10 Most Shocking Wrestling Heel Turns

He's sold his soul to the devil.

By David Cambridge /

WWE.com

We were promised something big at last week's Hell in a Cell, and - apart from Shane McMahon nearly dying after an insane leap off the structure's roof (which was written in the stars) - we got it.

Advertisement

Sami Zayn, long-time friend and latterly, adversary, of Kevin Owens, made the shocking decision to turn his back on the fans who supported him through thick and thin, shocking the world* by pulling KO out of harm's way and towards victory instead.

While today's shock-jock booking means wrestling fans must prepare themselves to watch just about anyone (John Cena excepted) make a deal with the devil, heel turns still have the ability to shock like nothing else.

There's just something innately disturbing about seeing a former warrior of the light, who once spoke of their kinship with the fans and disdain for anyone who defied the rule book, laughing maniacally as they finally snap.

*Except, obviously, for the part of the world who were actually in Detroit's Little Caesars Arena, most of whom presumably saw Zayn, without a disguise, lurking at the foot of the announce table the whole time.

10. R-Truth Bums A Smoke

Communal sing-alongs aside, R-Truth has always been better (read: less annoying) as a heel than a face - evidence of which was found during his run with TNA, in between the two WWE stints for which he is better known.

Advertisement

His 2011 turn still came as a surprise, though. Having been on a hard-luck losing streak, the erstwhile US Champion had neither the momentum nor, seemingly - having shown few signs of frustration in the build-up - much of a motive to go rogue.

But this actually made sense. When you've got nothing, as Bob Dylan famously noted, you've got nothing to lose - and it was only after seeing the chance to make real his main event dreams slip agonisingly through his fingers, with defeat to John Morrison in a number one contender's match on Raw, that he snapped.

After laying waste to his former tag team partner in an unprovoked assault (and this is one of the rare instances where the word assault - with Morrison getting his skull drilled into the barriccade - really is apt), Truth bummed a cigarette from a member of the UK crowd, and lit up whilst kneeling over The Shaman of Sexy's mangled carcas.

9. Batista Doesn't Rip Rey's Head Off

Perhaps, after watching Eddie Guerrero make public his switch to the dark side by beating up best friend Rey Mysterio in 2005, we should have seen this one - almost a blow-by-blow repeat - coming.

Advertisement

But while Eddie's turn had plenty of foreshadowing (at least a decade, if you really believe that Dominick was his son), Batista's four years later seemed to come out squarely of the blue.

It made little kayfabe sense, either, since the Animal's primary complaint against his ex-tag team partner was that he broke up his pin-fall attempt in a fatal four-way match in which they were, by definition, in opposite corners.

Instead of waiting for the following week's SmackDown - as is customary for any wrestler with a bone to pick - Big Dave let Rey know at Bragging Rights, with the dust still to settle on their match, exactly who he blamed for his loss.

And yet, for reasons unknown to anyone not named Batista, he didn't take the clear and present opportunity to remove his pint-sized victim's mask, despite promising moments before to "rip his head off".

8. The Rockers Clear The Air

Many have claimed that they saw Shawn Michaels' early-90s heel turn in their crystal balls - and, to be fair, they're probably telling the truth, since The Rockers had been at each other's throats for weeks (hence the "clear the air" barbershop talks).

Advertisement

But for the generation (a lot of them young kids) who watched live as HBK Superkicked Marty Jannetty out of nowhere, and then - in one of the all-time great heel moments - slammed his head through a pane of glass, this was one of the most viscerally impactful scenes in wrestling history.

Even for the pre-internet smarks, there must too have been some trepidation in predicting that Michaels would receive the backing for a solo push, when so many of those standing between him and the main event were beefed-up muscle monsters by comparison to whom he looked like a twig.

In that sense, it can be compared to Kevin Owens turning on Chris Jericho earlier this year: yes, you knew it was going to happen at some point, but after so many false dawns, it was still shocking to see KO beating up the man he used to call best friend.

7. Sami Zayn Rescues A Former Foe

Granted, there were a handful of fantasy bookers who called Sami Zayn's heel turn in advance, believing that a change of tack for the man who had spent the better part of a year in the role of Braun Strowman's punching bag was long overdue.

Advertisement

But, apart from the fact that Zayn and Owens - formerly indie duo favourite El Generico and Kevin Steen - share a history that dates back more than a decade, there was little reason to believe it would actually happen.

The Underdog From The Underground was, after all, only fleetingly involved in Hell in a Cell's build-up, losing yet another match to his former friend in what appeared to be little more than an opportunity for KO to collect some more heat en route to his date with Shane on October 8.

On paper, Sami had little to gain from making an enemy of the SmackDown Live commissioner, but in a frank promo 48 hours later the former ROH star made clear his frustrations at being continually misused since jumping ship from Raw. And suddenly well felt his pain.

6. Coachman Becomes The Coach

No-one saw Jonathan Coachman's SummerSlam 2003 heel turn coming. Mainly, however, because no-one cared about Jonathan Coachman enough to speculate on his being good or bad.

Advertisement

It was, all the same, still genuinely quite surprising to see the mild-mannered backstage reporter who spent much of his WWE career up to that point being humiliated by The Rock wrap a steel chair around the back of Shane McMahon, aligning himself in the process with Raw co-general manager Eric Bischoff.

