As a Doctor Who fan, I come across a lot of commentary from fellow fans about the show: sometimes I agree with them, but other times I just roll my eyes at how misplaced some of their critiques are. More often than not, its the criticism that new Doctor Who is nothing like old Doctor Who that really makes my blood boil. Critiques of this nature tend to fall into one of five categories and its those five that this article will focus on. There are of course criticisms of a more personal nature that Id rather not get into - for instance, Im not going to rehash the Steven Moffat is sexist argument because James Cornish has already written a rebuttal to it elsewhere on this website. Im merely offering counterarguments to some of the most baseless critiques of Doctor Who as it is today.
5 . There's Too Much Romance and Sexual Tension
Now, the critics are correct when they say this is a big difference between the classic series and the new series. Throughout the classic series, the Doctor was seen as a largely asexual figure. (Although the critics do seem to forget the existence of the Doctors granddaughter Susan. And when they dont forget her they try to explain it away by saying she wasnt really his granddaughter. Yes, that makes perfect sense.) It wasnt until the TV-Movie broke the taboo by having the Doctor kiss his companion that he was first portrayed as a romantic figure. So what happened between the classic and new eras that made the Doctor more open to romance? Simple: the Time War. Hes lost his home planet and with it, his people and his family. Hes more alone than hes ever been before. Its not beyond the realm of possibility that hed feel the need to cling to someone, even if she is just a girl who works in a shop. With River Song its a bit more believable because she at least has some Time Lord DNA and is therefore more relatable to him. In the end, the romantic aspect of the new series is primarily the result of how television drama is written these days. The Doctor is still the same old Time Lord at his core, even if he just so happens to lock lips with young women every now and then.
4. There's No Need for Story Arcs
One of the major changes between classic Who and new Who is the story arcs that run throughout each series. This is also due to the current television landscape. Since Doctor Who originally went off the air in 1989, story arcs have become more and more common in televised dramas. Thats not to say the classic run didnt have its share of story arcs as well. There was the hunt for the Key to Time that took up all of Season 16 and the Trial of a Time Lord arc that was the basis for Season 23. But the new series has placed a heavier emphasis on arcs than fans had anticipated. Some detractors say that these overarching storylines get in the way of what Doctor Who is supposed to be about. Namely, an alien time traveler having different adventures from week to week. I dont see it that way. I see these story arcs as a means of developing the characters and challenging them in ways that the classic series was unable or unwilling to do. Admittedly, the arcs have played a much larger role under Steven Moffat, particularly in Series 6. But Series 7 has been relatively arc-free thus far, even to the point of not having any two-part episodes. I think it helps to have diversity in storytelling and Doctor Who is certainly no exception.
3. Fans Shouldn't Be Allowed to Run the Show
Every so often Ill see a stray comment somewhere on the Internet that says something to the effect of, This is what happens when you let fanboys run the show. Both Russell T. Davies and Steven Moffat grew up watching Doctor Who and have been quite vocal about their lifelong love for it. Theyve brought in other writers who were fans growing up. As such, many episodes of the new series are peppered with references and inside jokes that only diehard fans will get. On occasion, the excessive use of continuity has caused some fans to accuse the showrunners of fanwank (inserting plot points that serve no purpose apart from referencing old stories). I have a simple question for people who think fans of Doctor Who should not be in charge of the franchise: Who would you prefer instead? Someone who hates Doctor Who? Or perhaps someone indifferent to it who says, I watched it a couple of times growing up but I never really got into it? Yes, Im sure someone like that would be embraced wholeheartedly by fandom. To run a show like Doctor Who you need to be passionate about it. And no one has more passion for it than people who watched it as kids on a regular basis. I should also point out that the idea of fans writing for the show is not unique to the new series. Before he became script editor in 1979, a position roughly analogous to showrunner, Douglas Adams had been a long-term fan. One of his stories, City of Death, is fondly remembered as one of the best episodes of Who ever made. While some dismiss the new series as nothing more than glorified fan fiction, the fact is fans have been making their mark on the show for a very long time.
2. It's Becoming Too Mainstream
Once upon a time, Doctor Who fans outside the UK could only watch their favorite show whenever it came on their local public broadcasting station. We are now light-years beyond that. Thanks to BBC America, SPACE in Canada, BBC iPlayer, iTunes, Amazon video, Netflix and numerous other platforms, theres an endless supply of Doctor Who for anyone who wants it. The show is finally starting to leave its mark on American pop culture as well. Earlier this year, it became the first British TV series to be featured on the cover of Entertainment Weekly. All this attention has left some fans wondering what will happen to their beloved program as it transitions from cult favorite to mainstream success. Ive heard stories of fans that are surprised to see Doctor Who has its own little section in Barnes & Noble or do a double take when they see someone wearing a Weeping Angels t-shirt on a train. They simply arent used to this level of interest in the show from the general public. While Doctor Who merchandising is nothing new, its current omnipresence leaves some longtime fans wishing they could go back to a time when the show wasnt being shoved in their face. I can sympathize with them to some degree but the fact is no one in their right mind has ever said, I wish I had a smaller audience. We all know what temporarily killed off Doctor Who in the late 80s: falling viewing figures. The BBCs merchandising and PR machines may seem excessive at times but ultimately they help to keep the show alive amidst competition from other channels. One consequence of the franchises continued success is that it can attract big name talent both in front of and behind the camera (see Gaiman, Neil and Gambon, Michael for examples). Who would want to give that up in favor of a return to the wilderness years of the 90s and early 2000s?
1. It's Not Doctor Who
This one just makes me want to throw something at my computer whenever I see it. Its more common than you might think. Ive even heard it from a respected writer who shall remain nameless. Its a kind of catchall argument that disgruntled fans use when they arent happy with the direction Doctor Who is going in. If they dont like the person running the show, the actor playing the Doctor, the new companion, a particular story arc or some combination thereof, they can simply say, This is not Doctor Who and leave it at that. It may be comforting to them but it is never true. The great thing about Doctor Who is that its premise allows its protagonist to theoretically go anywhere and do anything. That said there are some common sense limits to this notion. An episode in which the Doctor runs around randomly killing people just because he feels like it goes against everything the series stands for and would therefore be worthy of the label Not Doctor Who. But we all know that such an episode would never be made nor considered. Doctor Who is and always has been a family show. Sometimes it features things that may be more adult than were used to, although nothing comes close to the novels published during the wilderness years. Theres enough sex and violence in those to make Anne Rices work look tame by comparison. The point is that while Doctor Who cant please everyone all the time it is at the very least FOR everyone. Not many shows can claim as much cross-generational appeal as Who can. So even if youre not happy with the series as it is now, think twice before saying, Its not Doctor Who. For all you know, it might be Doctor Who again the following week. What do you think of these arguments against Doctor Who? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.