10 Observations From Attending WWE SummerSlam 2016 Live

The longest party of the summer!

By Scott Fried /

Sunday evening, WWE presented the 29th annual SummerSlam show, live from Brooklyn's Barclays Center. Even though the structure of the Royal Rumble (and its implications for WrestleMania) makes it the second-most purchased show of the year, SummerSlam has long been the company's second-most important. More than at any other event besides the show of shows, major matches and angles occur which will carry the company for months.

Advertisement

For the second straight year, SummerSlam came from Barclays Center, the only arena in New York City where WWE currently hosts televised programming. Last year's show was held in front of a raucous, sold-out crowd, but despite some good action, many fans considered it an overall disappointment. Would WWE be able to change that perception this year?

Well, no. Anyone who's seen SummerSlam knows that it was teeming with the kind of weakness that has become associated with WWE as of late - too much quantity, not enough quality. While fans at home had the option of pressing pause, going to sleep, and catching the rest of the show on Monday, those of us at Barclays for six hours got a little restless as things went on.

Here are 10 observations from attending SummerSlam 2016 live:

10. Rematch City

After a lengthy kickoff show, SummerSlam proper opened with Enzo and Big Cass versus the dream team of Chris Jericho and Kevin Owens. The bout was a fun opener with some good action, but a surprising finish - Jeri-KO won when Owens threw Enzo up and Jericho caught him with a Codebreaker on the way down.

Advertisement

Common logic would dictate that the established babyface tandem goes over the makeshift heel duo, especially since Jericho is rumored to be leaving WWE again in the near future. The only ways this win would make sense for the heels is if they're about to challenge for the tag titles (they're not) or if a rematch is brewing. The latter seems pretty likely.

Setting up rematches seemed to be the order of the day, especially on the Raw brand. Both the New Day-Club and Roman Reigns-Rusev feuds will need to lead to bouts at next month's Clash of Champions, and the Sasha Banks-Charlotte and Finn Balor-Seth Rollins bouts will also need to be brought back if injuries don't get in the way. It looks like there won't be much new ground broken on Raw anytime soon.

9. Banks Robbed

Though SummerSlam was a really strong card on paper, the Women's Championship match between Sasha Banks and Charlotte stood out as a potential show-stealer. Sure enough, the bout turned out great, second only to John Cena versus AJ Styles as the match of the evening.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the ending was a shock - and not in a good way. Banks locked Charlotte in the Banks Statement for the second time in the bout, and just about everyone was convinced that the challenger was going to submit. Instead, she rolled Banks onto her shoulders and pinned her, becoming a two-time WWE Women's Champion.

It since become clear that there's more to the story than just bad booking - Banks is reportedly suffering from a number of injuries and needs time off, meaning that the creative team had to choose between changing the title and putting it on ice temporarily.

Still, to the fans in attendance, beating Banks was the wrong choice, and it deflated a hot crowd.

8. Miz-Takes

Every WWE match follows a specific formula. In the beginning, the babyface outperforms the heel, just to remind everyone why they're cheering for him. Then, the heel turns the tide by either cheating or getting lucky, putting the face out with one particular move. The heel works the face over for a bit, but then the face makes a comeback, bumping the heel three times in a row. Then the false finishes start.

Advertisement

One notable (and very rare) exception to this formula came at SummerSlam in the Intercontinental Title match. The undermining of Apollo Crews continued as all of his early offense was cut out - The Miz attacked him from the get-go and they went straight into putting the heel on top. As a result, fans were even less likely to get behind Crews, whose terrible booking has become more frustrating than ever.

At just under six minutes, the match was the shortest on the entire card. Though Crews had some exciting offense after he made his comeback, nobody was surprised when The Miz beat him to retain the title. After all, if WWE was concerned with making him look good, they'd have let him have a regular match.

7. The High Point

Perhaps no match on the entire SummerSlam card was as anticipated as the final showdown between AJ Styles and John Cena. Their "15 years in the making" feud may have been a bit overblown to start with, but the interplay between both men has been great. All that was left was the last battle.

Advertisement

It didn't disappoint. Though Cena and Styles went into their false finishes early, the match kept going until it was a classic. Cena kicked out of a Styles Clash and escaped from the Calf Crusher, while Styles survived the STF and an Attitude Adjustment off the top rope. A second Styles Clash put Cena down, and the Phenomenal Forearm gave Styles the clean win.

This match was exactly what it need to be - it was a great bout that put Styles over without any reservations. Smackdown has a new star (hopefully one who'll be WWE World Champion before long), and John Cena's story has taken an interesting twist.

Unfortunately, the show was all downhill from here.

6. The Annual Show

Last year, SummerSlam celebrity guest Jon Stewart was well-received by the Brooklyn crowd. Not only was his interplay with Mick Foley early in the show amusing, but when he cost John Cena a match with Seth Rollins, he endeared himself to the smarks in attendance.

Advertisement

This year, though, the crowd wasn't as into Stewart. After a promo where he acknowledged that his attack on Cena last year made no sense, he introduced the WWE Tag Team Title match between The New Day and The Club. That bout was an above-average match, but it ended up turning into a backdrop for some media attention.

Once again, Stewart got involved, distracting The Club when they attempted to pin Kofi Kingston. The Club then tried to subject the former Daily Show host to a ringpost-based assault, but the returning Big E made a comeback, drawing the disqualification but popping the crowd.

Stewart is a real-life wrestling fan whose familiarity with the product makes him a refreshing guest star, but this wasn't as memorable an appearance as last year's. If he comes back in 2017, hopefully the company comes up with something better for him to do.

