Professional wrestling has forever predicated itself on the man-made mythology of its inhabitants. The men and women behind the costumes and the roles have had to live up to hyperbole and promotion, both of which raise expectations of the consumer. The very best have made good on the hype, matching every otherworldly promise that story could call upon. Wrestling is also a nostalgic endeavor for fans, something that entertains from the cradle to the grave. Today's fan has lived through several generations and eras of sports entertainment, and they've witnessed the exploits of countless icons that inspired them through their TV screens. Through that nostalgia, we as longtime fans do become wistful for the good old days of enjoying wrestling in our respective youths. The simpler days, we'll say. The serial nature of wrestling means that the action will always be there, and because of that, stars of the past are permitted to return after some type of prodigal exit. As fans yearn for those simpler days, those heroes are oftentimes welcome back. In some instances, the nostalgia is properly paid off (Hulk Hogan and Shawn Michaels in 2002, The Rock in 2012-13), and the stars live up to their lofty images. In other cases, as we're seeing with Shane McMahon's phantom punches today, it can be a daunting challenge living up to halcyon imagery.
Advertisement
10. "Superfly" Jimmy Snuka (1989)
Snuka was already 42 years old when he disappeared from WWE in July 1985, at which time he began a three-and-a-half year run of working for New Japan Pro Wrestling and Verne Gagne's AWA. By the time Snuka re-emerged in Titan around the time of WrestleMania 5, Snuka was 45, and much of the prior generation (Don Muraco, Sgt. Slaughter, The Iron Sheik, among many others) had already been drummed out. Snuka maintained some fleeting popularity from his days of diving off of steel cages and warring furiously with Rowdy Roddy Piper. However, he didn't quite fit into the increasingly-technicolor WWE, even with his rather vivid personality. The Snuka that thrilled at Madison Square Garden was treated as an afterthought throughout the cross-country TV taping circuit, and he primarily put over younger talent.
9. Bob Backlund (1992)
If Snuka was anachronistic after four years away, imagine what Backlund looked after over eight years out of the spotlight. Backlund didn't stick around long after dropping the gold to The Iron Sheik in late-1983, and only popped up here and there in the fading territorial embers throughout the remainder of the decade. It was probably just as well, since Backlund's white-meat, no-frills persona would've stuck out like a sore thumb next to WWE's Rock 'n Wrestling movement. He was even more conspicuous in 1992 alongside the likes of Nailz, The Mountie, and The Repo Man, since Backlund's image hadn't changed. Kids of the time didn't understand what was so special about such a basic wrestler, albeit a technically-gifted one. His 1994 heel turn was a brilliant reinvention, but until then, what a mismatch.
8. Jake "The Snake" Roberts (1996)
There was a palpable irony in a company that showed its pride in 1996 as "The New Generation" bringing back 40-year-old Jake Roberts more than three years after he was last seen in a major American promotion. At the same time WWE was making fun of Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage in mean-spirited skits, Roberts was unleashing a 17-foot snake to the consternation of fearful heels. Roberts had lost more than a step since the last time WWE fans had seen him, lacking the sinewy grace that had once balanced his persona in better days. As for why he was even brought back in the first place, check out the 1996 Royal Rumble match. He received a bigger reaction than everyone except for Shawn Michaels.
7. The Ultimate Warrior (1996)
Reinforcing the Roberts' example, star-power was limited in early-1996. While Roberts struggled to get through matches with Tatanka, main eventers Scott Hall and Kevin Nash had signed off on shiny-new WCW contracts. Desperate, Vince McMahon swallowed his pride and, with the help of wife Linda, brought Warrior back into the fold. It'd been over three years since his last WWE match, and he'd had only wrestled sporadically since. Embarrassingly-bad matches with Goldust and Jerry Lawler followed, and Warrior's simplistic style was clashing with the flavors of the time, like ECW's mayhem, WCW's cruiserweight movement, and a WWE with Michaels and Bret Hart on top. While Warrior was a far better performer than many gave him credit for, he had been out of practice by his short-lived WWE return.
