10 Dream Wrestling Matches That Only Happened Once
CM Punk vs. Eddie Guerrero? Once in a Lifetime! No, really...
Starting up a wrestling company seems like a fun idea until you realise just how much content you need to produce.
From the smallest indies to the intercontinental behemoths, wrestling never stops, and you need to put on a lot of matches to keep eyes on your product.
This means that pretty much every wrestler you can imagine has locked horns with every other wrestler you can imagine, usually more than once. When a dream match comes along, it stands to reason the company booking the talent milks it for all it’s worth until we’re watching Reigns/Lesnar round 45.
Sometimes, though, promotions manage (or are forced) to hold out, to deliver a “once in a lifetime” match and actually stick to it. Whether this is a creative decision or the realities of personnel changes kiboshing a potential rematch, there remain a scant few legendary wrestlers who’ve locked horns just once, and never again.
Some of these matches remain totally legendary for their one-off status; others could maybe have done with a replay to see if they couldn’t iron out a few creases. In any case, at the time of writing, these 10 bouts retain their unique status, something truly remarkable in the world of pro wrestling...
10. Kenny Omega vs Penta El Zero
The high point of 2018’s All In show is a perfectly pitched pro wrestling match, featuring non-stop high octane excitement which is no less psychologically sound for its frantic pace. In Penta and Omega, we had two guys at the top of their game who’d plied their trade half a world apart, finally meeting for a showdown.
It feels epic from the off, and within minutes we’ve seen a wild suicide dive from Penta, Omega’s mixture of strikes and high flying ability, and a fully believable sense of competition. The luchador leans on his weight advantage and Omega’s banged up shoulder, but The Cleaner constantly fires back with V triggers.
The pace and intensity only ramp up, with each hitting pretty frightening package piledrivers on the other. Penta’s overly casual pins ultimately cost him, though, and when Kenny finally hits the One Winged Angel, it’s all over.
The two have been AEW stalwarts for years, but their paths haven’t crossed again since. When Omega makes his way back from injury, it’d certainly be one to consider.
9. John Cena vs Neville
While he’d have higher profile matches before and after, for many fans John Cena was never better than during his US Championship run. Instigating an open invitational policy, Cena locked horns with many rising stars, never failing to elevate them in fantastic matches.
He’d enjoy a great series with Kevin Owens and a couple of bangers with Cesaro, but the best match of the bunch might be his 2015 bout against Neville. The British star was coming off a successful NXT run and he more than held his own in his highest profile match to date.
His innovative high-flying offense instantly gets the crowd on his side, and Cena is eager to give the Geordie as much of a push as he can. Neville nicks out of the AA and has the veteran seriously on the ropes as Cena has to dig deep to keep in the frantic contest.
Sadly, the match is ended by a Rusev interruption, and the pair never had the chance to renew hostilities. A shame - there was definitely something here.
8. CM Punk vs. Eddie Guerrero
In early 2002, a brash young CM Punk was starting to build a name for himself as IWA Mid-South’s champion. Meanwhile, Eddie Guerrero had left WWE due to personal issues and was rebuilding himself on the indies and in Japan. Their paths would cross just one in singles competition, and the sense of what could have been is palpable.
That’s not to say their match isn’t good, because it has plenty going for it. Guerrero brings star power in spades, swaggering around the ring and folding Punk with his selection of suplexes and kicks. If Punk isn’t the fully formed in ring competitor, his charisma is already off the scales; he feels like a star on Eddie’s level.
Punk eventually goes over - for which he later said he was very grateful to the late veteran - but this had the scope to be a great rivalry had their paths crossed again a little later on. Both wrestlers had that most valuable of qualities, to be able to get over basically being themselves but dialled up a bit. Had things turned out differently, it could have been a rivalry for the ages.
7. Cesaro vs. Ilja Dragunov
NXT TakeOver: Cardiff is an all-time great event, with a rabid Welsh crowd providing a unique atmosphere and a card with no duds. One particularly enjoyable element is seeing oft-wasted talent Cesaro being treated like the star he is in a blinder of a match against Ilja Dragunov.
The younger man is one of modern wrestling’s great babyfaces, able to convincingly sell both the beating he’s taking and the idea that he could summon the grit to overcome it better than almost anyone. And he certainly takes a beating here, with Cesaro muscling the Russian around the ring and pulling off one of the longest giant swings to date.
Ilya never takes it lying down, though, and fires back with the stiff chops and athleticism that’s made him one of the division’s best stars. From the off, they forgo the technical stuff. This is two prime athletes looking to dominate one another in crisp, stiff fashion.
Cesaro finally gets the win, but it’s a hard fought one that does wonders to elevate Dragunov - and remind anyone watching just how great the Swiss superstar is.
6. Trish Stratus vs Charlotte Flair
A cross-generational match of a slightly bittersweet nature, this SummerSlam 2019 show stealer makes it apparent just how much Trish Stratus could have accomplished had she worked in an era that cared more about women’s wrestling.
While she had some great matches at the time, she never worked a talent like Charlotte, and the past and present of WWE’s women's division combine to put on a real clinic. The cocky Flair spends long spells underestimating the returning veteran, using her size advantage to shove Trish around, but Stratus fights from underneath and shows off steel and technique that was sadly underutilised in her day.
