10 Absolute Worst Gimmicks In Wrestling Today
Aliens, ninjas and kings; there are some seriously wretched gimmicks around at the moment.
How important is a good gimmick in professional wrestling?
It is a difficult question to answer. Performers don't necessarily need a good gimmick to be a success after all. Pro wrestling history is full of megastars whose gimmicks didn't extend beyond the old 'your own personality turned up to 11' cliche. If you have the talent, the confidence and the luck, a good gimmick isn't necessarily that important.
A good gimmick isn't so important, but a bad gimmick can be utterly fatal to the career and fortunes of a professional wrestler. Find yourself saddled with a lame-duck persona and your credibility can be torn to shreds, leading to a career regression that many struggle to recover from. There are more of these in those same history books than the success stories; just ask Mantaur, Friar Ferguson, TL Hopper or The Goon.
Those names are part of wrestling history, but the current landscape has its fair share of stinkers. A need to stand out has led to a number of particularly wretched gimmicks making their way onto television, with both WWE and AEW at fault on a number of occasions. All bad gimmicks are awful, but some are more awful than others...
10. Brandi Rhodes
Does Brandi Rhodes have a gimmick, or is the problem that she has too many? One week she is a cocky heel, the next she is the brave woman protecting her family. She cuts promos as if she was a wily veteran, yet backs it up with youthful exuberance. She seems to carry her action figure with her wherever she goes, despite not doing anything that justifies the figure's existence. Brandi Rhodes is all things at once, meaning she is none of them at all.
In fact, her gimmick seems to be that she eats at the top table and thus can be all things she wants to be, at all times. She clearly wants to be taken seriously as an in-ring competitor but it is way cooler to do that as a blurred-lines badass, so a blurred-lines badass she is. When the Nightmare Family is under attack, all signs of that heel badass are gone, replaced by valiance and bravery.
By portraying childish versions of everyone's favourite wrestling personas, Brandi Rhodes has become a performer without a character, with a mess of a gimmick that confuses and irritates. The sooner she settles, the better.
9. King Corbin
Poor old Baron Corbin just can't catch a break. A longtime martyr for the poor state of WWE programming, Corbin has lurched from one uninspired feud to another, constantly getting blamed for monotonous matches and dull TV. Corbin's improvements seem to go unnoticed, ignored. That he has developed into a more than serviceable television wrestler seems to have gone over the heads of many viewers.
None of that changes the ridiculousness of the king gimmick. The poisoned crown of royalty sits heavy on the head of Big Banter Baron. Shorn of his rough and ready edges, the pompous form of aristocracy is not a fit for the former United States Champion, and it even seems to have cursed this writer with grandiose language. Baron Corbin is a tough dude, not a king.
Besides, why are we still seeing people get saddled with the king gimmick in 2020? There are no benefits to it whatsoever, and the sooner Corbin sheds it the better for all involved.
Saying that, King Corbin is infinitely better than Constable Corbin. Why can't he go back to being indie-hating banter merchant Baron Corbin?
8. Robert Stone
Whether or not it is a Tony Khan parody remains up in the air, but is there a less effective character on WWE today than Robert Stone? He turned up one day talking about his brand, a brand that has coddled together approximately bugger-all victories in its time on NXT. As of right now, the Robert Stone Brand consists of the man himself and Aliyah, a seven-year veteran who repeatedly stands out as the least improved performer on the roster.
If Robert Stone is indeed a parody of Tony Khan, who cares? Wrestling history is full of parodies of the competition, petty renderings of powerful people designed to belittle and reduce, almost all of which have been largely forgettable and unsuccessful. Why would Stone be any different? The existence of Robert Stone makes zero difference to how well or how poorly AEW does, in any way at all.
All that is true, but it doesn't make childish renderings of powerful people any less of a misstep. The man stuck in the gimmick is doing a sterling job of it, but the limitations and the transparency of it are clear for all to see.
7. Shorty G
Shorty G and articles about misused talent, bad gimmicks and WWE not having a clue what it is doing; name a more iconic combination, I'll wait.
That might not be how the meme works, but how in the blue hell is Chad Gable still floundering in WWE purgatory as Shorty G? The joke wasn't funny from inception, and it certainly isn't funny more than a year later. Gable is an Olympian, a legitimate wrestling genius with charisma for days, yet he's stuck doing job duty in a gimmick that is beneath him. It is a gimmick that should be beneath any and all professional wrestlers.
Shorty G is the sort of gimmick one gets as a punishment, but there doesn't seem to be a legitimate reason as to why Gable might get the harsh treatment. Was he too good at suplexing people? As long as he is saddled with this horrific gimmick, Chad Gable will continue to be the most misused talent on the entire WWE roster.
Oh, to go back to those days when American Alpha seemed set to revolutionise tag team wrestling in WWE.
6. Dexter Lumis
The creep from the creep farm. There are a lot of unwritten rules in both professional wrestling and television, but one is almost certainly universal; silent pseudo-serial killers should not be portrayed as babyface heroes on television.
Okay, so that might not exactly be an unwritten rule, and Dexter Lumis hasn't actually killed a bunch of people, but the point stands. There are a lot of reasons to throw shade at NXT in 2020, but the fact that there was a moment when Dexter Lumis was arguably the brand's biggest babyface may just be the biggest of them all.
