Star Trek: 10 Things You Didn't Know About The Bell Riots
They are a pivotal moment in Star Trek history. What were they, and what brought them about?
The Bell Riots are an enormously significant event in Star Trek. Starfleet would never have been created without them, so their impact can be measured in the organisation's effect on the universe. However, for as important a historical moment as they are, they have only been depicted in a single story from Deep Space Nine, with an allusion in Picard.
Past Tense sees Sisko, Bashir, and Dax travel back in time to San Francisco in 2024. There, they witnessed firsthand just how dark the world had become for the less fortunate members of society, as well as the apathy permeating the United States.
The story, written in the 90s, drew inspiration from well-documented historical events, while also seemingly serving as a chillingly prescient depiction of things to come in our future. On August 30th, 2024, three Starfleet officers arrived in our time. This is the breakdown of what, and how, the things that followed took place.
10. They Didn't Want To Do A Martin Luther King Jnr.
With the Bell Riots, writer Robert Hewitt Wolfe and Ira Steven Behr wanted to create an event that trickled through Star Trek history. They knew that the story would involve time travel, with Sisko replacing a crucial participant from the past. What they wanted to avoid was making Sisko one of the most recognisable figures in history.
They didn't want to make him 'Martin Luther King Jnr,' in that they wanted to avoid having him lead a march or making the speech that would reverberate through history. King was and remains one of the most well-known figures, and faces, in history. Gabriel Bell, as the character would be called, could not be so iconic.
In Little Green Men, Nog is seen perusing a PADD, specifically on Earth history. He notices that 'Gabriel Bell' bears a striking resemblance to Sisko, but the scene plays the recognition for laughs, while also highlighting that Bell's legacy, and not his face, would be what was important.
9. It Began With Homelessness
The Sanctuary Districts earned their name as they were areas of hope for the homeless and the down-on-their-luck residents of America. While we will explore just how much of a haven they became, they were inspired by Robert Hewitt Wolfe's discomfort and worry about the growing number of homeless people in Santa Monica. As per the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine Companion by Terry J. Erdmann and Paula M. Block, he stated that it was:
...difficult to turn a blind eye to the sight of people living on the streets in unprecedented numbers.'
Ira Steven Behr understood Wolfe's concerns, seeing the homeless as 'living statues' that people were content to 'step over'. Therefore, when Wolfe brought the original pitch to him, he knew that this was timely, but a story that had a deeper message behind it. They would eventually settle on something slightly bigger, but the first draft of the story would be called 'Cold And Distant Stars.'
In that version of the story, Sisko would travel back in time, but he would reveal his identity to the locals - only for them to call him schizophrenic and prescribe him Thorazine. While Behr couldn't make that script work, Star Trek: Voyager seems to have recycled the idea in Future's End for Captain Braxton.
8. We're Gonna Do Concentration Camps
When Cold And Distant Stars didn't work out, Behr drew inspiration from the Attica Prison Riot of 1971. There are several parallels between Past Tense and the Attica riots, though perhaps the clearest is the reasons behind them.
Before the outbreak of rioting in Attica on September 8th, 1971, many of the New York State prison's inmates were demanding improved conditions within the overcrowded facility. Attica, which had been designed to accommodate 1200 prisoners, had a population that swelled to over 2200. Racial inequality was rife, with African American prisoners forming more than half of the population.
Warden Vincent Mancusi subjected inmates to restrictions on their reading material and belongings, further fuelling tensions. In August 1971, a prominent member of the Black Panther Party, George Jackson, was shot and killed during an escape attempt from San Quentin State Prison. The following day, many of the Attica prisoners staged a hunger strike in protest. With nerves frayed, and conditions as poor as they were, the riot erupted following a fight between two inmates, which quickly escalated, involving many prison guards.
The riot lasted four days, at the end of which time more than 40 people were dead, most of whom from gunshot wounds as the government retook the prison.
