10 Great WWE NXT Storylines You Don't Remember

The NXT brand is highly regarded, but some prominent storylines have been lost to history.

By Andrew Champagne /

NXT, as we know it, burst onto the scene in 2012 and provided WWE fans with both a look into the future and a different-feeling product from everything else the company had been doing. Up-and-coming stars mixed with Performance Center projects looking for a big break, and the result has been one of the most consistent, entertaining wrestling shows anywhere in the world.

Advertisement

The brand has helped develop a number of recognizable stars, such as Seth Rollins, Finn Balor, Sami Zayn, and Kevin Owens. It's also been a vehicle for some of the best storylines of the past ten years, including the wars between Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa and the transformation of Bayley into a legitimate force.

Like with every promotion, though, some angles and storylines are more memorable than others, many of which require deeper dives into the history books. In NXT's case, many of those involve prominent wrestlers and personalities, and for one reason or another, they don't get mentioned much. With that in mind, let's dive in, take a look at ten of them, and give them the respect they deserve.

10. Juice Eats "Crowe"

Juice Robinson and Sami Callihan are well-known for their exploits outside of WWE. However, both were in the NXT system in 2015, and they had a memorable segment that doubled as Callihan's on-screen NXT debut.

Advertisement

Playing his CJ Parker character, the man better known as Robinson stormed to the ring and staged a protest over not being booked on the recent TakeOver: Arrival. As he hung "caution" tape around the ring, a vignette aired advertising Solomon Crowe (Callihan), who was set to finally make his NXT TV debut after previous injury setbacks.

Crowe stormed the ring and destroyed Parker, and he did well enough to genuinely fire up the Full Sail crowd. He grabbed a microphone, said, "and now, we return to your regularly scheduled broadcast," and marched off.

If you're a historical completionist, you'll absolutely love watching this back. These are two guys who have drawn a fair bit of money in their careers, used in different ways that, as it turned out, neither was overly crazy about. There was never a payoff to this, but the Crowe buildup and debut were both well done and provided a solid introduction to a new character.

9. Bull Gets Fit

Bull Dempsey had a few stops and starts during his NXT run in the mid-2010s. Initially used as an enhancement talent, he got a run as a midcard monster of sorts and feuded with the likes of Mojo Rawley and Baron Corbin.

Advertisement

After that, though, he was turned face with an oddly-entertaining gimmick. Dempsey, billed at 320 pounds, was now seen as too pudgy for his own good. After being chastised multiple times by NXT General Manager William Regal, Bull started appearing in vignettes advertising a new, "Bull-Fit" mindset - one of which saw him dressed in Zubaz pants, stumbling around a gym, and struggling through various exercises.

Anyone who fits in the "big and tall" category could instantly relate to what they saw on the screen. This was a funny enough comedy character that could've had some longevity to it, even if the "movement up the card" potential might have been limited.

Dempsey had a brief feud with Samoa Joe in early 2015 ahead of that star's NXT Title match with Finn Balor. However, those matches with Joe marked Dempsey's final TV appearances for the black and gold brand. He was released in early 2016 and has since popped up a few times around the independent scene.

8. The Ballad Of Blue Pants

Leva Bates wasn't a full-time NXT competitor. She was intended to be used as an enhancement talent when she first appeared in 2014, and she got the name Blue Pants from Enzo Amore and Colin Cassady (now AEW's Big Bill) prior to a match against their then-valet, Carmella.

Advertisement

However, Blue Pants gained fans within the NXT audience and parlayed a few initial appearances into a bigger role with the company. Most notably, we saw Blue Pants as a surprise appearance on the NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn card in 2015, when she came out to help the Vaudevillains win the Tag Team Titles from Wesley Blake and Buddy Murphy. The Barclays Center crowd anticipated the surprise of that one-off and popped loudly, both when she came out and when she neutralized Alexa Bliss.

It's refreshing to see a character get organically over and be rewarded for it, and that's part of what made this era of NXT such a breath of fresh air. Blue Pants made the most of every second of TV time she got, the crowd enjoyed her for what she was, and this served as a peak higher than many wrestlers will ever reach.

Blue Pants finished up with NXT later in 2015. In 2019, she signed an AEW contract, where she both wrestled (as The Librarian) and filled several off-camera roles until that contract expired in 2023.