6. The Legion Of Doom (1997)
Jim Cornette hits the nail on the head best in his 1997 WWE Timeline for Kayfabe Commentaries when he said, "The nostalgia couldn't keep up with what people's memories were," in regards to Animal and Hawk. It'd been over a decade since two Midwestern powerhouses applied intimidating face paint and fitted their shoulders with spiked pads, and took the wrestling world by storm, imitated many times over. In Cornette's words, "they were almost human," when trying to replicate the success of their earlier runs, and were each hovering around age 40 during the pre-Attitude kick at the can. Crowds still popped for the duo, but to diminishing returns over the next couple of years, after the act wore increasingly thin.
5. The British Bulldog (1999)
It felt just a bit icky when WWE proudly heralded the return of Davey Boy Smith less than three months after Owen Hart's death. While Smith was certainly free to work wherever he chose, he was only months removed from being laid up with a life-threatening spinal infection. His 1998 run in WCW was a far cry from his 1997 level of quality, and it was about to get much worse. Once an emboldened strongman with a million dollar smile, Smith looked incredibly rough as he stumbled his way through one-note brawls while wearing non-descript blue jeans. Before long, he was stuck with The Mean Street Posse for unclear reasons, and pretty much faded from television before his quiet exit in the spring of 2000.
4. Mr. Perfect (2002)
It seemed like Curt Hennig was plucked from low-level upstart X Wrestling Federation in late-2001 on a whim. What use would the post-Attitude WWE have for a 43-year-old that was rather far removed from his athletically-stellar heyday of the early 1990s? Mr. Perfect was slated for a guest appearance in the 2002 Royal Rumble, which went well enough. He got the big nostalgia pop, and the crowd went berserk when he dropped Kurt Angle with the Perfect-Plex. After that, it was all downhill. Perfect struggled to keep up with the likes of Edge and Rob Van Dam in TV matches, and the allure faded fast. His TNA run later in the year was worse, showing a steep decline from the days when he was one of McMahon's premier athletes.
3. Rowdy Roddy Piper (2003)
Piper was in a rather dark place by this point in his life, giving morose interviews on the state of professional wrestling, one of which he predicted he wouldn't live to the age of 65. He was also ranting and raving on NWA-TNA programming about Vince Russo having killed Owen Hart. When WWE shockingly brought him in at WrestleMania 19, it seemed like a way to get him to slow his roll. Then Piper wrestled. Fans derided him for his ghostly, flabby physique once his shirt was off, and matches against Rikishi and Mr. America (a masked Hulk Hogan) were atrocious. The depressing run ended in June 2003 once one of his downtrodden interviews aired on HBO's Real Sports, capping off one of the sadder three-month runs for any wrestling icon.
2. Bret Hart (2010)
When the WrestleMania 26 bout pitting Hart against Vince McMahon went into promotional overdrive, it was never mentioned that Hart had suffered a debilitating stroke in 2002 following a bicycle accident. That, on top of a career-ending concussion in 2000, left Hart in no condition to perform anywhere near his pantheon days as the "Excellence of Execution". Maybe it would've been alright if Hart simply crushed McMahon in no more than two minutes come WrestleMania, but I'm sure McMahon himself allotted budgeted 11 minutes of length (like Vince would work anything short) that exposed Hart as creaky and slow. It was more than understandable why, but the match was strangely promoted like it was the Bret of old facing off with Vince. This is hardly Hart's fault, and it was a rough use of a wrestler that fans have always seemed to believe in.
1. Shane McMahon (2016)
You can append the year with 2009 as well, since that was the first time Shane O'Mac broke out the ghastly air-punches, at that time against Randy Orton. While that calamity was quickly forgotten due to its conjunction with a secondary pay-per-view, his use of phantom strikes on recent editions of Raw have snuffed out the goodwill from his well-acclaimed return appearance on February 22. The Shane we all know and love is the crazy stuntman whose matches quickly become action-movie spectacles. Problem is, Shane's 46 now, and while he's no doubt preparing to endure some crazy leaps and crashes at WrestleMania in two weeks, the mystique and vigor are fading. The frequent botches in his promos don't help either.