Its about time they gave the audience a break. Since the cliffhanger ending to season four, with the group of rag-tag survivors trapped in a train car by another faction of zombie-killers who may or may not have been cannibals (FYI they totally were, which was a weird relief), and the trailers promising more death and destruction than ever before. Then stuff sort of settled down after last weeks Four Walls And A Roof - relatively, anyway - and now for something completely different. Its time for a Beth solo episode! Remember Beth? Possibly not, since shes been absent from the show since the latter half of The Walking Deads last season, where she got spirited away in a black car with a white cross on. Her on again/off again love interest Darryl tried his best to keep up but, awesome though he is, hes not as fast as an automobile. He didnt even try and shoot it with his crossbow. So whilst Ricks group are in a sort of limbo - albeit a safe one, having dealt with the immediate Terminus threat - the gears were shifted for the fourth episode of season five to take a look at what Beths been up to this whole time. It was a mixed bag, both for her and the viewers: here are the six things that Slabtown did right, and four it really didnt.
The Good:
6. A Different Rhythm
And breath. The opening of this season of The Walking Dead was one of the more intense in a long time (and this is a show that had the Governor hanging over it for a good few dozen episodes), as Ricky and company dealt with the ongoing threat of that Terminus lot and their rumbling stomachs. That confrontation ended in a more positive fashion than it usually does for the survivors in the show - relatively, anyway - so, whilst things settled down there, so too did the tone of Slabtown. The Walking Dead has always had a problem with pacing. The second season especially dragged a bunch, with the characters just sort of milling about on Hershels farm and not a whole lot else. This season, meanwhile, has been moving at breakneck speeds up until this point. Slabtown managed to strike a sweet spot right in the middle, with a sense of creeping dread and building tensions over the initial forty minutes exploding into that action packed finale. Its nice to have a change of pace every so often.
5. Sympathetic New Characters
When a new character shows up on The Walking Dead, theyre usually doomed to one of two fates: being a shifty so-and-so thats going to trick or otherwise come up against the group, or theyre going to be walker fodder pretty quickly. Occasionally somebody breaks through and gets to join Rick and his pals for a time, but for the most part, a new addition to the cast is either somebody whos going to be knocked off or be an antagonist. Which is why it was rather refreshing that not every new character who turned up in Slabtown was a total psychopath. Most of them were, obviously, but there were a few good uns in the mix to keep that low flickering flame in humanity from being extinguished. Dawn was a complete nutter (more on that sooner rather than later), as was the majority of her "staff", but a couple of roses were visible amongst the thorns. Dr Steven Edwards may have had some questionable methods for survival but, ultimately, he seemed like a genuinely empathetic soul - chatting to Beth about Caravaggio, letting her eat some of his roast guinea pig - hey, times are tough - and never asking for anything in return, which was out of step with the rest of the group. Noah too was a decent sort, even more so than the good doctor, which is a surprisingly sunny twosome for The Walking Dead.
4. Real Violence
Greg Nicotero and his team do an excellent job on The Walking Dead. The special effects bods are at least part of the reason AMC drop so much money on the show, to ensure that the zombies tearing people apart look like actual zombies tearing actual people apart. Or, well, how zombies tearing people apart would look if zombies were real. Whatever. Its always realistically grizzly and gory, but its still somewhat fantastical. Its sort of easy to disassociate yourself from the more bloody walker-related sights in the show, since you can tell its special effects. Its a person with a grey face chewing someones nose off. That doesnt tend to happen IRL. The real horror of The Walking Dead has always come from what the human survivors do to each other, though, rather than what the zombies do to them. Some of the most vicious moments in the series have come from people, and the violence enacted by people upon other people always tends to be more vicious. Slabtown was especially full of really grim, disturbing and disgusting scenes: the bodies being tossed down the elevator shaft was grimly inhuman, but the surgery scenes were especially gross considering the usual sort of gore.
3. The Ending
A rare feeling in The Walking Dead (and one that audiences have been clamouring for) is hope. Theres plenty of fear, tension, trepidation, and occasionally some boredom or incredulity - but hope is in shorter supply than food and razors. Toothpaste appears to remain plentiful, however. Despite the glittering gnashers the cast retain they almost never have anything to smile about, the untenable post-apocalyptic situation they find themselves in not often conducive to optimism. Four Walls And A Roof was the closest to upbeat the shows been in a while, and the bittersweet ending of Slabtown wasnt bad either. The slow burn of the episode, with Beth coming to the realisation that the supposedly utopian society was anything but, set up Slabtown to have an explosive finale - and it didnt disappoint. It was squeaky bum time for basically the entire ten minute sequence of her and Noah trying to break out of their prison. After the pitch-black shootout, punctuated with flashes of bullets singing through walkers heads (one of the best-directed action sequences in the show thus far), it was a genuine shock that Noah was the one to get away, not Beth. Yet it wasnt a downbeat ending by any stretch, as the tackled blonde looked up at her friend getting away and smiled. Theres still some hope left.
