10 Potential Megastars That Never Recovered From WWE Burials
No Going Back
The John Cena/Roman Reigns storyline heading in to No Mercy has been a transparent reflection of conversations that have taken place online about the pair for years. It's as if WWE staffers have looked at some of the more commonly held arguments against 'The Champ' and 'The Big Dog' and handed them straight off to the opposing wrestler, regardless of how well the verbiage can sink or float in a pro wrestling context.
Though company insiders will perhaps consider the narrative of the piece to simply be a challenge for Reigns to step up to, the former Shield member has understandably struggled delivering the dialogue with the composure and assuredness of his more experienced colleague. In Roman's defence, Cena has been on the other side of this exact fence once before (his battles with The Rock between 2011 and 2013 pulled at the same threads), and hasn't had a problem burying a colleague six feet under if given the opportunity or instruction.
As recently as last month, the leader of the Cenation was seeing to it that Baron Corbin's slide was further expedited, whilst Alex Riley, Ryback and others have spoken out about his ability to systematically deconstruct selected talents he doesn't jive with.
John Cena though, is still merely window dressing for WWE at large. The company has a history of breaking down performers theoretically to rebuild them. The strategy often fails, leaving behind a wrestler spent of confidence, charisma, and future career progression.
10. Scott Steiner
A weak non-finish in his debut match and a loss in the rematch against the worst incarnation of Triple H weren't going to be the glorious moments to anoint Scott Steiner as the second coming of Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock combined, but 'The Game' and his top level cronies already knew it was the beginning of the end for 'Big Poppa Pump'.
In like a lion and out like a lamb, Steiner was a footnote at the 2003 Survivor Series, exactly a year on from his explosive Madison Square Garden debut a year earlier. Admittedly, unexpected physical setbacks had limited how involved he could be in the early days of his run with the organisation, but such roadblocks have been skipped over for talents the company cared enough about to preserve.
Following the disastrous programme with 'The Game', Steiner was one of the scant few on the entire roster to miss WrestleMania 19, then found himself programmed against and with fellow midcard floater Test for almost the entire year following his return to television. Incapable of looking like a star after such a damning deconstruction, he sat out the remainder of his two year deal after a final appearance in the 2004 Royal Rumble, and never again reached the World Championship pinnacle he'd effortless ascended to in WCW.
9. Wade Barrett
Considering how high the company allegedly rated him, it's remarkable how frequently Wade Barrett was cut down to size when it really mattered.
His December 2010 humbling at the hands of John Cena was a damning conclusion to his time as leader of The Nexus, itself a storyline crippled by hierarchical panic that too many new superstars might accidentally get over at once. Hokey runs as leader of splinter group The Corre and a bare-knuckle experienced a profound lack of interest from the creative team, but Barrett again made the best of his circumstances following the decision to bring him back from a visa-enforced absence as an irritant mouthpiece.
As 'Bad News Barrett', Wade thrived. All gavel, podium and hashtags, Bad News Barrett was a Brother Love for the modern age in his ability to stir from the sidelines without ever appearing to have the chops to back it up. Thanks to his effortlessly entertaining delivery, the act rapidly gained traction with the audience, but the company specifically asked that he tone down so not to get too popular. It was fitting that his most prosperous period was so unnecessarily stymied. Wade was tragically always stuck being given bad news, rather than just getting to deliver it.
Aiding that calamitous decision, WWE booked him to win 2015's King Of The Ring and embrace the regalia to such an extent that the 'Bad News' aspect was phased out entirely for a 'King Barrett' act that generated less than half the heat.
8. Chris Kanyon
Chris Kanyon was twice decimated by The Undertaker during his WWE tenure, but the 2001 sh*t-kicking he and partner Diamond Dallas Page took couldn't compare to particularly cynical decimation he experienced two years later.
Wrestling doesn't have a particularly stellar record when it comes to delicately managing mental health, but it's safe to assume that the best way to aid a performer struggling to cope with his homosexuality in a notoriously narrow-minded industry isn't to dress him up as Boy George, have him 'come out' of a giant gift, then take concussion-inducing chair shots as a punishment.
Literally all of it happened though, and on a taped show no less.
Airing in full despite the company having 48 hours to consider if it was truly acceptable content, 'The Deadman's brutal assault on the returning Kanyon signalled exactly what most inside WWE thought of the prodigious WCW star's talents. Astonishingly, the dire segment was his actual return to television after an injury, but he was beaten with such fury that only a doomed stint on C-show Velocity beckoned in the aftermath.
