10 Insane Reasons Wrestlers Got Sued

The other kind of "wrestler's court".

By Adam Clery /

It doesn't matter if you're in the ring or outside it, wrestling is a hazardous business. While we all gleefully delight in watching human bodies plummet from atop ladders, through tables, or onto spiky things, what goes on in front of the cameras is normally choreographed to be as safe as humanly possible. Real-life, I'm sorry to inform you, is not.

Advertisement

Compared to the sort of trials awaiting them out there, the choreographed perils they endure as a "day job" usually pale in comparison. You see, pro-wrestling is an American pursuit and, as a national pastime, its popularity only really wilts next to the true cultural behemoths of baseball, patriotism, and filing frivolous lawsuits against absolutely anybody who has done you wrong.

And, in some cases, even people who obviously haven't.

Wrestlers, being the larger-than-life celebrities that they are, tend to get sued all the time. Usually, it's for boring things like image rights, violated contracts (Brock!), or mishaps inside the ring but, this being the most deranged industry on Earth, sometimes the legal proceedings are more bizarre than any story that's been concocted by Vince or his team of breastfed soap writers.

10. Allegedly Being A Dominatrix - Natalya

In 2014, prisoner Christopher Donnelly attempted to sue Natalya because, and I'm quoting directly here, "Neidhart was a dominatrix who had beaten him between the period of 2005 and 2009 when they were together at hotels throughout the U.S. and had forced him into extreme sexual abuse and even to prostitute himself." He was seeking damages in the region of $250,000.

Advertisement

If you've not made the leap already, I can tell you that not a single part of this is even remotely true.

Possibly the biggest giveaway here was that Donnelly decided to take it upon himself to be his own legal representative in this case, despite having no background in it whatsoever. It took a county judge mere minutes to throw the case out and reprimand him for wasting everyone's time.

Quite what Natalya thinks about this is anybody's guess, but I'm willing to bet she'd have quite happily obliged him some intense physical pain upon receiving the news. In a sensational rib, Total Divas would send her to visit an actual dominatrix in the following season.

9. Being Asked By A Fan For A Fight, And Obliging Him - The Big Show

Shedding his gimmick as Andre The Giant's Actual Son, in favour of real gimmick of Just Being One Of The Lads, Paul Wight was relaxing after a WCW show in New York by joining some fans for a drink in a hotel bar. As you can imagine, a man that size can seriously put the sauce away, so the rowdiness levels tend to get a bit lowty.

Advertisement

However, one man present, a Robert Sawyer, thought he should take things up a level by challenging The Big Show to a fight. Presumably, given that Sawyer himself was a fairly respectable 6'6", 220+lbs, he must have thought he could take him and repeatedly tried to goad his larger adversary with a series of verbal insults.

He insulted both his ability and size (?!?!) to no avail, before trying to push Show over. For his troubles, he received a right hook that simultaneously knocked him out and broke his jaw in the process, ending the fight about as quickly as it had started. He attempted to sue, Big Show's lawyer's claimed self-defence, the judge realised the man was an idiot, and found in the defendant's favour.

8. Getting Cattle-prodded - Titus O'Neil

Now, if I gave you a few small pieces of information, do you think you could orgainse them into a cohesive story? Let's try.

Advertisement

- A WWE employee files a lawsuit against another WWE employee.

- Titus O'Neil is jabbed with a cattle-prod.

- Paige is filming an episode of Swerved.

Now you, a normal person, have probably assumed that having been electrocuted by one of his colleagues, O'Neil saught legal damages for the physical trauma this no doubt caused. You'd be wrong, though, as it's actually O'Neil - again, the man literally jabbed with a cattle-prod - who ended up on the wrong side of this. Somehow.

According to reports in TMZ, cameraman Donald Anderson claimed that O'Neil kicked his camera out of his hand after being shocked during the prank. Allegedly, he suffered "serious injuries to his hands, fingers, and wrist, and was told to leave "in fear of future attacks". For this, he was looking for over a million dollars in damages, but settled out of court.

7. Dropping A Woman On A Small Child - The Rock / Triple H

God loves a trier.

Advertisement

You all remember Judgment Day 2000, if only for it being where The Undertaker first traded his life as a... zombie? mortician? whatever, for just being a big dad on a bike. But it was a more memorable night for a Ronald Basham who, he alleged, changed his life forever.

Merely a child at the time, Basham claimed that when The Rock and Triple H had spilled their match out into the crowd, they'd crushed him under the weight of a falling woman and displayed "reckless, willful and wanton conduct". The injuries he obtained under the woman had led to years of physical trauma and curtailed his life.

He also tried to sue the WWE for not providing proper safety for fans, but his case immediately hit a bit of a brick wall when it was revealed he'd not only been an active participant of several sports growing up, but an enthusiastic stock car racer. The fact he was only 17 when he decided to file the charges probably didn't help either.

6. Being In A Video Game - Randy Orton

Technically, Randy Orton didn't get both himself and WWE in trouble for merely appearing the video game, but rather his appearance in them was the issue. Specifically, by creating an incredible life-like model of the wrestler, WWE and 2K were infringing upon the intellectual property of the woman who designed his tattoos.

Advertisement

You see it's actually artist Catherine Alexander who owns the rights to Orton's body ink, and not the wrestler himself. WWE should have been well aware of this though, after they had a similar legal standoff over using his likeness in a range of toys, and were promptly told to go take a run and jump when they offered her a measly $450 for the rights.