2. Remember The Walkers
The human drama is the real draw of The Walking Dead, but tensions wouldn't be running so high in the first place were it not for the hordes of flesh-eating zombies that were roaming the Earth and making swift meals of every living person they come across. That does tend to make people a little more stressed out, prone to arguments and Mexican stand-offs, that sort of thing. Another part of genius pacing in Slabtown was to slowly reveal the horror of the settlement Beth had been dragged to, so that you almost forgot why they were ten floors up, and all those injured people kept rolling in. Dr Edwards was mostly a source of relief for Beth throughout the episode, but he was all too aware of the awful situation that humanity had found themselves in. Apparently thats the only way he can deal with the terrible way his life is lead, with a survival-of-the-fittest attitude and debts being hung over everybodys head: by reminding himself that outside is so, so much worse. The scene where he takes Beth down to the rattling gates not only reminded her but the audiences that, whilst the human characters cause plenty of drama, theres still all those walkers to contend with too...
1. Beth Goes Solo
The "previously on The Walking Dead" recap at the start of Slabtown was very telling. Well, usually the recaps are just obvious signposts of what storylines are going to be picked up and what characters will be involved, but this episode was a little different. It definitely set up the whole Beth situation true, but it also included a very important clip: her telling Daryl, in the middle of a training session with the iconic crossbow, suggested that shed be able to survive without his help before too long. Something that came full circle by the time of the episodes end, and about time too, The Walking Dead isnt particularly great with its female characters a lot of the time (partially owing to creator Robert Kirkmans neanderthal views on gender), and Beth has sorta been hot and cold. Sometimes she seems like she could be cool and independent; others shes a little too beholden to Daryl, what with her crush and all. Slabtown saw her transformation into exactly what she claimed to be back in season four: a survivor who can get by without any help, selflessly helps Noah to escape, with her smug smile at the end probably as much about being happy for him as her confidence that shes not going to be held captive for much longer. Beth is dead, long live Beth!
The Bad:
4. Crappy Writing
Right now television is going through something of a renaissance. Those cookie cutter franchises (CSI, NCIS, NTSF:SD:SUV::), game shows, or else trashy reality nonsense still exist, but starting on the fringes and creeping slowly into the mainstream has been a better quality of dramatic TV writing. Starting with Shawn Ryans superior cop show The Shield which begat Sons Of Anarchy, Mad Men, The Wire, Breaking Bad and any number of other programs you watch to keep up with the water cooler, the brilliance of small screenwriting has never been more assured. The Walking Dead, sadly, cant quite be counted in those higher echelons. Its certainly a damn sight better than the tired witticisms and hackneyed plots of other serialised shows, but its still not quite strong enough to run with the big boys. So whilst Slabtown was a definite success in its pacing, plot and structure, the dialogue - something the series has struggled with since day one, which is a problem when youre basing the show around human interactions and confrontation - was a bit naff. Officer Dawn had a few clangers, the girl who tried to leg it had that whole thing about the deal with the devil...seriously, who speaks like that? Especially in a zombie apocalypse...
3. Survival Above Transcendence
One of the better-written scenes in this weeks episode, meanwhile, was Dr Edwards little speech about the Caravaggio painting he found dumped out amongst the trash once everything started going to hell. Hes a smart guy, he knows that art isnt the most important thing when the human race is barely hanging on by a thread - as he points out, art should be about transcendence, not simply survival. Then theres some waffle about The Bible which wasnt quite as good or interesting, but never mind. Thing is, that whole treatise read like a critique of The Walking Dead itself. Either the writers knew exactly what they were doing by putting that little meta-comparison in there, and have an inflated idea of themselves, or the irony was totally lost on them. The Walking Dead is an entertaining, thrilling, pulpy show, but it rarely rises above that. The series is entirely about survival (both in the story and in the ratings) rather than transcendence, being driven by surprising deaths and plot twists than theme, character, or anything like that. Which is fine, but itd be nice for it to reach higher, or else not remind those watching that it doesnt.
2. Weird Character Motivations
Another place where the writing on The Walking Dead falls down is in the characters, and specifically their motivations. The determination of Hershel to remain on his farm and deny that zombies were even a thing despite all evidence pointing to the contrary didn't really make a whole lot of sense, Dales attempts to control the lives of everyone around him without their consent was supremely irritating. These are traits that were ripe for creating drama within the group, but they didnt really work in context. Hershels stubbornness and Dales meddling could have been explained with some back story, or else handled differently, but they weren't. Thats a problem too in Slabtown, with Officer Dawn - who runs the settlement with a shaky iron fist - never seeming quite like a fully fleshed-out character, and more of an obvious enemy for Beth to rail against. The rules of staying until youve paid your debt for having your life saved makes sense in the eye-for-an-eye world of The Walking Dead, but her frequent outbursts towards Beth are shocking not because of their violence, but because they seem totally random. Whys she taking it out on her? Its never explained, and she never does it to anyone else. Weird.
1. No Future
Hope, as previously mentioned, is something you dont see a whole lot of in The Walking Dead. Thats just down to the situation the characters find themselves in, and the world of the show as a whole: there genuinely isnt any hope. As Beth yells at Dawn towards the end of Slabtown, nobodys coming to save them. Theyre all thats left. And given the ways people act in this new, lawless society, that doesn't bode well. The episode opens with a suggestion that perhaps order can be restored to this chaotic post-apocalypse, something which slowly crumbles when the ways that the settlement rule are revealed. The doctors scrubs, the police uniforms, are all just costumes - they hint at a more civilised world that doesn't exist, and which certainly doesn't exist amongst those crooked (more so than usual) cops and scheming surgeons. Which makes sense, but its getting a little old. The last episode ended on a hopeful note, but only until the next threat comes at Rick and the group. Beths not gonna have a great time of it after her escape attempt. Its supposed to be a dark show, but you need some light every once in a while.