Credit must go to the man we later came to know as Coach for how well he took to the role, too. He was treading a path - from bookish announcer to smug heel - that only a handful before him had navigated with any success, and one on which Howard Finkel had stumbled the previous year.

And he did it well, first looking suitably unrepentant after beating up the chairman's son, and then later in the year moving in on JR's seat at the Raw announcer's table (taking, for a short while, Michael Cole's long-held mantle as the most maligned commentator in WWE).

5. Pupil Turns On Teacher

There's a reason everyone knew that James Ellsworth was going to betray Dean Ambrose last year, and this was it. Colin Delaney, the James Ellsworth (only more likeable) of his day, turning on one-time mentor Tommy Dreamer.

Advertisement

But while Ellsworth, however tenuous his grip on reality, at least had a motive - his belief that he could win the WWE Championship from AJ Styles - Delaney costing Dreamer in his ECW Title match with Mark Henry at The Great American Bash in 2008 made exactly no sense.

Without the veteran watching his back, Delaney was once again vulnerable to the attacks from which he was, for a short while, immune - not least of all from Dreamer himself, who beat him in an Extreme Rules match a couple of weeks later by way of recompense.

If the logic was missing, the shock value definitely wasn't. No-one expected Delaney to turn heel because no-one really believed that this obvious jobber, 140lb soaking wet, was going to stick around long enough to warrant any character development (and, sure enough, he didn't - getting released the following month).

4. Stone Cold Makes A Deal With The Devil

A tweener by nature, turning Stone Cold into a fully-fledged heel was a transformation that could only be completely realised by making him the ally of the most contemptible man in the world - but Donald Trump was busy, and they went with Vince McMahon instead.

Advertisement

Many have cited the moment the Texas Rattlesnake - having just won the world title in WrestleMania X7's much-vaunted main event - shook hands with the WWE chairman he had spent the last three years terrorising as the very second the Attitude Era drew to an abrupt end.

And that was precisely what made it so shocking: it made very little business sense to take the company's - and professional wrestling's - biggest and most beloved good guy and turn him into a figure of hate, particularly with Dwayne Johnson soon to to set his sights on a career in Hollywood.

Whatever the long-term implications, though, you had to admire the conviction with which the company executed its wicked plan - and, perhaps more impressively, Jim Ross for convincing children the world over that this was the most earth-shattering event they would ever see.

3. Bischoff And Hogan Get Their Man

Jeff Hardy's 2010 heel turn should probably be placed in the same category as Stone Cold's a decade earlier - and perhaps it's a little worse, actually, because TNA, more so than its competitor, was in desperate need of a leading face to spearhead the battle to become a legitimate ratings rival to WWE.

Advertisement

The Charismatic Enigma, booked in a three-way TNA Championship match with Kurt Angle and Mr Andeson, looked to be preparing a deserved attack on Eric Bischoff, but - shockingly - instead used the crutch Hogan gave him to attack his opponents, and seal a dubious title win in the process.

Considering that Hardy was made by TNA's new management regime to jump through hoops in order to earn a place in the Bound For Glory main event, this really did come out of nowhere - almost as though it was only dreamed up on the eve of the show.

But Bischoff-Hogan era TNA has already taken enough flak for its nonsensical booking and the shameful way it sidelined those who brought them to the big time in the firstp lace. They deserve at least a modicum of credit here for what was a genuinely shocking twist, albeit one that perhaps did little to unseat Vince McMahon.

2. JR Pays His Due

There are few sights in wrestling more shocking than that of a barely-conscious JR being made to kiss Vince McMahon's naked ass.

Advertisement

And if it were Kurt Angle alone, or just about any other wrestler on the roster, forcing Raw's beloved commentator to pucker up, it would have been slightly easier to watch - but there was something truly striking about the fact that it was Undertaker.

WWE's resident vigilante had spent the previous decade largely locking horns with foes who outreached him, only setting his sights on the helpless when they truly deserved it (sacrificial lamb Stephanie McMahon, for example).

For him to attack a commentator, after appearing to come to his aid, was a heel turn against which few can be compared in terms of shock value, thanks in no small part to the brilliant way in which Big Evil - one of wrestling's most underrated talkers - set it up.

After telling JR that everyone else in the locker room, at one point or another, had to kiss the chairman's ass, 'Taker asked whether he was planning to follow suit. "No" - and, by implication, "I'm better than you" - was the wrong answer.

1. Hogan Goes Hollywood

Fans who came of age in the Attitude Era know Hulk Hogan as one of wrestling's great heels - a role he has been taking perhaps a little too seriously over recent years - but the notion of the man who once embodied goodness and light as a villain sits a little less comfortably with some.

Advertisement

In the 1980s, Hogan was the leading figure of a wrestling industry which appealed, primarily, to wholesome family fun, rarely if ever passing up the opportunity to talk up the Hulkamaniacs by whom he was adored, or herald the United States as the world's number one.

When he wasn't rescuing kittens stuck up a tree or foiling Soviet plans for world domination, the Hulkster could usually be seen coming to the aid of his fellow goodies in their mutual fight against evil. And that's exactly what we expected to see when he rushed down to the ring at WCW's Bash at the Beach, as Randy Savage took a beating from Outsiders Hall and Nash.

But after watching the nWo's "Third Man" drop a leg on his former friend, everyone in the arena - not least of all Gene Okerlund - was legitimately stunned, and responded in kind as only wrestling fans could: by throwing their trash into the ring.

Advertisement