10 Most Heavily Protected Wrestlers In AEW Right Now
In the company where wins and losses matter, who is being made to look unbeatable?
Wrestling Twitter is filled with bad takes about wrestlers being buried the second they lose a match. It's a rash, nonsensical idea that any wrestler who loses a match has hit a brick wall, especially when it comes to anything in WWE where it doesn't have any impact on the booking.
One thing AEW has made perfectly clear since their inception is that wins and losses matter and by maintaining a ranking system, they have made some defeats feel major. When Adam Page lost his ranking when he was obliterated by Brian Cage, it felt impactful. It fed into a wonderful story and there is no way anyone could spin the narrative that Page was being buried.
The definition of being buried is whatever the hell is going on with Karrion Kross.
By putting such emphasis on winning and losing, AEW has built a wonderful ecosystem where every match matters and every result impacts the winner and losers next move. In victory or defeat, there are some wrestlers who are clearly being protected, either for current or future purposes as AEW doesn't just book week to week.
Quick note - this list doesn't include The Elite, as although they win loads, their constant cheating doesn't make them feel protected. Just saying.
10. Thunder Rosa
There is a reason why Thunder Rosa is being kept on the back burner in AEW, but at the same time, being kept impressively dominant.
Reports have stated that 'Big Bicep Tony' has pencilled in Thunder Rosa for a major push in 2022 and based on her history with the current AEW Women's Champion, Britt Baker, it makes perfect sense. Their brutal Lights Out match earlier this year was a critical smash and was as bloody as it was dramatic.
Rosa picked up the win, but as it was unsanctioned, it made little impact on her rankings. Since then, she has been booked mainly on AEW Dark and AEW Dark: Elevation, racking up the wins and keeping her as one of the dominant forces in the women's division. She had a great showing at the Casino Battle Royal at All Out 2021, finishing runner up to the debuting Ruby Soho.
Fans are clamouring for AEW to make further strides with the women's division, and whilst Britt Baker's ascension has been meteoric, it still feels like it needs a genuine legacy feud to full establish it. Thunder Rosa vs Britt Baker threatens to be not only that, but a career defining one for both women when it happens.
9. Orange Cassidy
This one might seem like an odd one out considering his middling, uninteresting feud with Matt Hardy, but hear me out.
Orange Cassidy has been one of the most protected wrestlers since AEW's inception, and still to this day, 'Freshly Squeezed' is treated like a big deal. Most takes on his current feud with the Hardy Family Office is that it feels like a waste of time and that Cassidy is treading water.
Everything about Cassidy's gimmick and aura is protected, from his slow-motion kicks to his hands in his pockets. He has gone toe to toe in the ring with some of the biggest names in the company and it was only at Double Or Nothing back in May this year that he was competing for the AEW World Championship.
AEW knows what they have in Cassidy. A unique performer who has a genuine connection to the fan base and whose popularity is so iron clad that he can be circled in and out of major feuds at a weeks notice. Having such a performer on the books is a massive plus and although at times he might feel lost in the shuffle, it never feels like Orange Cassidy is being jobbed out. In fact, as of the 22nd of September, Cassidy sits top of the AEW rankings.
Protected.
8. Jade Cargill
Which transitions us nicely into Jade Cargill, because at times it feels like AEW doesn't quite know what they have with her.
Aesthetically, Cargill could lay claim to being the most eye-catching wrestler on the entire roster. Her striking white hair along with her chiselled physique make her a unique specimen on the AEW roster and she certainly stands out in the burgeoning AEW Women's division.
Thrust into the spotlight by interrupting Cody on her debut, AEW never gave a satisfactory link between her and Shaq O'Neal. Then, Brandi's pregnancy killed their feud dead, and since then, Cargill has been made to tread water, besides her needless association with Mark Sterling.
Cargill is a star in waiting, but she has less than a year's experience between the ropes and to date has only competed in sixteen matches, the longest of which went seven-and-a-half minutes. Confined mostly to Dark and Dark: Elevation, Cargill is improving with every rep and has yet to taste defeat outside of the aforementioned Casino Battle Royale.
