10 Awesome Gimmicks Wasted On Terrible Wrestlers
For these 10, in-ring work did not enhance their characters...
Gimmicks in wrestling can be awesome as long as the man behind the character can work a compelling, enthralling match. The Undertaker, Mr. Perfect, Mankind, The Hurricane and Val Venis are a handful of gimmicks that worked because they were as believable between the ropes as they were on the mic or in introductory video packages.
Not every case was quite so successful.
Over the last 20 years, the sports-entertainment world has been home to some awesome gimmicks wasted on awful wrestlers, their effectiveness within the wrestling community hampered by the less-than thrilling work in competition.
In some instances, the wrestler was past his or her prime, a shell of the Superstar that previously captivated fans. In others, they were never what one would call a particularly skilled worker in the first place.
Whatever the case may be, their inability to impress when the bell sounded significantly lessened their impact with audiences.
These are just 10 examples in an endless line of them.
10. David Flair
There was plenty to hate about the end of WCW, including the way David Flair was forced into an on-screen role despite being largely unprepared and untrained. Yet, the second-generation competitor underwent a character change, segueing from golden boy to deranged, crowbar-swinging psychopath. Suddenly, his presence on Nitro and Thunder was more tolerable. The switch worked, getting the son of wrestling royalty over with audiences in a way he had never been.
With Crowbar and Daffney flanking him, Flair became a tag team champion and a staple of WCW programming. He was part of surreal storylines, including one in which he accused Buff Bagwell of being the father of former fiancee Stacy Keibler's child. No matter how much airtime he got or how many industry greats he shared the ring with, he simply could not back it all up from bell to bell.
Luckily, he had a tag team partner in Crowbar (known industry wide as Devon Storm) to help carry him in higher profile matches. Otherwise, the cool and wildly different gimmick would not have been enough to justify the television time invested in him.
9. Papa Shango
Papa Shango was a freaking voodoo doctor who lit opponents on fire and caused the top babyfaces in WWE to ooze black blood. How cool is that?
From the awesome makeup job to the special effects that accompanied the character, Shango was an attempt to capitalize on the success of The Undertaker, a dark and supernatural being who had connected with fans.
While the look and presence of the character was strong, the actual in-ring presentation was not. Charles Wright, who would go onto great success as 2016 Hall of Fame inductee The Godfather, was a green powerhouse whose performances between the ropes failed to live up to the hype. A series of comically bad battles with The Ultimate Warrior did not help matters.
Just over a year after the dangerous doctor of the dark arts arrived, he was gone and Wright was onto a considerably less-awesome gimmick: The Supreme Fighting Machine, Kama.
8. The West Texas Rednecks
Curt Hennig is one of the best professional wrestlers of all-time. Barry Windham is, arguably, one of the most natural performers in the industry's long and illustrious history. For as great as they were, there is little denying the fact that 1999 was not a particularly great year for them between the ropes.
Dubbed The West Texas Rednecks in the heat of a rivalry with rapper Master P, The No Limit Soldiers, Rey Mysterio and Konnan, the duo looked to be having the most fun they had in years. They were hilarious, strumming guitars to their "hit" song "Rap Is Crap" during a live performance. Together, Hennig and Windham, alongside Bobby Duncam Jr. and Kendall Windham, gleefully tore down the rap industry in a series of matches, vignettes and promos that remain one of the bright spots of that year's programming.
Unfortunately, neither Hennig nor Windham were remotely close to the workers they were earlier in their careers. In fact, it was in working with Mysterio and Konnan that their weaknesses and age were exposed. Hennig was out of shape, Windham out of cares and the result was an awesome gimmick wasted on poor workers.
Though, it may never have gotten over to the extent it did without the former Mr. Perfect hamming it up away from the squared circle.
7. The Boogeyman
Had the man behind the face paint been even a remotely competent professional wrestler, The Boogeyman could have been one hell of a sideshow gimmick in professional wrestling. The presentation was outstanding, the entrance was electric and the character was far more over than it had any right to be.
For the man behind the gimmick, wrestling was never really a strong suit. Marty Wright could eat worms with the best of them and completely immersed himself in the character, but his in-ring game was similar to that of a rookie backyard wrestler. Outside of traditional power holds and maneuvers, he floundered.
In fact, it was a lack of in-ring skill beyond the basics that robbed Boogeyman of a longer run with WWE. He very well could have been similar to Kane and Undertaker, two supernatural characters destined to remain over due to the uniqueness of their personas. Instead, he went the way of the dinosaurs.
He still pops up on WWE Network from time-to-time, making cameos on Swerved and The Edge and Christian Show That Totally Reeks of Awesomeness.
6. Kevin Thorn
The Kevin Thorn character was a reactionary creation on the part of a WWE writing staff looking to appease SyFy network, who had recently acquired rights to the relaunched ECW brand. Searching for a supernatural gimmick to fit the mold of the channel, WWE Creative dreamed up Thorn, a brooding vampire straight out of a 1996 Hot Topic catalog.
Perhaps it was the fact that he was flanked by a smoking hot vampiress named Ariel, who also happened to be a fortune teller, but Thorn was cool despite an overabundance of eyeliner and hair product.
While he was far from a bad worker, he never excelled past "solid hand" status. His failure to incorporate the gimmick into his in-ring performance certainly hurt, too. Thorn understood the theatrical significance of the character but never became the worker one would hope for out of someone who spent so much time in developmental.
In 2008, he was quietly released from his contract, his potential never released.
Had Thorn come along two years after he did, he would have been huge. Vampires were everywhere thanks to the spectacular crap show that was Twilight and Vince McMahon would have pushed him to the moon, regardless of his ability.
