10 Awesome Wrestlers Who Left WWE FAR Too Soon

Kairi Sane, Kaitlyn, Austin Aries - who else left WWE before their time?

By Michael John-Day /

The brightest stars often burn out the fastest.

Advertisement

World Wrestling Entertainment likes to think of itself as the be-all and end-all of the wrestling world. There was a time when this almost rang true, as the mark of being a successful wrestler was to have your name associated with the promotion.

Now, in 2021, WWE is not the only shop in town.

It often feels like the company's top brass looks at its stars and feels they should be grateful for having the opportunity to work in Stamford. Despite this, there are plenty of times when WWE performers have cut their time with the company short and decided to strike out their own. This is often great for them, as many have transformed their careers in the process, but it's a shame they weren't able to do this within the world's biggest promotion.

Whether it was by choice or not, the following wrestlers ended up leaving the company way before the audience had a chance to see them at their best. It's a real shame, but at least in most cases they went on to take control of their careers, and have seen greener pastures outside of WWE.

10. Colt Cabana (Scotty Goldman)

Sadly for the incredibly talented Colt Cabana, his time with WWE was cut short due to their clear lack of faith in him, and he was gone from the company before he was able to bring any of his signature charms.

Advertisement

Cabana signed with WWE in 2007 after working on the independent circuit for over five years. He floated around OVW and later FCW for some time before making his main roster debut for SmackDown, and instantly loosing to The Brian Kendrick. Sadly, this would become a quick identifier of the kind of career he would go on to have with WWE.

After losing a handful more matches, Colt he was released from the company, having only served under the WWE name for two years, with most of that time spent offscreen.

Anyone who knows of his great work in ROH and beyond is aware that Cabana is an incredibly unique wrestling presence. His focus on witty comedy wrestling could have had a great place in the land of sports entertainment, but it was cut short way before its time. At least fans have his podcast and AEW to get their Cabana fix.

9. Austin Aries

Aries is undoubtedly a divisive figure in the wrestling world, as many people herald him as a sublime performer while others think of him as an overrated and arrogant personality (understandable, given his social media activity). Whatever your opinions are, there is no denying that he certainly makes an impact wherever he goes. So with that being said, why was Aries' time with WWE so lacklustre?

Advertisement

The former TNA World Heavyweight Champion spent one year and seven months with the company. He had a somewhat strong NXT run and would eventually end up working within the cruiserweight division on Raw and 205 Live, but even in that smaller WWE branch, he never found much success and failed in his Cruiserweight Championship pursuits.

Although many people believed that Aries left the company due to frustrations with his position on the card, he was in fact released from his contract. In an interview with Chris Van Vliet Aries stated that the WWE writing staff "didn't have anything for him" and this is what led to his departure.

Despite his lack of impact within the company, it's still such a waste of potential to have seen the established wrestler only operate with them for the better half of two years.

8. EC3

EC3 has a unique place on this list, as he has left WWE before reaching his full potential on two separate occasions: once as Derrick Bateman and the second as EC3. Both of these departures were disappointing, but his second truly stands out, as the former FCW native had reinvented himself after his initial WWE release and looked set to show WWE how much better he had become.

Advertisement

After leaving the Derrick Bateman character behind, he adopted the moniker of EC3 and became a massive TNA presence under Dixie Carter. He was a bright spot in the company despite the rough patches it was going through, and fans were thrilled to learn that he would be returning to the land of WWE, after parting ways with Impact.

In his second run with the company, EC3 started showing the NXT crowd what his new persona was capable of, and although he didn't capture any championship gold, he proved why he should be taken seriously. Sadly, once making it to the main roster, he was lost in the shuffle and became a regular contender for the 24/7 title until his release after cost-cutting last year.

EC3 only lasted two years in his second WWE run, and that is woefully disappointing.

7. Zelina Vega

There is a genuine sadness to this entry, as Zelina Vega's departure from WWE has some significant ramifications and revelations about the dynamic between the company and its performers.

Advertisement

Thea Trinidad was reportedly fired from WWE due to her vocal protestations against WWE's ban on third-party platform use. Seeing the incredibly talented star dropped from the company after loyally serving them for three years was incredibly unfortunate, and knowing that it centred on WWE's stranglehold over its wrestlers makes it worse.

Excluding her sad dismissal, the loss of Vega was a huge waste of potential in itself. Fans never got to see a lot of her in-ring action within WWE, as she acted as a valet for Andrade for the majority of her time with NXT and the main roster. But even in that position, it was impossible to keep your eyes off of her utterly engaging presence, as she was full of energy and vibrancy.

It's a shame that fans never got the chance to fully see her operate as a wrestler, seeing as her time in TNA was thoroughly impressive and showed what a bright future she had. Hopefully she can get back into wrestling once her non-compete expires.

6. Monty Brown (Marcus Cor Von)

It is heartbreaking to look back on the hypothetical career that Monty Brown could have had with WWE, as very few wrestlers have ever possessed such a magnetic blend of skill and charisma.

Advertisement

After his American Football career ended due to an ankle injury, Brown chose to pursue a professional wrestling career. Two years after making his in-ring debut, he found himself working for TNA, and although it got off to a rocky start, he eventually became a prominent roster member.

