True Detective: 5 Crazy Theories On How It Will End

With the finale soon to hit out screens, we're guessing wildly about how it's going to wrap up.

By Mike Revell /

Despite a comparatively short lifespan, HBO's critically acclaimed True Detective has reached Lost levels of theorising, with the action unfolding cryptically enough for anything to happen in the series finale on Sunday. The internet is ablaze with weird and whacky ideas about cults and killers and Yellow Kings: fans are freeze-framing shots and zooming in to examine background props; they're cross-referencing lines of dialogue with old films and literature and mythology... and it's all in the name of trying to figure out the ending to this beautifully crafted show. But maybe we're all being a little presumptuous, and the final episode could play out without any twists whatsoever. Show writer/creator Nic Pizzolatto even went as far as to say:
€œI€™ve enjoyed reading people theorise about what€™s going to happen because it€™s a sign that you€™re connecting. But I€™m also sort of surprised by how far afield they€™re getting. Like, why do you think we€™re tricking you? It€™s because you€™ve been abused as an audience for more than 20 years. I cannot think of anything more insulting as an audience than to go through eight weeks, eight hours with these people, and then to be told it was a lie€”that what you were seeing wasn€™t really what was happening. The show€™s not trying to outsmart you.€
Naturally, half the fun is in trying to predict how it will end, even if some of the ideas are crazy. Seeds and red herrings have been planted for seven weeks and there are so many lingering questions. Is it important that the show wasn't called True Detectives (plural)? Does it mean that one of our heroes is the killer? Is there even going to be a monster at the end of the trail, or will we be left disappointed? Here are five crazy theories about how it will all end...

5. Rust Will Die

Early on in the show, it seemed Rust was a prime suspect. He's shady and has a mysterious past, he's obviously not at peace, and the washed-up modern-day character lied to the detectives interviewing him. But even though you can't rule out the possibility Rust did kill Dora Lange, it's looking less and less likely. He's passionate about the case, and meticulously studies every detail. Indeed, it seems to be the only thing keeping him alive. Last week, Rust told Marty, "My life€™s been a circle of violence and degradation as long as I can remember. I€™m ready to tie it off." That sounds like the words of a tired, tired detective to me. Here is a boozed up man who's gone from solving crime to serving drinks. He's lost his daughter, has no real family to speak of, and gains no enjoyment from life. Rust is this case. What happens when it's over? If he doesn't die trying to stop the murderer(s), will he commit suicide in the days that follow? We also now know that Matthew McConaughey won't be coming back for series two, and maybe there's more narrative behind that decision than simple actor unwillingness. All in all, Rust's future doesn't look too bright...

4. Marty's Daughter Is Involved

Something is going on with Audrey, Marty's eldest daughter. In 1995, when she was a child, we know that she drew people having sex in her notebook, and she even depicts a masked man, which obviously hints at the mysterious cult, and animal masks pop up in her other drawings as well. And then there's the toy dolls... What's it all about? She certainly remained quiet when her parents interrogated her. In another scene, we see her wearing a ribboned crown €“ much like the crown the girl wears in the disturbing rape video Rust shows Marty years later. The hints are there: has Audrey seen something? What happened to her in 1995? Whatever it was led to her risky sexual behaviour in the car and an apparent drug problem after that. It's plausible this is all due to the fact that Marty isn't a very good father - the signs are certainly there - but it's just as likely that Audrey has been involved with or come into contact with the killers in some way. Will a terrible fate befall her in the series finale? Is she going to be next?

3. Maggie Is In The Cult

And what about Maggie, Marty's wife? What if nothing was actually done to Audrey? What if the drawings and the dolls are just things that she's seen? What if her mother introduced her to these dark activities as a form of initiation? It's crazy, but think about it and it transforms nearly every episode of the show. When Maggie visited Rust, was she looking for information? Why did she lie outright to the detectives interviewing her? She didn't have any loyalty to Marty or Rust at that point, so perhaps she was simply protecting herself, and her Tuttle connections. Maggie never appeared shocked at the news of the murder, and though death is nothing new as a detective's wife, it's a particularly gruesome scene, which had an emotional impact on seasoned detectives. She's always eager to distract Rust, introduce him to women, get him to settle down. And why did Rust mow the Hart family lawn? Because he wanted to pop round to chat up his partner's wife, or because he wanted to investigate the family?

2. Rust Planted The Body

While it's unlikely now that Rust is the killer, that doesn't rule out the possibility it was he who planted the body in the first episode. Think about it: everything about the murderous cult is shrouded in secrecy; all the other missing girls Rust links to the case are like fairy dust on the wind. No one else connects them because there's nothing obvious to tie them together. Someone lit a fire to draw attention to the body in episode one: they wanted it to be found. Rust is never less than 10 steps ahead of Marty or anyone else working on the case: he's often displayed frustration at how slowly they join the dots. And €“ crucially €“ he appears to have been working on the mystery before it even started. That's right: the Dora Lange case started three months after Rust got the job. But we see a scene two weeks after he got the job, in which Marty visits his house and sees a number of weird books on a table. The most recently read one is boldly titled Sex Crimes. Additionally, Rust tells the detectives that his daughter was hit by a drunk driver, but what if she was murdered by the cult? It would explain his unwavering determination in the case, the one thing that keeps him going.

1. Marty Is The Killer

It's hard not to keep going back to the show's name and wondering why it's called True Detective, especially since we've followed two detectives this far into the murk, not one. Does it hint that one of them is the killer? And if it does, perhaps it's the slower of the two, the one you'd least expect, the family man whose life is unravelling before our eyes. Perhaps Marty is the Yellow King. It sounds strange at first, but there are a couple of scenes that are jarring in normal circumstances and lend weight to the theory. First of all, why did he shoot Reggie LeDoux in the head right out of the blue? Seeing the child victims may have disturbed him, but enough to murder someone at point-blank range? There could be more to it: with LeDoux caught, Marty might have known he'd talk and reveal his own role in the case. Remember, Rust found a number of important clues inside the Tuttle-funded school he visited again on his own €“ after Marty initially lured him away from it with a new lead. And why did Marty get so annoyed about Rust mowing his lawn? Because you don't mow another man's lawn... or because he was worried he might find something? Marty doesn't wear the scars we've come to associate with our serial killer. But he might not have to. We know masks are involved. We've seen and heard it time and time again. In The Locked Room, the preacher even warned us: "The face you wear is not your own." It wouldn't surprise me if this crazy theory is, in the end, the most likely of all, and that Rust has known all along. Which of these theories do you think carries the most weight? Share your picks below in the comments thread.