10 Fluke Wrestling Wins That Actually Worked

Roll-up! Roll-up! Getcha Roll-ups!

By Gareth Morgan /

WWE.com

Nothing quite beats the story of a plucky underdog trying to overcome the titanic odds that are laid out before them.

This is a through-line that WWE have explored numerous times in the past - to varying success. Daniel Bryan conquering the Authority was no mistake, but there is the odd occasion where a chance victory has presented a platform for a worker to push off and burn down the competition with the new found rocket attached to their back.

Advertisement

Of course, in modern day WWE, the roll-up 'stolen' victory is as common as a superkick and that renders the vast amount of competitors who gain a shock win in this way last week's news by the time Raw or SmackDown LIVE comes around again.

This isn't an attack on the sudden finish that litters our weekly television, it's merely an acknowledgement of how it, and properly executed 'flukes' in general, can be used to further a rookie or promising talent's career.

Anything can happen in the WWE! isn't just a catchphrase we're beaten over the head with; it's the reality that our favourite wrestlers live in. A slip, trip, quick thinking or being in the right place at the right time can change everything.

Now let's see how...

10. Sheamus Fumbles To The Gold (Vs John Cena)

After debuting on ECW as the formidable Sheamus, the Irishman made quick work of the likes of Goldust and Shelton Benjamin (more on him later), before transitioning into a role on the flagship, Monday Night Raw.

Sheamus bulldozed Jamie Noble and scored the deciding victory in his PPV debut at Survivor Series for Team Miz, pinning opposition captain John Morrison.

Advertisement

The big man was ready for the big time and there wasn't much bigger than the Franchise himself, John Cena. The soon to be Great White dumped Cena through a table in their contract singing and this acted as a precursor for what was to come.

At TLC, in their tables match, Cena looked to be in a position to launch Sheamus from the top rope through a set table below. Sheamus had other ideas and fumbled his way out of the predicament, leaving Cena to lose his balance a plummet through the wooden structure.

This fluke catapulted Sheamus into the main event picture, and he wouldn't leave it for long over the next six years. He picked up numerous accolades - World Championships, the Money in the Bank briefcase, Royal Rumble winner and King of the Ring - proving that this lucky break was a precise and intelligent move for all those involved in making it happen.

9. Cedric Alexander Shocks The Scottish Psychopath (Vs Drew McIntyre)

It's about damn time that Cedric Alexander got the push he so richly deserves!

Now that's out of the way, let's delve into how this all came to pass.

Advertisement

Alexander had been drafted to Raw in the 2019 (shudder) Superstar Shake-Up, going on to lose his debut match to Cesaro.

Excellent.

That loss alluded to an immediate burial of the former Cruiserweight champion, with him pretty much disappearing for the two months that followed. A brief 24/7 title reign brought him back to the audience's attention before Alexander disguised himself as Gary Garbutt in a losing battle, teaming with Roman Reigns to take on Shane McMahon and Drew McIntyre.

This sudden flip up into the main event scene definitely helped raise his stock in the company, as the following week saw him score a sensational upset pin over the Scottish Psychopath.

A fluke it may have been - Alexander lost the rematch - but it appeared to have set the man up as a serious competitor and he soon found himself with a pinfall over AJ Styles and a U.S.Title shot at Clash of Champions.

Alexander would go on to lose cleanly to Styles at the PPV, but the two showcased what excellent chemistry they have together and the defeat definitely didn’t take any shine off of Alexander's recent ascension.

That man deserves a rematch!

8. Fandango Takes The Dance (Vs Chris Jericho)

The win that inspired a movement.

Advertisement

Well, for a few weeks anyway.

When Chris Jericho's opponent for WrestleMania 29 was revealed to be the dancing sensation, Fandango, a few eyebrows were raised. Feuds have begun over some fairly ridiculous disputes over the years; now we had instigation due to a mispronunciation of a performer's name.

Scrapping in a short and sweet affair, the two put on a pleasant show and Fandango played the role of weasel heel as if he'd been doing it on the main roster for years. It looked as if he was to taste defeat in his main roster debut match when Jericho began to transition into the Walls of Jericho, only for Fandango to spot a 'tweak' in the veteran's knee and successfully tangle Y2J in a cradle for the pin.

A truly unexpected win, yet the best was still to come.