When he joined WWE, it was part of the newly revived ECW. While the show paled compared to its previous incarnation, there was at least plenty of spotlight shone on the new stars thanks to the New Breed stable, which featured Marcus as a significant member. Seeing him go up against ECW legends like Balls Mahoney, Tommy Dreamer, RVD and coming out victorious showed how the company could see a potential star in the making.

Unfortunately, his departure from WWE was an incredibly sad tale, as he left the company after his sister tragically passed away. Brown then made the heroic decision to retire from the wrestling business to take care of her children. Although it's easy to look back and wish he'd reached his full potential, the decision to prioritise family over his career was undeniably admirable.

5. Kaitlyn

Talk about someone who came, saw, conquered and subsequently left.

Advertisement

Kaitlyn was only part of WWE for roughly four years, but in that time she got over with the fans, won the third season of NXT and became the Divas Champion, holding the belt for 153 days. Despite this success, she left the promotion in 2014 to retire from wrestling and pursue other avenues.

The early days of NXT were a far cry from the successful brand that it has become today, yet it did produce some promising wrestlers, and Kaitlyn was one of the most memorable. Fans really got behind this performer, as Kaitlyn had a great look that contrasted the rest of the women's division and she had a devastating spear that outclassed many of her peers' finishing moves at the time.

After she chose to leave WWE and retire from in-ring work, she returned for one-off appearances on the independent circuit, and even re-joined WWE for a short spell as part of the 2018 Mae Young Classic, defeating Kavita Devi before losing to Mia Yim.

Seeing her back in the ring was a testament to how much fans could have had if she'd stuck around longer, as the women's division is so much stronger now, and seeing Kaitlyn become a part of it would have been amazing.

4. AJ Lee

There was a time when AJ Lee really was the women's division, as her dominant reigns, popularity and stellar in-ring performances were often a highlight on Raw. She played many roles within her time, from wrestler to Raw General Manager, wowing audiences everywhere with her commitment and character work.

Advertisement

Lee was only part of the main roster from 2011 to 2015, but she won the Divas Championship three times and became well-acclaimed by fans and critics alike. Despite her success, the women's division was still lacking any severity, and always felt underappreciated by the company during this period.

In her book, Crazy is my Superpower, AJ talked about how she made the decision to retire from wrestling thanks to cervical spine damage, and the fact she had achieved all she set out to. She also mentioned that she "felt caught in the middle" between her husband CM Punk and the company after his controversial departure. This likely also bore some significance behind her decision to leave the company behind.

Although she left on her own terms, it's still a shame, because if Lee had hung out for longer she, like Kaitlyn, could have been a part of the women's evolution, which she helped to pave the way for.

3. Low Ki (Kaval)

Kaval, better known to most as Low Ki, could have been a big-time WWE player. Although he looked small compared to his contemporaries, he was an absolute striking force and had a look that made him instantly stand out on the roster, but sadly, his time in the company would not live up to the reputation he had garnered for himself in TNA and the independent circuit.

Advertisement

Despite winning the second season of NXT and looking like he might have some support behind him, Kaval was devastated on the main roster by loss after loss. One particularly damaging defeat saw him lose his place on the SmackDown Bragging Rights Team to Tyler Reks after being beaten in a singles match against him. His character also lacked any respect, as he used his guaranteed title match - which he received after winning NXT season two - on the Intercontinental Championship, and didn't even win it.

Low Ki deserved much better, and although he didn't make any traction in the company, it was still clear to viewers that he was a great presence in the SmackDown line-up. Therefore, when he was released in 2010 having only been in the company since 2008, it caused a lot of aggravation amongst his fans.

2. Kairi Sane

The 'Pirate Princess' had such potential to be a massive babyface star. She had excellent matches, a tremendous and unique gimmick, and was universally beloved, but, as is often the way with NXT main roster call-ups, WWE never pulled the trigger on a significant push for her. The inaugural Mae Young Classic winner announced in 2020 that she would be leaving WWE to move back to Japan, cutting her time with the company drastically short.

Advertisement

WWE missed the ball on this one, as Sane's impressive main roster debut was met with tonnes of excitement, and pairing her up with Asuka felt like a quick way to get her over outside of the developmental brand. They never quite ran with her, as she was kept in this team - The Kabuki Warriors - for the entirety of her run, and never got the chance to become the massive singles star she could have been.

It is truly devastating that there were no fans in attendance to bid the unforgettable Kairi farewell. Still, she is probably much happier having moved back to Japan, living a great life with her husband, and helping the WWE Japan branch as a trainer, ambassador and occasional commentator.

1. James Storm

James Storm left WWE before he had even signed a contract, making him the quickest departure from the company within this list.

Advertisement

A former TNA World Champion and a great wrestler, 'Cowboy' feels like a mixture of 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels with a splash of Spaghetti Westerns thrown in. Therefore his exit from WWE NXT after taking part in only two matches - both victories - was a massive disappointment.

Storm is a fine example of the fact that WWE is not the only option out there for people, and for some isn't even the best. In the case of this former Beer Money member, he was offered a contract with WWE and stated in an episode of Busted Open Radio that they were confident he would have gotten over, but he turned the offer down as he and his wife were planning on having another child, and he wanted to be home as much as he could.

Although this was the right decision for him, it did mean that his time with the company was blink and you'll miss it, and he had left before he'd even properly joined. There must be an alternative universe somewhere which saw him become a significant WWE star, but it seems that this reality will never see such a place.

Advertisement