10 Best WWE Royal Rumble Performers (Who Never Won The Rumble)
Winning is overrated - these guys stole the show.
The end of the holidays is always bittersweet. On the one hand, it’s back to work for most of us, with a gruelling midwinter to wade through. On the other: Royal Rumble season is officially upon us!
The Rumble is the calendar highlight for many wrestling fans, and if done right it can be huge news for the lucky winner. In recent years, Drew McIntyre’s main eventer ticket has been punched by a well booked win, and Becky Lynch, Seth Rollins, and many more have done similarly well after the event.
But what about those whose hands aren’t raised at the end of the Rumble? WWE’s past and present roster is full of stars who never won the Rumble (though some may yet), but have nonetheless made names for themselves through the top rope showdown.
While these wrestlers may not have gotten the nod from management for the year’s first (and best) pay per view, they saw an opportunity to break off a little piece of the spotlight for themselves, be it in one particular Rumble or over the course of their careers, and they grabbed it with both hands (before both feet ultimately touched the ground, thereby eliminating them).
10. Mick Foley
As is his wont, Mick Foley approached the Royal Rumble with the same verve and inventiveness he did the rest of his wrestling career. While Foley floated around the top of the card during some great years for the Rumble, he was never given the nod to win the whole thing, but nonetheless lifted some flat events with his inimitable schtick.
Perhaps his finest year was 1998, a disappointing Rumble that amounted mostly to waiting for Stone Cold to finally make his entrance at 24 and win the thing. It was bolstered immensely by Foley, who entered in all three of his gimmicks, firstly opening the show as Cactus Jack, then appearing again as Mankind and Dude Love. Few wrestlers would be welcome to take up 10% of a Rumble - Foley is one of them.
His 2004 performance was also great, stealing Test’s spot so as to eliminate Randy Orton, as well as himself, thereby pushing forward their excellent feud. Whether as a novelty act or part of something more serious, Foley is, as ever, one of the best.
9. Beth Phoenix
The women’s Rumbles are as yet in their infancy, with only three under WWE’s belt so far. Beth Phoenix co-holds the record for the number of Rumble appearances, which isn’t so much to write about as she shares this with another 11 women.
What sets Phoenix apart from her cohorts at the top of the table is her 2010 appearance in the men’s Rumble. A few women have appeared in the men’s events, perhaps most notably Kharma, whose splashy entrance her subsequent WWE career sadly didn’t live up to.
Phoenix, though, tops the lot. 2010 was a great Rumble, with her brief but memorable appearance a high point. She made her shock entrance at #5, and did the WWE universe a big favour by quickly eliminating The Great Khali. She did so by smooching him to distract the giant, which is a bit regressive, but it got the job done all the same.
Since then she has made feel good comebacks in the modern iterations of the Rumble. Had the women’s event been around in her prime, no doubt she would have won it, but she left her mark on the competition all the same.
8. Goldust
While Dustin Rhodes’ past two years demonstrate he unequivocally did the right thing by going to AEW, it is a shame that Goldust will (probably) never again make a dramatic return at WWE’s finest pay per view, because no one did it better than he did.
With a 21 year span between Goldust’s first and last Rumbles (13 in all, tied for second most), his appearances in the competition are further evidence that Rhodes is one of the greatest professionals ever to lace up a pair of boots. Goldust would often make his returns at the Rumble, whether for a long time or just a good time, and the crowd would often react appropriately upon hearing the legend’s music.
WWE never took much notice of how over Goldust was, of course, but he encapsulates everything that’s great about the Rumble. Yes, the title shot is important, but we as fans want to see these blasts from the past. A large part of the event’s fun is that you never know just who’ll come out next, and when it’s Goldust, that’s always good news.
7. Natalya
Another member of the Three Rumbles club, Natalya has for many years been one of the most reliable women on WWE’s roster, and her usage in the Rumbles illustrates this. She holds the records for the longest time spent in a single women’s Rumble as well as cumulative minutes, and is as ever one of the most dependable women in the business.
Her finest moment came in 2019 when she put in a performance just shy of an hour, entering second and making it close to the very end, in the meantime escorting some untested performers like Lacey Evans and Mandy Rose through the opening stages of a quality event.
She had an impactful performance in the 2018 event, too, lasting half the time but eliminating three opponents, and appeared again at the 2020 Rumble.
She’s probably never going to win the event at this point, but as always Natalya can be called upon when needed to put in a great performance that flies under the radar while doing a lot of good for the product on the whole.
6. Daniel Bryan
Daniel Bryan shouldn’t be on this list. 2014 was the year of Bryan, and he had a great showing in the Rumble - in the opening match, against Bray Wyatt. That was a barn burner, but when Bryan failed to appear in the titular match, the Philly crowd reacted badly to say the least, booing Rey Mysterio of all people when he entered at #30.
In 2011, he kicked off the Rumble against CM Punk, an IWC dream that didn’t disappoint. Both put on a great show that can stand alongside pretty much any Royal Rumble starters. His greatest Rumble claim to fame was at the misnamed “Greatest” Royal Rumble in 2018, where Bryan broke the record for longest time spent in a single match at a lung busting 1:16.
