Everyone loves to talk about "what if" in sports. What if the 1975 Pittsburgh Steelers played the 1984 San Francisco 49ers? What if Babe Ruth played in Major League Baseball today? What if Muhammad Ali fought Mike Tyson? The questions and discussions are endless and allow us to imagine what could have been if situations were different. Professional wrestling is no different. Even though it is a predetermined sport, fans want to see the best against the best and fantasy booking is extremely popular online. Certain wrestlers seem to be natural opponents for others but, for a variety of different reasons, the matches simply never happened. Whether they were separated by time, distance, promotions, or backstage attitudes, these wrestlers never had the right situation to meet in the ring. Honestly, we could sit and argue for hours over who should win these matches but, at the end of the day, it doesn't matter. The match exists to entertain fans and this list is filled with matches that would bring fans to their feet. Whether it be a technical classic or a bloody and brutal brawl, a card stack with these ten matches would break every single box office record and draw record buys for pay-per-views. Obviously, none of these matches can occur today but, hey, it's fun to imagine.
10. Ricky Steamboat vs. Curt Hennig - 30 Minute Time Limit For The Intercontinental Title
Amazingly, despite working in the same promotion during the same time span, this match never took place (except maybe for a few unaired house show matches). There was a rumor that the match was scheduled for an August 1991 television taping but, due to Hennig's back issues, the match was canceled and Steamboat left the promotion shortly thereafter. While neither guy was exceptionally huge in stature, Hennig and Steamboat were perfect in their roles. Steamboat was the fiery babyface, showing emotion and anger at just the right times. Working with Ric Flair allowed Steamboat to become almost the perfect "good guy", someone who never cheated but eventually got fed up with the heel's shenanigans and kicked some righteous ass as the crowd went nuts. Hennig, on the other hand, was the perfect arrogant heel. He was smooth in the ring, had a mean streak, and could work the crowd as good as anyone. He was also one of the best sellers in the history of the business. Imagine Hennig feeding a Steamboat comeback after 20 minutes of beating on him, the crowd would go absolutely wild. A feud over the Intercontinental title would have been the obvious thing but, for whatever reason, Steamboat and Hennig never crossed paths in the ring. Steamboat had classic matches with Ric Flair on the big stage and there's no doubt that he would have done the same with Curt Hennig.
9. Randy Orton vs. Jake "The Snake" Roberts - Heel vs. Heel Grudge Match
The Viper vs. The Snake Like him or not, Randy Orton is going to go down as one of the icons of the TV-PG era mostly due to staying power and his ability to have good matches on the big stage. Orton's peers love his work with Bret Hart commenting that he's the best worker in the business today and Paul Heyman stating that, if he were starting a wrestling promotion tomorrow, he'd choose Orton as his centerpiece. Jake Roberts is quite simply a legend in every sense of the word. He was Steve Austin before being Steve Austin was cool. One of the best pure heels in the business, Roberts convinced most of the audience that he was 100% evil. Not only that but his promos were so legendary that people still rip them off over 20 years later. While other workers in the 1980s were screaming and yelling, Roberts spoke so softly that you had to turn the volume on the television up to hear him. He did this on purpose so that people would actually have to listen and pay attention to the words he was saying. While Orton has had many title runs during his time in WWE, Roberts never needed a title. Roberts was so over during his peak that he was the number two babyface in the company behind Hulk Hogan. When he turned heel later on, he was so effective that WCW signed him to a big money contract to wage a feud with Sting. It's a shame that Roberts personal demons robbed him of an even greater career. In the end, an Orton vs. Roberts match would be worth it if only for the promos. Roberts and Orton have both worked as heels and babyfaces but honestly, this match would be the best if it were a heel vs. heel match-up. They could both work their heel psychology and it would become a battle of "who can cheat the best", which would be tremendously entertaining. Both guys move very deliberately in the ring and every move would mean something. By the end, the crowd would be eating out of their hands.
