10 Precise Moments Kayfabe Ended

Break the fourth wall down.

By Michael Sidgwick /

Even now, in 2019, a year in which Orange Cassidy wrestles apathetically with his hands in his pockets, and Joey Ryan's penis is protected with the discipline of an All Japan Pro Wrestling 1990s super-finisher, the amorphous, fading concept of 'kayfabe' is staunchly protected within certain circles.

Advertisement

Kayfabe was never a means of preserving the work, because the business was exposed as a predetermined "sham" years before the invention of the Irish whip - a move that in itself reveals the artifice of the racket. Kayfabe was held in reverence because suspension of disbelief drove ticket sales. A wrestler not taking this sacred tenet seriously was akin to seeing a boom mic in the foreground of a feature film; an immersion-breaking distraction that asked too many questions of the process, revealing it as careless and unworthy of investment.

That was then: the now, of best, ******* bouts, draws on a celebration, not concealment, of the performance.

Mainstream wrestling nominally operates within a kayfabe universe, although the concept is used as a dramatic device - so much so that we are effectively through the looking glass...

10. A Tale Of Two Wrestling Matches

When did you first discover that wrestling isn't on the level?

Advertisement

The telltale slap of a super-kicking thigh? The stamp on the mat that accentuates - but reveals the lack of true connection behind - a punch to the face? The sense of real pain grasped from a real combat sport that puts one in the eye of wrestling's lack of bruising?

For the spectators drawn to Comiskey Park on September 4, 1911 - and the rest of the world, to which the events reverberated - it was the sequel to Frank Gotch Vs. George Hackenschmidt: 'The Event of the Century'.

Gotch was the man who, under the tutelage of the diminutive but nail-tough Farmer Burns, brought technical submission prowess to the big-time heavyweight theatre of pro wrestling, which itself comprehensively out-drew boxing, the less "legitimate" sport. Hackenschmidt, the Russian Lion, was a superhuman of absurd strength and resolve.

A rematch of a legendary, arduous, two-hour 1908 encounter widely considered to be a shoot, the 20 minute duration and sudden finish betrayed the old slogs to such a revealing extent that, as the Chicago Tribune had it:

"Most of the spectators filed out of the place in orderly fashion, feeling something had been done to them, they knew not exactly what, but something."

Fix? Screwjob? A sense of "going easy?"

A convergence of chicanery that could not be ignored - the same chicanery that always existed, but never so obviously - all but ended wrestling's reign as America's most popular sport.

9. Jack Pfefer Snitches

There's a strange, circular irony to the legacy of controversial promoter Jack Pfefer.

Advertisement

Both promoter and troll, Pfefer wrote to the press to denounce the legitimacy of professional wrestling, presumably to put over his defiant, open brand of it, which wasn't too dissimilar to the sports entertainment coined (but not exactly invented) by Vince McMahon. Pfefer used "freaks" and theatrics as part of his vision, introducing little people as pro wrestlers to the public, in contravention to the norm of legitimate, strong men grapplers. Moreover, he promoted the French and Swedish Angels, remarkable for their acromegaly-shaped looks.

Pfefer, much like Vince McMahon, traded in the outlandish.

He ended the thinnest pretence of kayfabe in the New York territory with the gleeful cackle of a total irritant, and, his revelations to the New York Daily Mirror twinned with the Great Depression, plummeted the integrity of the racket and gates in the city throughout the 1930s.

The industry in New York only recovered through the formation of Capitol Wrestling Corporation Ltd, formed by Toots Mondt and Jess McMahon. The company formed the WWWF in 1963, which quickly set itself apart as the moneyed, dominant territory through its straight-laced booking and the earnest, super-popular babyface Bruno Sammartino.

From Pfefer's ashes, the phoenix that became WWE was born - but Pfefer's visionary spirit informed the monopoly it became.

8. Vince McMahon Formally Drops The Pretence

Nobody of discerning age, who ever watched professional wrestling through a TV screen, ever thought of it as real. The jig was up decades before that.

Advertisement

The promoters who best cast the spell made the most money, and it was felt, by the magicians who felt they might as well have sawn themselves in half, for how much it hurt, that betraying the tenet publicly was the ultimate disrespect. They didn't endure the torment, only to be told that they didn't. It was an insult, and it was counterintuitive.

If the pain didn't hurt, to quote Dalton, why would anybody care?

Vince McMahon felt otherwise in 1989. He deemed the classification of pro wrestling as a real sport counterintuitive to maximising his profits. Feeling that regulation was a glorified tax grab that diluted his revenue, McMahon informed the New Jersey State Senate in 1989 that his WWF was "an activity in which participants struggle hand-in-hand primarily for the purpose of providing entertainment to spectators rather than conducting a bona fide athletic contest."