The message from WWE was painfully clear - he was gay first, and a wrestler second, no matter how talented he may have been. Continuously battling inner demons long after his 2004 WWE release, Kanyon tragically committed suicide in 2010.
7. Chris Candido
When Chris Candido adopted a 'No Gimmicks Needed' moniker in ECW, he took a dated swipe at the company he arrived just too soon at to be truly appreciated.
Charismatically unvarnished but with an exceptional in-ring presence and a valet that herself had the makings of being the industry's greatest ever female performer, it remains to be seen how well Skip and Sunny may have fared in WWE's Attitude Era instead of the cartoonish New Generation. And not least because Shawn Michaels wasn't really around in the locker room by then.
Bursting onto WWE screens in mid-1995, the pair were unsubtly positioned as obnoxious fitness gurus. And that is to say, that is literally what they were. In 1995, unless you already happened to be established as a character, you were destined to be a caricature. Though Sunny shone as she did in just about everything Vince McMahon envisioned for her, Skip was miscast as a ostentatious braggart, with his fall down the pecking order happening in parallel with the collapse of his reputation backstage.
Defeatedly looking elsewhere as the politically protected 'HBK' stole his girl, Candido was as big an afterthought on television as he was in his own relationship. A babyface turn didn't remotely help, and his talents were left to rot before the company granted him a 1996 escape.
6. Damien Sandow
The type of main roster failure that occurred with alarming regularity before WWE's aggressive injection of pre-established NXT talents from 2014 onwards, Damien Sandow truly did his best with everything the company gave him, and still went largely unrewarded for the effort.
Escaping the worst of some early missteps with his excellent 'Intellectual Saviour Of The Masses' persona, Sandow was an excellent sneering heel, but lost virtually all of his momentum as a scholarly threat after foolishly cashing in his Money In The Bank contract against a relatively fresh John Cena during an October 2013 edition of Monday Night Raw.
Having feuded extensively with former tag team partner Cody Rhodes to win and remain in possession of the valued shot, it was a needless and destructive sucker punch that the character never recovered from. Slumping after the defeat, Sandow was the company's biggest loser for months (and months) following the defeat, before gaining unlikely steam as a 'stunt double' for Hollywood douchebag The Miz.
The pair had world class chemistry, with the rechristened 'Mizdow' becoming a vital cog in The Miz machine as the pair scooped tag title glory en route to becoming the most entertaining act on the show. WWE let them both down. Paying off a long-running abuse storyline with a listless turn on Miz by Mizdow in WrestleMania 31's pre-show battle royal, Sandow was back to pure soulless parody as a Macho Man parody before sliding further down the card to obscurity ahead of his fiercely protested 2016 release.
5. Ryback
A vocal detractor of John Cena and the WWE machine since his 2016 exit from the organisation, Ryback has earned an somewhat unfair reputation merely as an embittered ex-employee, but further examination into his tenure with the organisation paints a picture of an unfairly maligned monster.
Rebounding from the Nexus debacle following a 2012 return to television, Ryback's undefeated streak over jobbers and lower card stars alike gained him huge support from a fanbase clawing at something - anything - to break up the monotony at the top of the cards beyond the thrilling John Cena/CM Punk.
Unfortunately for 'The Big Guy', WWE booked themselves into a corner when they elected to capitalise on his burgeoning success too early. When Cena legitimately injured himself ahead of a planned Hell In A Cell main event with Punk, Ryback was slotted in. The pay-per-view outdrew the prior year's event and comfortably out-performed most B-shows that year, exhibiting the intrigue in the maiden contest between the the undefeated monster and record-smashing WWE Champion.
Delivering a screwy finish in a failed effort to protect him, he then continued to stumble in the months that followed. Ryback was all but given up on, with a post-WrestleMania heel turn on John Cena little more than a reason for the two to engage in a passable time-killing angle for 'The Champ'.
Even after a pathetically dull 'Rybaxel' doubles run with Curtis Axel, he again regained enormous babyface support almost overnight following a late-2014 turn, but WWE again elected not to follow through, and he endlessly freewheeled in the midcard until his departure.
4. Baron Corbin
A plot still seems to be thickening as discussion of Baron Corbin's recent de-push rumbles on, with various stories emerging that it was less about his inadvertent abuse of a military man on Twitter, and far more to do with a categoric conclusion drawn between John Cena and Vince McMahon that 'The Lone Wolf' just didn't have 'it'.
Considering that he's only been wrestling five years, that's hardly all that surprising. It can take double that for a performer to even reach WWE let alone thrive in the complex environment, and even then, a future star's credibility with an audience can be smashed within a matter of seconds. For Corbin, it took just six.