By keeping her out of the mainstream spotlight but keeping her record as dominant as it is, it's clear AEW are protecting Cargill for something big. What that is however, isn't that clear.
7. Wardlow
Big, sexy Wardlow is an interesting choice for this list.
His three biggest single matches to date in AEW have all ended in defeat, yet Wardlow has never felt like a loser. He lost to Cody in the first ever cage match, was beaten by a resurgent Hangman Page in the contenders' tournament and lost to Jericho thanks to MJF's botched interference.
Make no mistake about it, AEW have been very careful with ensuring that Wardlow is protected and to this day, he still works perfectly as the at times put upon difference-maker in MJF's corner.
Whilst The Pinnacle feels like a dead act since MJF and Chris Jericho decided to make their feud more personal, Wardlow's slow-burning face turn has been kept alive. His recent hesitation when Brian Pillman Jr. was beating the ever-loving crap out of MJF was superb character work and when the moment arrives at some point when he does bite back, it will have been wonderfully earnt.
In the meantime, Wardlow continues to rack up impressive wins on Dark and Dark: Elevation, but Wardlow's inclusion on this is more to do with his presentation in MJF's corner, and how dangerous he can be when he steps in and gets involved on his behalf.
6. Christian Cage
Despite an underwhelming debut due to the fact that he wasn't CM Punk, Christian Cage's run in AEW had been an understated highlight of 2021.
Whilst many were sceptical of his replacement of Hangman Page as an opponent for Kenny Omega heading into All Out, 'Sweet TK' has done a fine job of protecting Cage not only as a wily veteran but as one who gets the job done.
When Kenny Omega absconded to IMPACT after winning the AEW World Championship in late 2020, many thought a full-on war would break out. That hasn't been the case and the use of IMPACT has been minimal at best, as has Omega's gimmick as the belt collector.
Enter Christian Cage, an IMPACT legend from their TNA days who not only beat Kenny Omega, he also lifted the belt from his shoulder and now represents the company as their figurehead for the first time in fourteen years. Often considered the 'wrestler's wrestler, Cage has been presented as one of the top guys in AEW since his arrival, climbing the rankings and only losing the second match to Omega due to shenanigans.
Keeping Cage strong is intrinsic to his ongoing storyline with Jungle Boy, who will no doubt get a huge rub by beating 'The Instant Classic' when the time is right.
5. Malakai Black
What a job they have done with Malakai Black.
When the lights shut off and heralded his arrival, the AEW fans lost their collective minds. Make no mistake about it, this man has a BIG following and AEW needed to get his presentation right, especially after his hokey, self-made promotional video.
Everything they have done with Black so far has been money, and when he walked out for his first entrance it was terrifying. The mask, the music, the sporadic plunges into darkness, made Black seem like a demon crawling from the depths of hell.
Feeding him Cody in a match that drew heavy comparisons to the phenomenal Brodie Lee squash was a smart move, but the pièce de résistance was having him pin Cody with one foot. As if he had just squashed a no named jobber. It was an electric debut for Malakai Black and their work with him since then has been great.
Undefeated and kicking the heads off of the Nightmare Family, there was a strong chance that Black would have been overshadowed by the recent arrivals of bonafide megastars CM Punk, Bryan Danielson and Adam Cole. But AEW have shown before they don't book week to week, and it looks like Malakai Black has an exciting future ahead.
4. Powerhouse Hobbs
One of the best things about being a wrestling fan is discovering a new talent. The first time you see an unknown superstar who clearly has the raw materials to be something special, it fills you with an excitement that one day you will witness that come to fruition.
That's what AEW have with Powerhouse Hobbs.
After some impressive early showings, AEW showed their hand by aligning Hobbs with the likes of Moxley and Allin against Team Taz, before having the young man shockingly turn heel and join Taz and his gaggle of bastards. In the months since, Hobbs helped eject the other monster, Brian Cage from the group, taking over the mantle as the baddest man of the stable.