8. Brock Lesnar vs. Big Van Vader - Hell In A Cell
Two of the most dominant big men of their era, Brock Lesnar and Big Van Vader were feared by fans and opponents alike. Even though professional wrestling is a work, there was real danger present whenever these two men stepped into the squared circle. Stronger than most of us can even imagine, these two monsters destroyed many opponents through fear and intimidation. Brock Lesnar is the current reigning WWE world champion. Starting in his 20s in WWE, he quickly rose through the ranks as the "Next Big Thing" and dominated the roster in short order. His mixture of power and speed was something that had never been seen before and his ability to do a Shooting Star Press from the top rope (seen in OVW and totally botched at Wrestlemania) was unheard of. After making the transition to UFC and unbelievably winning their heavyweight championship, Brock suddenly became one of the most feared men on earth. Now, when he walks to the ring, there is a big fight atmosphere and you can see how different Lesnar is from the rest of the roster. Before Brock Lesnar, there was Big Van Vader. If you only know him from his WWF run in the mid to late 1990s, you're really missing out on Vader. In the early 1990s, Vader was WCW's monster. He was a punishing champion who legitimately injured many who dared step into the ring with him. There are many stories of new wrestlers walking into Atlanta, seeing their name across from Vader's on the chalkboard, and then immediately grabbing their bags and running to their car, quitting the business that very day. Vader was a powerhouse who had agility and the ability to brawl with the best of them. A Hell in a Cell match between the two monsters would undoubtedly be one of the hardest-hitting,violent and brutal affairs in recent memory. Neither guy knows how to work any way but stiff so broken noses, black eyes, busted lips, and probably worse awaited them in this match. The match would honestly come down to who survived the beating the other delivered and the match may have surpassed any level of violence we would be able to imagine.
7. Big Show vs. Andre The Giant - Bodyslam Challenge
Andre the Giant, at his peak, was the biggest gate attraction in the world. He was one of the most popular athletes in history and also one of the most beloved figures in wrestling, despite the match that he had his biggest match as a hated heel. Younger Andre could move like someone half of his size, throwing dropkicks and impressing crowds all over the world with his athletic feats that no one else could ever equal. The Big Show is the closest thing we may ever see to Andre. While he certainly does not have the aura that Andre did in his day, Show does have his massive size and the ability to move around the ring, at times, in an impressive fashion. Years of terrible booking and nonsensical storylines have ruined the Big Show's "unstoppable monster" character but, given the right set of events, a match with Andre could draw huge business. The only problem with booking two big men against each other is that you lose the David vs. Goliath storyline that carries most of Andre's and Big Show's matches. When matched up with someone of somewhat equal height and weight, giants have to change their working style and it's not always for the best. However, if you could use the Wayback Machine to bring 1970s Andre and put him against mid-1990s Big Show, you could have an athletic contest that would impress most modern day fans. By incorporating the bodyslam stipulation, neither guy has to job cleanly, thus preserving their giant status for a future match.
6. The Dudley Boyz vs. The Road Warriors - Chicago/Dudleyville Street Fight
They are quite simply the two most successful tag teams in professional wrestling history. The Dudley Boyz dominated two separate promotions en route to championship gold and the Road Warriors may have been the most feared tag team in professional wrestling history. The Road Warriors, Hawk and Animal, broke the mold when it came to tag wrestlers. Looking like massive bodybuilders, Hawk and Animal quickly won over the crowd in Georgia and the NWA, despite being heels, due to their unbelievable look and fact that they never sold...anything. The Road Warriors dominated the tag team scene for so long that no one was perceived as a threat to their spot. When "Iron Man" by Black Sabbath played in the arena, fasn went so wild that any loud crowd reaction was then measured against a "Road Warrior pop". All in all, the Road Warriors won over 20 world titles as a team and were the only team to win the WWF, NWA, and AWA tag titles, becoming more successful than any team ever before. The Dudley Boyz started as a sideshow comedy act in ECW but quickly became one of their top attractions thanks to the work of Bubba Ray Dudley (Bully Ray) and D-Von. The two became some of the biggest stars in the company and moved to the WWF shortly thereafter. Thanks to their table gimmick and a penchant for powerbombing women, the Dudleyz became accepted members of the roster. However, it was a three-way battle with the Hardys and Edge and Christian in a series of TLC matches that turned all six men into bona fide superstars. As a team, they are 23-time tag champions and are the only team to win the WWE, WCW, ECW, IWGP, NWA, and TNA titles. They are the most successful team, by far, in the modern era. The good thing about booking a match between these two teams is that they are both brawling tag teams. The Dudleys and Road Warriors both thrived when rules were removed and matches turned into fights. Like the crazy brawls of the 1980s and the insanity of the ECW arena, this match would allow each team to beat the other until all four men were bloodied and battered. This street fight would spill all over the arena and fans would have a hard time keeping up with all of the action.