2015’s disastrous main event flopped in no small part due to WWE’s mishandling of Daniel Bryan - the crowd really turned nasty when he was dumped after 10 minutes - and his legacy in the event is as much down to what he hasn’t done as what he has, but until he wins the event - and he could yet do it this year - he’ll cast a shadow over this PPV.
5. CM Punk
Another underappreciated legend who somehow never won the Rumble, CM Punk nevertheless made the event his own two years on the trot. The Rumble is all about those little moments and subplots, and in 2010 and 2011 Punk’s charisma and mic skills meant that the first chunk of each match belonged to him alone.
In 2010, as the Straight Edge Saviour, he dominated proceedings, entering at number 3, taking out Dolph Ziggler and Evan Bourne, and then cutting a pitch perfect heel promo on a receptive crowd. JTG then entered, was swiftly dispatched, and Punk got back to it. This was one of the most memorable verbal moments for a match built almost entirely on action. He was eventually eliminated by Triple H, which he was no doubt thrilled about.
In 2011 he was back at it. After that brilliant opening stretch with Bryan, he began to assemble his Nexus faction around him and looked like a genuine potential winner. He lasted 35 minutes, the longest of anyone, until ultimately getting the boot from John Cena - again, a job we bet he relished.
4. Shayna Baszler
Unless Baszler’s booking becomes so frustrating that she leaves the company, the former MMA fighter will undoubtedly win the Rumble in due course, and could well do so this year. Typical of a true combat athlete, Baszler’s activity in the Rumble has thus far been the picture of efficiency.
She has eliminated 8 women in a single Rumble, a record among her peers. In her career she has eliminated just one fewer competitor than the record holder, Charlotte. Not only has Baszler managed this in a single match, she has managed all of this in less than five minutes.
Baszler may have spent less time in a Rumble than the average Undertaker entrance, but good Lord has she made her presence felt. She was nothing short of terrifying in 2020’s event, entering at number 30 and immediately ruining the days of everyone she came into contact with. She probably should have won.
With her grit, craft, and believability, Baszler has taken to pro wrestling as well as anyone, and her Royal Rumble aptitude is a perfect example of this. She finished second last time out - you wouldn’t bet against her going one better this time around.
3. Kofi Kingston
Before Kofimania and his brief but bright world title run, before The New Day turned him into one of the company’s most bankable performers, Kofi Kingston cemented his status as a great worker thanks in no small part to the Royal Rumble.
Kingston was a must-watch feature of the flagship match for his saves, which had to be seen to be believed. Year upon year he’d be launched from the ring, only to cling on by means equal parts inventive, athletic, and fortuitous.
He’d land on his hands and “walk” his way to the steps. He’d be dumped on the guard rail then pull off a gravity defying jump back to the squared circle. In perhaps his finest moment, he commandeered JBL’s announce chair and pogoed his way to safety in a spot so joyous it even had the cantankerous commentator waxing lyrical about it for the rest of the match.
Kofi has also taken part in 13 Rumbles, joint second most, and may take that second spot for his own this year. The veteran performer shows no signs of slowing down, and if it’s probably too late for him to win one, he can rest easy knowing he was MVP of the Rumble for many years.
2. Chris Jericho
There’s a strong argument to be made that Jericho is pro wrestling’s all time GOAT, and while he’s not quite the finest performer ever to fall short in the Rumble, his multiple appearances in the event generated some highlights in a truly remarkable career.
Typical for Jericho, the Rumble has provided a little bit of everything. There are some incredible athletic performances, including the likes of 2016 and 2017, both of which saw Y2J in the Iron Man position. He has injected the event with his brand of genuinely funny comedy, and used the Rumble to further or reignite rivalries, like with Shawn Michaels in 2003 and Dolph Ziggler in 2013.
He can also claim ownership of one of the finest Final Two segments, against eventual winner Sheamus in 2012. Indeed most of the fans expected Jericho to win this tussle (and he perhaps should have), but the two put on a great mini contest to seal the Celtic Warrior’s ascendancy.
At 30 seconds shy of five hours, Jericho can claim the longest time spent in cumulative Rumbles, and it isn’t even close. While you’d have to think he has finally definitively burned his bridges with WWE, it’s tough to see that record getting beaten any time soon.
1. Kane
2001’s Rumble is a contender for the best ever, and a big part of that is the remarkable performance from Kane. At the peak of his powers (and in his best ever ring gear), the Big Red Machine tears through the competition in a believably terrifying fashion.
He gets to do a bit of everything here - smash a guitar over Honky Tonk Man’s head, hurl lower midcarders over the ropes with utter disdain, take a real scalp in The Rock, and finally face off with Stone Cold Steve Austin for an electric conclusion that could have gone either way.
As the most reliable pro in the business, it’s no surprise Kane holds the record at 19 Rumbles performed in. His current status is unknown, but Glenn Jacobs is in decent enough shape and could easily notch another Rumble or two before he finally hangs up the mask.
As a character, Kane never needed a Rumble win, but when he’s deployed in the Rumble, you know things are about to get real. With a record 43 elmininations to his name, it’s undeniable that Kane has brought a great deal to this most exhilarating of events.