On Raw, the night after 'Mania, the crowd hijacked the show with a sing-a-long version of Fandango's theme music, accompanied by a jovial dance routine. The song caught fire, and even placed as high as #11 on the iTunes UK chart.

Fandango-ing was eventual stifled by WWE management (if it isn't their idea, they don't tend to be encouraging) but never forget the seismic popularity that a man - who danced to the ring - managed to garner due to a fluke victory on the Grandest Stage.

7. Randy Orton Strikes On His Debut (Vs Hardcore Holly)

As a former United States Marine who was dishonourably discharged - if not for his status as the third generation of the legendary Orton lineage - it would be hard to imagine WWE seeing this as a wise acquisition.

Advertisement

After cutting his teeth in Mid-Missouri as a dry run towards it, Randy Orton soon found himself in the WWE developmental territory Ohio Valley Wrestling by 2001, rubbing shoulders with the pre-superstardom likes of Batista, John Cena and Brock Lesnar.

By 2002, Orton had learnt all he could in OVW and was given the bump up to the big-time, debuting against Hardcore Holly on the April 25th episode of Smackdown! Orton showcased his impressive athleticism - with a spectacular cross-body off the top rope - and hinted at his natural aptitude for the business between the ropes. He would go on to score an inside cradle victory over Holly that set up a programme between the two which began to plant Orton in the forefront of the fan's minds.

Before long, Orton would be drafted to Raw, only to suffer the first of his many shoulder injuries.

He would return to join the stable Evolution and the rest, as they say, is history.

His lucky break against the wily Holly resonated with the fans and they were here for the ride (or rise) from that moment on.

6. John Cena Slips Under The Walls (Vs Chris Jericho)

Chris Jericho can't catch a break, can he?

Advertisement

Far and away from the John Cena we are exposed to today, this young rookie found himself thrown into a feud with the dastardly former World Champion and was placed in his first ever PPV bout with the man at Vengeance 2002.

Jericho went straight after Cena with a steel chair, only for Cena to steal the weapon and release his new found 'ruthless aggression' on the villain. Cena used this fire to blast Jericho in the early stages, but before long the seasoned Y2J used his superior ring IQ to grind down the green rookie. Cena had teased stealing the victory throughout the match, only for Jericho to out-smart him at every turn - it looked to be a futile experience for OVW's Prototype.

However, with Jericho's arrogance brimming, he tried to toy with Cena and half-heartedly attempted the Walls of Jericho. Young Cena finally successfully pulled the trigger and countered the submission into a roll-up for the win.

This PPV victory added more fuel to the John Cena hype-blaze that had newly erupted after his exchange with Kurt Angle on his official debut. Cena showed his potential as a crowd-popping babyface here and it would prove the foundation for the Cenation Leader we know today.

5. 1-2-3 Kid Flips The Landscape Onto Its Head (Vs Razor Ramon)

You had to know it was only a matter of time before this historic gem found its way onto this list.

In May of 1993 Razor Ramon was being held in very high regard by the then WWF, coming off the back of a WWF Title programme with Bret Hart and a WrestleMania win over Bob Backlund. The Kid on the other hand was quite green around the gills and hadn't been given much of a chance to show what he was made of as a singles competitor.

Advertisement

That all changed in a moonsault.

Catching Ramon off-guard after an enthralling encounter, The Kid flipped from the top rope and hung onto the more experienced foe for the three count - thus being christened the 1-2-3 Kid.

Understandably, this put Sean Waltman on the map as the new plucky underdog on the block. Yet, it was the programme that followed which slowly turned The Bad Guy into a fan favourite.

Going back and forth into the King of the Ring tournament - where Ramon showed The Kid had earned his respect - Ramon decided to help the young upstart conquer the all-powerful Million Dollar Man who was berating the two at the time.

If it wasn't for this excellent finish, none of these exchanges would have been formulated, and the two Clique members may not have scaled the heights they did in Vince McMahon's company.

4. Eddie Guerrero Ties Up The Olympian...But Not His Shoelaces (Vs Kurt Angle)

No character has been defined by the phrase 'making your own luck' like the late Eddie Guerrero.

Latino Heat managed to lie, cheat and steal his way to the WWE Championship in 2004 and the fans were grateful that their hero had finally ascended to the top of the mountain.

Advertisement

Enter the Olympic Wrestling Machine.

