would end up like Theo Van Gough if they aired the episode, a filmmaker who was murdered following a short film he released which showed violence against women in some Islamic societies. Security at South Park studios and Comedy Central HQ was increased. But Matt and Trey were not about to back down, nor were the South Park fans who hacked the Revolution Muslim website and organised a national €˜Draw Muhammad day€™. The creators sent the episode 201 to comedy central for airing, Muhammad and all. But in the end it was too much for Comedy Central, and they decided to censor the image of Muhammad regardless of what Matt and Trey said, as well as bleep out Kyle€™s entire final speech. And what was that speech about? Well according to Matt and Trey it was about not giving in to intimidation and fear. Oh, the irony...