10 Embarrassing WWE Debuts You’ve Totally Forgotten About

What's that old saying about first impressions?

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

What makes a good WWE debut?

Advertisement

Screw that question, because it's way more fun to analyse what makes a bad one. How about bored fans deciding to troll the product, wrestlers so bizarre not even tenured announcers know what to say, gimmicks that left Vince McMahon scrambling for some handy 'abort' button, nasty injuries that flattened the entire experience and totally unnecessary race-baiting?

All of those things are included here, and they helped usher in new characters, angles and matches that pretty much nobody was talking about in the car ride home from arenas. Or, if they were, it would've been followed by some chuckles and maybe a few, 'What the f*ck was that all about?' remarks before everyone got back to talking about what they enjoyed.

Advertisement

These debuts were so foul that they even left some of the workers themselves questioning what was next. If first impressions truly are everything, then it must've been sleepless nights all round after the show, but you've probably forgotten about this collection of disasters.

At least a few of them recovered and went on to bigger and better things...

Advertisement

10. Kizarny (2 January 2009 - SmackDown)

WWE.com

Flat, lifeless crowd? Check. A botched finisher? Check. Awkward dancing on the way to the ring? Check. Announcers struggling to put the new gimmick over as someone fans should care about? Check. Poor Kizarny was battling a sh*t ton of negatives before even dashing through the curtain.

Advertisement

His debut on the 2 January 2009 SmackDown was awful.

The character had supposedly run away as a youth to join the circus, but Kizarny was really an inside joke about behind-the-scenes vernacular, or 'carny'. You might know the kind - fans are "mizarks", not marks, and holds are "hizolds". That sort of stuff. Yeah...this was never going to work.

Advertisement

MVP gamely tried his best to put the newcomer over, but nobody was left convinced. WWE obviously agreed that it was a washout, because they quickly phased their new theatrical freak out and released him two months later.

9. Naked Mideon (28 August 2000 - Raw)

WWE.com

It was probably warmer inside the Greensboro Coliseum than usual on 28 August 2000, but temperatures weren't hot enough for someone to go streaking. Sadly for all onlookers, that's exactly what 'Naked' Mideon did during a mixed tag pitting Perry Saturn and Terri Runnels against Al Snow and The Kat.

Advertisement

Jerry Lawler loved every second of it, because of course he did.

The skin-loving colour commentator was one of the only ones though. Almost everyone else jokingly wolf whistled, sat in stunned amazement or hurled lung butter into their overpriced popcorn. The WWF had a new character, and he was fond of showing off the most jiggly of his jiggly bits on live television.

Advertisement

Mideon entered the ring as Snow and Saturn traded moves, gyrated like an 'Attitude' era precursor to New Day's Big E and then bolted from the scene. Weirdly, this supposed nudist was wearing pretty much the same amount of clothing as Perry.

8. Avatar (23 October 1995 - Raw)

WWE.com

Things were somehow worse for Snow almost five years earlier.

Advertisement

During his Raw debut as the masked Avatar character (a mask he only put on when the bell sounded), the future mannequin head-toting maniac depressed Vince McMahon to the point that one could audibly hear the WWF boss losing any and all enthusiasm for his Power Rangers-meets-Hayabusa gimmick.

Tasked with taking jobber Bryan Walsh to pieces and showcasing his skills, Avatar instead became the human version of a slip n' slide. He botched his earliest offence, which led McMahon to excuse this masked ninja by explaining that his mask was obscuring his vision, and Walsh refused to sell some of his stuff.

Advertisement

Fans, who had probably already sat through endless squash matches and dull mid-'90s fare, responded in kind with complete silence. The debut was so bad that Avatar lost his scheduled spot at Survivor Series '95 and was replaced by Bob Holly. Ouch.

7. Friar Ferguson (12 April 1993 - Raw)

WWE.com

You know your first gimmick was the sh*ts when 'creative services' renames you Bastion Booger and believes the best way to rescue your Federation career is to become the WWF's resident slob. That was the fate of one Mike Shaw - his introduction as the diabolically bad Friar Ferguson was ghastly.

Advertisement

On the 12 April 1993 episode of Raw (just over one week after WrestleMania IX), Ferguson was introduced as the "mad monk" and beat local job guy Chris Duffy. His shaky performance was a kiss of death for the gimmick before it even really got started. To fans looking on, this Friar was just some old dude with bad knees and nothing more.

Again, the fact that Vince McMahon and his merry band of creative minds decided that Booger would be an improvement says it all. Friar Ferguson was that much of a disgrace, and it wasn't Duffy's fault. He did everything any self-respecting enhancement worker is supposed to do, but Friar couldn't meet him halfway.

Advertisement

6. Kerwin White (10 September 2005 - Heat)

WWE
"Chavo? Chavo has left the building. He's probably trying to get a job at some taco stand like all the rest of those unemployed Hispanics" - Chavo Guerrero, 2005.

On 10 September 2005, Guerrero ditched his proud heritage to become the offensively atrocious Kerwin White. The gimmick blended Frank Sinatra sounds, golf and some sort of weird, WWE version of old-timey white supremacy, and it was one of the worst things to ever hit the pro wrestling scene.

Advertisement

Forget the fact that this character debuted on Sunday Night Heat for a second, because that was the least of Chavo's problems. Fans were totally unconvinced that changing the skilled Cruiserweight into one of Vince McMahon's Connecticut neighbours (probably, but it had to be based on somebody) was the right move.

