Gimmick matches have been around almost as long as modern professional wrestling itself. When a feud reaches new heights or needs a spark to continue as a drawing card, a gimmick match is just what the doctor ordered. More often than not they are used to enhance a feud and add a little sizzle to the steak. But what about the gimmick matches that made fans shake their heads instead of reach for their wallets? Imagine what those booking meetings sounded like: "Listen guys, we're going to have you fight in a cage surrounded by dogs! The audience will be worried about your throats getting ripped out....it's gonna be great!". "OK ladies, instead of a bra and panties match, we're going to have a match where you strip each other LITERALLY naked! All of the guys will be going crazy...they're gonna love it!". "OK boys, this is the best idea I've ever had. This match cannot end until one of you guys shoves a firecracker up the other guy's rectum and blows it up! The audience will go crazy!". By the way, I wish I had made that last one up... From promising naked women to putting guys in electric chairs to, yes, blowing up another man's anus, there have been some pro wrestling gimmick matches which seem positively insane. So let's take a look at some of weirdest, wildest, strangest gimmick matches in wrestling history while we all wonder what the hell they were thinking and/or smoking...
Advertisement
10. King Of The Road Match
At the 1995 edition of WCW Uncensored, second generation wrestler Dustin Rhodes took on the Blacktop Bully (Barry Darsow) in the first-ever King of the Road match. Uncensored was WCW's attempt to cash-in on the ECW-inspired hardcore craze with WCW, in their infinite wisdom, deciding that meant fans wanted to see two guys fight in the back of a truck. The "match" consisted of Dustin and the Bully battling among hay bales while the truck drove slowly down the roads of Tupelo, Mississippi. The truck had several cameras mounted on in the back, as well as a helicopter following the action, like it was the OJ Simpson chase or something. The winner would be the first one to fight their way to the front of the truck and blow a horn to earn the victory. Yes kids, someone was actually paid to come up with this. nonsense. The match was clearly taped before the event, which was fine, but the editing appeared to be done by drunken monkeys. The background of the match switched from day to night and then back again while Dustin's shirt was ripped off but then reappeared later in the bout. The announcers even had to put over the match as "dangerous" whenever the truck made a turn. FOR GOODNESS SAKE, CAN SOMEBODY GET THESE GUYS A SEATBELT?!? As an aside, Dustin bladed during the match (because hay is really sharp, I guess?), earning himself a pink slip from WCW and sending him to the WWF, where he'd reinvent himself as Goldust.
9. Shark Cage Match
When I was a kid, I was an avid reader of the Apter mags that my Mom would buy for me at the grocery store. One of my favorite parts was the section that gave results of bouts from all around the country in the different territories. You'd see all the standard gimmick matches, sure, but one in particular caught my eye: The 'Shark Cage' match. To my 10-year0-old mind, that sounded like the coolest thing possible. Can you imagine two guys battling in a freaking shark cage while, I presumed, a man-eating shark circled them, threatening to devour the loser and turn him into chum? This sounded like something I had to hunt down and watch immediately. Imagine my disappointment when it turned out there was no danger of death, there was no shark and there wasn't even any water. There was just a stupid little cage (like the one you go shark diving in) in the middle of a ring. The most famous (or infamous) Shark Cage match took place between "Bulldog" Don Kent and Chief Jay Strongbow in Detroit. The winner would be the first one to escape the tiny cage. Because the cage was so small, there was really nothing the two workers could do in terms of high spots, or in fact anything resembling wrestling. It feature lots of punching and choking while the fans sat on their hands and dreamed about Great Whites. Shame on you, Bill Apter. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eOOxv-LkhMI
8. Good Housekeeping Match
Vince Russo is very well-known for his love of bizarre gimmick matches and the WWF in the late 1990s featured no shortage of them. Jeff Jarrett was the Intercontinental Champion in 1999 and was playing a misogynistic jerk who liked to beat up women like the Fabulous Moolah. Chyna, the WWF's preeminent hulking female diva, took up the mantle for womanhood and challenged Jarrett to a Good Housekeeping match at No Mercy 1999. It was advertised as a no-disqualification match but there was one catch: only household items were allowed to be used as weapons. This resulted in some of the goofiest spots in the history of wrestling, as both wrestlers were hit with eggs, salamis, and cake batter that was made during the match. Believe it or not, even the kitchen sink was used as a weapon during this battle of the sexes. To make the whole thing weirder, the finish saw Jarrett hit Chyna with the Intercontinental title belt and get the pin but the match was immediately restarted because a title belt isn't a household item. Chyna then nailed Jarrett with a guitar and got the pin to the win the IC strap. To summarize: a title belt is not a household item but balsa wood acoustic guitar apparently is.
