10 Forgotten WWE NXT TakeOver Classics

Cole vs. Black, LeRae vs. Shirai and other forgotten bangers from NXT TakeOver history.

By Adam Morrison /

NXT TakeOver has played host to such a vast array of banging matches that ranking them was near-impossible.

Advertisement

You had to take everything from bell to bell into consideration. Neither the build to the match nor the aftermath of it matters in this case; this is solely to do with the in-ring content that was produced. The sheer intensity of it. Its effectiveness in getting everyone involved 'over' to a certain extent. The spots that would no doubt be sprawled throughout the entirety of the contest.

There was always going to be an abundance of honourable mentions. It's always the case when ranking the best of something, even more so where it pertains to professional wrestling. Title-less bouts, like Jushin 'Thunder' Liger vs. Tyler Breeze, Aleister Black vs. Hideo Itami, and Damian Priest vs. Killian Dain vs. Pete Dunne are just as worthy of a rewatch as title bouts - such as the Undisputed Era vs. Moustache Mountain, Shayna Baszler vs. Bianca Belair vs. Io Shirai vs. Kairi Sane, and the War Raiders vs. Aleister Black and Ricochet - are.

Those are merely a small percentage of the TakeOver bangers that have spanned the past seven years. The list is, quite literally, endless.

As for those that got lost in history, though?

10. Asuka Vs. Mickie James - NXT TakeOver: Toronto

Prior to her pregnancy putting a halt on the plans, WWE Hall of Famer Trish Stratus was penned for the TakeOver: Toronto Women's Championship bout vs. Asuka. Instead, her WrestleMania 22 adversary Mickie James was given the spot prior to her full-time comeback the following year.

Advertisement

The veteran didn't look a step out of place opposite the defending champion, wrestling a respectful bout with the Empress of Tomorrow that worked perfectly on a TakeOver card.

There was never a reason for James to dethrone Asuka - thankfully, she was submitted via Asuka Lock in about 13 minutes - and so this remains a solid example of a returning legend doing their job correctly. As far as us fans knew at the time of the November 2016 clash, the former Women's Champion hadn't signed an official contract. The only real benefit to having her partake in the outing was to give Asuka a meaningful victory to establish her as a legitimate top-tier star.

It worked, unsurprisingly.

Sadly slotted between two other certified bangers - DIY vs. the Revival and Samoa Joe vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - this match is now almost entirely forgotten about. WWE themselves eclipsed any memory of this with that dire outing between the duo on a September 2020 Raw with that finish. Still, this was solid stuff.

9. Austin Aries Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura - NXT TakeOver: The End

In reality, the entire TakeOver: The End card could be deemed a series of forgotten events.

Advertisement

Andrade 'Cien' Almas, in his debut, vs. Tye Dillinger was short but decent, a TakeOver: Dallas rematch between American Alpha and the Revival hit the right spot, Asuka and Nia Jax's title bout was fine, and Samoa Joe and Finn Balor had a cracking steel cage match.

As for Austin Aries vs. Shinsuke Nakamura? It was blissful perfection. Going down precisely as you'd expect it to, the pair lived up to the 'dream match' headline beautifully, made only better by each man's ability to sell the sh*t out of literally everything.

Highlights here included a brutal apron Death Valley Driver and Aries missing his attempted Suicide Dive, instead meeting the barricade head-first in a sick collision. It was crucial for Nakamura to win, though. Although both men's in-ring debuts had occurred on the same event - TakeOver: Dallas two months prior - NXT higher-ups clearly had a bigger vision in mind for the King of Strong Style than they ever did for A Double.

Everything about the match made sense. It was designed to get Shinsuke over to a potentially unaware audience. It did just that, as if his match vs. Sami Zayn hadn't already achieved it. Even in defeat, Aries still shone, this being the peak of his WWE run.

8. The Authors Of Pain Vs. DIY Vs. The Revival - NXT TakeOver: Orlando

The Authors of Pain were never intended to flourish in NXT, hailed as the land of the indie darlings. They were simply too bland to be classed as top-tier NXT stars when you had non-WWE standouts like Bobby Roode, Shinsuke Nakamura and Asuka coming through the ranks at the same time.

Advertisement

They did, however, produce a corker at TakeOver: Orlando.

A three-way elimination bout pitting them as the defending NXT Tag Team Champions against DIY and the Revival, the AOP's stance as hosses added some spice to the DIY/Revival series. They acted exactly as they needed to here, hence why all four challengers put their differences aside to take them down. The two challenging teams combining to hit each other's signature manoeuvres - the Meeting in the Middle and the Shatter Machine - remains an underrated TakeOver moment.

