10 Mistakes WWE Has Already Made With RETRIBUTION

Why has RETRIBUTION failed SO badly?

By Ewan McQuade /

RETRIBUTION is a good idea on paper.

Advertisement

A faction of estranged "Performance Center recruits" ravaging the main roster and creating a change in the status quo all works. The nWo and The Nexus are significant in this regard. Both acts were white hot during their inception, yet it was the booking leading forward that really hampered both groups.

RETRIBUTION, while a good idea, have not had the support of the company behind them. A group of incredibly talented performers have been slapped together to create a new anarchist faction on RAW because... reasons? The motivation is still lacking in this group and it seems that we won't be seeing any development going forward.

It seems that this was an idea brought forward by Vince McMahon just to get a small ratings pop. It coincided with the creation of RAW Underground (another shameless ratings grab). Both RAW Underground and RETRIBUTION were created with no foresight into how these acts will survive long term. While there are some very small positives to take away from RETRIBUTION so far, the majority of their run has been lacklustre maddening...

10. Revealing Mustafa Ali As The Leader

Mustafa Ali has been one of the most underutilised superstars under WWE's umbrella. He has a terrific move-set, he's quite a brilliant promo, and most importantly, he's a natural babyface. He has the ability to generate a positive, organic reaction through his matches and had previously been in line for two main event pushes.

Advertisement

Why WWE's creative team looked at Ali and decided to push him as the leader of RETRIBUTION is still a mystery. While the reveal was quite cool in isolation, it raises way more questions than it answers. Why is Ali so frustrated with WWE? Why is Ali aligning with the NXT wrestler when he never made his way through that system? How did he come into contact with this group of outcasts?

While there is potential for some of these questions to be answered going forward. It seems more than likely that WWE will brush all of this to the side. Instead, they will focus on establishing Mustafa Ali as a slippery heel. A role that doesn't fit this natural babyface.

9. Debuting The Group In The Midcard

In order to create a strong antagonist, you need to pair them with an equally captivating hero. Gargano and Ciampa, Cody and MJF, The Rock and Steve Austin. These rivalries felt big time because both of the characters WERE big time. With RETRIBUTION, the foils for the group were The Hurt Business.

Advertisement

The Hurt Business are a great act. They have great chemistry and MVP is really holding the group together throughout their tenure on RAW. That being said, they aren't positioned in the main event. They are upper mid-card at best. Having RETRIBUTION debut and face The Hurt Business has both teams slotted in a particular way... and that is midcard.

This was shown during the 6 October episode of RAW in which Ali revealed his alignment with RETRIBUTION. In order to make a statement and show that the group is a serious threat, this segment should have been positioned in the main event. Instead, it was Drew and Randy who closed the show.

If WWE truly had faith in RETRIBUTION they would have allowed this segment to close the show. Instead, RETRIBUTION and The Hurt Business were left floundering in the midcard.

8. Not A Single Squash Match

Squash matches can be quite divisive among the online wrestling community. Used correctly, squash matches can create a star in one two-minute segment. Look at Karrion Cross in NXT. He destroyed Ciampa and then went straight into the NXT title picture. This was the kind of elevation that RETRIBUTION needed when debuting.

Advertisement

There are some great talents in RETRIBUTION, all of whom could have had a fantastic squash match. Dominik Dijakovic, Mia Yim or even Shane Thorne. That's three members who all have a fantastic move-set and deserve to be showcased on a singles level.

Having T-Bar (Dijakovic) come out and absolutely destroy someone at the beginning of RAW would make a statement. It would show that this group is to be taken seriously. T-Bar hitting the Feast Your Eyes, which alone is a terrific move, and them immediately winning his first match would add credibility to his character. A simple brawl doesn't do enough to establish the team. A few squash matches would work wonders in improving the faction's in-ring prowess.

7. The SmackDown Ring Invasion

First impressions are everything in the wrestling business. Once that debut has been made, there is no going back in the eyes of the fans. RETRIBUTION made their presence known on the 7 August episode of Smackdown in which they "caused chaos".

Advertisement

What that means is they sloppily attacked the set in the Performance Center. Attacking members of the crowd, smashing on the protective shielding and cutting the ring ropes with a chainsaw. This act of destruction may have made for passable viewing if the characters in the ring didn't act like obnoxious cheerleaders.

The performance of the masked attackers really made this segment a laughing stock. Each member was cheering and screaming in a juvenile way. This wasn't a carefully constructed attack on WWE. It was more like a pep rally. This was our introduction to the group and it should have been a terrifying invasion of Smackdown. On their first appearance, RETRIBUTION looked like a joke in both the eyes of the audience and WWE.

6. The Masks And Costumes

Masks can work well, even in the current WWE product. However, the masks that WWE decided to use for RETRIBUTION really don't work for a modern wrestling product. The issue with the design is that they are trying to hard to be intimidating. They look overproduced and therefore... fake.

Advertisement

That's ignoring the fact that they very much look plastic, particularly T-Bar's Bane meets Mad Max abomination. The most infuriating problem with the masks is that they are completely unnecessary. The performers in the ring can get over on their own without being surrounded by all of these meaningless facades.