The inspirations that Past Tense takes from these events are obvious. Another source that Behr and Wolfe drew from was the Kent State Massacre (4th May, 1970). There, Ohio Nation Guardsmen killed four, and wounded a further nine, Kent State students who had been protesting the United States' Vietnam War expansion into Cambodia, as well as the National Guard's campus presence, and the draft.
The clear common thread between both of these inspirations was the deaths of unarmed people, as well as the historical vindication that followed these incidents.
7. Talk About Timely
While the writers were breaking the story for Past Tense, an article appeared in the L.A. Times that deeply unnerved them. Titled 'HOMELESS CAMP WEIGHED IN L.A. INDUSTRIAL AREA,' it discussed plans to open a fenced-in locale, based on a similar centre in San Diego, for homeless transients to voluntarily visit. The centre, the article advertised, would have showers and laundry facilities available, as well as a lawn for people to sleep on.
The article highlighted the division already springing up between the then-Riordan Administration and local homeless advocacy groups. Some supporters shrouded their intentions with statements like -
It’s about giving the homeless people options so they don’t have to stay on the streets
Other supporters were less opaque, declaring the intent to remove homeless people from sight. Don Spivack, director of operations for the Los Angeles Community Redevelopment Agency, went so far as to say:
We are not going to allow people to camp on the streets at will...
Behr and Wolfe, as well as René Echevarria, were shocked at how timely - and grim - this proposal was. Behr recalled a number of people approaching him to ask if he had known about the article in advance of writing the script, which he hadn't.
When the article was published, it became a fierce topic of debate in L.A., with voices arguing against the shelter for fear it would lower Downtown L.A.'s standards, while others blamed homeless people for rising crime rates. Though divided on the why, there seemed to be agreement that the centre wasn't enough - a more permanent solution was required.
Alexander Siddig would later recall:
I hadn't realised the country was so depressed as to need it...but the episode was almost a cinematic version of that statement by the LA Council.
6. Setting The Scene
Behr stated that they weren't actively trying to make a 'big political statement' when writing Past Tense, though in classic Deep Space Nine fashion, political statements were rarely far behind any script the show produced. For example, look at how the three officers dumped in the past are treated.
Jadzia materialises mere feet from Sisko and Bashir, but it is just enough to separate her from her shipmates. This means she is found by Chris Brynner, a middle-class businessman who immediately takes pity on her, despite her strange appearance and finding her sleeping on the street. He brings her to his home, then helps her in finding new clothes, and eventually helps her in locating her friends.
Sisko and Bashir, however, are found by security, who immediately dump them into Sanctuary District A. Vin, played the ever-charismatic and grumpy Dick Miller, has no interest in the men's stories. Instead, he sees two homeless, brown-skinned people, sleeping on his streets.
The less-than-subtle racism is key to how Past Tense sets up its narrative. Dax, played by the caucasian actress Terry Farrell, is welcomed with open arms. Sisko and Bashir, played by distinctly non-caucasian actors Avery Brooks and Siddig El Fadil/Alexander Siddig, are treated with hostility and repulsion. Though they are not immediately identified as criminals - as criminals aren't allowed in the Districts - they are hardly treated with much more respect.
5. No Criminals Allowed In Our Havens
Star Trek's Sanctuary Districts were designed as 'havens' for homeless people, or financially destitute people, to find shelter, a place to stay, or food. They were also specifically designed not to allow entry to anyone with a criminal record, attempting to shift the perception that they were designed as prisons.
In reality, residents were given very little choice as to their lot in life. Bashir bemoans the lack of medical care afforded to the people he sees in the processing centre, while Sisko describes the Districts as a 'bad mistake' in Earth's history. As he later explains to Bashir, the Districts are a symptom of the overwhelming issues faced by contemporary people. They had given up by this point in history, leading to so many who needed help being deposited inside.
Once inside, there was little chance to leave, as the inmates' stories were never shared with the outside world.