In front of a hometown Toronto crowd especially, Stratus feels every bit the megastar, and while Flair pulls the strings, Trish’s selling and emotional work are the backbones of the match. Flair ultimately locks on the Figure Eight for the win, bringing back that bittersweet feeling as Stratus presumably says goodbye to the business. Maybe this one could happen again; if not, it was a tremendous send off to a legend.
5. Velveteen Dream vs Aleister Black
For all its great qualities, Black and Gold era NXT was occasionally prone to replaying matches to death, with the likes of Gargano/Ciampa and Cole/O’Reilly going past their sell-by date.
They showed impressive restraint in never re-running Velveteen Dream vs Aleister Black. It was 2017’s rivalry of the year, their sole match at TakeOver: WarGames one of the best the company put on at the time - perhaps they knew it was unlikely to be topped.
The build was delightfully daft, with the brash, gobby Dream demanding to be acknowledged by the taciturn, spooky Black. Dream, relatively new to the company, throws out all of his flashy but old school offence while attempting to rile the Dutchman into acknowledging him. Ultimately, Black puts his opponent away decisively with the heel kick, but in a nice touch, gives his fallen foe what he wants by saying his name post-match.
Sadly the WWE story of Dream and Black ended in, respectively, murky behaviour and a bizarre release respectively, but in their sole one on one match, they left a killer legacy.
4. AJ Styles vs. Minoru Suzuki
From the epic stare down to the hard fought finale, this is a proper dream match that actually lives up to expectations. AJ Styles and Minoru Suzuki were each outsiders in New Japan Pro Wrestling, both the leaders of heel factions. and at the 2014 G1 Climax, their paths collided.
The similarities end there, though, and the disparate techniques of the two performers make this a fantastically exciting watch. We start off with a flurry of quick offence from Styles, who gets Suzuki off his feet and out of the ring surprisingly quickly. Once Suzuki gets his hands on AJ, though, the match turns on its head, and he deals out his full repertoire of brutally convincing strikes which Styles sells for his life.
While he’s every part the gaijin heel, Styles plays the underdog to perfection here. He absorbs Suzuki’s thunderous chops and fires back with his own; there’s a great mat based trade of submissions towards the end, before AJ finally hoists his foe into the Styles Clash and proves why, in 2014, there was no one better.
3. Dean Ambrose vs Roman Reigns vs Seth Rollins
WWE did so much right with The Shield, creating a massively popular faction which paved the way for three new main eventers. At the final hurdle, though - the climactic triple threat match - they dropped the ball, giving the match away on a C-tier PPV.
Their sole triple threat outing is a decent match, unsurprisingly. The breaks had been put on the Roman Reigns push for the time being, and the crowd is wild for champion Dean Ambrose, even if he never really has the backing of the office.
This was a WrestleMania main event, though, not the closer for Battleground 2016. While the main aim of The Shield was to birth a new top guy in Roman Reigns, they wound up with three different but fantastic stars with a compelling backstory and great in-ring chemistry.
Placing the three together to close the show of shows would have demonstrated that WWE still has the ability to create new stars. Instead, they chucked this one away with no real justification.
2. Bryan Danielson vs. Fergal Devitt
It seems unlikely that anyone in WWE’s back office would watch this 2007 match taking place in front of about 50 people in a New York firehall while Daniel Bryan was still on their books, but if they had, they’d surely have run it again.
Working here under their real names, Danielson and Devitt are in their physical prime here and with gas in the tank to work a relentless 20 minutes. It’s a technical masterclass, full of incredibly crisp mat exchanges, flipping in and out of bridges and submissions that look absolutely exhausting.
There’s a great sense of fun, too. The crowd is noticeably tiny but this gives the performers the freedom to do whatever they want, exchanging pins and reversals to the point of parody and mugging it up to the audience. Indeed the crowd do themselves proud, making noise enough to overcome the meagre attendance.
Finally, things end with a Danielson superplex, but this is a great showing for the pair of wrestlers, even if there weren’t too many people there to see it.
1. Samoa Joe vs. Kenta Kobashi
There are plenty of reasons not to repeat a match, but an underrated one is: it was just too horrid to do again. For those not used to ‘90s All Japan particularly, this 2005 Ring Of Honor war is incredibly savage, and must have had both men throbbing for weeks.
Kobashi apparently feared the American fans wouldn’t know who he was; this was proved unfounded, but even if they didn’t know the man before, he gives a good account of himself from the off. Kobashi’s chops and strikes are disgustingly thunderous; the sweat flying from Joe’s chest as his opponent pulverises him is a remarkable visual, to say nothing of the sound.
Joe meets violence with violence, occasionally pulling out wrestling moves but more often slipping back into tried and tested kicks to the head. It’s simple stuff but with a powerful build. Each throws everything he has at the other; it’s down to who can take the most punishment.
It turns out it’s Kobashi, who finally downs Joe with a sickening strike to the neck. Both are left utterly spent, bruised and battered, and in possession of a true classic on their resumes.