10 Reasons You Should Be Watching WWE Mixed Match Challenge

The social media experiment is delivering surprisingly fun weekly wrestling.

By Tom Beasley /

It was easy to be cynical when WWE first announced the Mixed Match Challenge. The prospect of a tournament entirely geared around social media interaction seemed like the recipe for a disaster, particularly given the matches would be mixed tag team bouts - a format the company never seems able to turn into good in-ring action.

Advertisement

However, the tournament has been something of a pleasant surprise. It's true that the social media nature of it is a little weird, especially when every episode begins with Michael Cole and Corey Graves telling an audience consisting mostly of grown adults how to use a smartphone. The content itself, though, has proven to be a delightful slice of fun that has managed to make itself must-watch, even given the deluge of WWE material every week.

There are concerns among the top brass at WWE, though, that the Mixed Match Challenge is failing to pull in viewers. Viewership has fallen dramatically since the show first aired on Facebook Watch, with the UK getting access via the WWE Network. This week's episode, featuring the first second round match, pulled in the lowest live audience to date.

Audiences simply aren't flocking to the Mixed Match Challenge and, given the quality of the programming, that's a real shame.

10. Tournaments Are Always Fun

WWE often struggles to create stakes in its television product. There are throwaway matches on TV every week that mean nothing for either of the superstars involved, whether they win or lose. One of the quickest ways to change that is with a tournament format. The jeopardy of a single elimination tournament means every bout is sudden death.

Advertisement

A tournament also works because it's easy to dip in and dip out without missing any ongoing storylines or crucial developments. A glance at the bracket is all it takes to be completely up to speed with the events, which is ideal for a show that is confined to a fairly little-used corner of social media.

The company has fallen in love with this format in recent years, whether it's with the semi-regular Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic on NXT or the highly successful WWE Network tournaments for women and cruiserweights of the last few summers. WWE has found a huge number of ways to use tournaments in order to seduce fans into spending more time with the Network. The inherent excitement of the elimination stipulation gives every match stakes and makes every bout worth watching.

9. Beth Phoenix

The roster of commentators WWE currently has available is a rather stale bunch. Michael Cole has been the hegemonic voice of the company for decades and, while there are entertaining voices on the team, it still feels very similar to what we have heard for a very long time. Over on Mixed Match Challenge, though, there's Beth Phoenix.

Advertisement

It's fair to say that the former four-time champion is not the most naturally gifted announcer in the world. She's often slightly clunky and many of her interjections add little to the conversation, but she is a refreshingly different voice to hear calling matches in WWE and a massive improvement over Lita's work alongside JR during the Mae Young Classic last year.

Given the prominence of women in the modern WWE landscape, it makes sense for the company to put a female voice behind the announce table. Renee Young is a popular choice, but has been vocal about the fact she doesn't rate her previous work at the desk. With Young out of the picture, WWE could do far worse than Phoenix, who is developing into a fun voice, with a different take on what is happening in the ring.

8. Charity

As much as Mixed Match Challenge is clearly an experiment for WWE in deciding whether social media formats are a viable medium for isolated storytelling, it's also another showcase for the company's philanthropic side. Every partnership on the show is fighting for charities, including UNICEF and Girl Up, with the winning couple netting a $100,000 donation for their chosen cause and every eliminated charity receiving $1,000 for competing.

Advertisement

There's no doubt that WWE invests heavily in philanthropic pursuits, whether it's their own efforts in building Connor's Cure or the annual support of Susan G. Komen during Breast Cancer Awareness Month. Fans enjoy the opportunity to cynically bring up Stephanie McMahon's tweet from 2015, calling philanthropy "the future of marketing". Whatever the motivation, though, anything that results in more money for good causes is undoubtedly positive.

It's for this reason that fans should support Mixed Match Challenge, sending a message to the company that incorporating charitable giving into the in-ring competition is the kind of idea that audiences want to see happen again.

7. Promo Time

Mic skills are a prerequisite for a top WWE star, but it's often only the main event players trusted with time on the stick. The likes of Roman Reigns and AJ Styles deliver lengthy slabs of verbiage every week, but that's not true of many of WWE's midcard players. Over in the world of Mixed Match Challenge, everybody gets to speak, and the result is highly entertaining.

Advertisement

Through the backstage selfie promos now so beloved of WWE to post-match interviews with Renee Young, the Mixed Match Challenge format opens up plenty of opportunities for the superstars involved to speak. In addition, these promos appear, at least on the surface, to be rather less scripted than the spoken segments on the main TV shows.

Lana and Rusev managed to get a whole new song over in their appearance at the end of episode four and episode two concluded with a great skit in which Alexa Bliss and Braun Strowman blushed their way through apparent romantic chemistry to the delight of the WWE Universe. Allowed to speak freely, the Mixed Match Challenge is letting its performers embrace and develop their characters to great effect.

6. Unique Combos

When WWE was first assembling the teams for the Mixed Match Challenge, one of the major selling points was the odd couple pairings that would fill the tournament field. These are performers who would never normally work together and will almost certainly not be paired again once the dust has settled on the tournament.

Advertisement

There's certainly an intrigue to seeing a babyface and a heel join forces with each other - more on that later - but it's also strange to see performers from disparate corners of the roster working in the same ring.