4. No One Is Simply One Thing
Biddle Coleridge, or BC (named in honour of DS9 assistant director B.C. Cameron), was played by Frank Military in Past Tense. He is a 'ghost,' one of the residents of the Sancutary Districts that leaned toward violence. He is introduced as an unpleasant person hassling Sisko and Bashir, though later is shown murdering Gabriel Bell in a scuffle. He takes the processing centre hostage, coming face to face with Sisko, now claiming to be Bell.
It would have been easy to write BC as a stereotypical thug who uses murder as a means to an end. However, Behr was insistent that they needed to make him something more. BC murders Bell in Past Tense Pt 1, and the murder isn't discussed at all in Pt 2.
As Behr comments in the DS9 Companion:
We didn't want the crux of the thing to be 'Sisko trapped with a murderer'...he wasn't inherently a murderer
Behr and the writing team crafted a large backstory for BC which, though little of it was seen on-screen, explained what drove him to commit his crimes. He would have been something like a mechanic in his former life, down on his luck, forced into this District, and left to fend for himself. Not defining him as murderer was something that Behr was very proud of.
3. What Were The Riots For?
The demands that the District residents make include the closure of the Sanctuary Districts, jobs for those inside, and the reinstation of the Federal Employment Act. This act, repealed sometime before 2024 in Star Trek, was based on the real Employment Act of 1946.
The Act was conceived to make the Federal Government responsible for halting inflation and seeking to provide full employment for the populace. This Act was born in the post-WWII years. The War had seen full employment via wartime industries, though with that work drying up and millions of soldiers about to head home, a new policy was required.
The Act as conceived never made it to law. There is currently a version of the Act in place, though the wording 'full employment' was removed. The Conservative Coalition of Northern Republicans and Southern Democrats pressured that the Bill proposed would include more general wording, effectively removing the responsibility from the Government, and replacing it with a set of guidelines to aid in economic spending.
While the Act is far from perfect, it does inspire any Government to continue concentrating on employing the population. With it repealed, the United States of 2024 in Deep Space Nine simply had no reason to do anything to change.
2. It's Not My Fault And Nothing Ever Changes
Lee, played by Tina Lifford, was a Public Health Official in Sanctuary District A. She is the one who processes Sisko and Bashir on their arrival and becomes one of the hostages when BC takes over the centre.
Lee was designed to be a brow-beaten official, constantly underpaid and overworked, trapped in a job that was sapping her life. The script called for her desk to be littered with paper, something that was already deemed somewhat obsolete in the rest of San Francisco of 2024, as a visual clue to her situation. She is also given one of the starkest lines in both episodes.
When Bashir helps her, she gives him a little of her story, recounting the time she allowed a woman to enter the District, despite having a warrant for her arrest. The woman, she explained, had abandoned her baby with people who could care for him, knowing that she could not. Lee took pity and almost lost her job for it, settling then into a life of 'just doing the work.' Bashir kindly tells her that it isn't her fault, the way that things are.
Everybody tells themselves that. And nothing ever changes.
Lee's reply succinctly delivers the message of the episodes.
1. Life Is Like A Soapbox
Ira Steven Behr reflected on the episode as the years passed, noting that Past Tense has been reviewed as too 'liberal' or 'soapboxy.' As per the DS9 Companion:
I suppose we could have shown the 'positive aspects' of concentration camps
The episodes had to balance the message of the Riots, as well as weaving Star Trek technobabble and some lighter elements, to make it all work. Clint Howard's character provides some comic relief, while Kira and O'Brien's trips through time add some silliness, something director Jonathan Frakes wasn't thrilled about, although he does credit Past Tense pt 2 and Cause And Effect as the two episodes that got him the directorial job on Star Trek: First Contact.
Behr ultimately feels that Past Tense was a success. It was released in 1995, the year that Forrest Gump did big numbers at the Box Office, while also helping audiences feel good. Behr had this closing comment in the DS9 Companion on the matter:
Yes, it's important to feel good and I'm not putting that down. But in reality, in 1995, Forrest Gump would be homeless. I just thought it was important to show the other side.