10 Reasons WrestleMania 32 Could Be Dropped From WWE Network

WWE could be mulling over a one night return to pay per view.

By Grahame Herbert /

WrestleMania 32 is set to be WWE's biggest show of all time, with 100,000 fans packing out the Cowboys Stadium in Dallas, Texas. In order to draw such a huge crowd, WWE are already planning out a range of spectacular main events. The early indications are that a Stone Cold Steve Austin versus Brock Lesnar match would be the key draw. Especially with Austin's Texas heritage, it makes a whole world of sense to do his first match in fourteen years at WrestleMania 32. He even teased the idea of a 'Texas Death Match' when hyping the potential match to Paul Heyman on the WWE Network Austin Podcast. Other main events would include The Undertaker (in his final ever match) possibly wrestling the WCW icon Sting. In an equally huge match, The Rock is expected to come back for a match with Triple H, in a follow on from the angle at WrestleMania 31 this year. As for the WWE Title, Roman Reigns is pencilled in to either be defending or challenging. Hulk Hogan is also continuing to push the fact that he's supposedly healthy and available for a match. He wants to wrestle, but it is questionable if he will. It is a hell of a show, but it could also be a source of controversy. Writing in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Dave Meltzer is already questioning if WWE will be putting WrestleMania 32 on the WWE Network. There's a chance it could be dropped, in a stunning return to a one off pay per view spectacular. The following are some of the several reasons why.

Advertisement

10. The UFC Example

The reason that WWE brought in the WWE Network was because they thought that the pay per view business model was dead. They were wrong. Pay per view isn't dead, it was just that WWE had failed to create star draws. If a talent was over enough, pay per view would still have worked for WWE. A perfect example is Ronda Rousey in the UFC. She's a star, she's over with the fans, and her pay per view numbers do 400,000 to 600,000 buys. Overall, the UFC still regularly posts solid pay per view numbers. WWE could have done the same if they had created stars. At WrestleMania 32, they will have stars, calling on the past and part timers to present a card that will draw. In maximising the financial gain, it would make sense for WWE to resurrect the PPV model and shut the Network coverage down for one night only.

9. The Mayweather Vs Pacquiao Effect

The pay per view numbers for Floyd Mayweather vs Manny Pacquiao were extraordinary. Industry experts always expected the boxing bout would deliver buys, but no one ever really believed the figure of 4.4 million was possible. It is a figure that almost doubled the previous PPV record. It also proved that fans will pay way more for what they perceive to be a can't miss event. At one hundred dollars, it was expensive, but fans still bought it in record numbers. As a businessman, Vince McMahon will be looking at that. Austin versus Lesnar is the Mayweather vs Pacquiao of pro wrestling. Why give it away for ten dollars on the WWE Network when you could charge up to a hundred dollars on pay per view?

8. The Money

One of the biggest reasons WWE could drop WrestleMania 32 from the Network is the money. Writing in the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Dave Meltzer estimates WWE could make up to $39 million on pay per view alone. That would be factoring a 1.25 million buy rate and $79 price. But bear in mind that it would likely shatter the WWE PPV record set at WrestleMania 28, so the number of buys could actually be a hell of a lot more than 1.25 million. What WWE need to do is weigh it up on the financial damage it could do to the WWE Network. Subscriptions would inevitably be hurt, but the PPV returns would more than make up for it. The bigger damage question could be long term and how it makes fans perceive the Network.

7. There's No WrestleMania Network Bump To Be Had Next Year

Thus far, WWE used WrestleMania as a key selling point for the Network. It creates a bump each year in subscribers, as witnessed this year when the subscriber rate hit a record of 1.3 million. But there are diminishing returns in this aspect. There are a limited number of fans willing to subscribe, and if they didn't subscribe for WreslteMania 31, chances are they won't subscribe for Mania 32 either. If you're a big WWE fan, you are already subscribing year round. The occasional casual fan boost only puts it up to 1.3 million as Mania 31 proved. The way WWE should look at it is the money that a PPV show would generate compared to the slighter money a boost in Network subscribers would generate. The gulf in value of WrestleMania as a PPV event and as a network event is enormous. Also, the Network is a long term investment. A one night, short term return to PPV, is an acceptable move.

