10 Explanations For WWE’s Marginalisation Of Randy Savage

It's 2014 and the Macho Man is still not in the WWE Hall Of Fame. What gives?

By Aaron Hyden /

We, as wrestling fans, have a lot of different opinions on things. We argue and bicker about who is good, who isn't good, who deserves to be pushed more, who should be signed where, and everything else under the sun. It's what we do, and it has been since the Internet Wrestling Community was born. However, one thing that just about everyone can agree on is that "Macho Man" Randy Savage is one of the greatest professional wrestlers of all-time, and is absolutely, positively deserving of a spot in the WWE Hall Of Fame. Of course, Savage isn't in the WWE Hall Of Fame, and nobody is sure if he'll ever be there. Why? Why wouldn't one of the all-time greats be inducted, when people who have achieved far less than he ever did get inducted every year? We've seen plenty of rumors, speculation, stories, and hearsay, so it's time to sit back and discuss all of the possible reasons as to why this travesty continues to be a yearly occurrence. Some of these things are much more possible explanations than others, but they all make sense as reasons why Randy Savage has yet to be added to the WWE Hall Of Fame, whether we want to agree with them or not.

10. Billionaire Ted Skits

Yes, WCW had basically tried to turn the Monday Night War into a playground battle with devious plots and name-calling, but when the WWF decided to air their "Billionaire Ted" skits, lampooning the likes of WCW owner Ted Turner (Billionaire Ted), "Mean" Gene Okerlund (Scheme Gene), Hulk Hogan (The Huckster), and Randy Savage (The Nacho Man), it took things to an entirely different level. The skits started out innocently enough. Making fun of Hogan and Savage for being old, making fun of Turner for being some hick that only cares about buying and selling people, and making fun of Okerlund for trying to scam people into calling his old 1-900 hotline. However, when one skit insinuated that Hogan had been intimate with Miss Elizabeth, that's when Savage supposedly blew up, enraged that the WWF would have the nerve to put something like that on television. Savage was notoriously jealous and protective, as well as being very private. There had already been bad blood between Savage and Hogan over Randy's thinking something was going on between Hulk and Elizabeth, and this merely brought it back to the forefront, and in a very public way. It was yet another thing that added fuel to the fire, and if you believe the stories, was something that Randy never forgave Vince McMahon for doing.

9. Saving Him For Another Year

This one would probably be a lot more likely if Randy were still alive and well. When these guys are alive and aren't in terrible health, WWE has to figure they'll be there to induct whenever the company is "ready" for them. Of course, impatient fans would want him in as soon as possible, but as long as he was alive and inducted, it could be in 2010, 2015, 2020, or 2050. Once Randy passed away, it turned into a "what are you waiting for" situation. He died on May 20th, 2011, which means his induction should have come in 2012, on the night before WrestleMania 28 in Miami, to fully take advantage of the nostalgia wave that fans would have had. His kayfabe home was always in Florida, and he has a lot of history there, anyway, so even that would have made sense. The emotional connection would have been strong. The idea of saving him comes from there only being a certain amount of people who can headline a Hall Of Fame class. If you spread them out, and don't induct too many in one year, you can have huge classes for years and years to come. Without sounding heartless, some would say that he's already dead, so there's no rush to induct him at this point, but with the emotional connection possibly getting smaller and smaller the more they continue to phase him out, the less punch his induction will finally pack once it does happen.

8. Money Dispute

We've seen a couple different variations on this story through the years. One says that Savage was owed a certain amount of money by the WWF when he left for WCW, and he was never paid that money. One says that Randy was working on a return to the WWF, but received an "insulting" offer, and nothing ever happened. Money is an interesting thing in life, whether you're used to having it or not. It can change relationships, if not outright ruin them. No matter what any fans and outsiders might think, it's certainly something that can have two grown men hold grudges against each other for years. Does that make Vince McMahon especially petty if he continues to hold the grudge, even after Savage has passed away? Yes, it does, but when was the last time anyone accused Vince of not caring about his money? It's sad to think about, but it's also something that is definitely plausible.

