10 Best WWE SummerSlam Main Events Ever - According To Dave Meltzer

Sunny Days.

By Michael Hamflett /

Though the August pay-per-view spectcaular hasn't ever produced a five star match in the eyes of Wrestling Observer doyen Dave Meltzer, the heat of summer hasn't quite melted all of his prestigious snowflakes.

Advertisement

As WWE approaches the thirtieth incarnation of the show with a product rich in match quality but starved of emotional investment, 2017's edition should get the required evocative injection in the Universal Title blockbuster featuring Champion Brock Lesnar defending against Samoa Joe, Roman Reigns and Braun Strowman.

The four have spent the past few months destroying one another in matches and segments that have routinely been highlights of Monday Night Raw, and their amalgamation in time for the 'Biggest Party Of The Summer was the flagship show's (and company's) best stab at a main event befitting what many consider to be the second biggest show of the year underneath WrestleMania.

But how will it compare with previous classics? SummerSlam show-closers have been met with high praise in recent years, and the event has played host to some choice era-defining clashes in the 90s and 00s.

A trek through Meltzer's all-time greats won't only showcase the highlights of years gone by, but might also foreshadow what's to be expected from the quarelling quartet on August 20th.

(NOTE: In the event of a tied rating, the most recent match slots in lower on the list. Wrestling evolves at a breakneck pace, and any older contest keeping pace with a contemporary equivalent is deserving of the elevated status)

10. SummerSlam 2000 - The Rock Vs Triple H Vs Kurt Angle (***3/4)

Perhaps even a little underrated thanks to its competition elsewhere on the card, The Rock's stirring defence of his WWE Title against the backdrop of the Triple H/Kurt Angle/Stephanie McMahon love triangle and an unexpected hurdle of the Olympic Gold Medallist's real life concussion.

Advertisement

Expertly structured throughout, the match opened with 'The Game' tearing into Kurt following Angle's hasty decision to plant a kiss on Stephanie at the end of the go-home edition of SmackDown earlier in the week, but their war almost ended in disaster after the Spanish announce table bearing their weight collapsed before Triple H could hit his Pedigree.

Later revealed by Kurt Angle and clearly visible upon re-watch, 'The Game' had to repeatedly tell his fellow challenger to stay down, such was the concussed Angle's instinct to rise to his feet. Communicating Kurt's state to referee Earl Hebner, Triple H readied himself for what amounted mainly to a singles match with The Rock, unaware if Angle would even make it back for the detailed closing sequence.

The two warred (as they had done all year) for over ten minutes, before cameras cut to the backstage area where Stephanie McMahon begged a clearly still-dazed Kurt to return to ringside and 'help' Triple H.

Walked through every step by Stephanie, Hunter and Rock, Kurt miraculously played his part to perfection, allowing the match to play out as planned and The Rock to retain his title. It was a stunning but frightening exhibition that would thankfully never happen in 2017's concussion-conscious WWE.

9. SummerSlam 2015 - The Undertaker Vs Brock Lesnar (****)

Just over a year earlier, Brock Lesnar and The Undertaker contested a match that resulted in one of the biggest shocks in company history, but the 25 minutes and nine seconds that preceded Lesnar's unthinkable pinfall victory over 'The Deadman' left something of a sour aftertaste to the historic ending of Undertaker's WrestleMania winning streak.

Advertisement

Prior to their renewed hostilities, 'Taker had only resurfaced once since the loss - in tepid and needless victory over Bray Wyatt at WrestleMania 31, the same night Brock Lesnar would lose the WWE Title against Seth Rollins without even being pinned. Coincidentally, it would Lesnar's July rematch where he'd chase redemption.

Appearing from nowhere to down Brock with a low blow, chokeslam and two Tombstones, Undertaker exhibited an unseen desperation, which carried over to the pair's exceptional pull-apart brawl on Raw the next night and SummerSlam 2015 clash.

Atoning for their WrestleMania disappointment, the two went at it with gusto, brawling from the bell and smashing each other with finishers midway through the match that only scored two. Lesnar's kickout drew the bout's most iconic moment. Calling back to his domineering victory over John Cena one year earlier, Lesnar sat up with an incredulous chuckle, only to be met by Undertaker maniacally laughing in his face.

A poorly executed finish saw Undertaker sneak victory after Brock was distracted by the timekeeper's inadvertent read of the referee's count, but the dramatic conclusion would at least justify their exlposive final battle at October's Hell In A Cell.

8. SummerSlam 2007 - John Cena Vs Randy Orton (****)

Harkening back to a time when John Cena and Randy Orton could face off without the pained cries of submission from an overstuffed fanbase, their SummerSlam show-closer was perhaps the best straight one-on-one encounter the two ever had before the constant stream of stipulation-heavy retreads diluted any further interest in ever seeing them fight again.

