10 Most Boring Wrestlers Of 2022

You WON'T see some of these picks coming. Look out those pitchforks now!

By Jamie Kennedy /

Y'know what's worse than bad? BORING.

Advertisement

Think back to some of the worst moments in pro wrestling history. The Gobbledygooker? Papa Shango making The Ultimate Warrior spew up goo? Vince McMahon's look of sheer horror when Hornswoggle was revealed as his erm...illegitimate son? Sure, horrible TV moments, but they weren't dull.

Boring is a death knell for characters in wrestling, but it isn't always the actual worker's fault. No, bad creative or a total lack of chemistry between two pros can also make for lifeless telly. It's also worth pointing out that some of the picks here will not go down well with everybody - that's fine, everyone has their own choices.

These were the wrestlers in WWE and AEW that almost sent this writer to sleep in 2022 though. Again, that doesn't mean they're doomed to fail in 2023 or beyond. It just means that their January-December run this year was either absolutely crap or very uninspiring to watch play out. Or both.

Surely a collection of talent like this is capable of more? Fingers crossed things do get better from January 2023 onwards.

10. Ronda Rousey

Starting out with a biggie.

Advertisement

Ronda Rousey was a lot of things during her first WWE run, but "boring" was never really one of them. 2022 hasn't been kind to the ex-UFC mauler though; Ronda has won the Royal Rumble and reigned supreme as SmackDown Women's Champ, but her matches can be terribly flat.

Worse, Rousey on the mic is a shaky, under-confident mess when she's supposed to be composed, self-assured and dominant. Sure, it's unfair to slag someone off because promos aren't a core strength, but WWE need to realise that consistently booking Ronda into a corner on the mic is...a bit thick.

Matches vs. Natayla, Liv Morgan, Shotzi and others have been bang average this year. In fact, Charlotte Flair is arguably the only one who has been able to pull some sort of excitement from Rousey. She's a big star, yes, but Ronda still feels like someone playing pro wrestler rather than being one.

9. Hook

Ooooooooooh boy, this won't go down well.

Advertisement

Look, this fan thinks Hook has a bright future ahead of him. He has quiet, brooding charisma and has improved as a worker since those early squashes charmed everyone in late-2021/early-2022. However, when does Tony Khan plan on moving things along a little and ending this FTW Title monotony?

It's a little shocking that Hook was at his most engaging when working a comedy tag gimmick alongside walking curse-giver Danhausen. That was a short-lived experiment though, and AEW returned Taz's lad to singles stardom shortly afterwards. Except...they didn't, not really.

Hook has been treading water (primarily on Rampage) for a while now. Mini-feuds vs. The Trustbusters went nowhere, and his segments typically gobble up valuable minutes on a show that only has 60 to work with every week. 2023 is gonna have to be a bit more thrilling if Hook wants to live up to his obvious potential, put it that way.

8. Nyla Rose

Where does AEW turn with Nyla Rose next? She's been a physically-overwhelming force and recently branched out to try her hand at some "sports entertainment"-style work. Neither has landed her a full-time spot at the top of the company's women's division, so it's back to the drawing board.

Advertisement

Nyla doesn't have the organic magnetism as a character/star that someone like Jade Cargill does; that star power does a lot of heavy lifting for Jade (her matches rarely delight), but at least it's there. Meanwhile, Rose comes across as somebody who is supposed to be some huge deal yet never actually delivers on that front.

The partnership with Vickie Guerrero and Marina Shafir is also drier than a box of crackers. It's never been properly explained why Nyla hangs around with that duo anyway, so fans struggle to give a toss about it. Yeah, Rose had a very boring 2022 - her TBS Title thievery was tedious too.

"It's back to the drawing board".

7. Shinsuke Nakamura

The bloom came off Shin's WWE rose years ago.

Advertisement

Nakamura used to be one of the most vibrant performers going. His in-ring style stood out as unique for WWE's main roster, and he was capable of having belting match after belting match on TV regardless of opponent. Now, in 2022, Shinsuke is all-but-phoning it in.

The guy started 2022 by teaming with Rick Boogs. Then, when injuries robbed Boogs of ring time, Shin went solo yet again and became the promotion's ultimate bit part player. Honestly, what has he done that's really worth talking about this year? Challenge GUNTHER for the IC Title? One off. Team with Hit Row? Woohoo.

Some might point to Nakamura as a "utility player". Nah, that's something Sami Zayn does well. He can fit into any role Triple H wants. Shinsuke is just sort of there, and contributing very little to the on-screen product. His appearances are boring because fans know they won't lead to anything.

6. Jake Hager

He really likes that hat.

Advertisement

Can silly little incidental gimmicks get over in wrestling? Yes, yes they can. Will Jake Hager adoring a purple bucket hat be the next surprise smash hit in AEW circles though? No, probably not. Sadly, it's all the former Jack Swagger has going for him on Dynamite and Rampage these days.