7. Buck Naked Match
Attempting to capitalize on the popularity of ECW in the late 1990s, Rob Black established rival promotion XPW and attempted to go to the extreme even more often than ECW did. One of those attempts included employing porn stars as valets, promising fans that they would see their women in a completely X-rated fashion. One of those porn stars was Rob Black's own wife, Lizzy Borden. In 2002, Borden faced off against fellow adult film starlet Veronica Caine in a so-called Buck Naked match. Similar to a bra and panties match (all the rage in the early 2000s), this bout could only be won when one of the women stripped the other completely naked. Listen, I'm a fan of attractive women fighting in skimpy clothing but come on, let's be practical here. You cannot promote a girl getting naked during a wrestling show. If you want to see women naked, go to a damn strip club. The joke was on the horny Los Angeles fans, however, as the house lights were turned completely off just before any full-frontal nudity was glimpsed, completely trolling the audience and robbing them of the one aspect of the match that they cared about. Thankfully, Rob Black and his Buck Naked matches have since gone out of business.
6. Reverse Battle Royal
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A0uSg2i-bqo&scrlybrkr=0e404026 Battle royals have been a pro-wrestling institution for an age. The formula is well established and works. So leave it to Total Nonstop Action wrestling to take a totally fine match concept and make it completely stupid and needlessly complicated. Instead of a traditional battle royal where wrestlers attempt to throw each over over the top rope and to the floor, the Reverse Battle Royal is exactly what it sounds like: wrestlers start on the floor and attempt to fight their way inside the ring. This results in a bunch of guys bunched together on the small area around the ring with no discernible way to tell what's going on or who is winning the match. In 2007, TNA took this a step further by adding more wrinkles to this already pointless endeaavor. Once 10 men had fought their way inside the ring, the match switched over to being a traditional battle royal with the wrestlers being ranked 1-10 based on their elimination order. Once the match was down to two guys, it turned into a regular one-on-one match. Listen, this stuff isn't Shakespeare - throw a guy over the top, win the match. Why all the unnecessary rules? Did TNA actually think they were being "innovative" with this stuff? They might as well have a ladder match but call it a 'Reverse Ladder Match' and force two guys to try and fight their way down a ladder. Classic TNA.
5. Steel Asylum Match
While we are on the subject of 'classic' TNA, let's take a look at one of the worst-executed steel cage matches in wrestling history, courtesy of Dixie Carter and her tremendous creative team. Just looking at that large, red monstrosity should tell you all you need to know about the match. First of all, it was extraordinarily difficult to see what was going on in the ring because the thick red bars of the cage obstructed the view of the ring. Secondly, the object of the match is to climb out of the cage but the only opening is at the very top of the roof, requiring the wrestler to have the monkey-like ability to scale the thing, all the while constantly worrying about falling and breaking their necks. When TNA attempted to restart the Monday Night War on January 4, 2010, they featured the Steel Asylum. Not only could you not see any of the action in the ring but Homicide, the booked winner of the match, became stuck as he attempted to exit the roof of the structure. The announcers attempted to cover for Homicide the best they could but it became very clear that he wasn't playing around and was legitimately fearful of falling directly on his head. With the move to Pop TV, at least we can rest easy knowing that only a few dozen people will see this match, should TNA ever bring it out of the mothballs.