7. Sheriff Samoa Joe

Samoa Joe's first NXT run is the stuff of legend. He jumped ship from TNA in 2015 and initially signed a non-exclusive deal, but his merchandise sales were so strong WWE soon snatched him up on a full-time basis. The Samoan Submission Machine's feuds with Finn Balor and Shinsuke Nakamura resulted in plenty of hard-hitting contests that have held up very well over the past eight or nine years.

Advertisement

Joe's second NXT run, though, is largely lost to history. After a four-year main roster run and a release in 2021, Joe was rehired in June of that year. Initially, he served as GM William Regal's "enforcer," which was a fun callback to Steve Austin's time as a non-wrestling "sheriff" of Monday Night Raw.

Unlike Austin's angle nearly two decades earlier, this one had a payoff. After weeks of tension with NXT Champion Karrion Kross, Joe won the title for the third time at NXT TakeOver 36. However, Samoa Joe wouldn't wrestle another match with the company, giving up the strap after testing positive for COVID-19, which came around the same time Vince McMahon wanted to revamp the developmental company (into what turned out to be NXT 2.0).

There's much more good than bad here, though. Samoa Joe got to return to WWE after being released and show he had more gas in the tank, which gave NXT fans another great moment.

6. Matt Riddle, The Eight-Second Man

The first of two Matt Riddle items on this list comes from one of his very first matches under the NXT banner, with the barefoot ex-MMA fighter signing with WWE in 2018 after tearing up the independent scene.

Advertisement

Riddle's first NXT PLE match was an impromptu one, coming when he was interrupted by Kassius Ohno on the pre-show for NXT TakeOver: WarGames II. The former and future Chris Hero was challenged to a match later that night, and it didn't last long. Riddle floored a charging Ohno with a knee strike and immediately covered him for the pinfall. The official time of the match was eight seconds.

Riddle and Ohno would face off again at NXT TakeOver: Phoenix in January 2019, getting a bit more time for a match that Riddle won by submission after a bit more than nine minutes.

The Original Bro would do great things with WWE over his five-year run with the company, and some of that can be credited to the "rub" Ohno gave him right when he started. Ohno played a "gatekeeper" role here, and he did so to perfection, getting Riddle ready for bigger things without being hurt by putting the newcomer over. Sometimes, wrestling is at its best when it's simple, and that's what happened here.

5. James Storm Comes And Goes

Everyone loves a shocking crossover, and NXT teased a pretty big one in late 2015. That's when James Storm, who had made his name on the TNA roster for more than a decade, surprisingly showed up for a handful of matches in NXT.

Advertisement

Storm's debut caught the Full Sail crowd off-guard, and it's worth rewatching on the WWE Network. An unfamiliar country song blared over the speakers, and out came "The Cowboy" in his signature Stetson hat to a massive pop.

Both of Storm's televised matches were short, but showed why Storm had achieved so much elsewhere in the wrestling world. He squashed Danny Burch and Adam Rose in a pair of fast-paced matches designed to make him look like a killer, and a promo exists on the WWE YouTube channel where he touts his own arrival. Excitement was palpable, especially since Storm clearly seemed to have plenty left in the tank (both in the ring and on the microphone).

It was awesome, it was thrilling... and then it was over. Storm opted to re-sign with TNA at the start of 2016. His Beer Money tag team with Bobby Roode was reunited, but Roode himself would make the jump to NXT just a few short months later. One has to wonder what might have been if Storm stuck it out, especially given everything his former partner accomplished after jumping ship.

4. Andrade Steals A Weekend

Then known as Andrade "Cien" Almas, the former La Sombra had an all-time 48-hour period in January 2018. Riding high while on an outstanding run as NXT's top heel, Andrade successfully defended his NXT Championship against Johnny Gargano at NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia. It earned a five-star rating from Dave Meltzer and was the first NXT singles match in history to receive that distinction.

Advertisement

Andrade wasn't done yet, though. Just 24 hours later, he appeared at the Royal Rumble as a surprise entrant, and the crowd popped as manager Zelina Vega cheered him on while walking to the ring. Almas lasted nearly 30 minutes in that match before being eliminated by Randy Orton, and he looked the part of a legitimate prospect.