Advertisement

The August 2007 contest was, astoundingly, their first ever singles WWE Title match, with 'The Viper' named Number One contender after decking Cena with the RKO the night after his July Great American Bash pay-per-view victory over Bobby Lashley.

Orton had floated aimlessly throughout 2007 following the breakdown of his dynamic 'Rated-RKO' unit with Edge, but in Cena he met an opponent that unsurprisingly brought the best out of his homogised in-house style. The two tore the house down, with Orton repeatedly attempting to soften 'The Champ' up for the RKO having hit Cena with it twice more in the build-up following his originally predatory attack.

It was just about the culmination of an electric year for the divisive Champion, who'd defeat Randy once more at the following month's Unforgiven pay-per-view before going down with a pectoral injury days later at October's No Mercy supercard. In truth, their rivalry had already peaked with this forgotten gem, and Cena's knock gave both a much needed break before the resumed conflict in early 2008.

7. SummerSlam 1996 - Shawn Michaels Vs Vader (****)

Shawn Michaels could carry the proverbial wrestling broomstick to three stars in 1996, so it's unsurprising his clash with the super-working super-heavyweight Vader managed one better, even with the WWE Champion throwing an almighty strop halfway through.

Advertisement

Vader had pinned Shawn one month earlier in the six-man main event of July's In Your House: International Incident, piling the pressure on the white mean babyface titleholder after he'd decisively dispatched fellow Camp Cornette member Davey Boy Smith just one month earlier.

Truthfully, the contest was great in spite of itself, with WWE unwilling to fully commit to the formula Vader had with Sting in WCW that propelled him to North American superstardom. Those matches called for Vader to utterly decimate Sting, notably at the Great American Bash 1992, where 'The Stinger' took a 17 minute hammering en route to losing his WCW World Heavyweight Title.

This contest teased a similar chemistry, but was instead truncated by two false finishes (one countout, one disqualification) that were chalked off ostensibly to make Michaels look like an all conquering hero. As magnificent as Michaels was at times during the contest, his less-than-heroic tantrum following Vader's failure to adhere to a complex elbow drop spot became one of the bout's major takeaways.

6. SummerSlam 2014 - John Cena Vs Brock Lesnar (****1/4)

Almost more of a brave booking masterstroke rather than just a match, the SummerSlam 2014 annihilation of John Cena by Brock Lesnar reset 'The Beast' in just about every conceivable manner after questionable handling of his return had almost rendered him as uninspired as the chasing pack of regulars on the roster.

Advertisement

Though the match was sensational, defeat to 'The Champ' at that year's Extreme Rules pay-per-view had thoroughly dented his momentum, and deeply unoriginal bores with Triple H stretching into 2013 sucked the remaining specialness out of his once-mammoth presence.

A match one year earlier against CM Punk had helped turn a corner for Brock, but few considered him the rightful choice to end Undertaker's WrestleMania streak until they witnessed his systematic destruction of John Cena the following August.

Cena, to his credit, was selfless almost to a fault. Allowing Brock to hit him with 16 German Suplexes before a second F5 polished him off, Cena was effectively beaten from the opening seconds after getting surprised with Lesnar's finisher before even having a chance to find his feet.

It was a unique venture for WWE, both in how they booked Cena and main events in general, and became the the template for the future (substantially more satisfying) Brock battles.

5. SummerSlam 2009 - CM Punk Vs Jeff Hardy (****1/4)

Wrestling in the penultimate match of his WWE career before his unlikely WrestleMania 33 return alongside brother Matt, Jeff Hardy put in a spellbinding shift against CM Punk in their powerful 'Tables, Ladders & Chairs' main event of SummerSlam 2009.

Advertisement

Hardy would fall again days later in a 'Loser Leaves WWE' steel cage match against the 'Straight Edge Superstar', but it became matches such as the duo's summer stunt show that WWE fans would pine for during the combination of legal turmoil, personal demons and professional vindication that kept Jeff away from the company for eight years.

The feud between the polar opposites had written itself, and had for a period looked to at long last cement Punk in the upper echelon before a backstage etiquette disagreement with The Undertaker resulted in him losing the title he fought so hard here to win a little over two months later.

Fought under the company's PG directive, the action-packed affair featured a raft of wicked weapons shots as Punk dragged Hardy down to his vicious level in an effort to disable him long enough to climb the ladder and grab the gold.

Unfortunately, Jeff's devilry was his undoing. A jaw-dropping Swanton Bomb on the challenger through the Spanish announce table harmed him more than his opponent, allowing Punk to win a footrace up the ladder after scoring with pinpoint kicks to his injured ribs.

A cute lights off/lights on return of The Undertaker in the post-match was the icing on the cake.