7. A Bar Fight Between Randy & Vince

This has to be one of the more intriguing theories out there. The story goes that Vince used to go out with "the boys" after shows, and go for drinks, dinner, or whatever was going on that night. One night, Vince may have stepped over the line, and Savage put him in check with a hard slap across the face. Men like "Rowdy" Roddy Piper have told the story through the years, saying that Vince was at fault, and that they didn't blame someone for physically responding to him. Of course, with an ego the size of Vince McMahon's, you can understand if someone putting their hands on you and embarrassing you in front of your employees would upset you, and when things like that happen, it's not very difficult to picture a grudge being held for a long time.

6. Randy Declined The Invitation While He Was Alive

This one would have everyone changing their minds and how they view the entire situation really quickly. One rumor that we've seen has WWE reaching out to Randy while he was still alive, and saying they wanted to induct him into the WWE Hall Of Fame, only for Savage to decline the entire thing. Just like that. End of story. No scams, grudges, and backstage politics. Just a simple "do you want in", followed by a simple "no thanks", and that's that. If this actually happened, it makes you wonder about Macho's reasoning. Unless you're a bitter ex-employee, there really is no reason to turn down an induction into the Hall Of Fame. The chance to mingle with some of your fellow legends, the opportunity to be in the spotlight one more time, the fancy Hall Of Fame ring, the money... it just makes sense to be there and do the ceremony. You don't just turn it down because, say, your girlfriend's birthday is WrestleMania weekend and you want to go on a mini-vacation with her, or you're having a Fantasy Baseball draft on that day. While we're discussing Savage declining the invitation, though...

5. All Poffos Or No Poffos

Yet another version of the "Randy Savage declined a Hall Of Fame invitation when he was alive" story is that Randy has always said he wants to be inducted with his brother (former WWF wrestler, "Leaping" Lanny Poffo aka The Genius) and his father (former wrestler Angelo Poffo). After he passed away, Lanny would continue to reiterate that in several media interviews, saying that the reason his brother was never inducted is because he told WWE he wouldn't accept their invitation unless the company inducted his entire family together. Immediately, some fans saw issues with this. When Lanny was giving these interviews, his father and his brother had already passed away, so it was only him remaining. People saw it like Lanny was lying, merely trying to capitalize on his brother's fame, thinking that he could sneak into the Hall Of Fame that way. Looking back on their careers, Lanny and Angelo Poffo probably don't fit the criteria for the WWE Hall Of Fame. Lanny was never anything special in his WWF career, and Angelo saw only marginal success, but never with the WWF. If you ask most "in the know", they would say neither man deserves to be in the Hall Of Fame. It would truly be a shame if one of the greatest to ever do it had to remain on the outside, looking in, based on extreme loyalty to family, or even worse, based on lies and greed by his family that have nothing to do with him. On the subject of Angelo Poffo...

4. Randy Losing Respect For Vince Over Angelo Being Snubbed

In 1987, the WWF was putting together a big "Legends Match", with big names from the past competing. Randy Savage went to Vince McMahon and specifically requested that the company allow his father to compete in the match, even though Angelo Poffo had no experience with the company. Vince declined the request, and if you believe the story, this was the exact moment that the relationship between Randy and Vince went sour. Looking at it from Randy's perspective, you can see why he might be upset over something like this. He wasn't asking for his father to pin the WWF Champion. He merely wanted his father to get some shine, and for the WWF to pay homage to what Angelo Poffo had accomplished in his career. By Vince turning it down, it's easy to see Randy taking this as a slap in the face, not only to him, but to his father, and the entire legacy of the Poffo family. If you look at it from Vince's point of view, you can also see why he did what he did. When you look at the names that ended up competing in the Legends Battle Royal, you'll see people like Lou Thesz (the man who won the match), Bobo Brazil, Nick Bockwinkel, Pat O'Connor, Dominic DeNucci, Tony Garea, Rene Goulet, Killer Kowalski, Gene Kiniski, Pedro Morales, Baron Mikel Scicluna, Arnold Skaaland, Chief Jay Strongbow, Ray Stevens, and more. That list includes some of the biggest and best in the history of wrestling. It could easily be argued that there just wasn't room for an Angelo Poffo in the match. Sure, Vince could have added him, but that's the beauty of being the ruler of his domain... he can make whatever decisions he wants, whenever he wants, for whatever reasons he wants.

