10 Strangest WWE Pushes

Just what did WWE see in these guys to catapult them to the top?

By Jamie Kennedy /

Vince McMahon, the man who has final say on what happens in WWE, has long been fascinated by larger-than-life men. An odd sentence, for sure, but in terms of Vince's vision for what professional wrestling (or "sports entertainment") should be, bigger is often better. Of course, there have been times throughout WWE history when exceptions have been thrust into the forefront of the product. Men such as Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Chris Benoit and even Daniel Bryan are classic example of workrate winning the day, but on the whole, McMahon has been noted as preferring his performers to be monstrous. The ins and outs of what dictates any given wrestler is deemed ready for a push in WWE are sometime sketchy, which is why many have been pushed relentlessly, despite not immediately having the qualifications expected of a headliner - whether that be in the eyes of Vince, or those of the fans. Detailed here are 10 different pushes, all happening for a variety of reasons, but none of them successful in the long term. Not all of these men were pushed as top liners, working in main events, but they were heavily featured on WWF/WWE programming, before going against the grain or not possessing what it takes to be a sustained main event player in the promotion.

10. Carlito

Bursting onto the scene in late-2004, Carlito instantly made an impression as a mid-card heel by spitting chunks of apple in the faces of his opponents, apparently for not being cool enough. It was a basic character, but something to work with, and put a lot of emphasis on the verbal skills of the man - Carly Colon - behind the gimmick. Fans were responding to Carlito, and he'd capture a lot of gold in WWE. Not only did the guy hold the WWE Tag-Team Titles, but he was also given a run with the Intercontinental and United States Championships too. Around 2005, it seemed like the company might take a chance on their latest sensation, and shunt him further up the card, but Colon didn't really see eye-to-eye with management a lot of time, and never got that sustained momentum which would have helped his cause. Leaving WWE in 2010, Carlito is almost regarded by fans as one who got away. It was clear the man had all the talent in the world, but the promotion weren't really sure what to do with him, and clearly didn't really like his refusal to attend rehab after violating the WWE Wellness Policy. It's strange that a wrestler as accomplished as Carlito didn't make a bigger splash.

9. Kenzo Suzuki

The pro wrestling world rejoiced when news hit that Kenta Kobayashi had signed with WWE in 2014. Even being renamed Hideo Itami by the company couldn't derail the excitement surrounding the guy, and fans remain convinced he's capable of doing huge things for WWE, should the creative team let him. A similar level of buzz didn't really follow Kenzo Suzuki, another Japanese grappler who joined WWE in 2004. Originally, Suzuki was earmarked to play Hirohito, an anti-American dictator, but those plans were scrapped in favour of the more straightforward persona he would debut as on Smackdown. WWE's brand extension was in full swing, so the group needed all the star power they could muster on Smackdown. Fans found it difficult to connect to the less-than-charismatic Oriental star however, and even though he was given a run as a WWE Tag-Team Champion alongside Renee Dupree, Suzuki would never fulfill what WWE hoped their new international employee would. Who knows if a run as Hirohito would have changed anything, but Suzuki wasn't a great fit for WWE, and stood out like a sore thumb.

8. Chris Masters

Looking like an amalgamation between Rick Rude, Hercules Hernandez and Lex Luger, Chris Masters had all the physical gifts necessary to get by in World Wrestling Entertainment. Unfortunately, just like Luger before him, the man's narcissistic schtick wouldn't really get over with the fans, who were largely indifferent to Masters. Even matches against the likes of Ric Flair and Shawn Michaels, being given the rub by both, couldn't really help his plight. Masters was WWE's own pet project for two years, from his debut in 2005 right up until his first departure in 2007. The 'Masterlock Challenge' struggled to fill airtime with any purpose, and audiences didn't really see the man as anything special. Bizarrely, Masters returned to WWE in 2009, and was routinely having some of the best matches of the week (albeit on shows such as Superstars) before the company canned him once more in 2011. Remarking in an interview that he didn't see the latest release coming, Masters noted that Triple H had told him he'd be getting a decent run on either Raw or Smackdown just days before he was let go.

