10 Moves Tony Khan Must Make To Save AEW

That title might read as hyperbole - but tell that to AEW's advance ticket sales...

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW is in a spot of trouble, the extent to which isn't as obvious as the statement.

Advertisement

It's still the best promotion on the planet, but what, really, does that mean these days? Not one company, despite WWE's numbers and the optimistic narrative surrounding it, is operating at the peak of its powers. WWE is overly reliant on long matches that are good, not great, and not heated. NJPW has felt stale for a long time, and the other Japanese promotions won't feel anything more than bittersweet until packed, full-throated fans are all the way back for good. ROH is...well. Read on. Impact is probably more consistent than ever, actually, but the highs are nowhere near what they once were. GCW appears to have had its time. PWG, its identity subsumed, has lost the old soul that once resided in Reseda.

Is AEW in a similar place?

If not quite facing an existential crisis - Warner Bros. Discovery are reportedly "very happy" with its performance - AEW is in danger of losing that which made it so wonderful. Then again, look at those advance ticket sales. Yikes is the word; the November 4 live Rampage taping has sold just 1,022, which is frightening - particularly since AEW tends to shift the majority of its tickets in one early surge. Ultimately, despite strong enough TV ratings and mostly good or at times great shows, AEW doesn't feel like AEW. The magic is vanishing.

It can however feel like AEW again...

10. Make A Rule #1: End Or Severely Limit Recruitment Storylines

All worthy, traditional narrative fiction adheres to a set of rules.

Advertisement

For it to make sense - and for the audience to invest - it must be trusted. Things have to matter, characters should behave in a certain, consistent way. Establishing a fixed set of rules allows the author/show-runner/booker not to fall into traps and make a sloppy, trope-ridden mess. Break this discipline, and problems mount.

In short, Tony Khan must remember that which made AEW so vital at its peak.

Khan needs to erect a dry erase board and bind himself to a certain set of rules. The core issue, and it's a sprawling one, is that there's so little narrative discipline to AEW's product of late. It is imperative that Khan tightens his sh*t up.

The faction-boss-recruits-new-acts thing is almost laughably passé at this point. It used to work as a key narrative driver, but what's happened is that joining or forming a stable is hardly a guarantee of career progression, and the device is unconvincing.

Consider Private Party. They were once over because they burst onto the scene as a breakout indie act with agency. Now, they've spent the last two years under the guidance of Matt Hardy, and then Andrade, and now, Matt is trying to win them back. It's ridiculous. Why would they bother? They're in the semi-frequent Rampage abyss. They're better off on their own. The premise of this story is impossible to take seriously.

In turn, so is AEW all too often.

9. Make A Rule #2: Preserve The Forbidden Door

The Forbidden Door used to be the coolest thing in wrestling.

Advertisement

The same was once written about the King's Road, the absorbing length of the New Japan epic, the turbo-drama off the NXT TakeOver formula. Do anything to excess, and its brilliance wanes.

We're at that stage now with the Forbidden Door, which encompasses inter-promotional matches, one-and-done cameos and even free agent signings. It no longer feels like this surreal dream factory of a thing. Remember when Jeff Cobb turned up in February 2020? It was a stunning twist in the Chris Jericho Vs. Jon Moxley programme. Their match was as physical as it was thoroughly unexpected. Mox was presented as even more of a brick sh*thouse, and the episodic story itself benefitted: what else could Jericho do to neutralise the threat?

The last time Cobb worked a TV match, against Cash Wheeler on Rampage ahead of Forbidden Door, it was good and nothing more, really. Do you even remember that it happened?

Probably not, since before the PPV - premised on surreal dream clashes - Khan indulged one of his favourite tropes by bringing in Johnny Elite, W. Morrissey and Big Damo for cameos. Surreal feels normal now.

The constant use of imports is affecting the way in which the full-time roster is used and perceived, too. Stringing together a series of wins, the old focal point of the promotion, doesn't matter as much in 2022 - and the ceaseless use of the Forbidden Door makes it difficult to invest in singles performers who rarely feature every week.

8. Make A Rule #3: Emphasise The Rankings

Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter reported that AEW is de-emphasising the rankings framework.

Advertisement

This is a terrible move.

At present, the roster feels muddied. So many acts feel like they're just existing, no closer to the title picture, no better or worse than so many of their peers. Consider the babyface midcard scene. Orange Cassidy, Ricky Starks, Darby Allin, HOOK, Eddie Kingston: who among them is truly being readied for a significant run worth the investment?

At the exact same time as Tony Khan is asking the audience to invest in so many acts, he has ignored the narrative mechanism with which he gives you the answer; to compound the lack of focus, he has removed the clarity. And now, the audience is only mildly investing in a bunch of guys they quite like.