Hager has been Chris Jericho's bodyguard in both The Inner Circle and the Jericho Appreciation Society. His role is to stand around looking mean, then bail his mate out when babyfaces start getting the upper hand on him. Rinse, repeat and oh yeah - he really likes that hat.

There's nothing to Jake's character beyond that. The dude doesn't even strike home runs as an occasional in-ring attraction anymore either. Indeed, to back that point up, Hager's only singles win in 2022 was a three minute win over Bryce Donovan on the 22 November edition of 'C' show Dark.

5. Natalya

Hey, remember when WWE tried to get ditzy newcomer Aliyah over by having Natalya crow about 'World Records' before repeatedly getting egg in her face for being arrogant? Yeah, don't worry, most fans won't remember that January mini-feud. That's a shame, because...

Advertisement

...it was one of the only rivalries Nattie had all year.

"One of". The other was a short title tilt vs. Ronda Rousey heading into Money In The Bank, but both ranked amongst the most drab experiments WWE tried in 2022. Despite the lack of any real focus, Natalya has worked extensively on TV. The problem? Her matches whizz past without leaving an impression.

She is, without doubt, one of the most 'fast-forwardable' (not a real word) wrestlers in WWE today. Being fair, Nattie is solid in-ring and does probably play a veteran role behind the scenes that helps ease newbies in. She's just not very exciting to watch these days though.

4. Tamina

Nattie is Roman Reigns compared to Tamina.

Advertisement

Tam's only real spot in WWE throughout 2022 was as either a default tag-team partner or as part of the dreadful 24/7 Title hunt. You might've forgotten all that the dire wedding sh*t creative served up involving Akira Tozawa earlier in the year. That's good, 'cause it was painful.

It was also incredibly boring, which is not something any wrestling wedding should be. Still, what did WWE expect when they put Tamina and Tozawa in there as a possible happy couple? Neither worker connects with live crowds, largely because fans have been conditioned not to care about anything they get up to.

In December 2022, Tamina is a female 'Iron' Mike Sharpe. She's borderline enhancement talent who has longevity so is expected to retain some sort of credibility with an audience who sit around twiddling their thumbs. WWE should either come up with something that provokes fan emotion or stop pretending this is enough.

3. The Dark Order

Admittedly, there was a time when The Dark Order worked as a cult-like lower-card fascination for AEW devotees. There's also some goodwill holding over from Brodie Lee's time in the faction, but even that's a case of diminishing returns each and every time the group strolls through an All Elite curtain.

Advertisement

2022 was their lowest ebb yet.

Hearing JR shout, "Johnny Hungee!" whenever John Silver launches a comeback is now incredibly tiresome. The same goes for any and all pretence that The Order should be hanging around with top stars like Hangman Page; if anything, Page buddying up with these guys lessened his own appeal.

Preston '10' Vance's recent turn will hopefully bring the curtain down on The Dark Order in AEW. It's an act that has long-since grown stale, and there's no need to continue it on into 2023. Seriously, Tony Khan, stop blighting episodes of Rampage with The Order's backstage promos and/or matches.

2. QT Marshall

In years to come, wrestling writers will pen articles like 'X Worst AEW Factions Ever'. The Factory might well be jousting with The Trustbusters for top spot on that list, because QT Marshall's group is so unbelievably unnecessary it isn't even funny. What do they even do?!

Advertisement

On TV, the announcers allege that Marshall is training lads like Cole Karter and Aaron Solo up for future greatness. OK then. Does that still work as a plan when QT loses 99% of his own matches and is about as much of a threat to babyfaces as Tony Schiavone?

Yep, Marshall's AEW run is definitely boring.

He's a hangover from the days when Cody Rhodes was looking out for close friends, and doesn't really have much of a place on All Elite telly in 2022. Regardless, he's still sniffing around and getting TV time that could be better-used on other, more exciting acts that get a reaction from fans.

1. Matt Hardy

First of all, it's worth saying that this lifelong wrestling enthusiast has always been a huge Matt Hardy fan. So, it kinda hurts to even type this, but here goes: Matt has been the single most boring wrestler across WWE and AEW in 2022, and there's no sign of that changing anytime soon.

Advertisement

A reunion with brother Jeff earlier in the year got folks excited for more Hardy Boys goodness, but the quality of their matches ranged from so-so to 'is that it?'. Since Jeff's run-in with the law and sabbatical, Matt has been splitting time between guiding Private Party and somehow having his contract seized by The Firm.

None of it has been thrilling.

The latter story hasn't even ended up going anywhere, and there isn't much sizzle to Marq Quen and Isiah Kassidy looking to Hardy for advice. How did one of the hottest free agent gets from 2020 become such a nothing character just two years later?

Which other wrestlers have been boring in 2022? For more WWE/AEW, check out 10 WWE Wrestlers Triple H SAVED In 2022 and ROH Final Battle 2022: 10 Things That Must Happen!

Advertisement