You Season 4: 10 Biggest Questions It Must Answer

Thinking about what's next for everybody's favourite serial killer/stalker...

By David Ng'ethe /

The third season of You has been here for a while and just like its predecessors, the new season is expectedly wild and horrifying in equal measure. The last season ended with Joe marrying Love, an act he clearly abhorred but did in order to be there for his unborn child.

Advertisement

Season three kicks off with the birth of Joe and Love's child, Henry, and the family's relocation to Madre Linda. Our protagonist promises himself (and us by extension) that he will not give in to his worst instincts but with Love and a whole new town full of less than appealing neighbours, it was only a matter of time before Joe's idea of a happy ever after was completely shattered.

To say that the third season took the show to ridiculously compelling new heights would be an understatement. Watching Joe and Love go toe-to-toe was unsettling, but Penn Badgely and Victoria Pedretti's absorbing performances made it entertaining at the same time.

The season finale wrapped up a few narrative loose ends and also changed the setting yet again due to Joe faking his death after killing Love. Naturally, this raises a number of questions as to where the show can go with its stories and painfully unaware protagonist.

10. A Fresh Start In Paris?

The third season of You ended in a shocking note with Joe killing Love and faking his death to make it look like she killed him, herself as well as Natalie and Gil.

Advertisement

Before the final showdown with Love, Joe and Marienne consummated their relationship before the latter fled Madre Linda to avoid unwanted attention following the murder of her ex-husband. To this end, the final shot has Joe walking out of a Parisian cafe, indicating that he is keen on finding Marienne and having his happily ever after with her.

It brings up the question of whether Joe will be able to start afresh in the City of Love without attracting attention his way. He may be in a foreign country but in this interconnected day and age all it takes is one person to recognize him and ruin his plans. This concern is especially pertinent following the surveillance sub-plot with Natalie's husband, Matthew.

9. Tying Loose Ends With Dotty

The last time Love's overbearing mother was seen onscreen, she was on her way to rehab following a chaotic drunken binge that saw her kidnap Henry and burn her new vineyard to spite her ex-husband. It was the culmination of one too many bad days for the Quinn matriarch, who was at odds with her daughter and grieving the loss of her son, Forty.

Advertisement

Before leaving the Quinn-Goldberg driveway for rehab, Dotty and Joe had a brief conversation about Love's deceased husband, James. She heavily insinuated that her daughter had a hand in her lover's death and this reveal greatly distresses Joe, who at that point intended to leave Love.

Now, Dotty may have seen the Joe/Love murder-suicide story and assume that history grimly repeated itself but the Quinn matriarch has shown to be more intuitive than that. She figured out that Love had conflicted feelings for Theo and it was entirely possible that she knew more about Joe than she let on due to her contacts in the world of private investigators.

8. How Will The Joe And Marienne Reunion Play Out?

As mentioned earlier, the finale saw Joe in Paris looking for Marienne in order to be with her and her young daughter. The two met during Joe's time at the library and due to their shared experiences and interests, formed a strong bond that gave way to a brief but passionate affair.

Advertisement

Unfortunately (or fortunately?), the affair did not blossom into a full-blown relationship due to Love's intervention. She convinced Marienne that her presence was detrimental to her marriage and that she needed to leave Joe alone for her (Marienne) own sake before she is caught in Joe's toxic sphere.

Before Love could kill Marienne, the latter's daughter unintentionally intervened by walking into the Quinn-Goldberg house, immediately stopping Love in her tracks. The main question here is whether Marienne will be willing to take Joe back, especially in light of what Love told her and the now-mysterious circumstances surrounding Love's death and Joe's survival.

7. Will Sherry And Cary Return?

The introduction of Sherry and Cary Conrad was one of the third season's most delightful surprises. Played to infuriating perfection by Shalita Gabriel and Travis van Winkle, the couple were Joe and Love's perfect foil due to their gratingly 'perfect" personas.

Advertisement

The disgustingly perfect pairing of girlboss and dudebro, Sherry and Cary's sensibilities were a goldmine of laughs throughout the third season, and their interactions with Joe and Love highlighted how shallow and saccharine Madre Linda was.

Somehow, this did not stop the couples from becoming good friends (much to Joe's chagrin) and this culminated in a swinging party gone horribly wrong due to the Conrads finding out about Natalie's murder and their subsequent imprisonment by the Quinn-Goldbergs because of this.

The couple was able to escape their imprisonment (but not before exposing uncomfortable truths about themselves) and in true Conrad fashion, turn their traumatic experience into their next cashcow. With their newfound success, will we see more of the Conrads in the fourth season, especially now that they know more about Joe than he would have wanted?

6. Joe's Growing (?) Self-awareness

Joe Goldberg's internal monologues are often some of the show's most entertaining moments, as they provide much needed insight into the serial killer's mind. Also, they make for darkly humorous asides whenever Joe is expressing his displeasure with someone or a certain turn of events.

