10 Recent Mistakes That WWE MUST Learn From

Three months of constant missteps.

By Andy H Murray /

2017 hasn't been a good year for WWE creative. It has brought great moments like the Kevin Owens/Chris Jericho split and Neville's rise as 'King Of The Cruiserweights,' but each of these highs are tempered by at least two or three lows, and the company's failings are many.

Advertisement

From the horrific Randy Orton vs. Bray Wyatt and Alexa Bliss vs. Bayley feuds to Jinder Mahal's sudden ascent and James Ellsworth stealing history at Money In The Bank, the past eight months have been rife with missteps. It'd be a stretch to call this a creative crisis, but this is one area in which they're falling woefully short of their goal of "super-serving" the audience.

The problems have been particularly pronounced over the past few months. SmackDown is slumping, Raw is as inconsistent as ever, and WWE's declining PPV quality reached a nadir at Battleground. These are all products of their own shoddy decision-making, and while WWE obviously can't please everybody at once, it's frustrating to see a company with so many great assets floundering.

The McMahons aren't known for their self-awareness, but WWE will be setting themselves up for a rocky end to the year if they don't learn from these mistakes.

10. Mike Kanellis' DOA Debut

Mike Kanellis' WWE run has been a perfect example of how not to book a debuting superstar.

Advertisement

The former TNA and ROH man arrived with wife Maria at Money In The Bank. It was a cold, confusing debut segment that played up the duo's affection for each other, and saw them promising to bring "the power of love" to SmackDown. Mike entered a brief feud with Sami Zayn over the coming weeks, and after a series of listless backstage segments, it ended with a tag match loss on 25 July.

Kanellis hasn't wrestled since. Him and Maria couldn't be colder at the moment, which is primarily down to the lame, dead on arrival gimmick they've been lumbered with. It's roughly the same shtick they were using on Impact, and with no character depth outside of "he really loves his wife," Mike has no hope of getting over.

The follow up has been equally poor, with Mike and Sami going 1-1 in singles bouts prior to the tag match. Now, he just isn't being used. WWE have buried him beneath 2017's most ineffectual debut, and they must take measures to ensure these errors aren't repeated with other new arrivals.

9. Hot-Shotting The Belts

WWE's habit of constantly hot-shotting their title belts is becoming chronic. We saw it with the Raw Women's Championship last year, but the tactic actually worked that time, and helped bring an air of unpredictability to the Sasha Banks vs. Charlotte feud. Now, the habit has spread far beyond that division, with the Cruiserweight and United States Championships the latest to fall victim.

Advertisement

Neville's win over Akira Tozawa at SummerSlam saw him retake the 205lb belt just six days after losing it. Kevin Owens and AJ Styles recently passed the US gold around thrice within an 18-day period, though their Battleground finish is thought to be a botch. Either way, WWE have rarely treated title changes with such disregard, and it's taking a toll.

Few things erode a belt's credibility like a meaningless switch, and that's what's happening here. Instead of booking their titles in ways that make sense from a narrative standpoint, WWE are having them change hands solely to create a talking point, which works the first couple of times you do it, but soon wears off. They must realise this if they have any aspirations of making these belts mean something again.

8. Booking Cena Vs. Nakamura Too Early

WWE's propensity for wasting potentially huge pay-per-view matches on weekly television is an unfortunate byproduct of their current episodic format. The company have five hours of main roster television to fill, and only so many ways to do it. This leaves them with little choice but to occasionally burn major bouts on Raw or SmackDown, but doesn't justify every single instance.

Advertisement

John Cena vs. Shinsuke Nakamura was a match fans had been waiting years to see. The version we received on the 1 August episode of SD was fine, but it could've been so much more had they been given 20-25 minutes of pay-per-view time instead. WWE are inevitably going to have to waste a few first-time contests on television every once in a while, but this one was too big to burn, and WWE's lack of patience shouldn't be excused.