In reality, the challengers didn't need to succeed in their quest for gold here. Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa were on the cusp of their impeccable rivalry, whereas Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder were off to the Raw roster mere days later.

As for Akam and Rezar? They were still fresh into their title run, having won them at the previous TakeOver, and they desperately needed the straps to keep their aura alive.

Inarguably one of the AOP's greatest matches ever, it proved that WWE could do tag team wrestling right when they wanted to. They just needed the right combination.

7. Danny Burch & Oney Lorcan Vs. The Undisputed Era - NXT TakeOver: Chicago II

Another prime example of WWE getting tag team wrestling correct, Danny Burch and Oney Lorcan's challenge for Roderick Strong and Kyle O'Reilly's NXT Tag Team Championships went down a treat at the second TakeOver: Chicago.

Advertisement

This is the match where Burch and Lorcan won over the NXT audience, having previously been a fodder tandem for the likes of the AOP, Pete Dunne and Roderick Strong, and even f**king Riddick Moss and Tino Sabbatelli. They came into this being booed by the Chicago audience. By the end? Those same fans were chanting for the future Kings of NXT.

It was vital that this bout be cut in half; starting off slow, it was a certified banger by the end that saw Oney Lorcan revert to indie darling Biff Busick. The guy that had once torn down the American Legion Post #308 in Reseda was doing the same thing in Rosemont's Allstate Arena, executing his once-patented half and half suplex and running uppercut.

This all went down without a hitch. Strong and O'Reilly were hardly going to drop the straps, but Danny and Oney had to get over here. That they did so in such an exceptional contest is a testament to how tremendously well-booked NXT was at the time.

6. Dakota Kai Vs. Tegan Nox - NXT TakeOver: Portland

Overshadowed by the debut of Raquel Gonzalez, the TakeOver: Portland Street Fight between Dakota Kai and Tegan Nox is severely underrated.

Advertisement

The former tag partners aren't to blame for that, though. It went down on a TakeOver that most have forgotten even existed. Coming immediately after Keith Lee and Dominik Dijakovic's instant classic also didn't help the duo. Regardless, Kai and Nox still created a banger of a Street Fight.

This wasn't your typically bland WWE weapons-oriented match, either. They made use of all manner of weapons to get across the tone that they legitimately detested one another. Chairs and trash cans are symbolic of any WWE no disqualifications bout; chains and cricket bats, however, are not.

What made this remarkable were the spots on offer. Tegan placing a trash can over Dakota's head to perform a senton-esque strike was unusual and innovative, despite the slight botch on the actual execution. The same goes for Dakota taking a f**king sick German suplex onto a trash can; it looked beautiful, but the trash can barely dented. While not a botch per se, it heightened the riskiness.

It's a shame this match - and this TakeOver in general - has been forgotten about almost entirely, but hey, a potential Women's Championship TakeOver bout awaits them once Nox has returned from injury and Kai has inevitably pried the title away from Raquel.

5. Adrian Neville Vs. Sami Zayn Vs. Tyler Breeze Vs. Tyson Kidd - NXT TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way

Serving as the precursor to Sami Zayn's capture of the NXT Championship that December, NXT TakeOver: Fatal 4-Way's title bout was as perfect a fatal four way match as you could ever want.

Advertisement

Zayn, Tyler Breeze, Tyson Kidd and defending champion Adrian Neville crafted an admirable match to main event TakeOver in an era where TakeOvers weren't as special as they now are. It was WWE's fault, though; who was honestly going to tune in to a Hair vs. Hair match between Enzo Amore and Sylvester Lefort?

Nonetheless, this banged hard.

From Neville's utterly gorgeous Asia moonsault, to Breeze going on a rampage by taking everyone out via Beauty Shot, Supermodel Kick, and dropkick, there literally wasn't a moment to rest. While it did at times follow the multi-man trope of two guys in at a time while the others rest, this was only for short periods. When there were at least three involved at once, it was blissfully perfect.

Zayn diving onto Neville to eliminate the champion from the equation, and then rapidly scampering to Helluva Kick Tyson Kidd was also a class finish, made only better by the future Bastard yanking the referee out of the ring. This was genuinely impeccable, and should be a must-watch for wrestling trainees if they hope to perfect a multi-man contest.

4. Adam Cole Vs. Aleister Black - NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia

Just look at that GIF. One glance, and you can already see how vastly different this was from your standard WWE Extreme Rules Match.

