Supergirl: 6 Ups And 4 Downs From The Pilot

Is it a bird? Is it a plane? No, it's SuperGIRL!

By James Hunt /

After months of waiting, and having the pilot episode leak online, CBS' entry into the superhero genre, Supergirl, is finally here. Everything about this show screams The CW, so much so that it's hard to believe it isn't actually a stablemate of Arrow and, more notably, The Flash, which it shares a lot in common with. Of course, this does have much of the same team behind it, including Greg Berlanti, and it should appeal to a similar set of fans. However, there's much more to Supergirl than just being a female-led version of The Flash. Although this is just the first episode, it already shows signs of being fun, fast, and confident (ok, it's still sounding a lot like The Flash). Melissa Benoist is the girl tasked with being super, or Kara Danvers as she's otherwise known, and she is what this series will live or die on. So far, she comes across as extremely likable, and perfectly capable of handling the dual roles of being a regular girl and a superhero. We also met the rest of the main players, including Mehcad Brooks as James Olsen, Jeremy Jordan as Winn Schott, and Calista Lockhart as Cat Grant. While there was a lot to like in this debut, which was pretty self-assured and solid as pilot episodes go, it wasn't perfect, though hopefully it can iron out those mistakes as the show progresses.

Advertisement

10. Flight 237 - Up

After dealing with some fast setup about how Kara left Krypton and arrived on Earth, we're pretty quickly into the action. She's on a rather terrible blind date when news reports of a plane going down emerge, and when she realises that Alex, her surrogate sister, is onboard, she's off to help quick as a, er, Flash. We see her remembering how to fly, and then the thrilling moments where she's underneath the plane and stopping it from going down, all pleased with herself, only to then be faced by a bridge. Obviously it all works out ok, as we knew it would, but the sequence still plays out really well and does a very good job of establishing Kara Danvers as the hero. It's also nice that she takes a moment to seemingly bask in the glory, her face beaming due to the fact that she's just saved so many lives, which is often missing from the gritty and grounded superhero approach.

9. Superman's Shadow - Down

Speaking of gritty and grounded superheroes, hello Superman. We don't see Kal-El properly in the show, but his shadow hangs over it and the life of his cousin Kara. There are a lot of references to the Man of Steel throughout the pilot, and it isn't really for the best. While you probably can't make a proper Supergirl show without addressing the fact that the two are related, this could be done quite quickly and you can then move on from it. However, time and again the show goes back to referencing Superman, and how Kara isn't like him, or wants to be like him, or how much of a hero he is, to the point where you're sick of Superman without even seeing him. Hopefully now that it's got the pilot out of the way it can stand on its own two feet. While including subtle Easter eggs will be a nice way to please the fans, the constant on-the-nose references grow tiresome pretty quickly.

8. Costume Change - Up

Kara saves the plane while wearing her normal clothes, something not very superhero-y. Obviously, she needs to get a costume, and does so in a fun scene alongside her friend and potential love interest (he wishes, anyway) Winn Schott (who comics fans will know has a rather significant name). We first see her trying on the rather more revealing outfit above, which he's impressed with but thankfully she isn't, and then a covered-up version of the same, before adding the finishing touches such as the iconic 'S' (it doesn't stand for Super), and in a scene that reminded me a bit of The Incredibles, a cape. We'll no doubt see various iterations of the costume should the show last beyond it's first season, but this was as good a way as any of starting things off, and especially felt right for the tone of this series.

7. Breakneck Pace - Down

Supergirl came racing out of the blocks, going at a breakneck speed (resisting to make another Flash comparison here...), and didn't really slow up for the majority of its 45-minute running time. While I liked the plane saving, that came about 10 minutes into the pilot episode. We'd barely met the character, and here she was flying about and being a hero already. Then it whizzes through her secret being spilled to pretty much everybody, Supergirl becoming a social media star and front page icon, some stuff with a specialised unit setup to combat alien threats, of which she is one apparently, and then her saving the day. Phew. She just about had time to stop and pick up a latte and a lettuce wrap for her boss, but apart from that it was non-stop. While this pace can be exciting at times, it's going to need to learn to slow things down if it wants to really have audiences invested in the story and the characters for a full season.