If the company had booked the Cena vs. Nak number one contender's bout for SummerSlam instead, we wouldn't have had to sit through their turgid bouts with Baron Corbin and Jinder Mahal respectively. That alone would've made waiting worthwhile, but the company decided to pollute the year's second biggest PPV with nonsense instead.

7. The Lana Experiment

Letting Lana try her hand at a full-time wrestling career wasn't an inherently bad idea, but WWE pulled the trigger entirely too early. Instead of giving 'The Ravishing Russian' a few years to train, they inserted her into the SmackDown Women's Title picture after just a few months in the Performance Center, and the results weren't pretty.

Advertisement

Lana looked well off the pace in her match with Naomi at Money In The Bank, and even worse over the weeks that followed. The champ defeated her in under a minute two weeks later, then squashed her in less than 10 seconds on 4 July, and her latest defeat came to Charlotte a few weeks ago. Lana's credibility is shot to pieces, and the company have been forced to relegate her back to management duties through her alliance with Tamina.

This will almost certainly coincide with an upturn in fortunes, as Lana is one of the best managers in the business, but her sudden ascension effectively held the women's division up for a month. Unless WWE were out to deliberately bury Lana, the whole affair was a complete waste of time, and her value as an active wrestler may already be exhausted.

6. Reviving The Punjabi Prison

Bringing the Punjabi Prison match back might have made sense for Jinder Mahal's character, but it was a catastrophically bad idea from WWE. The stipulation had only been used twice prior to Battleground, but each was a shambles, with the gimmick's contrived rules (and ludicrous bamboo structure) totally stifling the performers. Combine this with the general tedium surrounding Jinder's feud with Randy Orton, and you have a blueprint for disaster.

Advertisement

The match stunk. It was Mahal at his basic, sloppy worst, and Orton at his most uninspired. They tried to throw some weak weapon spots and Singh Brothers shenanigans in to spice things up, but it didn't work, and while The Great Khali's interference got a surprisingly strong pop, it couldn't save the Punjabi Prison.

Worst of all, the stipulation's massive structure didn't just make it difficult for the live crowd to see what was going on, but rendered the affair completely unwatchable for most. Fans had every right to be angry after paying all that money only to stare at a wooden cage for 30 minutes, and the backlash was entirely deserved. Here's hoping WWE had their ears open, because the Prison should never be resurrected again.

5. Splitting Enzo & Cass

Big Cass was always going to turn on Enzo Amore. Vince McMahon loves tall guys, and given that Cass' main selling point is his height, a big singles run was inevitable. Unfortunately, it has not only left the big man without a valuable mouthpiece, but totally killed what used to be one of Raw's hottest babyface acts.

Advertisement

Enzo and Cass are massively flawed performers, but they complimented one another. Cass' general lack of charisma was covered by his livewire tag partner, and Enzo's in-ring shortcomings were at least partially hidden by his pal (though Cass himself is no Vader). Their union was very effective in hiding their respective shortcomings, but tearing them apart has exposed them to the world.

Cass' singles matches have stunk, his character is generic, and he has convinced nobody of his main event prowess. Meanwhile, Enzo's popularity is dwindling by the week, and he has no clear direction going forward, even after showing up on 205 Live.

The seven-footer's injury was a freak accident, but here's hoping WWE use it to reconsider his direction. He just isn't ready for this level of exposure, and his career will be dead in the water if he picks up where he left off.

4. The Mahal Vs. Nakamura Program

Shinsuke Nakamura vs. Jinder Mahal wasn't SummerSlam's worst match, but it wasn't far off either. 'The King Of Strong Style's workrate has dwindled on the main roster, while Jinder remains one of the most basic workers in the company, and somebody whose flaws must be hidden by endless Singh Brothers distractions. Their bout was always going to suck, and so it transpired.

Advertisement

Fans could have put up with the dull match had it produced the right outcome, but it didn't. Mahal successfully overcame Nakamura, needlessly killing his main roster undefeated streak, and dealing further damage to the former NXT Champion's rapidly dwindling star power.