Alexa Bliss and Braun Strowman are nominally heels - or at least they were when the bracket was put together - but they would never exist in the same segments on Raw. In the Mixed Match Challenge, though, they are one of the most entertaining tandems, complete with their own double team finishing move.

The joy of the Mixed Match Challenge is in watching performers that have been seen on television for years, working slightly outside of their characters in ways that make for compelling in-ring excitement and fun social media product. It's incredibly silly, but that's what wrestling is all about.

5. Room To Breathe

It's possible for WWE to get through almost an hour of Raw without a single moment of in-ring action. The initial promo can take almost half an hour, with the subsequent barrage of backstage segments and advert breaks pushing it close to the hour mark before the bell rings on some action. That's not the case on the Mixed Match Challenge, where the short running time places the focus squarely between the ropes.

Advertisement

With between 10 and 15 minutes inside the ring on most shows, there's plenty of room for the matches to breathe and, therefore, for the performers to tell a story with their physicality or indulge in a few minutes of entertaining silliness. They're not hamstrung by commercial breaks or the need to cut backstage to see which inanimate object Braun Strowman is destroying with his fists this week.

This focus on the wrestling, whether serious or comedic, is something that makes Mixed Match Challenge refreshing and different in comparison to everything else that WWE puts out each week. It's a little, hermetically-sealed world where the only baggage in a match is which wrestlers happen to be better than the others on that given day.

4. Unusual Face-Heel Dynamics

The clear dividing line between babyfaces and heels is fuzzier than it has ever been, largely as a result of defiant fans refusing to cheer or boo as directed by WWE. However, the roster of the company is still split between the nominal good guys and the nominal bad guys, with every thrown together eight-man tag a reminder of how every babyface is supposed to be on the same side, against every heel.

Advertisement

In that environment, squeaky clean Bayley would never join forces with the arrogant Elias and the fiery fair play of Becky Lynch would run a mile from the nauseating irritant that Sami Zayn has become. That's not the case in Mixed Match Challenge, which eschews traditional boundaries and exists in its own little side-canon where any alliance is possible.

There's something thrilling about seeing these people battle together in the ring. Bayley's attempts to join in on Elias's latest hit song were compelling and the strange dynamic between Lynch and Zayn was a joy to watch. Meanwhile, Miz's attempts to bring out the arrogant side of partner Asuka point to the kind of character change that stuck in NXT and could do so again on the main roster. That sort of intrigue definitely merits watching.

3. Comedy

Comedy wrestling gets a bad rap and, as a result, it's not often seen in WWE outside of the New Day and their pancake-themed antics. The inherent strangeness of the Mixed Match Challenge format has proved to be a solid vessel for the sort of silliness that is tough to convey in the confines of Raw or SmackDown Live.

Advertisement

A prime example is the match between Naomi and Jimmy Uso and Goldust, teaming with Absolution member Mandy Rose. On paper, it's not exactly a thrilling contest, but the opening few minutes of comedy made it very entertaining, as Goldust and Mandy Rose tried to match the connection of their husband and wife opponents. Goldust has always had a flair for comedy, but he rarely has the opportunity to embrace or convey that during this later portion of his career.

Mixed Match Challenge provides the room for this sort of action to unfold given its complete separation from everything else that WWE releases. It's a world where starting a match with five minutes of comedy is an entertaining sideshow, rather than something that risks angering half the internet and could potentially torpedo a developing storyline.

2. Break From Continuity

With five hours of main roster content across Raw and SmackDown Live every week, plus an hour of 205 Live and an hour of NXT, as well as pay-per-views twice a month, there's an awful lot of continuity to keep up with in WWE. It's a lot for even the most hardcore of fans to withstand, let alone the casual fans the company would hope to woo into spending their money on a WWE Network subscription.

Advertisement

The Mixed Match Challenge is a breath of fresh air due to its existence as completely separate from the main storylines and characters of WWE. It's only tangentially related to what's happening on the main shows and it's exciting to know that anything can take place, without it needing to reverberate on to main programming. Viewers can simply relax and enjoy the wrestling for what it is on the surface, knowing that it's all going to be over when the final bell rings.

The limitations of the enormous WWE machine are that there's no room for the performers to experiment and enjoy themselves, as everything they do has to impact future plans and booking logic. The Mixed Match Challenge universe allows more freedom and more entertainment value.

1. Brevity

Mixed Match Challenge episodes are usually in the region of 20 minutes long. After five hours of Raw and SmackDown, plus everything else discussed in the last entry, there's something enormously appealing about a TV show that can run from start to finish in the time it takes to drink a cup of tea. Mixed Match Challenge is built to be a quick hit of simple fun, which is why it works so well.

Advertisement

This timeslot feels perfectly designed for the Mixed Match Challenge structure, which begins with brief pre-match backstage promos and entrances, features a 10-15 minute match and then adds a few minutes of reaction after the final bell rings. A longer running time would lead to the show overstaying its welcome and feeling bloated, particularly as it's intended to be watched on a smartphone or tablet via Facebook Watch.

In the modern media landscape of ten-hour binge watch marathons and endless boxsets, the brevity of a 20-minute wrestling broadcast is something that should be treasured and enjoyed for its sheer simplicity.

Advertisement