5. Muhammad Hassan
Muhammad Hassan was an awesome character, in theory at least.
In a hostile, post-9/11 United States where Arab-Americans faced daily prejudices, labeled terrorists by uninformed hate mongers, Hassan reminded fans that he was an American citizen, that he was born in the country and deserved the same respect as everyone else.
Except, no one wanted to cheer him, no matter the validity of his statements. He looked like the enemy and no pleas for common decency would change that fact.
The character lost its uniqueness and Hassan became a generic foreign heel in a long line of them. It was okay, though, because it became apparent rather quickly that Hassan was not a terribly talented professional wrestler. His move set was generic and his in-ring charisma was nonexistent.
Never before were his weaknesses more obvious than at Backlash in May 2005, in the biggest match of his career, where he was overshadowed by on-screen associate Daivari in a loss to Shawn Michaels and Hulk Hogan.
The character may have been intriguing but the man behind it simply was not good enough to carry it to the heights it probably should have reached, though poor timing and another international tragedy had something to do with it.
4. Big Poppa Pump
There was a time in his career when Scott Steiner was considered the next great main event prospect. With a physique chiseled from stone and an athleticism matched by few, he had all of the tools necessary to achieve greatness inside the squared circle.
Years of wear and tear left his body a mangled mess by the time 1998 arrived, though. Once one of the most dynamic performers in the industry, Steiner was relegated to punches, kicks and the most generic power moves imaginable. His in-ring game suffered tremendously.
It is for that reason his development of the Big Poppa Pump character was even more disappointing. The loudmouth, womanizing, sexually dominant persona captivated fans and stood out amid the white-bread, generic characters that had made up WCW at the time. He was brash, cocky and the enemy of Standards and Practices at Turner Broadcasting.
He was edgy, unpredictable and dangerous, a trifecta the 18-35 demographic appreciated in their wrestlers during the Monday Night Wars. Unfortunately for Steiner and his millions of fans, he was unable to back up the engaging promos and Big Bad Booty Daddy nickname with anything resembling a good match. Like so many WCW main event competitors, his credibility as a headliner was hurt by his inability to back up the act with a quality in-ring performance.
More style than substance, Steiner's run atop WCW as it neared its death remains entertaining only for his off-the-cuff promos.
3. Sable
Sable was so incredibly sexy that it is often forgotten just how awesome her character was.
Originally a valet in the same vein as Miss Elizabeth, she accompanied real life husband "Wildman" Marc Mero to the ring. When he went down with a knee injury, she remained a fixture on WWE television, gaining a fan following that suddenly had her atop the wrestling world, one of its most popular stars. Mero, now known as "Marvelous," was jealous of his manager's success and began belittling her on a weekly basis.
Sable generated a great deal of sympathy but, at the same time, would not allow herself to be degraded by a man. Eventually, she stood up for herself, breaking free of the oppressive rule of the former intercontinental champion. She even dropped him with a Sable Bomb in a moment that drew an enormous pop.
Now a star on the level of Steve Austin, Sable became a mainstream celebrity and one of the must-see performers of WWE's Attitude Era. The blonde bombshell was riding a tidal wave of momentum until management decided to resurrect the Women's Championship and make her the centerpiece of the new division.
While she had been extraordinary in a few mixed tag team matches in which her male counterparts could carry the action until she entered the ring and hit a few signature moves, there was no man to hide behind. As a more traditional in-ring performer, her weaknesses were exposed and it became abundantly clear just how bad a professional wrestler Sable actually was.
A sure-fire Hall of Famer thanks to her numerous contributions to WWE during its most popular era, her place in history is preserved, as is her reputation as one of the worst wrestlers to ever be handed an awesome, strong, independent character.
2. Waylon Mercy
Based on 1991's Cape Fear, Waylon Mercy was a soft-spoken, disturbing villain who was every bit as dangerous as he was charming. Debuting in a series of pre-taped vignettes, the character captivated fans, the peace in his words offset by the danger in his eyes.
Unfortunately the man behind Mercy was Dan Spivey, a veteran of the ring game whose best days as a performer were well behind him. Known best for his days as one-half of The Skyscrapers with Sid Vicious in WCW, Spivey had competed in WWE before, but not since the 1980s. Years of wear and tear had robbed him of in-ring quality.
Spivey was a shell of his former self by 1995 and an injury suffered early into his run as Mercy doomed the character to failure.
There is no telling just how successful the character would have been. The mid-1990s was a wasteland of horrendous gimmicks, mostly of the occupational variety. Mercy was different but audiences routinely rejected on-screen personas not born in reality. It is likely the Max Cady ripoff would have suffered the same fate.
1. Sean O'Haire
Late in 2002, Sean O'Haire debuted on SmackDown via a series of vignettes in which he spoke intimately with the WWE fans. Rather than inspiring them to do good, he spoke to their human nature. He insisted they partake in the seven deadly sins, a grin on his face and a glimmer in his eye while doing so. He appealed to the younger males in the audience, most of whon enjoyed morally questionable characters who broke the mold of the prototypical good and bad guys.
The character was so good, and O'Haire had shown such promise during his days in WCW, that it felt like an idea guaranteed to succeed.
The problem was, O'Haire was never the singles worker that he was in tag team competition. Without the chance to explode into the ring off of a hot tag, delivering his high-impact offense and finishing foes with this Seanton Bomb, he was exposed as the limited worker with little experience that he was.
Add to that the fact that he could not cut a promo outside of a pre-taped environment and you had a recipe for disaster.
The final nail in the character's coffin? His status as a lackey for Roddy Piper during the 6,000th program between Hot Rod and Hulk Hogan in 2003.
But I'm not telling you anything you don't already know.