Their skepticism would prove correct. Nobody wanted this race-baiting b*llocks - nobody. It was embarrassing to see someone as respected as Chavo be reduced to such a one-note joke who needed racism to even provoke a reaction from an audience who couldn't wait to hit the merch stands.

Advertisement

5. The Shining Stars (16 May 2016 - Raw)

WWE.com

Shills for the Puerto Rican tourism board.

Advertisement

That was literally Primo and Epico's new gimmick, and they gave it a test run on the 16 May 2016 edition of Raw to the delight of precisely no-one. One can only guess that WWE challenged its writing staff to come up with some follow-up nobody would guess after the tag-team had previously played matadors. 'Hey, how about holiday reps?'.

The Shining Stars, as they were re-dubbed, were handed several weeks of boring vignettes before encouraging local job lads Scott Jackson and Bryan Kennedy to book up for San Juan boat tours immediately. After all, visiting the "Shining Star of the Caribbean" had to be better than the $150 they were paid to take bumps.

Advertisement

Fans didn't care, and why would they have? The team's vignettes hadn't exactly painted them as killer heels who deserved to be booed, and few were going to leap out of their seats at the prospect of seeing glorified travel agents wrestle.

4. Phantasio (16 July 1995 - Wrestling Challenge)

WWE.com

God bless Gorilla Monsoon. No, really. The announcing great genuinely tried to present his astonishment and excitement on a 1995 episode of antiquated weekly Wrestling Challenge, and he did it when Phantasio (of all people) was in the ring. What a worker - Gorilla, not the magician.

Advertisement

He was crap.

Phantasio's litany of "incredible" tricks included pulling his mask off to reveal he was wearing face paint that were identical to said mask, pulling what looked like Christmas tinsel out of his mouth, pulling opponent Tony DeVito's underwear off for the finish and pulling everyone's leg that he deserved to do this nonsense inside a WWF ring.

Advertisement

The man behind the erm...magic holds the distinction of only wrestling one televised match for the company before heading back from whence he came to the USWA. Nobody missed him, except for Monsoon. If only fans had shared the commentator's energy.

3. Johnny Curtis (3 June 2011 - SmackDown)

WWE

NXT used to be garbage.

Advertisement

WWE's faux-reality show was designed to create new stars and offer something different to those who just needed obstacle courses and eating contests as part of their weekly pro wrasslin' fix. By season three, it was sagging, but that didn't stop the company from strapping a rocket to series winner Johnny Curtis.

Or not. The promotion's big plan for Curtis was unveiled on the 3 June 2011 episode of SmackDown when he debuted in a backstage skit and cried as he poured milk over his own head. That is not a lie - this actually happened, and someone thought it'd get the future Fandango over.

Advertisement

What wasn't made clear was that Curtis bemoaned the fact he wasn't getting his promised Tag-Team Title shot alongside NXT 'Pro' R-Truth, and that this was meant to be a clever nod towards the timeless phrase, 'don't cry over spilled milk'. Unfortunately for WWE, it didn't lead to some sort of 'Got Milk?' crossover that'd rival Randy Savage's Slim Jim deal in the 90s.

There's time yet.

Advertisement

2. Lord Tensai (2 April 2012 - Raw)

WWE.com

What could be worse than being reminded you used to play a human penis for a living when you're trying to get a new gimmick over? That might be up there on the list of things no person wants to experience, but it happened to the physically dominant heel monster Lord Tensai on the 2 April 2012 Raw.

Advertisement

Fans in Miami had a blast roaring "Aaaaaaaalbeeeeert!" at the big guy.

Unwavering, Tensai did his able best to squash John Cena's favourite wrestler Alex Riley and become WWE's new heel sensation. It was an uphill battle, and it wasn't going to happen. No amount of tattoos, incongruous Japanese lore or flashy entrance routines could sell people on the thought that Prince Albert/Albert/A-Train was some fearsome samurai overlord.

Advertisement

This gimmick belonged in 1993, not 2012. To think, it also debuted 24 hours after WrestleMania XXVIII; that was a poor decision on WWE's part. The post-'Mania Raw crowds are well-known for trolling, being drunk and demanding neat surprises. Debuting Tensai here was creative sabotage.

1. Edge (22 June 1998 - Raw)

WWE

Weren't expecting this guy to be here, were you?

Advertisement

It's true. Back on the 22 June 1998 edition of Raw Is War, future great and comeback king Edge had quite the stinker during his full, in-person TV debut. During a flip dive to the outside, Edge's boot caught opponent José Estrada Jr right on the head, and led to painful pinched nerves in the Puerto Rican's neck.

The situation was a distressing one for all parties involved. Once it became clear that Estrada was out the game and unable to continue, the referee counted him out and raised a miffed Edge's hand high into the air. The Canadian was not thrilled, but also realised the seriousness of Estrada's plight. At the same time, he was probably worried about the backlash a WWF newbie would get for injuring one of the roster.

Advertisement

The ending wasn't popular with the live crowd either. Edge had been booked to hit Estrada with his new 'Downward Spiral' finisher and then roar like the "tormented soul" (Jerry Lawler's words) he was as the camera zoomed in on his moody expressions.

This future 'Rated-R Superstar' wasn't off to a hot start.

Advertisement

What other embarrassing WWE debuts can you think of? For more like this, check out 10 Secret Conversations That Changed Wrestling History Forever and 10 WWE Moves That NEVER Win Matches!