If prolonging Mahal's title reign was the preferred outcome, then WWE shouldn't have booked the match in the first place. It was too early for Nakamura to lose his streak, and while there's still a chance he'll take the belt from 'The Modern Day Maharaja,' SummerSlam was a pointless hold-up. Now we're doomed to another pay-per-view cycle with Mahal as champion, and if Nak does triumph, the moment will feel a lot less exciting than it should have.

WWE have continually demonstrated their inability to preserve Nakamura's superstar aura over the past few months. Is it unreasonable to expect this to change? Perhaps, but it shouldn't be.

3. Devaluing AJ Styles

It'd be a stretch to say that AJ Styles carried SmackDown last year, but it's no coincidence that the brand's peak months in 2016 came when he was booked on top. Regardless of whether he was holding or chasing the WWE Championship, Styles was comfortably the most enjoyable wrestler in the company last year, and his run as SmackDown's ace was tremendous.

Advertisement

He's still putting on decent matches, and his name brings oodles of credibility to the United States Title, but 'The Phenomenal One' has found himself marginalised in recent months. His feud with Kevin Owens hasn't been about him or the belt, but setting up a future feud between KO and SmackDown Commissioner Shane McMahon, who was a special guest referee in the duo's SummerSlam bout.

Shane took centre stage that night. AJ won, but it was all about the McMahon/Owens tension, and it continued on SmackDown, when Shane once again stuck his nose in a US Title match. WWE put the spotlight on him, not Styles, and that's no way to use one of the best wrestlers in the world.

Fans want to see AJ in his own spotlight, not on the periphery of a boss vs. wrestler story. Here's hoping this is the end of his marginalisation.

2. Baron Corbin's Current Arc

Baron Corbin's Money In The Bank triumph was telegraphed months in advance. Most news outlets predicted he'd snatch the briefcase, then feud with WWE Champion Randy Orton over the summer, and while the latter half obviously didn't materialise, the former came to pass.

Advertisement

'The Lone Wolf's' apparent main event push started with the case, but ended last week. Corbin botched his MITB cash-in by letting himself get distracted by John Cena. Jinder Mahal rolled him up almost as soon as the bell had rang, and just like that, Baron's meal ticket was gone. He followed this up with a dismal loss to Cena at SummerSlam, and by all accounts, his push has now come to an end.

The burial certainly hasn't sparked an outrage, as Corbin would've likely been a lousy WWE Champion anyway, given his clear deficiencies in the ring and on the microphone. That doesn't change the fact that WWE essentially wasted two months of television by building this guy up, though. They presented Corbin as the next guy up, then tore him to pieces in the blink of an eye, and instead of using the MITB briefcase to benefit a more engaging wrestler like Sami Zayn, they've burned it completely.

1. The Jason Jordan Debacle

Jason Jordan's current run might be WWE creative's biggest mistake of the year thus far.

Advertisement

Many fans rejected his unveiling as Kurt Angle's son the night it happened. From there, the former American Alpha man has been given an entrance theme that sounds like a bad cover of Angle's, saddled with a painfully vanilla babyface personality, and presented as a chump.

Curt Hawkins is the only active roster member he has defeated thus far. At SummerSlam, Jordan was worryingly pinned by The Miz, and one night later, he was soundly defeated by Finn Bálor.

The losses suggest that WWE may already be losing faith in Jason, but the fans are way ahead of them. Jordan hasn't been cheered at all since joining Raw. His crowd reactions usually consist of complete indifference, but the past few weeks have seen an increasing amount of jeers creeping in, which certainly doesn't bode well for his future.

Turning Jason heel looks like WWE's only option, but that brings no guarantee of success either. Jordan's a fine wrestler, but it's abundantly clear that the company chose the wrong guy for this role, and instead of pushing him forward, the angle has sabotaged his career. Perhaps booking a goofy father/soon storyline in 2017 wasn't such a good idea after all.

Advertisement