It shows how highly AEW think of Hobbs, as not only has he completely overshadowed Cage who now seems like an afterthought, but they have had him target CM Punk as his next opponent heading into AEW Rampage: Grand Slam. It's a hell of a role for Hobbs to have so soon into his AEW run and coupled with his impressive win/loss record where he currently sits second in the overall rankings, it is clear that Powerhouse Hobbs is being groomed to be a major player within the company.
3. Jon Moxley
Jon Moxley is the people's champion of AEW. This isn't some lame comparison to The Rock, because their characters couldn't be more different, but there is no one on the AEW roster who feels as connected to the fans, who feels like a conduit for their journey with the company, more than Moxley.
Ever since he arrived and breathed in the atmosphere, his bond with the audience has been sacred. Walking away from the WWE to help start up the genuine competition endeared him to them immediately. But he was also a huge star. A multiple-time WWE champion and part of their biggest success of the last decade.
After holding the AEW World Championship for nearly a year and going to hell with the likes of Eddie Kingston, Brodie Lee and Brian Cage, Moxley was the top guy. In the ten months since he lost the belt to Omega, AEW has been careful to keep him as strong as possible. He rarely loses, almost always picks up the pinfall victory and is still in multiple main events.
He's an 80's action hero brought to life, and recently has shown interesting flashes of turning heel. If he does or doesn't, it isn't hard to see Moxley as the most likely man to become the first two-time AEW Champion.
2. Miro
Is Miro currently the best thing in AEW? There is a strong argument to suggest that he is.
What a transformation. From being held up as a 'Not all ex-WWE guys succeed in AEW' to being the most devastating force on the roster. Let's be clear, this 'Redeemer' character and his run with the AEW TNT Championship has turned Miro into one of the hottest acts on the planet. Considering the loyal fanbase who wanted him to succeed, it's great to see.
Since obliterating Darby Allin and taking the belt in May of this year, Miro has been as dominant as he has been terrifying. His 2021 record stands at 13-0 and his promos have been flawless. Give this man a minute and he will sell you on any upcoming title defence. His use of action movie one-liners is sensational and every threat he spouts to his opponents is believable. If you haven't seen the promo for his bout with Eddie Kingston, then you need to hit up YouTube right now.
Tony Khan made a point that Miro would have to wait until 2021 for the rankings to reset before the AEW fans saw the best of him. Well, the man wasn't wrong, and the only thing more certain than a dominant Miro victory nowadays is that he will most certainly be satisfying his hot wife in the aftermath.
1. MJF
Long term storytelling.
It's a compliment when it's thrown AEW's way and a stick to beat WWE with. One thing AEW has received critical acclaim for is it's near two year arc for Hangman Page and when he does dethrone Kenny Omega and become champion, it will be a cathartic moment. But then, he will usurped by another long term story coming to fruition.
MJF is the most protected man on the AEW roster. A machine gun with the mic in hand, he is fast becoming the most loathed heel in the business as well as one of the most must see. Cleverly, AEW have been able to keep him away from the title picture since his feud with Moxley by having him feud with Jericho, but MJF is the man to take the belt from Page when the time comes.
In two years of AEW programming, MJF has only ever lost a singles match twice. Both times, he has a genuine claim to being screwed over. Moxley used an illegal manoeuvre and he only lost to Jericho once the match had been restarted. The 'Salt Of The Earth' has been kept phenomenally strong throughout every storyline, outsmarting babyfaces and also showing a sadistic streak. His lashings of Cody's back were a seminal moment for the company, but MJF still felt the need to kick the man in the grapefruits.
Given ample opportunities to prove his worth in the ring as well as an almost weekly promo due to his mic skills, it is crazy to think MJF is this good at just twenty five years old. And all of this protection will have been worth it when he finally wins the AEW World Championship.