Lumis has a unique look, that much is undeniable, but the rest of the gimmick stinks. The Tortured Artist doesn't speak and barely sells, yet people will still crow that far more talented performers don't get the push they deserve because they 'can't cut promos'. If your boy doesn't speak and can't sell, what hope is there? The gimmick may have brought Lumis to television, but it has almost immediately left him in a creative straightjacket.
Yes, there is a pun in there.
Modern television's desperation with having edgy good guys and blurring the lines between good and bad has a lot to answer for. Dexter Lumis is just the latest dud character to come out of that jarring trend.
5. Akira Tozawa
Akira Tozawa is currently portraying a ninja who may or may not have been eaten by a shark on a recent episode of WWE RAW. That is surely all that you need to know?
WWE's talent-heavy roster has led to some seriously impressive professional wrestlers getting saddled with nonsense gimmicks in the hope of consistent television appearances, which is the only plausible explanation as to why the ultra-talented Akira Tozawa has been randomly portraying a ninja for the last few months.
A former WWE Cruiserweight Champion, Akira Tozawa deserves more than his current lot, although that should be true of almost everyone that has ever been eaten by a shark. The comedy role may be the easiest ticket in pro wrestling but Tozawa is better than his current spot.
More importantly, the ninja gimmick is death, a character from a different time that made little sense in its own heydey. It is far too open to humiliation and jokes of questionable origin, far too easy to ridicule and far too easy to book in a cruelly offensive manner.
Ninjas! Come on WWE, you're better than that.
4. Kris Statlander
Kris Statlander is an alien. There, that's all there is to it, why was Jim Ross so confused? She's an alien, no need to ask more questions.
Okay, but we are yet to prove the existence of aliens, so is she a missing link? Shouldn't she be on international news, not duking it out in a professional wrestling promotion? I'm no science major, but actual living proof of an alien comes off as something that might be considered a big deal. Not that AEW's women's division isn't a big deal, but it doesn't quite compare to, you know, the biggest scientific breakthrough of modern history.
Oh, she's just portraying an alien, okay. Why? None of this has been explained. Granted, not everything in professional wrestling needs to be explained, but this seems like something that could benefit from even the tiniest bit of backstory. Her name is Kris Statlander, which doesn't sound particularly alien-like, either.
Statlander could develop into a serious player in the world of professional wrestling, but she sure as heck ain't going to do while portraying a poorly-conceived alien with little to no backstory.
3. Michael Nakazawa
In the cartoon world of independent wrestling, a character like Michael Nakazawa could be a lot of fun. The baby oil is wacky, the man has great facial expressions and the whole schtick is tailor-made for getting a laugh in the confined environment of a gym or a leisure centre. It is an indie gimmick, and there is nothing wrong with that.
The problems arise once that gimmick finds its way onto national television. Rewind back to Double or Nothing, the first official AEW pay-per-view, and the Casino Battle Royale that opened the Buy-In pre-show. In a battle royal that included some weird gimmicks Nakazawa sticks out like a sore thumb, a change-the-channel gimmick in a world that needed to establish itself before anything else.
Many of the gimmicks on this list are largely harmless, creative missteps that do more damage to individual careers than the fates of companies. Not so with Nakazawa; his is a gimmick that turns viewers off and damages AEW's overall credibility.
Amazing what the liberal application of baby oil can do to the way a wrestling company is perceived and enjoyed.
2. RAW Underground
Is RAW Underground dead? One can only hope. Utterly directionless and void of any purpose, Shane McMahon's underground fight club has been fully deserving of every bit of ridicule that has come its way. Even if it has been giving the kibosh after a relatively short time on our screens, it will forever be remembered as another lame creative misstep by 21st century WWE.
A weird mix of Fight Club, Brawl For All and modern-day WWE, RAW Underground has achieved nothing outside of belittling the sanctioned matches that take place on the rest of the show. Are we supposed to believe that these 'shoot' fights are of any meaning? If Dolph Ziggler can truck fools in a ring without ropes, why is he unable to transpose that success into the more streamlined nature of official competition? Are fans supposed to think that these fights are real and that the ones we've been watching all these years are not?
Putting aside the whole 'none of it is real' thing, RAW Underground has muddied waters and made a mockery of both itself and the show it claims to be an alternative to. Worst of all, it has brought Shane McMahon back to WWE TV.
1. RETRIBUTION
Even before the wacky names, RETRIBUTION was a bust. The influence behind the gimmick is as clear as day, a transparent bit of playground backchatting that is as poorly-constructed as it is childishly conceived. In short, Vince McMahon is a wealthy man who is too ignorant to understand why people around the world take to the streets to protest inequality and social injustice. Enter RETRIBUTION.
The group has some serious talent within its ranks. Mustafa Ali has long been considered one of the most misused performers on the roster, while Dominic Dijakovic has had no shortage of great matches in recent years. The same can be said of Mia Yim, and Shane Thorne has proven himself to be a more than reliable performer between the ropes. Dio Maddin is tall.
But no amount of talent will save this. The McMahon family is just about as far removed from the issues that people protest and RETRIBUTION is the result, an embarrassingly childish attempt at relevance, complete with logical issues and wacky camera shaking. The men and women in the group are tremendous performers, but there is no worse gimmick in the world of professional wrestling today.