Precisely what Orton's degree of liability is here, given that the work is printed on his body and he'll presumably have given either his employers or 2K permission to use him in the games. This one's still ongoing, actually, and a trial date was initially set for April 2020. It's subsequently been moved back with everything else that's going on, but it'll be rescheduled for sometime this year.

5. Giving Another Wrestler Hepatitis - Abdullah The Butcher

Abdullah the Butcher was... and I'm not totally sure how to put this... very at ease with the idea of slicing up both his flesh, and that of his opponents, for the amusement of crowds of all sizes. 3,000 indie showpiece? He'll bleed everywhere for you. Bingo hall with 30 people (only 6 of whom weren't just on the guestlist)? He'll bleed everywhere for you.

Advertisement

Anyway, on a 2007 show, Abdullah was set to take on Hannibal in a match that nobody on earth was calling a "potential technical masterpiece". They came to blows, cut each other up, and everyone in attendance left feeling like they'd got their money's worth. However for Hannibal, real name Devon Nicholson, there was to be severe consequences.

Discovering that he had Hepatitis C, Nicholson took Abdullah to court alleging that he'd sliced them both with the same blade, causing the spread of the disease, and this had scuppered his chances of signing with WWE. Abdullah, in his defence, claimed that as Nicholson was the promoter he was just doing what he was told, but the court ordered him to pay $2.3 million in damages.

4. Just Having A Laugh! - Hulk Hogan

Ah, good! One we literally have the footage of!

Advertisement

At the height of his fame, Hogan (and his good pal Mr. T) appeared on the Richard Belzer light entertainment show to do some incredibly light entertaining. They were just big lads! Two big lads there to have a big laugh! But the presenter, big square corporate dork Richard Belzer, just couldn't take a joke properly and passed out. Nerd.

Hogan was just doing what any normal 6 foot 7, 300lbs man would have done in his position and applied shoot sleeper hold to 120lbs-when-soaking-wet TV anchor. Belzer, seemingly leaving his sense of humour at home, presumably in the pocket of some other god-awful tweed jacket, stopped breathing and passed out between the Pythons.

Undoubtedly wounded that his Very Funny Joke hadn't been taken the wrong way, Hogan released the hold and Belzer, not satisfied with just ruining the segment, collapsed onto the ground and split his head open on the studio floor. He sued Hogan for $5m, settled out of court, then stiffed his own lawyers on the fees causing them to call him a "paradigm of ingratitude".

3. Shagging - Hulk Hogan

The legal history between Hulk Hogan and his ex-wife Linda Bollea is both confusing and complicated. Between them, the pair have sued and counter-sued more times than Hogan worked WrestleMania (probably, I haven't checked) and the precise arrangement they now have over who gets what percentage of whose money, is unclear.

Advertisement

One thing that is absolutely obvious though, is that all of this stems from Hogan's insatiable desire to have sex with women he isn't married to. Despite a marriage that had survived over two decades, rumours of his affairs were legendary by the latter part of the 2000s. Then, in 2009, sh*t really hit the fan, brother, when it emerged Hogan had been cheating on his wife with Christiane Plante... a friend of his daughter Brooke.

This led to an almighty divorce settlement that cost Hogan 70% of the family assets, $3m in property, and 40% of all future earnings. A few years later, the infamous Gawker case (you know, where Hogan had been caught shagging his best friend's wife) netted him a juicy $31m settlement, only for Linda to assert that Hogan was withholding specifics over his income and go after him for a slice of that.

2. Calling Someone "One Of The Most Worthless Pieces Of S**t I Have Ever Met In My Entire Life"

As far as defamation suits go, if you're going to wind up in one you might as well go all out. There's no point saying someone was loosely incompetent, or that their inaction might have negatively impacted a delicate situation if you're going to wind up in court anyway, so just f**ing bury the guy, IMHO.

Advertisement

Specifically, do what CM Punk did in the now legendary Art of Wrestling Podcast with Colt Cabana where, when discussing all the events that led to him walking out on WWE, took a figurate bat to the figurative skull of Dr. Chris Amann's figurate reputation.

"So I roll under the f***ing corner and I motion to Doc, I go 'I have a concussion.' And he was like 'what do you want me to do?' And I just started laughing and I was just like 'Doctor, you are one of the most worthless pieces of s**t I have ever met in my entire life."

This line, as well as several suggestions of both incompetence and malpractice, led to wrestling's most high-profile lawsuit in recent years. Punk, after much legal wrangling, eventually won the $1m civil suit.

1. Disrespecting A Panda - Vince McMahon

Everybody knows that the WWF were forced to rebrand to WWE when the crushing weight of the World Wildlife Foundation was brought to bear against Titan Towers. However, what it was, specifically, that had irked the wildness preservation bods tends to get diluted by the scale of the fallout. After all, both WWFs had coexisted in harmony for decades prior.

Advertisement

The short version of this story is that, with both companies enjoying large scale expansion in the 1980s, they were inevitably set on a collision course over the shared name. In 1994 a deal was struck between the two that allowed them both to use the initialism, with Vince ensuring that the company was largely referred to "the World Wrestling Federation" in its published materials.

However when the boom of the Attitude Era went straight to both Vince's crotch and pockets, his newfound sense of invincibility stopped him giving a single, solitary f**k about this. He began using the term "WWF" completely freely, the Pandas said "not on our watch", and a few short years later they stripped him of it entirely in court.

Advertisement