Kurt Angle presented himself as the maniacal heel that Guerrero would have to overcome in order to earn his WrestleMania moment. Angle used the programme to poke and criticise the Champion for his substance abuse. This only made the crowd sympathise for Guerrero's recovery, and they were completely in his corner by the time 'Mania XX came around.

Guerrero found out early on that he may have bitten off more than he could chew, and Angle's ruthless wrestling pushed the Champ to desperate measures.

Untying his shoe lace to relieve the pressure from a clinical Ankle Lock, Guerrero hobbled around the ring, luring Angle into making his move. Another Ankle Lock was attempted but Eddie's boot came loose, leaving Angle vulnerable to a small package and the 1-2-3.

If it wasn't for his ingenuity we would have never got to see the journeyman have his WrestleMania moment.

3. A Hurricane Flusters The Great One (Vs The Rock)

Even though it's been 16 years since this match actually happened, it still doesn't feel real.

The match in question all stemmed from backstage segments involving the two, where The Rock referred to The Hurricane as 'The Hamburglar'. These skits were hilarious and helped get Hurricane over as the comedic superhero tonic we all needed at the time.

Advertisement

Of course, none of this hilarity would be much use unless it culminated in a match. Rock played the cocky heel who was too good for the wannabe hero, with Hurricane struggling to get much offense in at all.

A WrestleMania match with Stone Cold Steve Austin was in need of promoting, so the Rattlesnake appeared on the entrance ramp to distract his nemesis.

It worked.

Hurricane rolled up The Great One and the fans lost their minds.

This is a perfect example of how backstage work and leaning into a wrestler's character (however far fetched) in those skits can lead to sizeable crowd investment. The match helped Hurricane feel like a star for a few weeks and he's still cherished by many - just look at his Royal Rumble appearance in 2018.

None of that is possible without this mini-programme and him lucking out on a Rattlesnake rearing its head.

2. Santino Marella's Miracle In Milan (Vs Umaga)

WWE has a patchy record when leaning into the hometown of a superstar by giving them a crowd-pleasing victory. So for them to allow a complete unknown (a fan in the eyes of the public) to gain a victory in the place of his heritage, would be an unrealistic dream, right?

You'd think, but all bets were off when Vince McMahon decided to jibe the capacity crowd in Milan, picking a mere mortal from the crowd to face his vicious monster - the Intercontinental Champion - Umaga.

Advertisement

McMahon's hubris got the better of him when he decided the title match would be fought under a No Holds Barred stipulation. Umaga and The Boss' enemy at the time, Bobby Lashley, would soon intervene, setting Marella up for an easy pin and maiden title victory on his debut.

The Italian fans understandably lost their minds, unaware that Marella had actually been on the OVW books for some time, training for his moment to shine. He seized his chance and fixed himself into WWE history forever.

This miracle in Milan would set Marella on a path involving countless amusing moments, drag and a sock puppet to rival Mr. Socko.

Not bad for a 'random' Canadian (of Italian heritage) in the audience.

1. Ain't No Stoppin' Shelton Benjamin (Vs Triple H)

Way back in 2004, Benjamin was coming off the back of a successful spell on SmackDown! as one half of the World's Greatest Tag Team, with partner Charlie Haas. Then, the future Gold Standard was abruptly drafted to Raw and his future was left hanging in the balance.

Upon his arrival as the flagship's newest singles blood, Benjamin found himself in one on one action with the, newly usurped former World Heavyweight Champion, Triple H.

Advertisement

The underdog was giving as good as he got but still couldn't put The Game - assisted by Ric Flair - away. Chris Benoit, the World Champ at the time, bombed down to ringside to extinguish the parasitic threat of the Nature Boy's constant interference. Benjamin capitalised on the inadvertent distraction and caught the King of Kings off guard with a splash in the corner, leading to a roll-up victory.

Benjamin scurried away and left with a 'W' over the multiple time World Champion. With that sort of scalp on his resume, Benjamin soon found himself feuding for the Intercontinental Title - which he would claim on numerous occasions.

Although he's never got the illustrious World Title run he more than deserves, his athletic displays and charismatic charm (his Momma also had a hand in proceedings) helped to get Benjamin over as one of the strongest talents on the roster.

His opportunistic coming out party against the now COO proved to be the blueprint for the man's evergreen success.

Advertisement