The deregulation bill successfully passed through the Senate, and Vince better monetised the WWF's presence in a state adjacent to its home base of New York.

Since Akeem, the Honky Tonk Man, and Brutus Beefcake were all on the books at the time, it was hardly a shock to the public.

7. "I Respect You, Booker Man"

In an era of talent agency, and a creeping reception to a change everybody knew was needed (but didn't know how to effect), Brian Pillman's maverick, devised ideas made it to WCW television in the mid-1990s.

Advertisement

Pillman sought to use creativity when he couldn't draw on his size, nor the established star power WCW deemed a requirement to compete with the WWF. His revolutionary 'Loose Cannon' persona was, in pitch and superb performance, magnificent. Pillman, erratic in his body language, with his eyes peeled white, played the role of the unhinged wild man so well that many thought it real. It was a self-serving gimmick, but it was the most self-serving of times. If Hulk Hogan was the established star with creative control, Pillman fashioned himself as an iconoclast - the Loose Cannon in a fixed world - to be received as a counter-cultural icon to an audience he was clever enough to know was ready for a revolution.

At SuperBrawl '96, Pillman, working everybody with Eric Bischoff - and Bischoff - grabbed a mic a minute into his raucous brawl with Kevin Sullivan, and said "I respect you, booker man".

There's an irony to this narrative (and indeed this list): why was Pillman so revered, where Vince Russo was so reviled?

Pillman's message was coded; it meant nothing to the casuals, and served as a fascinating complement to the hardcores. Russo's approach to kayfabe minimised it to a point that it bore no meaning.

There was nothing left to rebel against.

6. You Grunt, I'll Groan

Jackie Pallo was one of the earliest stars of the British pro wrestling circuit.

Advertisement

In a controversy as old as the industry, Pallo's approach and the internal reaction to it wasn't at all dissimilar to the fierce criticism drawn by the Young Bucks, Orange Cassidy, and really, the next generation of stars who will experiment beyond a boundary that nobody has ever objectively defined. On the inside, Pallo was considered as much a menace to the integrity of grappling as he was to audiences who loathed his detestable actions and cocky theatrics. A household name - apocrypha has it that his matches out-drew football, which is astonishing, given the oscillating fortunes of each sport in 2019 - Pallo bit his lip to produce the all-important, drama-enhancing blood.

This is a practise he did not maintain in retirement.

To the disgust of dying industry, Pallo released an exposé of it with the release of his 1985 autobiography 'You'll Grunt, I'll Groan', in which he revealed, for the first time on these isles, the inner, predetermined workings of the business. Everybody already knew, obviously, but this didn't endear him to those who still needed to monetise the illusion.

Pallo's justification was loyal to his old heel persona, at least: to him, the fat lads of the 1970s had already broken it with their terrible athleticism.

5. Koji Kitao Causes An Earthquake

Koji Kitao was one the of those Stampy The Elephant-cum-Homer Simpson types.

Advertisement

Some people are just jerks, and Kitao was a jerk: expelled from the sumo world after physically battering a trainee - and striking the wife of his stable boss on the way out - this just awful, belligerent disposition followed him to the professional wrestling arena. It intensified, if anything, because on the evidence of his infamous match with John 'Earthquake' Tenta, he had zero respect for it.

Certain malcontents had threatened to expose the sham on Japanese soil before - the Great Antonio tried to clown on Antonio Inoki, who simply beat the sh*t out of him with such ironic professionalism that it felt like a deliberate takedown, and not a frenzied assault - but Kitao's transgression was different. Refusing to cooperate with lesser-ranking sumo Tenta under the illusion of competition, in a 1991 Super World of Sports match, Kitao stood steadfast in his awkwardness. An increasingly pissed off Tenta screamed "This is pro wrestling!". Kitao, like a true bully, kicked not Tenta but the referee. The match was thrown out.

Kitao grabbed a microphone and roared at Tenta "You're just a monkey in this fake wrestling circus!"

Kitao was fired in the aftermath, and to underscore how little this sort of thing matters, post-1911, puro continued to thrive throughout a hugely lucrative decade.

4. Vince Russo's Bizarre WCW Mission Statement

The October 18, 1999 WCW Nitro marked the first of the Vince Russo era.