5. Chris Benoit vs. Daniel Bryan - Submission Match
Chris Benoit and Daniel Bryan both traveled similar paths throughout their careers. Both guys were thought of as "too small" for the main event slot. For years, Benoit was thought of as just a great midcard worker who would never be anything more. Kevin Nash himself even referred to Benoit as a "vanilla midget", making fun of both his size and his lack of charisma/personality that featured main event guys were thought to have required. The story of Daniel Bryan has been well-documented in recent years and his fight against the establishment was equally driven by the internet. Bryan was one of the best workers on the roster but also was able to provide some great storyline moments. His heel act with his innocent manager, AJ Lee, brought back memories of Randy Savage and Miss Elizabeth with the pretty girl helplessly in love with the egotistical jerk. A partnership with Kane seemingly propelled Bryan to the top of the card and his longtime battle with the Authority both frustrated and thrilled fans. Both were also probably the best technical wrestler of their generation. Bryan and Benoit have similar movesets and were never afraid to put their body at risk with a diving headbutt or a dive to the outside. Watching the psychology between these two would be amazing and, given ample time, this match would steal the show on any pay-per-view event.
4. Bret Hart vs. Kurt Angle - Two Out Of Three Falls
Speaking of technical wrestlers, probably the only two who could rival Chris Benoit and Daniel Bryan are Bret Hart and Kurt Angle. Both were former amateur stars who turned their attention to the world of professional wrestling and became bigger stars than almost anyone in the business. Bret was probably the most dependable WWF champion of the modern era, defending the title on nearly every show against all different types of wrestlers. At one point, Hart was one of (if not the) best workers in the world and performed just as hard on Raw as he did at a pay-per-view. His legendary rivalries with Shawn Michaels and Steve Austin made the WWF the juggernaut it became and helped turn the Monday Night War around. While never the most charismatic worker in the world, Hart could bring it in the ring better than anyone and could show a mean streak when the situation called for it. Kurt Angle, quite simply, is a freak. The 1996 Olympic gold medalist from Pittsburgh joined the World Wrestling Federation due to a lack of other athletic opportunities and became instantly one of the promotion's biggest stars. Angle picked up professional wrestling faster than anyone else and became world champion only a year after his debut in the company. Angle rose through the ranks to main event Wrestlemania XIX and still, at over 40 years old, is one of the best workers in the world when he's healthy. A match between these two would be a technical marvel and really showcase both men's athletic talents. A two out of three falls match would allow each to use their submission moves, their psychology, and their big spots to work the crowd and move to a third and deciding fall with the crowd firmly in the palm of their hands. At their peak, no one could touch Hart and Angle in the ring and this would be a five-star classic.
3. New World Order vs. D-Generation X vs. The Four Horsemen - War Games
When you have two rings, one cage, and possibly the most brutal match in the history of wrestling, what better choice for participants than the three most dominant stables in wrestling history? For this match, let's assume it's going to be a 4 vs. 4 vs. 4 match where anything goes and surrender is the only way to win. The New World Order ran roughshod over WCW for years. It was the hottest angle in wrestling in 1996 and turned WCW from an afterthought to the number one promotion in North America. When Scott Hall and Kevin Nash made their debuts on WCW Nitro, you could almost feel the wrestling world shift and now all eyes were on Atlanta, Georgia. They became probably the most dominant heel faction in wrestling history and grew to a tremendous size that eventually led to the death of the company. However, for this match, you'd have Hulk Hogan, Scott Hall, Kevin Nash, and the Giant. If the New World Order were the reason WCW started to win the Monday Night War, then D-Generation X was one of the main catalysts of the WWF Attitude Era. Pushing the envelope before that was cool, the original pairing of Shawn Michaels and Triple H pushed the bounds of good taste and became huge stars because of it. After Shawn's back injury, the group morphed into one of the hottest acts in wrestling's hottest period, winning countless titles and selling more merchandise than anyone imagined. DX shirts still fly off the shelf and a recent reunion was successful as well. For the War Games match, DX would send out Triple H, X-Pac, and the New Age Outlaws. When you think of stables in professional wrestling, if you don't think of the Four Horsemen then you need to stop watching wrestling. The Horsemen defined what a heel stable should be and ruled Jim Crockett Promotions for years in many different incarnations. With Ric Flair as the crown jewel, the Andersons as the dominant tag team, and Tully Blanchard as the US champion, the Four Horsemen were the studs of professional wrestling. They engaged in legendary rivalries with Sting, Lex Luger, the Hollywood Blondes, and the New World Order. To this day, the Four Horsemen are over with fans and still have a place in history. For the match, the Horsemen would send out their original incarnation of Ric Flair, Arn and Ole Anderson, and Tully Blanchard. Always a bloody and brutal affair, a three-way War Games match between the three factions would set the standard for War Games. The amount of storylines that could be told in this match would be endless and some of the greatest workers in wrestling history would be inside the ring at the same time. You could do Hulk Hogan vs. Ric Flair, Triple H vs. Scott Hall, and the Andersons vs. the New Age Outlaws. The match would need at least 60 minutes and would deserve every single second of it.
