10 Reasons WrestleMania 32 Will Be Forgotten

Examining the legacy of WrestleMania 32.

By Grahame Herbert /

WrestleMania 32 wasn't a very good show, there's no getting away from it. Following the excellence of Manias 30 and 31, a dud was due, and that's exactly what fans got in Dallas.

Advertisement

The problems were multiple. Injuries and bad creative going in didn't help matters, but on the night there was still potential for the matches to deliver. But that didn't happen, there wasn't a match of the year contender, and the long term legacy of the event is limited. 

Vince McMahon's priority was of course to make money, and he did a fine job of that. The legitimate attendance was just under 94,000 and the live gate was $17 million. That's the entire point of WWE's business, so it was a job well done from that point of view. 

Critically, Mania 32 didn't live up to its staging. Some matches were good, some spots were thrilling, but there wasn't really that sense of a great WrestleMania match. The event will largely be forgotten, and these are the reasons why.

10. A Ridiculous Run Time

Less is more, Vince McMahon should think about that.

Advertisement

WrestleMania 32's main show went for nearly five hours, while the pre show was a long two hours of insignificant segments and matches. That's too much WWE for even the most passionate of fans, especially when there had also been the NXT special on the Friday and the Hall Of Fame on the Saturday.

Wrestling fans have other interests and lives to lead. The time investment on WrestleMania 32 was a sap on energy and enthusiasm. Seeing the 46 year old Shane McMahon in a half hour match was a bore. Half an hour of Reigns and Hunter was also counter productive, albeit that was still a good match. 

The overall pacing of this year's WrestleMania will hurt its legacy, it isn't a show that anyone will be in a rush to sit through again. It lacked the vibrancy of the better structured Mania 31.

9. Reigns' Moment Was A Next Step

WrestleMania 32 wasn't Roman Reigns' first Mania main event, nor was it his first WWE Championship victory. It was more like a next step. It isn't like an era changing moment fans will reflect upon, it was just the next stop in the franchise project's journey.

Advertisement

In contrast, the most memorable Mania shows, are watershed moments. Seth Rollins cashing in MITB for the first time at Mania, winning his first WWE Title, that's a legacy moment.

But for Reigns at Mania 32, what happened was just the transition of the title back on to him. It was all very predictable. It wasn't a bad match, he did deserve the victory, and he could be set for an amazing few years in the franchise slot. But he'll still look back to that Mania 31 match with Lesnar as his best Mania performance. That was an all time classic, the Hunter match wasn't.

8. Sasha Banks Didn't Win The Gold

The women's title match was fine. With the exception of a few sloppy spots, it was arguably the best match of the entire night.

Advertisement

But that doesn't mean it will live on in the memory, especially with Charlotte retaining her title. The finish was very flat, as most fans had built up the belief that Sasha Banks would be winning.

Banks is one of the best wrestlers on the roster, and could have had a real legacy moment by becoming the new Women's Champion. Instead, Charlotte simply swapped her Divas Title for the Women's Title. It just didn't feel as big.

Which isn't to knock Charlotte, she performed very well at Mania, you can't begrudge her victory, and long heel championship reigns mean bigger things ahead. But for Mania 32, the booking means that the match won't go down in history in the way it perhaps could have done with a Banks victory.

7. Shane McMahon Is Gone

The visual of Shane McMahon diving off the Hell In A Cell was an awesome spot. Insane, but awesome. 

Advertisement

However, the match sucked, and it isn't like the spot is worth much to WWE going forward. 

Shane McMahon is gone now, it isn't like Mankind in 1998 where replaying the spot made the guy. There's nothing to be gained from bringing it up again and again, it was a one time pop, largely needed to cover for Shane's in ring limitations.

Mania 32 will also be forgotten based on the fact Shane won't now be rescuing WWE from Mr McMahon's control. He's gone, he was only ever in there as desperation cover for the injured John Cena.



6. A Lack Of Focus In The Booking

When WWE booked WrestleMania 32, it was like their biggest priority was accommodating as many wrestlers as possible on the card.