The Tag Team Gauntlet match of August 27, 2020 was incredible; it pit the four highest-ranked teams against one another, made the Young Bucks' chase that bit more agonising, got FTR further over as d*ckhead heels, and, by threatening their dream match on free TV, made you realise just how big you wanted it to be. It drove a significant chapter of the Elite's company-long saga, too. It was majestic booking that further established a tier of credible talent. You were once able to trace the steps without quite knowing where you were going: it was the best blend of logical but unpredictable booking.

The ranking system isn't the only way in which AEW must rediscover its own identity - and there's a grim reason why it is only barely in place now...

7. Bring Back And Do Not Abandon The 'Opening Banger'

The show-opening Dynamite promo became a fixture so gradually that you didn't even notice.

Advertisement

Tony Khan has tinkered with the format to the detriment of Dynamite of late. Despite being "very happy" with AEW, the network has imposed certain things. The word "sh*t" is bleeped now, the flow of blood has been bandaged, and something like the Lights Out match between Ricky Starks and Powerhouse Hobbs (while very good) wasn't the ultra-violent fare that the promotion was once permitted to indulge. If the opening promo isn't a semi-regular network mandate, it needs to go. The traditional opening 'banger' was once so vital in setting the tone and igniting the crowd into creating waves of what, sadly, might now be referred to as the "old" noise.

In another insidious tweak, which must have been ordered by the network, the opening match, when it even happens, is interrupted by an ad break. This has a noticeable effect on the atmosphere, which fades when the wrestlers involved do little when the tape machines stop rolling. Remember the days of the uninterrupted first match?

They were glorious. At the very least, AEW should transpose the Rampage gimmick of the almost imperceptible "90 seconds!" of picture-in-picture break.

The new format is all too similar to WWE - and, on the subject of which...

6. Differentiate The Product From WWE

Impromptu matches are the ultimate, subjective pet peeve, but even if the wider audience doesn't care too much about the inherent lack of logic - what was meant to happen in the slot, and isn't it all too convenient that a skirmish broke out to set the scene? - it's still a signature WWE device.

Advertisement

Now more than ever, AEW must distinguish itself from the competition.

Merely being better by default is nowhere near enough; even if you personally think that the success of the 'Papa H' era is overstated, the narrative has taken hold. A better than usual Raw is more remarkable than a worse than usual Dynamite, even if Dynamite remains the better show. It's stupid, frankly, but that's what appears to have happened in the online sphere.

AEW should relish the challenge and set about being the true alternative again. Never again book an impromptu match. If Paige can't go, and Tony Khan has an onscreen authority figure role in mind for her, abandon it. Immediately. It has already reduced the women's division and made the TV feel fake and contrived. Calm down with the interference-laden finishes; did John Silver really need to be protected against Rush?

That Rampage finish just telegraphed the result of Rush Vs. Hangman Page and put the heat on the booker, as is too often the case with U.S. wrestling in its modern era.

5. Watch The Peak Shows Again

When AEW resumed live touring following the U.S. vaccination effort, Tony Khan lost a little bit of what made AEW special despite, until deep into 2022, promoting many seminal episodes of Dynamite.

Advertisement

Knowing that there was once more a big, enraptured crowd acting as a backdrop, he indulged in the surprise debut, the interactive back-and-forth promo segment, and the run-in for easy pops. These are all staples of the episodic TV experience, but then, he once transcended the medium he is merely operating within now.

On the June 30, 2021 Dynamite - the last held when Daily's Place acted as AEW's residency - Khan booked 20 of the best minutes of wrestling TV ever. Or of TV ever generally: Penta El Zero Miedo and Eddie Kingston defeated the Young Bucks in what was an absolutely incredible match and deliriously entertaining spectacle, all at the same time. The pops were utterly relentless; after so much d*ckhead heel chicanery, justice was served and catharsis was elicited via Elite Hunter Frankie Kazarian evening the odds and, in an unforgettably hilarious visual, Brandon Cutler blinding himself with freeze spray.

This was peak Dynamite: a gonzo bonanza of emotion, irreverence, and energy packaged together through the medium of state-of-the-art wrestling that advanced a million different things without losing focus of anything.

It was supreme narrative elegance masquerading as intoxicating chaos: a cast of characters interacting with one another to deliver an overload of pure joy. It was a quintessentially deft AEW segment, whereas now, AEW feels more regimented than ever before: a very good show that isn't truly remarkable nor distinctive.

Watching this all back is crucial in determining what, exactly, has been lost.

4. Fix The Women's Division

Cody Rhodes coined the catchphrase "undesirable to undeniable", and it's time for Tony Khan to apply it to his women's division.

Advertisement

Perhaps the fact that it's still his is the problem. He knows how to book. We know this, despite his foibles, which makes his handling of the women's division all the more egregious. It's a case of apathy, not incompetence, and it simply will not do.

