10 Most Controversial Wrestlers On The Planet Right Now

Kings and jesters roam the court of public opinion.

By Michael Sidgwick /

Defining the theme of the article - "The English dictionary defines 'controversial' as..." - is a hack's trick, but it's worth clarifying here.

Advertisement

The controversial wrestler isn't the bad-tempered, unprofessional head case, and as such, you'll not see Austin Aries listed here. The reception to Aries is pretty much unanimous at this point. He is almost as good a professional wrestler as he thinks he is - which is a gigantic compliment - but his attitude is unwarranted, and has all but expelled him from any promotion of renown. It's very telling that, in an era in which every talented performer has landed a mainstream gig irrespective of whether they can be accommodated, WWE, AEW nor NJPW has courted his signature.

Teddy Hart was another nightmare for promoters, but appears to have matured in Major League Wrestling, improbably and (very) belatedly. Vince Russo has lost his controversial edge in 2019. With his WWE-runs-AEW conspiracy theory, he all but confirmed that he's a sh*t-poster too obvious to get worked up about.

This is a list designed to highlight the divisive wrestlers that fuel the pro wrestling discourse - overrated, underrated, a disgrace to or pioneer of the profession? - and offer a subjective author's take...

10. Johnny Gargano

Johnny Gargano is either one of the best professional wrestlers in the world, or the most self-indulgent.

Advertisement

He's so beloved that those who love him can scarcely believe that some don't. He is capable of orchestrating unreal drama and cauldron atmospheres of awe and emotion, but is it to a cost? Does Gargano get way, way too much sh*t in? That's the counterargument to the notion that Gargano is among the very best pro wrestlers in the world, which is the premise of the divide. Nobody of rational mind would claim that Gargano isn't at least an excellent professional wrestler, but the overload of content and finisher kick-outs, to some, removes him from the conversation. Is it character work that conveys the sheer size of his heart, or a hollow shortcut to drama?

And who is Gargano, incidentally? A conflicted hero, or uneven character?

Author's take: Gargano is both; he has lost support since elevating the NXT in-ring standard to the all-time great stratosphere, but, barring the ridiculous TakeOver:Toronto main event, Gargano makes a fan of this naysayer all over again, every time.

That's the sign of a wrestler who is every bit as good a worker.

9. Seth Rollins

In his most uninteresting year onscreen, Seth Rollins has courted controversy off it.

Advertisement

His wildly ill-advised company man ranting in the spring sparked a debate over how good Rollins actually is. Is he among the Best Pro Wrestlers In The World, Period - or is he overrated, and ironically indebted to the "little guys" he mocked to widespread mockery?

He is inconsistent, which fuelled everything: his Money In The Bank banger with AJ Styles, and his tremendous, layered babyface performance opposite Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam were both triumphs, but his record is patchy elsewhere. He revealed his lack of detail and depth in an overbooked disaster of an Iron Man match against Dolph Ziggler last year, his solid wrestling match in a personal blood feud with Dean Ambrose at TLC '18 was an unqualified and tedious disaster, and his uninteresting character work across RAW has added to its malaise.

Author's take: His suicide dive is a flying high five, and his segment work is dorky and melodramatic. Rollins is a character badly lacking in definition, likely because he isn't a babyface.

He certainly isn't among the global elite class, but the heel turn that is so badly needed might reconcile everything: his act and the reception to it.

8. Baron Corbin

"You're meant to hate the heel."

Advertisement

Baron Corbin is a heel, certainly. Loathed by some fans for a level of workrate deemed well below the modern standard, Corbin wrestles at a more deliberate pace and stalls, with verbal tirades and rest holds, on the beg for boos. It's easy to see why WWE likes him so much: he's never injured, he's safe, he's solid, he's tall, and he can cut an obnoxious-as-hell heel promo.

But you're meant to love to hate the heel, and those boos rarely materialise because there's no real ingenuity nor danger to his work. Corbin's pace doesn't invigorate crowds. His lack of energy is reciprocal; he drains the crowd of it just like he drains his opponents of it in long, repeated rest hold spots. He doesn't so much cheat as smugly luxuriate in the boredom of the people. It's loathsome, but not entertaining.

But maybe, increasingly, all of that is in the past tense.