2. Shawn Michaels vs. The Rock - 60 Minute Iron Man Match
Another match that never happened despite both workers working for the same promotion at the same time, The Rock and Shawn Michaels are two of the most charismatic stars in the history of professional wrestling. Not only can both guys talk circles around anyone else in the business, very few were able to out-perform them in big match situations. Rumors persist that Vince McMahon wanted this match to happen but The Rock shut it down due to his dislike of Shawn Michaels and his backstage attitude. Shawn Michaels could be the greatest all-around performer to ever step inside the ring. Being able to adapt to the new WWF Attitude, Shawn Michaels went from a tag team performer to the main event star of the World Wrestling Federation. After a back injury seemed to end his career, Michaels found Jesus and seemingly was granted a second chance in wrestling, returning to WWE and building a second career for himself, cementing himself as a legend of the ring. Michaels has left a countless number of classic matches in his wake and is one of the few workers who could go 60 minutes and still be effective. The Rock was such a big star that professional wrestling was too small to hold him. Now the highest paid actor in Hollywood, The Rock was destined to be a superstar from the moment he set foot in the ring. No one knew how big, of course, but a well-timed heel turn changed The Rock from a hated babyface into one of the most successful heels of all-time. In addition to growing into one of the best workers in the business, The Rock was (and probably still is) the best promo man in the business. Both of these men have proven that they can go 60 minutes. Shawn Michaels had a classic matchup with Bret Hart in an Iron Man match at Wrestlemania XII and The Rock went an hour with Triple H in 2000 (ironically with Shawn Michaels as the special guest referee). The promos leading up to the match would be worth the price of admission alone and the match would simply be spectacular. Since this match seems unlikely to occur now, we can only imagine what it would be like.
1. Hulk Hogan vs. "Stone Cold" Steve Austin - One Fall For The World Heavyweight Title
How can you not pick this match as number one? It is a match of the two biggest stars in the history of professional wrestling for the biggest prize in wrestling. Hulk Hogan was the one of the biggest stars in the world in the 1980s. Hulkamania was running wild and the Golden Age of professional wrestling saw the sport set ratings and attendance records all over the world. Hogan was drawing money against everyone he was put up against and that culminated in a Wrestlemania III clash with Andre the Giant that symbolized the peak of Vince McMahon's promotion in the 80s. Hogan was the classic babyface who always did the right thing, helped his friends, and worked hard against the odds. Hulk Hogan was a role model to millions, a pop culture icon, and is still one the most recognizable stars in the industry. If Hogan was the classic babyface, then Steve Austin changed what a babyface could be in the late 1990s. A castoff from WCW, Austin found a home in the WWF and quickly rose through the ranks as someone who rebelled against authority and the establishment. Austin became a babyface even though he never changed his mannerisms, Austin the babyface did the exact same things as Austin the heel, his targets just changed. Austin's feud with Vince McMahon drew more money than anything else in the history of professional wrestling and he still stands as the biggest draw in wrestling history. For you younger fans, you cannot even being to imagine how many "Austin 3:16" t-shirts were worn in the late 1990s. Austin brought the WWF to new heights and made Monday Night Raw must-see television for years. If you could take 1987 Hulk Hogan and place him against 1998 Steve Austin, you would have the most legendary match possible. There have never been two bigger stars and there would never be a bigger match. Honestly, would it matter who won?