3. Randy Being Offended Over His Move To Commentary

At WrestleMania 7, Savage lost to The Ultimate Warrior in a match where the loser would be forced to retire. According to the rumors, Vince felt that Randy was coming to the end of his career, anyway, and that he didn't have much more to contribute in the ring, so he came up with the idea of moving him to commentary, since he was still such a popular figure. As anybody would react if their boss basically told them that they were washed up, Randy did not take very kindly to the career change. He flipped out, and his relationship with Vince continued to sour. For one reason or another, the move to commentary wasn't a permanent one. A little over eight months later, the Macho Man was back in the ring, and he would actually wrestle pretty regularly from that point up until the time he left the WWF in October 1994. Since we're discussing his WWF departure...

2. Heading To WCW

WCW had been in contact with Savage towards the end of his WWF contract, and Vince caught wind of this. He had a few sit-downs with Randy about it, and reports are that, each and every time the subject came up, Randy told Vince to his face that he would be re-signing with the WWF and would not be "jumping ship". The time came and went, and not only did Savage not re-sign with the WWF, but he did, in fact, sign with WCW, debuting for them soon after his deal had expired. Through everything that had supposedly gone down in their relationship, Vince still looked at Randy like a brother, and he was said to be devastated that his "brother" had left the company, and by lying to do so. Obviously, it was Randy's life and contract, and he was free to do whatever he wanted with it, but if the story is true, could he have handled himself better? Vince already knew WCW was knocking on his door, so couldn't he have just told Vince about his grievances, said he is considering WCW's offer, and waited to see if Vince would respond with something better, either financially or to rebuild their relationship? That way, even if you did end up leaving for WCW, it wouldn't be on terrible terms, and you probably would have gotten bonuses for it, as WCW would have probably upped their offer for you once they found out about your negotiations. It really isn't that difficult. If any of you have ever been lied to you by someone you loved and considered family, you could understand just how Vince must have felt when he saw that Randy's contract had officially expired, and that he was gone from the company.

1. A Possible Affair With An Underage Stephanie McMahon

Look, this is something that has to be discussed, whether we like it or not. One of the most infamous urban legends in wrestling history, the story is that Randy Savage had a sexual relationship with an underage Stephanie McMahon. The exact time of the relationship is unknown, but Stephanie turned 18 in September 1994, which is a month before Savage left the WWF, so the time frame certainly fits. The story continues that Vince would eventually find out about what happened, but not until the later part of the 1990s, long after Savage went to WCW. Think about this, and place yourself in Vince's shoes. Is there anything physically possible that would piss you off more than finding out one of your employees had sexual relations with your underage daughter? Not only would many of you hold a grudge against Randy Savage forever if you were Vince, but you probably would have been sent to prison for what you did (or at least tried to do) to him, WCW employee or not. This isn't to say that the incident did happen, but nothing else even comes close to explaining a nearly 20-year grudge that Vince has apparently had towards Savage. Vince has had people lie to him in the past. Vince has had people physically attack him in the past. Vince has had people try to run him out of business in the past. Vince has had people say some terrible things about him in interviews. With each of those instances, he has worked with those individuals again. For him to go out of his way to tell his employees to not mention Savage's name (as stories indicate) during creative meetings and directly to him, there had to have been something major done in the past. We may not want to think about this being a possibility, but we almost have no choice with how much it makes sense. Unfortunately, we'll probably never find out the 100% truth behind what happened.