Author's take: In trading rest holds for a neat spot in which he smashes the heads of his opponents against the ring post, Corbin has traded groans for winces, tweaking the in-ring aspect of his character to become a nastier proposition.

If King Corbin can prove himself against opponents that aren't great, long may he reign.

7. Joey Janela

Just this week, Joey Janela took to Twitter to reveal that his car had been broken in into. It was very on-brand; Janela draws controversy, even when he isn't actively trying.

Advertisement

Janela infamously took one of the most psycho bumps in CZW's outrageous history to announce himself in the viral sphere, following which he has redefined Independent wrestling with his absolutely inspired approach to nostalgia: he has a knack for determining which wrestlers never went away, but were in fact cryogenically frozen in something wonderfully close to their prime. Wrestling and booking invisible men, bilateral amputees, and guys from the 1980s who can still go to *** standard, Janela has diversified the niche scene, which now flourishes under the sort of irony that inspires conniption fits in the old guard.

That old guard loathes 'Jelly' Janela for his absurd stunts, outwardly disrespectful attitude and doughy physique, which you expect he maintains, ahead of his move to the mainstream, purely to piss them off.

Author's take: The man retrieved a tennis racket from under the ring at AEW All Out, pulled an hilarious expression of disgust, and tossed it aside as the symbol of old values it is. Hate him or not, there's an inspired poetry to his philosophy. He's a rebel, but he's creative as hell with it.

He's also a great wrestler. The substance helps put over his vogue, '80s-inspired presentation.

6. KENTA

KENTA's NJPW debut in itself proved controversial; many fans projected puro values of loyalty onto him, believing that he should have returned to and helped out the struggling Pro Wrestling NOAH league in which he made his name.

Advertisement

His run has also divided opinion. A part of the seminal G1 Climax tournament - revered critically as the greatest of all time - KENTA starred in several absorbing matches, the best of which was his gripping struggle to topple Kazuchika Okada. But his glaring botches and deliberate pacing led many to write him off. He was having very good matches against an elite group of talent incapable of wrestling bad ones, they said, and he has also taken his Bullet Club induction too seriously. He has finally grasped the worst sports entertainment bullsh*t after leaving WWE in his shortcut match with Kota Ibushi this week.

Author's take: KENTA is in clear physical decline, and suffers - to an extent - when working against performers well beyond his wavelength of timing. But his matches are over spectacles because he hasn't lost the ability to project a threatening d*ckhead aura.

Pitchforks out if he gets a bigger match than Tomohiro Ishii at the Tokyo Dome, but until then...

5. Goldberg

Matt Riddle's mischievous angling for a money match - he first wanted to retire Brock Lesnar, and now wants to expose Goldberg - has reignited an old dialogue.

Advertisement

Is Goldberg a terrible professional wrestler?

In the immediate fallout of Super ShowDown, judged strictly from what the business is at its core - an emulation of combat in which the performers do everything not to seriously hurt one another - it was hard to argue. Goldberg was a danger to both himself and others after headbutting a door before the match. He'd already knocked himself loopy with this (ultimately selfish) psych-up routine in 2017.

But Goldberg's SummerSlam retcon restored the thrilling, totally unique essence of his act. Very few wrestlers ever looked as good as Goldberg did when breaking asses in half.

Author's take: How good Goldberg is is directly proportionate to how effectively he is produced. That all but confirms that he's hardly a master, but the key is: WCW Goldberg = awesome, WWE Goldberg = limited and boring, WWE's impression of WCW Goldberg = awesome.

Sh*te knee bar, mind.

4. Charlotte Flair

Though nowhere near to the same, noxious extent, since Roman Reigns has earned renewed respect from wrestling fans, Charlotte Flair is next in line for the dreaded 'Super' treatment.

Advertisement

Charlotte receives "too many" opportunities in comparison to the rest of the roster. She's over-pushed, she's favoured by management, she's holding the rest of the locker room down, she's...

She's Roman Reigns.

Roman Reigns is also great.

Ronda Rousey's WWE run was awesome, and her match against Charlotte was the best of the crop - a stunningly physical war of a sprint. It formed a larger pattern. Charlotte has wrestled the best match of Becky Lynch's main roster career (Evolution), Sasha Banks' main roster career (RAW, October 3, 2016), Bayley's (RAW, February 13, 2017), Asuka's (WrestleMania 34)...

