10 Controversial Wrestling Matches You'll Never See Again

"Never, EVER come close to doing this again" - Vince McMahon.

By Michael Hamflett /

Controversy and currency make strange bedfellows in professional wrestling.

Advertisement

Eric Bischoff might have leaned hard on the alliterative phrasing when flogging his "Controversy Creates Cash" book during and after its release, but the message simplified a philosophy far more complicated than it may have first appeared.

Manufactured controversy is amazing. It makes a pre-determined product feel real, dangerous and unpredictable. It's also incredibly hard to pull off because everybody's seen and done everything that even the coolest work you've ever seen is getting unpicked on Twitter as you read these words. Unfortunately, this cold reality creates the need for promotions to push things beyond the performative and closer to reality than should be necessary. The controversy follows, but rapidly becomes the sort that organisations would rather gets forgotten that forged into history.

Contests getting violent, exploitative and/or legitimately dangerous, booking decisions existing to troll paying punters rather than "putting smiles on faces", or even wrestlers attempting to kill the game and being accused of killing the entire business, there are plenty of ways to skin the controversial cat. But this lot provide a compelling argument for why it's sometimes not worth the hassle.

10. Jeff Hardy Vs. Sheamus (WWE SmackDown, July 24th 2020)

Jeff Hardy's issues with substance abuse have featured far too prominently in pro wrestling over the years.

Advertisement

It's not a surprise that nobody seemed to learn anything from the horrendous night Hardy main evented a TNA pay-per-view in no condition to perform, but when stories of his recovery were used for inspirational fodder in 2020 there was a creeping unease that was rapidly vindicated during his SmackDown feud with Sheamus.

'The Celtic Warrior' framed him for a hit-and-run and forced him to take a drug test just so Vince McMahon could re-run an old segment where somebody gets a face full of p*ss, and the two eventually had this payoff in a bar.

Surrounded by his vices and forced to engage in the sort of match that those vices often medicated, Hardy was put in an unenviable and unpleasant position during a period in which WWE were allegedly attempting to be the escapist nonsense the world needed. Vince McMahon called the whole thing pre-determined to avoid paying tax in 1989 - why did this sh*t have to be so real 30 years later?

9. D-Von Dudley & Mass Transit Vs The Gangstas (ECW, November 23rd, 1996)

Not on the WWE Network/Peacock thanks to it taking place for fancams rather than ECW's television ones, the infamous "Mass Transit Incident" finds all of pro wrestling's ills converging around one ugly scene that had devastating short and longterm ramifications.

Advertisement

The long story short - and it's been well told at this point - is of an underage and mostly untrained Erich Kulas talking a good game, ECW being in need of a jobber for a Gangstas match, and New Jack allowing everything to spiral out of control from the delicate position it was already in.

Oh, and the blood literally shooting out of Kulas' head like a fountain.

Kulas had told boss Paul Heyman he was 21 and trained by Killer Kowalski when neither were true, and asked Jack to blade him when the controversial figure was far too happy to oblige. Going deep with a surgical scalpel, the cut resulted in the horrifying bloodshed and ECW's pay-per-view plans temporarily going up in smoke. The Kulas family were tied up in legal battles over it for years, further damaging what was ultimately a tragically short life - Erich passed away in 2022 at just 22 due to gastric bypass surgery complications.

8. Brock Lesnar Vs Undertaker (WWE WrestleMania 30)

"Controversial" because the result will probably be debated forevermore, and "you'll never see again" because nobody in WWE will ever amass an unbeaten streak so remarkable that the result of the contest would matter enough to generate debate.

Advertisement

The Undertaker's WrestleMania record became something even more powerful than a championship belt on the 'Grandest Stage Of Them All', and it had reached a point that a fairly tepid television feud with Brock Lesnar hadn't really done an effective job of suggesting there'd be much drama on the night.

How wrong everybody was.

Pressing the shock-and-awe button just to see what happened, Vince McMahon himself made the call and Undertaker looked at the lights as per his boss' request. For years and years (and years) people had speculated on who could benefit from beating him until chatter flipped and most agreed he should keep it forever. 'The Beast' was subsequently the answer to a question people had stopped asking, which does explain why the move was ultimately so effective.

7. Rey Mysterio Vs. Seth Rollins (WWE The Horror Show At Extreme Rules)

The nadir from WWE's wretched and enforced Performance Center era, Rey Mysterio and Seth Rollins' "Eye For An Eye" match was the worst of the organisation's bizarre situational excesses.

Advertisement

COVID-19 was and is a very serious threat to one's immune system, but it seemed to warp the minds of promotion and performers alike, acting as a masking agent to common sense and giving all involved the feeling that everything would be forgotten when the empty arena era had passed. This despite wrestling being the show that never ends and careers constantly defined more by what they've done in the past than the "story" they're involved in day-to-day.

Foolishly from WWE's point of view, the wilder the ideas got, the more they burned themselves into the memory. Eye For An Eye was the perfect example - nothing simmering between Rollins and Mysterio justified the removal of an eye, particularly via corner of the steel stairs. Nor could any of this be bought watching at home. And the stunt eye looked like a ping pong ball dripping in ketchup, as if a good prop would have made this any better.

6. Matt Hardy Vs Sammy Guevara (AEW All Out 2021)

To use mastabatory Bret Hart tribute dialogue for this one, "controversial" wasn't the g*ddamn word for it - this was bullsh*t.

Advertisement

A disastrous match that summed up the feud in general, Matt Hardy and Sammy Guevara's senseless brawl at All Out 2020 killed the vibe of the whole evening and looked like it almost did the same to the poor veteran following a scary bump gone wrong.