4. Punjabi Prison Match
In 2006, WWE decided to release its most horrible creation on their legions of fans around the world: The push of the Great Khali. Despite being one of the absolute worst wrestlers in the history of wrestling, WWE pushed the giant native of India all the the way to the World Heavyweight title. To make matters even worse, they gave him his very own and very stupid gimmick match. At the 2006 Great American Bash event, Khali was slated to face the Undertaker in the first Punjabi Prison match. The structure consisted of two bamboo cages which wrestlers had to escape much like a standard cage match. However, there were time limits as to how long the doors to the cages could be open and, if those time limits expired, the wrestlers would be forced to climb over the walls of the cage, which had been fashioned into sharp spikes. The match lost its point once the event arrived, as Khali was medically unable to perform at the event so the Big Show took his place. That's right, the first-ever Punjabi Prison match was the Undertaker vs. the Big Show. When Khali was finally able to compete in "his match" at No Mercy 2007, he was slow, plodding, boring, and, basically, the Great Khali. Batista did his best to pull a good match out of the immobile behemoth but he was fighting a lost cause. The match wasn't salvageable. Being sent to an actual Punjabi prison might just be more enjoyable than watching Khali wrestle.
3. Kennel From Hell Match
One of the most infamous matches of the Attitude Era, the Kennel from Hell match between the Big Bossman and Al Snow remains one of the oddest matches ever put on by a major wrestling promotion. The match was set up by Big Bossman tricking Al into eating his own pet dog (no, seriously), leading to a showdown at Unforgiven 1999. To get his revenge on the super-villain Bossman, Snow proposed a Kennel from Hell match. So what is a Kennel From Hell match? Well, the match consisted of the classic blue bar cage surrounded by the Hell in a Cell structure. On the arena floor between the two, Snow promised there would be a pack of angry Rottweilers who were poised to rip the Bossman to shreds if he dared to exit the cage. Which works, at least in theory, but the dogs spent the entire match peeing on the floor and humping each other. The Rottweilers seemed terrified of the wrestlers and the trainers had to drag the poor dogs around to give the illusion that they actually wanted to attack Snow and the Bossman. The match quickly turned into a nightmare of epic proportions and the Kennel from Hell was never mentioned ever again. As a side note, track down this match with Mick Foley and Kevin Kelly on commentary (it was an extra on Foley's Hardy Knocks and Cheap Pops DVD releases). They call the match like as if it were the main event of WrestleMania and it's absolutely hilarious.
2. Chamber Of Horrors Match
The early 1990s were dark times in World Championship Wrestling and nothing illustrated that point better than the Chamber of Horrors match at Halloween Havoc 1991. Capitalizing on the Halloween theme of the show, WCW booked a match that included such legends as Vader, the Steiner Brothers, Mick Foley, Sting, and Scott Hall. With names that like, you would figure that a great match was automatic, however WCW decided to put them in one of the weirdest gimmick matches in history. The Chamber of Horrors consisted of a large Thunderdome cage that covered the whole ring and the only way to win the match was to (and this is serious) strap your opponent into an electric chair and throw the switch. Yes, this was a thing that happened. They expected us to pay for it and not laugh at it and everything. The wrestlers brawled aimlessly until the electric chair was lowered into the ring while the match was in progress, causing everyone to stop and stare at the chair in awe. More weak brawling followed until Abdullah the Butcher had the honor of being strapped into the death chair. He was then "electrocuted" while cheap-looking fireworks shot out of the sides of the chair and Abby shook like a guy on a vibrating bed in a rundown motel. It was completely insane. Oh WCW, how I miss you.
1. Anus Explosion Death Match
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ShgRtPNfAQA&scrlybrkr=0e404026 I honestly wish I were making this one up. In October 1998, the nutty Frontier Martial-Arts Wrestling promotion in Japan staged an Anus Explosion Deathmatch between Hayabusa (known simply as "H" at the time, since he was unmasked) and Mr. Gannosuke, who was calling himself Hayabusa and dressing like his foe in order to mock him. The object of the match was to incapacitate your opponent long enough to shove a firecracker up his backside and light it. You have to give FMW credit. I mean, at least it was unique. The match itself was standard deathmatch stuff with light tubes, barb wire, glass and all the other garbage wrestling staples that old-school fans hate. After much brutality, Gonnosuke tied H's arms around the turnbuckle and shoved the firecracker up his rectum like he was Wile E. Coyote. While the firecracker certainly didn't "explode" H's anus, it certainly did set off some sparks, so the gimmick was most definitely paid off. The firecracker bit was apparently a reference to a stunt that the older Japanese wrestlers used to force the trainees (or young boys) to do as a hazing ritual, so that's something. Still, the idea of wrestling fans paying money to watch a guy's posterior explode is not something that I'm sure I'm entirely comfortable with.