Short of gifting 30 minutes of TV to Allison Danger every week, which he won't do, he needs to start caring and making bold, uncharacteristic choices. He is able to preserve the big matches in the men's division because he has the trifecta of credible losers: the veteran types (Dustin Rhodes et al.), the great midcard hands (Tony Nese et al.), and the prodigious yet unrefined rookies (Lee Johnson et al.)

He does not have this luxury with the women's division, and so he should take a Gedo-esque approach and book all-star matches, spaced out, with a definitive winner and loser. And, for Christ's sake, book more than one women's match per show. It can't be overstated how strong a message that would send; as it is, the division registers only as an obligation. It's beyond token. In its current state, the women's division will always act as the worst or most inessential part of Dynamite.

Save it, and the difficult scope of the task may well mean he saves the perception of the company as the very best pro wrestling has to offer.

3. Abandon Ring Of Honor

Is this where it all went wrong?

Advertisement

That's a drastic way of putting it. AEW still promotes largely very good shows. Still, the sense that AEW just doesn’t feel like AEW anymore is hard to shake.

When did AEW last really feel like AEW? This is as subjective, gut feeling as an insight gets, but Revolution '22 might well be it. The CM Punk Vs. MJF feud in particular saw AEW at its brilliant, unparalleled best. The sheer thought that went into it - from Punk refusing the handshake to MJF revealing that Punk shaking Bryan Danielson's hand is what brought him into the business, pivoting to the incredible exploration of stan culture - hasn't been surpassed since.

And that's because Tony Khan has too much to think about now.

Something like Anarchy In The Arena was a quintessential AEW masterpiece - the sort of incredible theatre of which no other promotion is capable - but somehow, that used to be the standard. AEW used to be surreally, impossibly great. The clumsy attempt to integrate (or impose) a secondary brand has detracted from the old magic.

ROH has devalued the prestige and importance of titles and allowed a generic, unimaginative quality to creep into Khan's booking. Nobody would truly miss it if it went away, so perhaps it needs to go away. It has accelerated Khan's burn-out, as the cynics predicted it would.

It would be embarrassing to bin it off, but that can't be worse than the rather tedious mess it has created. Asking who the ROH Women's champion is a difficult trivia question at this point.

2. Be More Bold

This is where the rules come back into play.

Advertisement

Ultimately, as a result of his indulgent recruitment strategy, Tony Khan has confronted himself with a stacked roster of performers that he doesn't want to beat. This creates a problem from a luxury; what's the use in such a great crop of performers if they barely interact at a significant level?

The combination of volume of talent and unadventurous booking negates the entire point. Interference finishes are up, too few big matches happen, and momentum is too easy to lose.

So start beating people.

Khan really could do with getting the dry erase board out and circling the names of around eight acts in the men's division and four in the women's that will form the PPV-drawing core of the promotion. Anybody else is fair game to do a clean job.

Would you rather

A) Miro doesn't get booked, or

B) Fuego Del Sol et al. eat pins on TV in his absence?

Not everybody can win all the time, but if they aren't booked half the time, you're just faced with a separate issue.

This rule in turn will foster creativity, which is what rules, paradoxically, accomplish. This is a company that once had Jon Moxley and Nick Gage - two of the biggest "aura" guys in the entire business - lose across back-to-back weeks. And, because the finishes were so creative, they lost nothing other than the match.

Kenny Omega lost frequently in the early phase of AEW's history, and went into became a big PPV headliner draw. His Nielsens as the Belt Collector were very strong too. Losing isn't bad.

Bad finishes are bad.

1. Cut The Sh*t

Belief in the AEW brand is fading.

Advertisement

The discourse is the discourse. Some people are always going to dislike AEW for what it is, and the exact same thing is true for those who like it for what it is. Tribalism isn't a new trend, nor will it ever go away. Pinning down a consensus is impossible - it slips between a collective of fans enjoying or not enjoying the show subjectively - but is anybody, truthfully and justifiably, calling this era the very best of AEW?

No chance, and if you somehow can't feel the mood through the screen - or can't face it, as is too often the case among grown adults - you can look at the objective, damning numbers.

Simply put: the same minor problems aren't going away, and it's time AEW cut the sh*t.

AEW Dynamite is the best show on TV, but it's too easy to take the piss out of. It's too easy to roll one's eyes at its foibles. Get rid of the sh*t that people bury every week, and AEW will do so much to rid itself of the stigma and convince its base that its back and that it is listening again.

Stop interrupting every backstage interview. Let ostensibly important developments breathe. Let Excalbur breathe.

Make the promotion less easy to meme, basically.

Be smarter than the smart alec critics.

Advertisement