6. The Devil Wears Prada - Up

Cat Grant is the face and brains behind CatCo, the media enterprise where Kara works as her assistant. Ally McBeal is doing her best Meryl Streep impression, as the feisty boss that you don't want to cross, while Kara serves the Anne Hathaway role as the slightly hapless and put-upon assistant. There's an excellent dynamic between them, and it really shines through in all of the scenes that happen at Kara's workplace. She may be a hero in her secret life, but at work she's just an assistant, and is going to be ordered around, forced to buy coffees and sandwiches, and then almost fired. Calista Flockhart is a great addition to the cast, and the only major player we've met so far who doesn't know Kara's secret, so seeing how that develops going forward is going to be fun to watch.

5. The Special Effects - Down

You had Kara flying around, saving planes, keeping pace with traffic, fighting bad guys with lasers from her eyes. It all created the world and her powers really well, but the only drawback here was the special effects work. Granted, it's on CBS, so it isn't going to have the biggest of budgets, and it's only the pilot so there's plenty of room to improve, but a lot of the time in this episode they really didn't look too impressive. In particular the opening stuff on Krypton wasn't great. It's not the biggest problem with the show, and they should be cut some leeway for managing to pull off flight on a network TV show, but with the good effects work done on shows like, uh, The Flash without a big budget, there's certainly room for improvement here.

4. James Olsen - Up

One of the biggest connections to Kara's cousin in this episode comes in the form of James (not Jimmy!) Olsen, the Pulitzer Prize winning photographer who's enjoyed a close relationship with Superman, and as revealed at the end of the episode is in on the secret all along. Comic fans will perhaps find him rather unrecognisable from the version that adorns the page - gone is the pale, freckled-face and ginger hair, replaced by the rather more muscular form of Brooks - but that change doesn't necessarily have to be a bad thing. He immediately comes off as being charismatic, and a good guy as he helps Kara out when she's about to get fired by Cat. While the obvious but needless references to Superman are irritating, this can provide a tangible connection that actually serves the story, and the two already have a good chemistry between them that should only get better as the season goes on.

3. An Underwhelming Villain - Down

If this opening episode had a major weak point, it was with the villain, Vartox (who is actually an ally of Superman in the comics). He doesn't turn up until Supergirl arrives on the scene, as he's hell-bent on getting revenge on her mother. The fight scenes between them here aren't the problem, although the formulaic nature of the villain-of-the-week means that you know how it's going to play out. What's really the issue is his dialogue, which is far too cheesy even for this show. Whether it's one of The CW shows, or something from the MCU side of things, villains in superhero shows over the last year have been generally quite excellent, even with the minor weekly ones. Vartox doesn't really bring anything to the party; his performance his bland, and lines such as "I'll make you bleed, and your city will bleed" don't really help matters. Hopefully things will be a lot better with the big bad, teased at the end of the episode as being Kara's aunt. Now that should be an interesting development.

2. A Greg Berlanti Girl - Up

How you feel about this show, and more specifically its lead character Kara, may well depend on how you feel about Arrow's Felicity Smoak. Although the two shows don't have anything in-universe to do with each other (yet, anyway, though who knows what the future holds), there's a clear link between the two. Kara is intelligent, heroic though you'd never guess it, and awkwardly charming and funny. Put short, she's a Greg Berlanti girl. We've seen this for the past few years with Felicity, who's now getting back to her best in Arrow's fourth season, while The Flash has just introduced us to Patty Spivot, a bright-eyed, enthusisatic, funny, and of course awkward new character who'll be a love interest for Barry Allen in Season 2. Much like those two, Kara appears to be straight out of the Berlanti textbook. If you're in the camp who doesn't like those characters, then you probably won't care for this one. If, however, you recognise how awesome Felicity is, and already think Patty is a great addition to The Flash, then you'll like Benoist's character, and her performance is absolutely full of charm which makes not liking her really difficult.

1. A Female Hero - Up

SuperGIRL? How can you call her SuperGIRL? It's anti-feminist or something. That's the protest of Kara, once the new moniker has been revealed, but then Cat delivers a speech about how she's a girl, and yet strong and smart and successful. Supergirl could easily have chosen to ignore the fact that it has a female superhero as its lead character, something which is unfortunately still a noteworthy occurrence, but instead it has chosen to really embrace that fact, and wear its colours on its sleeve. The speech from Cat is perhaps the most direct and obvious example of this, but it's far from being the only one (nor is it the most successful). There are both obvious and subtle hints to female empowerment throughout, such as the fact that she uses being a girl to her advantage to defeat the main villain, to her relationship with Alex and the fact she also kicks-ass, to that yes, she can be a superhero even though she's a female. More strong female characters are always welcome on the screen, especially in the superhero world, and in Supergirl TV may have just found one of its strongest yet. What were your thoughts on the Supergirl pilot? Let us know down in the comments.