The Walking Dead: 10 Most Disappointing Episodes Ever
Shambling into view like rotting Walkers.
The Walking Dead is one of the longest-running shows in modern television; set to conclude with its eleventh season, it's been quite the cash cow for AMC. After bringing the zombie sub-genre to the mainstream in 2010, it's held consistently high ratings ever since. It's also been held in high regard critically, especially for its debut season.
With that said, the series has been criticised a fair bit for its samey, often formulaic narratives. This was especially true of seasons five through seven which relied heavily on the group travelling between settlements, meeting a new antagonist then moving on.
With any adaptations, changes are going to be made to bring a popular property to the screen; Robert Kirkman's original vision often differs massively from the show. Some divergences haven't worked out for the best, disappointing fans and viewers alike. Much of the horror elements that made the comics so entertaining have translated over well enough, but other creative choices made by the showrunners haven't fared as well.
These are the ten most disappointing episodes of the show; entries you can easily skip on the way to the next big set piece. Massive spoilers ahead for every episode...
10. Last Day On Earth (Season 6, Episode 16)
To start off, we have the conclusion of season 6, probably one of the biggest "sequel-bait" sequences in modern small-screen history.
Upon settling in Alexandria, a new threat emerges in the form of the Saviours, who ruthlessly dominate any rival group who comes their way. We know that a man named Negan is in charge, but we never meet Jeffery Dean Morgan's character until the very end of season 6. Rick's group are on their knees and the nasty leader chooses one victim as retaliation for their misbehaviour.
Cutting to a first person view, Negan smashes somebody's head in with his favourite weapon, a razor coated bat nicknamed Lucille. The key word was "somebody" as the episode concluded immediately afterwards. It was a real slap in the face to the fans as they were forced to wait another year for the mystery victim to be revealed. The first victim was revealed to be Abraham, an ultimately inconsequential character death.
To build up this new antagonist for so long and then cut viewers off with a lousy cliffhanger? It was undoubtedly a ploy to keep audiences coming back for the next season. This tactic worked as ratings exceeded seventeen million upon season seven's opening. What this creative choice ended up doing was completely neuter the death of Glenn Rhee, something which switched many a viewer off from the show.
9. 18 Miles Out (Season 2, Episode 10)
Season 2 of The Walking Dead is widely regarded as one of its weakest, most notably due to the dull and uneventful occurrences on Hershel's farm. With the characters settled here for an entire season, the showrunners ended up artificially extending the length on a massively reduced budget.
Nowhere is this more evident than with 18 Miles Out. In previous episodes, Rick and Hershel rescue Randyll, a young member of a rival group. From here, he becomes little more than a thorn in their side, a means to keep the group arguing before the season finale. Rick doesn't believe in killing Randyll, but Shane insists that the boy should be offed to prevent his clan from invading the farm.
In Episode 10 they decide to take him to an abandoned wrecking factory to execution, only to get caught up in a major zombie infestation. It contributes very little to the story and boasts some very illogical moments of hand-to-hand action.
As Rick and Shane drive back to the farm with Randyll in tow, you realise just how pointless this episode really was. Outside of fuelling the duo's increasing animosity it was the worst kind of padding, designed to keep Randyll around a while longer and prolong an already bland second season.
8. Coda (Season 5, Episode 8)
Next up, we have "Coda", falling squarely in the middle of the show's ten seasons. Some of the characters, including Carol and Beth, end up stuck in a hospital ran by the controlling police officers of Atlanta. It's an episode of reunions, but one that falls well short of better episodes.
It was the mid-season finale of TWD's fifth season and going in, you knew they were going to have a big shock to mark the halfway point. As the scattered members of the group close in on the hospital, a confrontation ensues between the rogue police force and their patients. The build-up to the climax was rather limp already and the episode's final twist isn't able to land with the right impact.
From the moment Beth turns around and confronts Dawn head-on, it's already too obvious that something bad is going to happen. Instead of taking her medicine and walking away, she instead stabs the officer with scissors. Dawn's gun discharges, killing Beth instantly, followed by a distraught Daryl killing Dawn as well.
While competently acted by everyone involved, Beth's untimely and ultimately predictable demise drains the episode of much of its tension. Afterwards the group proceeds on the road to the next major settlement.
7. Heads Up (Season 6, Episode 7)
The Walking Dead's sixth season saw the group settled into Alexandria and a handful of uneventful episodes ensued. The seventh episode, "Heads Up" is one of the greatest offenders.
Stringing audiences along, the season left one question unanswered; what happened to Glenn and Nicholas? The last time audiences saw them, the two were cornered in an alley on top of a dumpster. The latter shot himself, causing them both to tumble off into the ravenous horde below.
What makes Heads Up such a letdown is its opening; after a few episodes of no word, many an audience member was very disappointed to see that Glenn Rhee's death in the episode "Thank You" was little more than a cop-out, as the popular character crawled under the dumpster while Nicholas was devoured. This fake death was shot very intentionally to trick the audience, something The Walking Dead has generally avoided in the past.
This was an incredibly lazy and poorly thought out bit of writing. It neutered much of the tension that had been building beforehand and rendered future twists in the season rather toothless. Outside of that, the episode stands out as rather uneventful; it's merely a case of the characters reacting to the Wolves attack, leading up to another zombie infestation.
6. Cherokee Rose (Season 2, Episode 4)
As mentioned previously, season 2 of The Walking Dead was slow and drawn out to a fault. Episode 4, Cherokee Rose is when the season really started to get plodding and tedious. The series has worked best when it blends its characters with the horror of the undead and this entry widely misses the mark.
Following Carl's recovery from his gunshot wound, Rick's group is now fully settled on Hershel's farm, cue a collection of bland sequences that rarely move the plot forward.