Comparing RETRIBUTION with other current wrestling factions, it seems that the look simply doesn't hold up. Take The Dark Order for instance. Their look is uniform and there is hierarchy designated by the masks. The masks are basic Lucha masks but they still give off a sense of order and intimidation.

RETRIBUTION doesn't have this kind of order. They have random masks and random costumes with no sense of logic behind the design. There is nothing deep about the ring gear and that makes the act basic and surface level.

5. Those Names...

Asuka. Drew McIntyre. Roman Reigns. All of these top guys have killer names. While they may not be anything special, they stand out in your mind. Even mid-card acts like Bobby Lashley, Ricochet and Keith Lee have very concise names that roll of the tongue. RETRIBUTION, on the other hand, were dealt easily some of the worst names in recent WWE history.

Advertisement

Slapjack, T-Bar, Mace, Reckoning. All of these names are truly terrible. They do nothing to help get the characters over, they tell you nothing about the personalities. They are just dumb, useless, uninspired name. How is anyone going to take this group of heels seriously?

The names were only introduced on commentary during their first match and that shows how unsure WWE were on these names. If they were confident, they would have announced it during their opening promo. Instead, it was left to the commentary team to fill us in on the names of the characters. Saddling the group with these names immediately slots them at a jobber level, something they will never recover from.

4. Not Utilising Dominik Dijakovic

Easily the biggest star in RETRIBUTION, Dominik Dijakovic should never have been part of this group. He is easily one of the most talented performers on the WWE roster and he should be allowed to showcase his in-ring ability. Simply put Dijakovic versus Keith Lee and let them tear the house down.

Advertisement

This rivalry made a star out of both men and would have worked wonders for the main roster. Instead, we have one of the most imposing forces in NXT relegated to snarling comic book villain. This could have worked well for Dijakovic. Maybe this could rejuvenate his character after a few losses on NXT. Instead, it has tanked all of his credibility.

It is well documented that Vince McMahon loves big guys. Simply look at how he has pushed the likes of Drew McIntyre and Braun Strowman. Why he felt the need to take one of the most imposing big men in the company and book him into the ground is beyond me. The look, the promos and the matches are a massive disservice to this incredible talent.

3. Awful Scripted Promos

It's very hard to find a good promo on the main roster. Don't get us wrong, there are some incredible talkers such as Samoa Joe and Paul Heyman. The difficult thing is finding performers who can deliver the incredibly stilted, scripted garbage that the creative team come up with each week.

Advertisement

RETRIBUTION were given some AWFUL garbage to spout during their introductory period. From the single-camera promo to their in-ring promo, they have been given some of the worst dialogue in recent years. Lines such as "we hope you enjoy your last days in oblivion" or "we're here to gut your reality" are the absolute worst. They don't have any impact because they aren't natural. It makes the group look like Saturday morning cartoon fodder for the Ninja Turtles.

The majority of the group have all proven they are good talkers. Dio Madden was even a part of RAW's commentary team! Just give these guys the mic and let them go out there and tell their own stories. Create their own characters. Then WWE, you might be onto something with the group.

2. Being Granted RAW Contracts

Perhaps the biggest logic hole surrounding RETRIBUTION is the baffling decision to grant them official RAW contracts. This makes absolutely no sense from both the perspective of the RAW management team (Is this Adam Pearce?) and the perspective of RETRIBUTION.

Advertisement

Why would RAW give this faction a contract? They have destroyed production trucks, they have destroyed the performance centre, they have threatened to destroy WWE in its entirety. Why would you look at that group and say..."Yeah! Those guys!". It doesn't make any sense! This blatant logic hole drags down the entire act because they are surrounded by plot holes.

Finally, why would a faction who hate WWE so much sign with the company? There is the argument that they want to destroy it from within...but that has never been mentioned. This group who loathe the main roster so much have signed with the main roster. It makes the group look lame. It seems that they value money and a payday over their own philosophical beliefs. You can't be an anti-authority group and agree to side with the authority.

This booking hampers RETRIBUTION constantly and is something that needs to be addressed going forward!

1. Losing... Then Losing Again!

The hardest obstacle that RETRIBUTION now has to overcome is their consecutive losses. RETRIBUTION lost their first match on TV in one of the dumbest DQ finishes of the year and then lost their second match CLEAN to The Hurt Business. This has completely annihilated any of the remaining credibility this group had left.

Advertisement

You would think that RETRIBUTION would win their first match right? It seems like the most logical step to take in order to establish them as a cohesive unit. But no, a DQ loss to The Hurt Business. DQ losses can sometimes be salvaged by a killer angle afterwards. Maybe the group send MVP home on a stretcher or throw Bobby Lashley through an LED screen. Nothing like that happened and nothing was salvaged from their first loss.

The second loss was even more baffling because it wasn't just a clean loss, it was a submission loss! One of the most decisive finishes in wrestling. A submission finish can make or break an act and it completely broke this one. T-Bar tapped out almost immediately to Lashley's Hurt Lock. This submission loss solidifies the reputation of RETRIBUTION. It will be insanely hard to recover from this kind of defeat and there's not a lot that can be salvaged from this acts painfully short and lacklustre run.

Advertisement