Advertisement

Adam Cole and Aleister Black's outing at the January 2018 TakeOver: Philadelphia was undeniably one of the company's greatest weapons bouts promoted in the last few years. Everything was logical here. They simply wanted to hurt each other; at one point early on, Black just said f**k it and forearmed the piss out of Cole's face. This set the perfect atmosphere.

The rest of this was unreal. Black taunting Cole by both sitting on the mat and on a steel chair in the Dutch Destroyer's signature pose was mint, as were some of the spots that WWE matches had never before seen. A Death Valley Driver atop two chairs was the highlight for Black here.

That there wasn't much of a story didn't matter. All the focus was placed on the in-ring process from the two that totally blew minds that night. It's not exactly difficult to analyse what made it such a banger. You take Adam Cole and Aleister Black, you place them on a TakeOver card, and you give them a stipulation to work with. It was only ever going to be a scintillating end result.

3. Blake & Murphy Vs. The Vaudevillians - NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn

NXT fans cared about Wesley Blake, Buddy Murphy, Aiden English and Simon Gotch. Watching main roster WWE, though, you'd never realise such a thing. The image above shows precisely how much the NXT fanbase loved the Vaudevillains in their moment of glory.

Advertisement

The match that contained said moment of glory was a belter, too.

Going down at the hit TakeOver: Brooklyn the weekend of SummerSlam 2015, English and Gotch wrestled a compelling match against the champions, capped off with the pair hitting Murphy with the Whirling Dervish to lift the straps after Gotch's divine hot tag. Sticking to some of the typical Babyface vs. Heel tropes didn't matter too much; there was still enough flavour to make this as delightful a match as it was.

It's strange looking back and seeing a major venue go wild for the quartet. Far and away the highlight of English and Gotch's WWE tenure together, this was the beginning of the NXT Tag Team Championships becoming a massive factor of NXT programming. At this time, the division was beginning to boom, with these two, American Alpha, the Revival, and Enzo Amore and Big Cass all coming through.

Again, while not the night's biggest match, it's still worth a rewatch today for the pops alone. The Vaudevillians were a class tag team that suffered immensely; they were deserving of this sort of moment.

2. Andrade 'Cien' Almas Vs. Roderick Strong - NXT TakeOver: San Antonio

Roderick Strong and Andrade 'Cien' Almas had an irrefutable cracker at TakeOver: San Antonio, acting as the coming out party for the latter in WWE. Until this point, the former La Sombra had been nothing more than a blight on an already stacked NXT roster.

Advertisement

By the end, though? He certified himself as a banger machine.

Wrestling a typically strong TakeOver bout for the time, the pair combined banal rest holds with expert strikes and marvellous backbreakers from the future Undisputed Era man to craft such an outstanding affair. Andrade was as elegant in his character work here, being in full tranquilo form, as Roddy was at each backbreaker variation he pulled off.

In the 12 minutes they shared in-ring, the duo turned an otherwise meaningless bout into a spectacle that, if masterfully perfected, could be deemed worthy of the TakeOver main event spot. It was Roderick Strong that won the match, downing Andrade via Sick Kick, but it was Almas that won over the fans. That's why he went on such an impressive run afterwards that he became NXT Champion by year's end.

Similar to Dakota Kai vs. Tegan Nox at TakeOver: Portland, this match went down on a TakeOver that not many remember. It's an issue that has plagued the majority of the January TakeOvers, sadly. Regardless, the pair overdelivered.

1. Candice LeRae Vs. Io Shirai - NXT TakeOver: Toronto II

How did this fall off the map as much as it has?

Advertisement

Fresh off her heel turn on Candice LeRae a month-and-a-half prior, NXT TakeOver: Toronto II saw the Stardom legend produce one of TakeOver's greatest non-title bouts up against the Poison Pixie. That Shirai suplexed LeRae atop the announce table within the first minute set the mood perfectly.

The remainder of this was fresh, compelling professional wrestling. You may remember Candice's savage reverse Frankensteiner as a significant highlight, and rightfully so; it was beyond graceful. Io's top-rope backflip - and landing on her feet - to evade a top-rope German suplex was equally as alluring.

This served as the best possible follow-up to Io's heel turn. Arguably one of NXT's most enthralling turns, the Joshi Judas was more captivating as a heel against Candice than she ever was as a babyface. From her mesmerising entrance, to her unique mannerisms throughout the match, Shirai had turned up a level at a point where the women's division in NXT needed it most.

Respect must also be placed in LeRae's direction, though. She played her role to sheer perfection on this August 2019 event, from ambushing the future Women's Champion before the bell, to attempting literal neck compression with that aforementioned reverse 'rana. Two all-time great NXT performers unsurprisingly made for a first-rate TakeOver clash.

Advertisement