5. The Show Is Safe

Dolph Ziggler earned a shot at WWE World Champion Dean Ambrose by winning a six-man match on the first post-draft edition of Smackdown Live. Ambrose, though, was unimpressed. He criticized Ziggler as a man more obsessed with stealing the show than winning matches, sparking a feud between the two. Ziggler vowed to win Ambrose's title and steal the show.

Advertisement

At SummerSlam, he did neither. Not only did Ambrose win, as everybody had expected, but the match was a stunning disappointment. Whether the two men's styles didn't mesh properly or there was some bad road agent work afoot, the bout simply felt sloppy and drawn out.

Part of the problem was the face/heel dynamic, which got confused in the match's buildup. Both men are babyfaces, but Dean Ambrose had been acting like a bully toward Dolph over the past few weeks. Still, "The Lunatic Fringe" was the crowd favorite, but that changed on Sunday. The fans at SummerSlam rejected Ambrose somewhat, and though they wanted to champion Dolph, they knew he had no chance of winning. The result was a muted reaction to a sub-par contest.

4. This Is What Red Belts Do

Finn Balor may have spent more time in NXT than anyone though he would, but WWE decided to make up for it by pushing him to the moon upon his callup. He debuted on Raw the evening after Battleground, and less than a month later, he can call himself a world champion.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the world championship in question is the WWE Universal Championship, one of the ugliest title belts introduced in recent memory. A cheap-looking copy of the WWE World Championship, the design shows no innovation and the red strap makes it look hideous. The title was unveiled just prior to the Finn Balor-Seth Rollins match, and the Barclays Center crowd hated it.

The disgust over the belt completely overshadowed what was supposed to be a dream match. Despite the fact that the Balor-Rollins contest was good (the third-best match on the show, easily), fans wouldn't drop the belt thing - they spent several minutes chanting about how bad it looked, then booed whenever it was shown on the overhead screens.

Seth Rollins was vocal on Twitter about his disappointment in the fans, and it's hard to blame him - he came to Brooklyn to compete and put on a great show, and nobody noticed. Still, when a title is brand-new and has no inherent meaning, it should at least look like something worth fighting for.

3. Bait And Switch

The supposed de-push of Roman Reigns has, effectively, turned into little more than a temporary push for the United States Championship. Despite the fact that the idea behind the storyline was to endear fans to Reigns by (briefly) not shoving him down their throats, "The Guy" has still been racking up main events and dominating TV.

Advertisement

At SummerSlam, he was scheduled to challenge Rusev for the secondary title on the Raw brand - right after the match for the brand's top title. It was strange placement, but the match never got underway - Reigns beat up Rusev before the bout started, and he did so much damage that the contest couldn't take place.

The crowd reaction was largely apathetic. Reigns has been gaining support on TV, but that wasn't the case in Brooklyn. Fans chanted "Rusev Machka," "CM Punk," and other distractions, but by this point - several hours into the show - nobody seemed to care that the match wasn't happening. The sole pop came when Reigns speared Rusev outside the ring, and even that led to boos when he ignored "One more time!" chants.

2. Two In A Row

The main event of the evening was the highly-anticipated Brock Lesnar versus Randy Orton match, but in a matter of minutes, the wind was taken out of the audience. Early on, it became clear that the bout just wasn't going to be anything special.

Advertisement

SummerSlam 2016 may well be remembered as the evening when "Suplex City" jumped the shark. Brock did his usual shtick, but it was so expected that it didn't mean much (not to mention the fact that "The Beast" was clearly taking it easy on "The Viper's" weak neck). Things finally turned around when Orton gave Brock an RKO on the announcers' table, but the finish - which saw Lesnar win by TKO after breaking Orton's face open with an elbow - came off as flat.

Though the bout's ending felt a bit premature, apparently the plan was almost identical to what happened (albeit without so much blood). That's a pretty awful way to misread the crowd, then, because the Barclays Center fans were not fond of the ending. Fans booed the abrupt and confusing nature of the main event's conclusion.

The same thing happened last year, when The Undertaker beat Brock Lesnar (Lesnar made Undertaker tap out, but the referee didn't see it, so the match continued and 'Taker choked Brock out). At that show, angry fans chanted "Bullsh*t" as the show went off the air. All in all, history repeated itself.

1. Giving Us Our Money's Worth

All in all, SummerSlam was a middle-of-the-road show - there was a lot of disappointing stuff, but the few good matches were enough to keep it from being a solid thumbs down. It would be hard to tell that from the general reaction, though - fans in Barclays Center completely lost interest in the show, while those online were excoriating it verbally.

Advertisement

That reaction seems a little excessive, but it's not the fault of the fans - it's the fault of WWE. As good as Cena versus Styles was, it's hard to focus on it when it was followed by two-and-a-half largely disappointing hours. When a show is as long as SummerSlam was (and as WrestleMania was), it's only natural that fans will get harder to please as it goes along.

Someone at WWE seems to think that, since we're all spending $9.99 a month for the network anyway, extra content is just gravy - and it makes the deal more enticing to non-subscribers. It's just not true. None of the 1.5 million people who get the WWE Network are going to complain if a Pay-Per-View only runs three hours - and the truth is, none should ever run longer than that, except for WrestleMania, which can go four. A kickoff show can run 30 minutes and have one match.

In this era of six-hour shows, the good gets obscured and the bad gets magnified. Until WWE learns that less is more, expect similar misfires.

Advertisement