Advertisement

Over the course of one, bizarre angle, he set a tone that alienated the very same hardcores to which he geared a product with legit mainstream penetration and household stars. Those drawn to the draws were clearly left baffled by the postmodern approach. Those aware of and fascinated by the backstage goings-on, of which there were relatively very few, weren't much interested, either. This wasn't lurid, real-life fascination. This was worked-shoot fascination.

So, to recap: Russo diluted the traditional version of wrestling and his own.

Immediately, wrestlers began to acknowledge the "script", revealing this new era of WCW as outwardly predetermined. Madusa complained aloud that 'they' were making her perform in an Evening Gown match. Tony Schiavone and Bobby Heenan wondered aloud why Buff Bagwell was out there. It wasn't on the format! This new WCW wasn't going to follow the rules, bro!

Buff appeared later, for his match against La Parka, with a different disposition. He was no longer the Chosen One 'they' said he was, and so, in the parameters of a pro wrestling match, he lazily went through his worked routine and invited La Parka to get to the prearranged finish, all while wearing his job face.

Who's the better man? has sustained huge box office combat for forever.

Who am I booking to be the better man? was Russo's arrogant, insane reinvention, and it sunk a company.

3. Shinya Hashimoto Gets Destroyed

New Japan Pro Wrestling was founded on a philosophy - King of Sports - premised on the strictest emulation of just that.

Advertisement

Founded by and driven by the legit skills of Antonio Inoki and advanced through the technical wizardry of Tatsumi Fujinami and, subsequently, the eclectic but formidable Three Musketeers trio, everything about the presentation adhered strictly to kayfabe: the tournament frameworks, the clean finishes, the lack of tacky, theatrical stipulation matches: until the dire and unpopular experimentation of Inokism, NJPW thrived on the old values. The mere notion of a Ladder match informed the dynamic of the snake-bit Kenny Omega Vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi feud of 2016. The stip, imported from the western world, was framed as a transgressive disruption of them.

Ironically, it was Inoki's deranged pursuit of legitimacy that almost engulfed the very promotion he founded.

Totally enamoured by his project Naoya Ogawa, a former judoka who appealed to his legitimate sensibilities, Inoki dispatched him to rearrange top star Shinya Hashimoto's face - for real - at the huge January 4, 1999 show, under the mentality of introducing Ogawa as a lethal, instant threat. Hashimoto was the poorest, most damaging opponent for a damaging idea: the most legitimate act in a predetermined world, Inoki scorched years of build to sacrifice his aura.

He defined the ideals of a company that itself was battered under the philosophy.

2. Dixie Carter's State Of The Roster Address

Much like LOLWCW, LOLTNA also never held itself to tradition under Vince Russo's preferred philosophy.

Advertisement

But Dixie Carter infamously exposed everything - the pretence, the integrity of the roster, everything - in a phenomenally counterproductive 2009 'State of the Roster Address'. It was, of course, an idiotic thing to do in itself - watching a group of subservient, browbeaten combat athletes, heels and faces sitting together amicably was beyond the point of all of this - but the verbal tirade was very much off-target. TNA management was always the problem; the hard-working, very talented roster toiled amid asinine, sh*t-show booking.

"When you're questioning things in this company, you're questioning me," Carter said. "And I cannot allow that to happen," Carter followed up, the same Dixie Carter who inherited a sh*tload of money and lost almost as much because she was utterly unqualified to run a profitable pro wrestling company that wasn't considered an abject joke, and was only considered good in spite of itself on account of the talent she saw fit to bury.

"It's time for us to swing for the fences, it really is," she continued, as if it any of it was their fault.

"Stop drawing dicks on your face, Joe! It's time to get serious, come on."

1. WWE Changes What It Means To Be The Face Of Pro Wrestling

"It's called a promo, kid..."

Advertisement

WWE had for years acknowledged in some form that its product was predetermined, and not just to the Jersey Senate: the fallout of the Montreal Screwjob forced Vince to address the scripted nature of the business and the fraught politics that come with it. The Screwjob itself is only missing here because it is a cannibalised subject most have little desire to revisit.

In August of 2017, WWE didn't merely acknowledge the predetermined nature of the industry; the company told its audience that its face must know how to present itself accordingly. John Cena Vs. Roman Reigns wasn't premised on the age-old 'Who is the better man?' concept. Instead, the question asked of the public was:

'Is Roman Reigns capable of performing as the top star?'

Cena acknowledged his own struggles to change the "content of his character", and called out Reigns for his inability to cut a promo off the cuff. Or "inability". Reigns fired back by claiming Cena couldn't "bury" him, presumably because he was booked to win their upcoming match at No Mercy.

This was true through-the-looking-glass stuff, in that it wasn't a feud: it was a screen test.

Advertisement