6. Wrestlers Will Earn More

Hosting WrestleMania 32 on a pay per view platform would mean that WWE can lure wrestlers like Stone Cold Steve Austin with greater ease. Basically, a return to a PPV format, would mean more money for the performers. The huge differences in revenue compared to the Network model allows for bigger payoffs. That was actually one of the things that CM Punk quit the company over, as he couldn't get a straight answer on what would happen with PPV bonuses when the Network came in. Given the amount of part timers who are expected to come in for WrestleMania 32, the promise of a healthy pay per view bonus could make all the difference in them signing.

5. WrestleMania 31 Was The Least Profitable Mania Since 1997

Despite having a record gate and record merchandise sales, WrestleMania 31 actually ended up being the least profitable Mania since 1997. That's bad. Really bad when you consider where the WWF was in 1997 with struggles to even stay in business. That Mania was the one that Shawn Michaels skipped, leaving The Undertaker to main event against Sycho Sid. It bombed at the box office. Mania 31 suffered primarily because it was on the WWE Network. If it had been solely a pay per view show, it would have been way more profitable. That's something WWE have to consider with WrestleMania 32 and making sure they get the most money possible out of these expensive productions.

4. Can't Miss Matches

Part of WWE's logic in returning to pay per view would be that it is a nailed on success for buys. It is a variety of factors which make it the most unmissable WrestleMania all of time, with a string of can't miss matches that won't ever be seen again. In some instances, it'll also be a case of wrestlers who'll never be seen competing again. Wrestling their final ever match will be Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Undertaker and Sting. There's also a possibility that it could be The Rock's final ever match, given his age and commitments outside the ring. There's even a remote possibility that Triple H would choose to retire in front of a record setting crowd. You never know, maybe even WWE would try to tempt Shawn Michaels (also from Texas) back to the ring for the occasion. There really will be a lot of unique special attractions, making it a bankable show for a pay per view only broadcast.

3. Lesnar Vs Austin

Stone Cold Steve Austin was the biggest pay per view star of WWE's popular Attitude Era. Brock Lesnar to this day still holds the record for the most bought UFC pay per view of all time. Putting these two PPV stars together would be box office dynamite. It is a gigantic reason why WWE would make Mania 32 a pay per view only show. It would almost be madness to have a huge pay per view calibre match like this on a ten dollar internet stream. Lesnar Vs Austin would easily smash the WWE pay per view record set by WrestleMania 28's (Rock vs Cena) 1.3 million pay per view buys. The most optimistic observers would argue that Austin and Lesnar could crack two million buys. If that's the case, WWE simply must make it a PPV only show. The WWE Network just doesn't hold the same type of worth for a main event of this magnitude.

2. The Insider Verdict

The very fact that a respected wrestling industry insider like Dave Meltzer is bringing this possibility up is indicative of what will be getting discussed in the WWE board room. "If you had Austin vs. Lesnar, it also makes no sense to put that on the WWE network, because what appears to be the current show if you add that main event, would be expected to break the all-time pro wrestling record," Meltzer states about a potential move back to PPV for Mania. Maybe Meltzer has heard something on the grapevine, or maybe he's just putting forward a theory of his own. Either way, he's an intelligent guy and knows what he's talking about. If he's thinking like this, then there's a very good chance that WWE are too. WrestleMania 32 on pay per view and absent from the Network is going to be very profitable for Vince McMahon.

1. Will It Happen?

In conclusion, there looks to be a very good chance of WrestleMania 32 returning to pay per view for the WWE. No decision will be official yet, and it is a big choice that WWE must make. The issue is, will it hurt the perception of the WWE Network? The Network is a long term priority, something that WWE are sacrificing short term gains in order to help develop a consistent customer base. WrestleMania is really the crown jewel of its annual schedule, especially for casual fans who only subscribe intermittently. But does it really make sense for WWE to give away a Lesnar vs Austin main event for $9.99? Surely not, surely this is a pay per view at the $79 to $99 retail price. You wouldn't see a Ronda Rousey or Floyd Mayweather event available at a ten dollar price point. WWE need to be smart, weigh up the options, and most likely take WrestleMania 32 off the WWE Network schedule. Austin versus Lesnar is money, a match that demands to be a pay per view exclusive.