4. SummerSlam 2004 - Chris Benoit Vs Randy Orton (****1/4)

Lost to the horrific crimes of his final weekend, Chris Benoit's last pay-per-view World Title defence was the best match of his 2004 tenure as Champion since his first.

Advertisement

Hindsight showed it was way too soon for Randy Orton to be elevated to the company's top spot despite growing support for him as a heel during his Intercontinental Title run earlier in the year, but it was a gracious attempt to get him there from 'The Crippler'.

Passing the title rather than the whole torch, Benoit dealt out the requisite kicking the young upstart was required to endure, but positioned himself as the inferior strategist in the match, falling to a single RKO (outta' nowhere) despite hitting seven german suplexes and locking in the Sharpshooter and Crippler Crossface for a dramatic close calls.

Orton's babyface turn the following night was foreshadowed in the post-match, as Benoit ordered the victor to 'Be A Man' and shake his hand. Celebrating in the aftermath of his coming-of-age triumph, the new World Champion would never look quite so cool. Only one night later, Randy was unceremoniously dumped from Evolution by the malevolent Triple H, before pathetically losing his title to 'The Game' at Hunter's first attempt the following month.

3. SummerSlam 1992 - Bret Hart Vs The British Bulldog (****1/4)

Few recommendations for the legendary British Bulldog/Bret Hart match rank as highly as 'The Hitman's own.

Advertisement

Considering it his best ever performance in his exceptional autobiography, Bret recounts crafting the story of the contest out in advance exactly as it eventually played out, highlighting his inch-perfect understanding of how to emotionally involve a crowd as well as ability to guide his opponent through the match after the nerve-wracked and crack-addled challenger completely forgot the plan.

As Bret writes, Bulldog and attempted to calm himself down in the build-up to their historic Intercontinental Title classic by going on an almighty bender with Jim Neidhart, rendering him useless at retaining the vast of intricate and complex spots the nuanced clash was set to feature. Always able to take guidance well, Bulldog listened attentively and contributed his end to an absorbing clash that provided one of WWE's biggest ever crowds with a fittingly epic main event and victory for the hometown hero.

Bulldog's physical and mental state leave an interesting 'What If?' on the table as relates to the SummerSlam clash. Three years later, the pair would have an outstanding bloodbath at December 1995's In Your House 5, which many observers consider marginally better than their original smash. It's interesting to speculate if the iconic Wembley Stadium clash could have achieved even more hand Bulldog been fully fighting fit.

2. SummerSlam 2013 - John Cena Vs Daniel Bryan (****1/2)

A superlative scrap for the ages that got somewhat overpowered by the angle that followed, John Cena's unsuccessful title defence over Daniel Bryan was an era-defining battle that marked a clear change in styles for main events going forward.

Advertisement

Driven first by CM Punk's iconic Las Vegas 'pipebomb' that later translated to the Straight Edge Superstar's high profile main events against Bryan and Brock Lesnar, Daniel Bryan's entire ascent through 'The Champ' was built on the fantasy-becomes-reality story that he didn't look or act like Vince McMahon's vision of a WWE Superstar or brand representative.

Long underrated and determined to disarm any of his remaining critics, Cena once again showed his physical prowess by matching Bryan's natural energy and technical wizardry, particularly in a dramatic final third in which the challenger's victory started to become more of an impossibility than a fleeting opportunity.

The finish was the ideal way to pay off what had genuinely played out as a tactical giant killing. Both had worn each other down with their respective submission holds, and neither had given an inch in their an exhausted flurry of kicks and punches. Bryan recovered with a huge boot to Cena's head, then nailed a killer running knee to knock out 'The Champ' and (briefly) claim his first WWE World Title.

1. SummerSlam 2008 - The Undertaker Vs Edge (****1/2)

A gloriously epic payoff to one of the longest simmering rivalries in the company's post-Attitude Era tenure, The Undertaker's decisive Hell in a Cell victory over Edge capped off the best non-WrestleMania match period of 'The Deadman's entire career.

Advertisement

Exhibiting the chemistry that had carried their rivalry through multiple pay-per-views that year including a magnificent WrestleMania main event, the SummerSlam show-closer even fed into Edge's own return the prior November in a separate Hell In A Cell contest between 'The Deadman' and Batista.

Without the help of a scorned Vickie Guerrero and his decimated goon squad, Edge was systematically destroyed by his larger rival. An even-handed match eventually went in favour of Undertaker, as he completed a sequence that gave the wily heel absolutely no chance of recourse.

Chokeslamming Edge through a table, then hitting a Spear, then a shot with the camera as Edge had done in Taker's aforementioned Batista defeat, then hitting a con-chair-to and then a Tombstone, Undertaker made Edge feel every pain he had endured during the entire feud.

It was a perfect, perfect conclusion to their war. Writing Edge off of television for months, Undertaker chokeslammed 'The Rated-R Superstar' through the ring to finally see him off for good.

Advertisement