Author's take: The transparent pursuit to accelerate through title reigns - just like her dad! - is a bit vexing, but so is the discourse. Charlotte is pushed because she is the best all-round talent in the Women's division. It's as if certain wrestling fans don't grasp what it means to be a star, a new change in attitude that is likely a byproduct from complete content exhaustion.

3. Jim Cornette

An enduring heel to the very end, Jim Cornette's primary source of income is critiquing a product he is predisposed to hating.

Advertisement

His memories of the Omni don't draw the clicks (a shame, but no less true) and so he reviews every major AEW show on his Experience podcast, principally because his 'Cult' loves his "cosplay wrasslers" rants, and AEW fans tune in out of hate despite knowing better.

Hatred is a theme; Cornette lashed out against Jordynne Grace in a rant teeming with misogyny, and the choice of words he used to bury Sonny Kiss were, at best, ill-advised. Cornette actually makes some very salient points throughout what is an increasingly tiresome exercise in bad faith; some aspects of an ever-changing industry will always remain timeless, and Cornette pinpoints exactly when the finish should arrive, what needs to be emphasised and put over, and when a move shouldn't be repeated before the finish, even in a context he cannot abide.

Is it still real to Jim, damnit, or his plea for realism much needed for a company not without niche self-indulgence?

Author's take: Some of his schtick is still piss-funny, but he cannot be objective. He hates Kenny Omega with his core, and he simply skips the women's matches through the bias of misogyny. None of these women to his knowledge have ever wrestled a blow-up doll. He writes them off on the basis of their gender.

If he's a critic, and not a troll, he's not convincing anybody.

2. Joey Ryan

Loved for his creative, lewd comedy spots, Joey Ryan is the "famous d*ck wrestler" who sent Twitter into meltdown after "suplexing" Danshoku Dino with his "penis" in 2015. The concept of a penis possessing the strength of an arm is absurd, and quite funny, but not, apparently, in the context of professional wrestling.

Advertisement

Jim Cornette despises the man, as does every pro wrestling fan of traditional leaning, because the move he has used to redefine wrestling as an industry with its own avant-garde sub-genres ruins the integrity of it, which is beyond oxymoronic, but there you go.

Ryan and Cornette resume their old, exhausting rivalry, every now and then, and deep down they realise it is mutually beneficial; Ryan's flirtation with the mainstream is all but over - "Khaaaaan!" - and Cornette maintains his relevance by taking Sprite sh*ts on his kind.

Author's take: Don't enjoy the act at all, personally, but wrestling is a vast, varied medium, and the fact that The Hottie And The Nottie exists doesn't in any way devalue Blade Runner, just like the existence of Ryan doesn't in any way detract from the magic spell cast in the best matches of 2019.

1. Orange Cassidy

In an industry that has given us voodoo witchdoctors, incestuous pirates, hispanic men who have disavowed their heritage to become white men, fat chick thrillers, evil bearers of Christmas gifts, and this one doofus who uses a sledgehammer as a weapon, as if you'd find it around a ring and it wouldn't kill somebody, its fans are up in arms about a guy who wrestles with his hands in his pockets.

Advertisement

Orange Cassidy wrestles ironically. He lightly grazes the calves of his opponents with apathetic kicks, and rolls around the canvas when his opponents are running the ropes. This deeply annoys fans who enjoy wrestling as the strictest emulation of sport. To them, Cassidy is a disgrace to the mat where their childhood heroes once stood. But Cassidy's work is credible in a different context; when faced with a David Starr or a Nick Gage, he either drops the pretence immediately, or furthers it to draw an error from his incandescent, over-emotional opponent.

Author's take: Again: Orange Cassidy ruins wrestling like a remake of a popular film. Vince Vaughn didn't erase the master footage of the original Psycho. You can ignore his performance, just like you can ignore Cassidy's. The rolling-on-the-mat spot is too much, but Cassidy's schtick is so absurd to be hilarious - and pissed-off, that's-it Cassidy does a better suicide dive with his hands in his pockets than the WWE Universal Champion.

Advertisement