The first three came as he lost his Money In The Bank briefcase thanks to an over-zealous cash-in attempt on Jinder Mahal just days before his SummerSlam match with John Cena. The three seconds he took to stare at the lights in that match must have felt longer than then years he'd spent training just to get to that point.
'The Champ' eviscerated Corbin in a reductive display of peacocking ill-befitting of an experienced professional an in industry that fundamentally requires robust cooperation regardless of the ingrained individualism. D*cking about in JBL's cowboy hat at ringside then repurposing a 'Where's Your Briefcase?' heckle for Baron into a 'Let's Go Cena/Cena Sucks' chant just for himself, 'Big Match John' was instead a Big Time Charlie. Less a brightly burning starlet, Corbin was cruelly incinerated in the spotlight.
3. Shane Douglas
Shortly into his 1995 WWE tenure, Shane Douglas failed a significant in-house company litmus test that not only damaged his reputation with higher ups, but also fractured his relationship with the locker room's most powerful political force.
Earning a shake of disappointment rather than a nod of approval from the 1-2-3 Kid following their match, the rechristened Dean was earmarked for failure from that moment. Consensus amongst the roster at the time was that if you couldn't have a good match with The Kid, you couldn't with anybody. As a member of The Clique, Sean Waltman's say carried more weight than his miniature frame, and Douglas' apparently unacceptable grasp of the basics became the first of several strikes against the former ECW firebrand.
Signed with healthy expectations having over-achieved as Paul Heyman's 'Franchise' during the Philadelphia outfit's most groundbreaking period, Douglas mistakenly advised Vince McMahon that he had a background in teaching. It was 1995, remember, and sure enough, 'The Dean' was born.
It was as if the entire education system had thrown up on him. Vignettes saw him in a classroom setting, or analysing wrestlers with a chalkboard backstage. In the ring, he sported farcically ceremonial academic attire. Precisely none of it resonated with the crowd, and the company seemed content to let him fail as further matches with The Kid and Razor Ramon underwhelmed.
2. Roman Reigns
WWE had already burdened Roman Reigns with a toxic Royal Rumble victory having learned absolutely nothing from Batista's victory one year earlier, but to wrongly assume yet again that he was a Daniel Bryan surrogate with the vocal majority of the audience was idiotic in the extreme.
Winning a four-man tournament for a WWE Title vacated by Seth Rollins less than a month earlier, Roman was dethroned whilst his confetti still fell.
The victim of a cash-in from inexplicable Money In The Bank winner Sheamus, WWE attempted to recreate the foiled dream that made Randy Orton's same assault on the 'Yes Man' just over a year earlier so heart-wrenching.
It heavily missed the mark of course. Roman didn't have the hearts of the masses as Bryan did and still does, so Reigns' darkest day was only met with half-hearted boos and even fleeting cheers for the ordinarily ignored 'Celtic Warrior'.
Worse still, whilst Bryan's return to the title was littered with seemingly insurmountable obstacles he never ever stopped attempting to scale, Roman's immediate response was tearful remorse. It wasn't needful determination, nor was it something that should have been focussed on. That his crushed expression became the event's biggest visual takeaway only furthered their thoughtless and misguided portrayal.
1. Diamond Dallas Page
Retrospective puff pieces on WCW produced by WWE routinely trot out the line that the Atlanta outfit couldn't create bonafide stars. This is demonstrably not the case of course, but it doesn't stop the simplified line of reasoning being an old favourite whenever a soulless soundbite is required.
Diamond Dallas Page was one such breakout talent, surviving some of the organisation's darkest days as a comedy heel to burst out of the pack as a lone insurgent against the New World Order to become a man-of-the-people World Champion and decorated company icon.
One of the few willing to sacrifice his bulky AOL/Time Warner contract, DDP became the first high profile star to be revealed on WWE television, though he probably didn't expect to be ripping off a balaclava when he made his shocking debut.
Confirmed as the sinister stalker of The Undertaker's wife Sara, Page suggested he'd done so just to get 'The Deadman's attention and to be 'made famous'. This ludicrous assertion that one of WCW's top stars during the company's hottest period wouldn't be known by audiences at large highlighted exactly how Vince McMahon still felt about his derilict opposition.
Speaking of derelict opposition, that's exactly what DDP offered Undertaker in their eventual 'match'. Battered all over the arena at June 2001's King Of The Ring, he was then defeated by Sara herself, before losing a tag team squash alongside Kanyon in a shameful embarrassment of an encounter. Attempts to rebuild him as a motivational speaker were insulting and fruitless, and he was gone less than a year after his regretable debut.