By far the episode's weakest moment is the walker in the well; the group finds a bloated zombie clogging up the water supply and need to pull it out. Their solution? Lower Glenn Rhee down as bait to haul the monster out with a rope; it's one of the most cringe worthy and non-sensical moments of the entire series. The tension is so artificial and stilted; yet if they removed this sequence, there would have been no undead engagement for the entire episode.
At best, Cherokee Rose establishes the bond between Glenn and Maggie; at worst it places the former in an utterly nonsensical situation. Upping the episode count while limiting the show's budget severely damaged The Walking Dead's second season and episode 4 is proof positive of that.
5. The Suicide King (Season 3, Episode 9)
The first half of The Walking Dead's third season had been a success for the most part; holed up in an abandoned prison, the surviving members of the group were able to carve out a living for themselves. That is, until David Morrisey's Governor showed up.
Episode 9, The Suicide King had some high expectations to live up as the first direct clash between Rick and the Governor unfolded. While the build-up towards the previous episode was well established, TSK struggles to maintain the momentum.
Previously, things were left off on quite a cliffhanger by the mid-season finale; the Governor had lost an eye at the hands of Michonne and Daryl was about to be forced to fight his brother Merle to the death for Woodbury's amusement. Unfortunately, it doesn't amount to very much in the end as the two are quickly rescued by Rick and company without much difficulty.
The Suicide King's inconsistent pacing ultimately drags it down; the rescue and escape from Woodbury unfolds far too quickly to build tension and the aftermath is mostly characters discussing matters. The final ill-advised choice was to have Rick suddenly hallucinate his dead wife Lori. It comes out of nowhere at the end of the episode and feels very misplaced.
4. Dead Weight (Season 4, Episode 7)
Following his introduction, The Governor became the most dangerous adversary in The Walking Dead for an extended period. In a fit of rage, the Governor mercilessly guns down his entire platoon at the end of season 3 and presumably flees into the wilderness shortly afterwards. It's only deep into season 4 when we pick up the villain's story again.
Things kick off in episode 6, "Live Bait"; we see the Governor as a drifter, wandering the ruins of Woodbury and eventually coming into contact with a new group. Thanks to his charisma, he's able to win the people over to his side and persuade them that Rick and company are their sworn enemy. Before that however, we've got a trudging and slow episode to go through. In "Dead Weight", the Governor slays his former lieutenant Martinez and takes full command of the survivors.
Ironically enough, the title of "Dead Weight" is an apt description for the Governor's sluggish takeover. Did it need to be stretched out over two episodes? Likely not; the slower sections of "Live Bait" could have been reworked to show the Governor taking control and building his new army. At the very least, the mid-season finale "Too Far Gone" goes a long way to make up for it.
3. I Ain't A Judas (Season 3, Episode 11)
The cast of The Walking Dead are often defined by their loyalties and the web of motivations has only gotten more complex through the seasons. The sense of morality in the zombie apocalypse often fuels many twists and turns in the wider genre.
However, not every piece of character writing translates into effective episodes. Tensions are continuing to boil between Rick and The Governor with their discussion having failed to calm the animosity. In between the two sides, there's one character struggling to figure out who she should support. "I Ain't A Judas" homes in on this thread.
There's a big focus on Andrea in this one and overall, things just feel extremely indecisive and illogical. From the beginning of season 3, the character was torn between her life in Woodbury and loyalties to the original group. She returns to the prison, finding great distruct among the inhabitants, then turns around and heads back in the other direction.
To finish up, Andrea has an opportunity to kill the Governor in his sleep, but refuses to. On the whole, nothing much really happened in "I Ain't A Judas", leaving the final two episodes in the season to pick up the pieces. Luckily, they both offer far more engaging events to close things out.
2. Now (Season 6, Episode 5)
The Walking Dead's sixth season saw the group proceed on through the wilderness, settling permanently at the walled town of Alexandria. Some animosity between letting Rick and company in eventually subsided as the community started to crank out a living.
It appears an ideal place to rebuild; that is, until the Wolves show up. A minor group in the series, this pack of hunters is characterised by their creepy face paint and hostility to peaceful co-existence. Things come to a head when the enemy attacks, intent on taking Alexandria's resources for themselves.
In the previous episode "Here's Not Here" the Wolves attack the settlement and casualties ensue. It was a fairly unpredictable confrontation with the two sides sneaking around Alexandria to get the drop on each other. When it came to following up the encounter, things quickly went sideways with a mostly uneventful outing.
As the aftermath of Alexandria's invasion weighed heavily on the characters, The Walking Dead fell back on a rather underhanded trope. Much like season 2 before it, the episode mainly involves the characters reacting to events that transpired. This effectively stops the season dead in its tracks and wastes an episode on character interactions rather than working to push things forward.
1. Swear (Season 7, Episode 6)
Last, but certainly not least, we have "Swear", perhaps the show's most widely disliked episode. It falls in season seven as the group splits up after attacking the Saviours. We closely follow Alanna Masterton's Tara, who has slowly worked her way into a main role.
How ironic then that it proves to be a massive letdown. After getting separated from Heath, Tara stumbles across a tightly-knit community on the coast known as Oceanside. They're a group of isolationists who wish to hide their presence from everyone, so already you can tell how little of an impact they're going to have.
It's a very tedious slog as Tara is caught by Oceanside, discusses their ethics and approach to survival, then turns around and finds her way back to Alexandria while refusing to reveal the coastline's presence. Very little happens of real consequence all the way through.
In addition to feeling very detached from the rest of the season, "Swear" features an incredibly lacklustre performance from Alanna Masterson, who fails to bring any substantial development to Tara. It's especially disappointing considering this was her first move out of recurring status and into the main set.
Which episodes of the The Walking Dead fell flat for you? Let us know in the comments below...