Unsurprisingly, Andrade was called up to the main roster just a few months after that weekend in the City of Brotherly Love. After a few turbulent years where he didn't reach his lofty potential, though, he was released in March 2021. After a 2 1/2-year run with All Elite Wrestling, Andrade returned to WWE at the 2024 Royal Rumble, and he recently won the WWE Speed Championship.

3. Velveteen Dream Enjoys Infamy (No, Not Like That...)

As entertaining as it was, fans can't be blamed for wanting to forget Velveteen Dream's NXT run, given the way it ended. In 2017, though, the real-life Patrick Clark earned rave reviews for the Velveteen Dream gimmick, and his first high-profile match was against Aleister Black at TakeOver: WarGames in 2017.

Advertisement

The buildup to this was refreshingly simple. Black was a man of few words and, in his own promos, Velveteen Dream said his aim was to make Black say his name. The in-ring contrast between the two couldn't have been more stark, either. Black's stiff strikes were met by Dream's over-the-top showmanship, which included an elaborate entrance and (straight out of the "Ravishing" Rick Rude playbook) a reveal of tights featuring both men and the NXT logo.

The match was a hard-hitting, back-and-forth affair, one won by Black. After the match, though, Black obliged with a few simple words: "Enjoy infamy... Velveteen Dream."

Velveteen Dream would go on to carry the NXT North American Championship for more than seven months. In April 2020, though, the man behind the gimmick was accused of some truly disgusting actions. An internal investigation by WWE could not corroborate the accusations, but he was released in May 2021 after a long spell off television.

2. Hideo Itami's Attacker

Rechristened Hideo Itami, the man otherwise known as KENTA did better than most remember. He won his way into the 2015 Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal when that meant a spot on the WrestleMania card. His matches, while not classics, were solid, and there was reason to believe Itami would be a force once he adapted to fit the North American wrestling style.

Advertisement

However, later in 2015, he suffered a shoulder injury and was written out off TV. NXT did this by placing Itami as the victim of an assault in the parking lot outside Full Sail. It's logical to think they would eventually have Itami return for vengeance, especially given several segments involving Kevin Owens (one where he discovered Itami in the parking lot, another where he denied being Itami's attacker).

An Owens/Itami program, assuming that was the plan, would have been big business for NXT. Other than a singles match at a 2015 house show, the two had never squared off, and the idea of Owens's power against Itami's striking skills was a tantalizing prospect. Even if that wasn't the plan, a fired-up Itami mowing through the roster upon his return was an idea with legs, too.

Itami, however, took more than a year to return to action. By that time, Owens was a main roster fixture. Any plans of pushing the Japanese superstar were put on the back burner, and the "attacker" storyline was totally dropped. After a few years spent in NXT and on 205 Live, Itami was released in 2019.

1. The Rise Of The Broserweights

Finishing with a fantastic example of the "wacky tag team partners" genre working to perfection, Matt Riddle and Pete Dunne were thrown together as a tag team prior to the 2020 Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic. In a formula also co-opted by dozens of movie and TV comedies, Riddle's carefree persona was met by Dunne's grumpy exterior. - and the NXT crowd loved it, especially given the established in-ring track records of both men.

Advertisement

According to Riddle, this was supposed to be a short-lived experiment. The team gelled so much, though, they won the tournament and, by extension, a shot at the NXT Tag Team Championships.

That match came at NXT TakeOver: Portland, and included a buildup where Riddle and Dunne road-tripped to the venue. The vignettes were some of the funniest in NXT history, but, befitting the gimmick, the two were all-business once the bell rang. Once they got to the arena following their hijinks and shenanigans, Riddle and Dunne had a stellar match with Bobby Fish and Kyle O'Reilly, where the challengers won the belts.

Unfortunately, outside events and hideous timing intervened. Just a few weeks after that event, the pandemic hit. Dunne could not travel to the U.S., Riddle and replacement Timothy Thatcher lost the belts to Imperium in fairly short order, and the story ended not with a bang, but a whimper. It's why we don't remember it as fondly as we should, and if you haven't seen this or want to relive it, seeking out the Portland show is time well spent.

Advertisement