Advertisement

The third season paired these monologues with flashbacks to dig deep into what made Joe tick, as well as serve as parallels to present day events in the show. Audiences got more insight into Joe's troubled childhood, abandonment by his mother and how his experience with his boys' home nurse shaped him into who he is in the present.

His new obsession with Marienne and his discovery of her troubled life made Joe realize that he is drawn to women who have endured abuse in their lives due to his own complicated relationship with his mother, herself a victim of abuse.

This revelation may have been obvious to most viewers, but Joe has never been the self-aware type. So it remains to be seen if this will lead to a Joe who is more honest with himself or will he continue to justify his violent and invasive actions.

5. Matthew And Theo

Matthew and Theo Engler were some of the more welcome additions to the series, as the death of Natalie (their wife and step-mother, respectively) sparked very different reactions from the father-son duo and set them on a collision course with the Quinn-Goldberg couple.

Advertisement

Joe and Matthew briefly bonded over fatherhood during the former's bout with the measles but this burgeoning pairing was quickly stomped by the latter's realization that Joe and Natalie were closer than expected.

Theo, on the other hand was enamoured with Love who initally rebuffed the young Engler's advances but ultimately gave in due to feeling neglected by her husband. This proved to be Theo's undoing as he attempted to free the Conrads from their imprisonment but was knocked out by a desperate Love.

Fortunately, he survived the attack and the season ended with the Englers slowly mending fences. Out of all the loose ends left in Madre Linda, they pose the biggest threat in Madre Linda due to their knowledge of Natalie's death and Matthew's deep connections in the world of surevillance.

4. Will Joe Find Someone New To Fixate On?

One trait that has come to define Joe Goldberg is his ever-changing interests in women. From Candace, to Beck, Love, Natalie and now Marienne, You's protagonist cannot seem to stick to one love interest.

Advertisement

This has often been a liability to Joe, but a source of great entertainment for audiences and one of the show's strongest narrative devices. However, as Joe grows as a person (however slowly and misguided), it begs the question of whether he will stick to Marienne or find someone new that he would literally kill for.

It has been established that it does not take much for Joe to fall head over heels for someone so it is entirely possible that he may walk into a Parisian café and be enamoured with one of the staff or a customer.

That said, he did go to great lengths to secure his reunion with Marienne so it would feel anticlimactic if he chose to go for someone else despite his new relationship having significant narrative potential.

3. Will Joe Ever Get To See Henry Again?

The addition of Henry Forty Quinn-Goldberg to the overall story took the third season in an interesting direction relative to its predecessors as it simultaneously gave Love and Joe reasons to work on their relationship but also end it.

Advertisement

Unhealthy marital dynamics aside, Joe genuinely loved Henry and was willing to change his murderous ways to be an emotionally available and providing father. The relationship may have been shaky at due to Henry's discomfort and Joe's desire for his son to have been a daughter but it was only a matter of time before the pair formed a strong bond.

Unfortunately, all that had to end due to Joe murdering Love and faking his own death. This forced him to leave Henry with his colleague Dante as he fled for Paris. It remains to be seen if Joe will come back for his son, as he wished to be there in his son's life but also felt that Dante and his partner would make better parents than he could ever be.

2. Is Love Still Alive?

Arguably one of the more out there points of speculation, the question of whether Love survived her fiery demise is undoubtedly intriguing to think about, even if it is based on rather shaky justification.

Advertisement

Having been subjected to the same poison that she injected Joe with, Love was left helpless in her house as it came down on her in a blaze. This sounds like a rather definitive death, but at the same time we did not see her body being engulfed by the flames, so this leaves the door open for her return.

However, even if You chooses to engage this well-worn trope, surviving being paralyzed in a burning house is a stretch, even for this show. That said, Love has been established as being able to predict Joe's moves so it stands to reason that she may have ingested the antidote just as he did and crawl out to safety.

In addition to this, there is precedence with Joe not being thorough with his murders (Candace, anyone?) so in a show as wild as You, it is entirely possible for Love to survive and be a source of pain and terror for Joe in season 4.

1. Can The Show Maintain Its Entertainingly Bonkers Energy?

You has never shied away from embracing absurdity, and this has helped it become one of Netflix's strongest guilty pleasures and be part of pop culture discourse over its three year run. This absurdity is anchored by a strong cast, amusing dialogue and unsubtle but appreciated commentary on upper middle-class American millennials.

Advertisement

However, can the show run on this indefinitely? A fourth season is definitely a welcome addition to the You canon (it is the whole point of this article after all) but at what point will the twists and thrills become predictable, stale or too unbelievable?

To its credit, the show has been able to reinvent itself even as it centers on a rather flat protagonist so it stands to reason that the fourth season will continue the momentum built over three years. The hope is that the show does not resort to shock value in favour of careful plotting and risk jumping the shark and undoing years worth of goodwill.

Advertisement