The two wrestled on a wobbly scaffold before tumbling from it to what looked like certain doom for the North Carolinian. Everything seemed to go in slow motion after Hardy cracked his head full force on the concrete floor, with various medics, referees and the wrestlers themselves scrambling over what to do next.

Hardy looked in awful condition, turning a scary shade while exhibiting a look of somebody operating entirely on autopilot. The match recklessly continued (with bigger spots to perform, no less), but remains an irresponsible low for the organisation to this day.

5. Royal Rumble 2015

Roman Reigns will never again generate the sort of response he did after last eliminating Rusev from the horrendously booked and significantly damaging 2015 Royal Rumble.

Advertisement

Nothing the 'Tribal Chief' will ever do as a heel or babyface will create such fury in a building or stadium, not least because the fans that might once have fumed are simply no longer there. Many lifelong pro wrestling fans very literally took their business elsewhere when AEW showed itself as the provider of the content they desired, resulting in 2022 WWE crowds that mostly respond as requested to anything they're served, if they're making noise at all.

Reigns being mercilessly abused throughout, Big Show and Kane limply lifting out all the perennial favourites like sacks of sh*t, 'The Bulgarian Brute' being presented as the final boss heel but received as the last babyface hope - every single steer at the climax of this match was a bum one. As if it could have gone any other way after Daniel Bryan's earlier elimination.

Like the part-time 'Head Of The Table', the Royal Rumble doesn't always deliver a match of the year candidate. But it'll never be this bad again.

4. Joey Janela Vs Jimmy Lloyd (GCW, March 21st 2020)

Well, hopefully you'll never see it again.

Advertisement

A charming idea from a company that ultimately failed in its pandemic efforts in the longterm, GCW's Social Distancing match between Joey Janela and Jimmy Lloyd saw both men engage in the sort of thing that once would have baited the old guard had said talking heads not exploded with far hotter takes long before a global pandemic changed everything.

Years after The Young Bucks et al had been accused of killing the business, Janela and Lloyd kept it going a little bit longer when COVID-19 started shutting it all down. The rules of the Social Distancing match required the wrestlers to maintain the advisory space between one another during the earliest days of the coronavirus outbreak. Wrestling as if Invisible Man/Stan stood between them both, the pair fed, sold and bumped as if they were connecting but with the requisite fresh air between them.

It was creatively inspired but born out of grim necessity nobody wants to revisit.

3. Vince McMahon Vs Stephanie McMahon (WWE No Mercy 2003)

The recent corporate change at WWE's top table has positioned Stephanie McMahon as the interim Chairwoman for (at least) the duration of the company's investigations into misconduct allegations against Vince McMahon.

Advertisement

The move feels more for the benefit of public perception than any kind of professional or philosophical shift, with "interim" being thrown around more in WWE press releases than on AEW television. Regardless, stories of team meetings and togetherness present a new ideal as the company looks to move forward from an ugly story with even uglier ramifications.

Which is why this one is surely getting locked down forever more.

Enjoying a bit of warped wish fulfilment in the name of his own entertainment (and per his own DVD documentary it could have been even grosser), Vince McMahon knocking his real life daughter about within the showbiz squared circle was destined to age horribly long before fresh grim allegations surfaced about what goes on within his autocratic empire.

It's sh*t anyway - surreal in still images, it's indulgent trash in movement. Like McMahon himself, WWE should have gotten rid of this one a long time ago.

2. Mankind Vs The Undertaker (WWE King Of The Ring 1998)

The Vince McMahon quote in the summary line to this very article was attributed to the former Chairman by Mankind, who noted McMahon's request after he slumped back through the curtain following his epic encounter with The Undertaker at King Of The Ring 1998.

Advertisement

Has the instruction been followed?

Possibly. Shane McMahon has artlessly jumped from the top a few times and more than a few midcarders have taken a table plunge closer to Shawn Michaels' original than this iconic fall from Foley, but that discounts the further punishment Mankind put himself through elsewhere in the match.

Also, with the possible exception of Cody Rhodes in 2022, nobody has gone into the structure carrying as serious an injury as 'The Deadman' did that day. Undertaker's broken foot necessitated creative carnage in the first place, even if the first throw off the side was a literal leap too far and 'Mrs Foley's Baby Boy's second plummet was a partial accident.

Of course, you'll see clips of this match over and over and over again forever and ever, but in terms of recreating it now or in the future - nothing will ever stand a chance.

1. Mickie James, Kelly Kelly & Gail Kim Vs. Maryse, Rosa Mendes & Alicia Fox, (WWE Raw, July 13th 2009)

As with most forms of entertainment, wrestling has certain leeway during retrospective looks at past content thanks to certain aspects being "of the time".

Advertisement

This is a low bar of course - the best forms of entertainment attempt to read societal changes, act progressively and end up speaking truths about times yet to come. WWE, for as long as Vince McMahon has been at the helm, has existed about five years behind the outside world's curve.

This bikini match (billed as a "Summer Swim Suit Spectacular") took place in 2009, several years after the advent of a hardworking Knockouts division in TNA and the advent of Shimmer on the indies and a decade and a half removed from All Japan Women's Wrestling's Big Egg Wrestling Universe but interestingly six years before Stephanie McMahon invented women's wrestling in 2015.

WWE have attempted at points to lionise this era when it suits, and the women themselves have rightfully stood up for doing the best with the sh*t they were served, but the likes of Gail Kim, Mickie James and Maryse all traded more successfully as pro wrestlers the second they were permitted to by promoters. Dated at the time, this is archaic by post-Women's Revolution standards.

Advertisement