Advertisement

Astonishingly, there was only a single straight up one on one match, AJ Styles versus Chris Jericho. Everything else was either a gimmick match, or a multi person match.

That lack of focus was compounded by the segments. Getting veterans on for nostalgia pops came at the expense of some of today's prospects. It wasn't about looking to the future, it was about looking to the past. Even with things like Shane and Hunter in the main events, it just felt a bit outdated. 

Yes, Hunter can go, he's great, but his main event gig did feel like an ego trip. You can't help but feel his booking wasn't focused on what was best, it was focused on him wanting to main event the biggest wrestling show of all time. He's always been a history buff, he's always cared about his legacy more than he should.

5. Ambrose And Lesnar Wasted

Dean Ambrose and Brock Lesnar was a waste. It just sort of came and went, in an underwhelming thirteen minutes. None of the spots were that special, and Ambrose just did the job like he always does. 

Advertisement

What would have been a legacy moment for the show, would have been if Ambrose defeated Lesnar. He could have valiantly survived the Beast's onslaught, fighting back to victory in a David and Goliath moment. But it wasn't to be, and even the weapons spots were disappointing.

It wasn't like Lesnar versus Cena, or Lesnar versus Punk, and there's really no good reason to ever revisit this match with Ambrose.

4. No Breakthrough Star

Finn Balor and the Bullet Club invading WrestleMania 32? No. Instead fans had to make do with an attempt for Baron Corbin to be the breakthrough star of the night, when he proved victorious in the Andre battle royal.

Advertisement

Fair enough, Corbin has a good look and has improved in the ring, but he isn't going to springboard into a huge career off the back of Mania 32. In fact, the past two Andre winners, gained nothing from the spot.

The best Mania shows make legends, but Mania 32 failed to do that. Zack Ryder winning the IC title ladder match sums it up. Guys like Owens and Zayn were involved, but far from making their name, they arguably diminished their status in the shadow of Ryder's triumph.


3. Misfortune

It is important to point out that WrestleMania 32's failures were in part beyond WWE's control. When you look back at the success of Mania 30 and 31, you see that the company had a much richer talent base at their disposal.

Advertisement

But this year, the best wrestler in the world (Seth Rollins) was injured, and biggest wrestling star in the world (John Cena) was injured.

They were major losses. If Cena had been fit, it could have been a dream match against The Undertaker. As for Rollins, he'd have perhaps faced Triple H. Those would have been matches that got talked about in Mania folklore. But fate was cruel to WWE.

And then you have guys like Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton who weren't available. It was unfortunate that the biggest Mania crowd of all time had to endure one of the most depleted rosters of all time.

2. Fans Didn't Like It

While WWE can write the history books, it is fans who really dictate what is and isn't a great Mania. And the overwhelming verdict on WrestleMania 32 is a thumbs down. Be it in forums or on social media, the collective IWC has spoken, and Mania 32 has earned disappointment.

Advertisement

Smarks were always going to hate on Reigns as winner, but it is the show as a whole that seems to have upset them. 

From a more neutral perspective, you could sum it up as average to good, and definitely not great. 

But the IWC being the IWC, the reaction has been way more aggressive than that. Outright disgust has been expressed. But of course, WWE's attendance, live gate, and Network subscriptions mean fan opinion largely doesn't matter to McMahon. Still, in the eye of the fans, Mania 32 isn't going to be looked back upon fondly.

1. WrestleMania 33

Being sandwiched between the excellent Mania 31 and the potential of Mania 33 (Cena versus The Undertaker, Reigns versus Lesnar) is likely to be enough to condemn WrestleMania 32 to the list of forgotten WrestleMania shows.

Advertisement

Not just that, but Orlando in general should mean a much better time for WWE fans. Dallas is just a city, but Orlando is a proper vacation. The fun factor will be much higher, and as New Orleans proved, that can make a big difference in how an event is remembered.

But really, it is the Cena-Taker booking which will make Mania 33 stand out. It should have been the Mania 32 main event, and if it had been, then Dallas may have gone down in history. 

Instead, it will be WrestleMania 33 in Orlando playing host to the biggest match of the decade.

Advertisement