7. Mark Henry

Signing a bumper contract in 1996, Mark Henry committed himself to WWF/WWE for the next decade. Having competed in weightlifting at the '96 Olympic Games in Atlanta, Henry was considered perfect for wrestling, debuting as an All-American babyface who was out to win the favour of the fans. Such a character was seriously dated by the mid-90's, which meant a change was needed. Going down with injury, Henry would join the heel faction, Nation Of Domination, shortly after his return. There was an overwhelming feeling that WWE would neglect to renew the terms of Henry's contract once 2006 rolled around, but the big man signed on once more, and was thrust into the mix for the World Heavyweight Championship. It wouldn't be until 2011, when the man was pushing 40, that the promotion would pull the trigger on a World Title run, defeating Randy Orton to bag the belt. Looking at TV figures during his reign as champ, Henry wasn't the most popular of choices, even if his 'Hall Of Pain' heel character did provide some intense physical confrontations. Perceived by many as a wrestler who has never really drawn much money, there was some head-scratching when WWE decided he should be World Champion.

6. Jack Swagger

The stop/start booking mentality prevalent in WWE has been written about at length, and few men know more about it than Jack Swagger! Looking like a blue-chip prospect, Swagger was personally recommended by WWE Hall Of Fame announcer Jim Ross, who felt the 6ft 7inch wrestler had all the attributes to be a main eventer in the company. A legitimate athletic background seemed to go in Swagger's favour - this is still something WWE scouts look for today in newcomers. In early-2009, he won the ECW Title, only losing out at Backlash to a returning Christian, before being moved upwards in the WWE food chain to Raw. In 2010, Swagger won the Money In The Bank Ladder Match at Wrestlemania XXVI, cashing in on the next episode of Smackdown to win the World Heavyweight Title from Chris Jericho. It seemed like a really sudden ascent for Swagger, who didn't look nearly ready enough to hold the top title on the blue brand. Perhaps WWE handled the guy unfairly, only giving him a nondescript three month run with the title, and he has been treading water pretty much ever since.

5. Mabel

If wrestling fans believe WWE are short of talent nowadays, they should use the magic of the WWE Network to travel back to 1995. It was a long, difficult year for the then-WWF, who didn't really appear to have much of a clue what their core audience wanted to see, resulting in many cartoon-like characters who failed to register much interest. One of those cartoon stars was the giant Mabel, who performed alongside Mo as the heel tag-team, Men On A Mission. Entered into the 1995 King Of The Ring, not many felt the company would push the man to the moon, but that's exactly what happened. A WWF Title match against reigning champion Diesel followed, but fans weren't buying it. Throwing his significant weight around, Mabel managed to legit injure The Undertaker, squashing his face during a match, and would dwindle down the card, eventually being released shortly after the 1996 Royal Rumble. Putting the King Of The Ring crown on him was baffling, and did nothing for the King gimmick itself.

4. Giant Gonzalez

There was a period of The Undertaker's career where he seemingly did little else other than battle monstrous characters Vince McMahon would dream up. It was almost like McMahon had taken the place of Rita Repulsa from Power Rangers, concocting all sorts of villains for the hero to wage war against and vanquish back into the otherworld. Making a name for himself as El Gigante in WCW, Jorge Gonzalez was his generation's equivalent of The Great Khali - a slow-moving mountain of a man who could do little other than lumber around the ring awkwardly. Making his way to WWE in 1993, the redubbed Giant Gonzalez would attack 'Taker at the Royal Rumble, and did actually have fans in the ARCO Arena stunned, mainly due to the man's sheer size. It wasn't long before the novelty had worn off though, and audiences cared little for seeing Gonzalez stumble around the place during matches against an Undertaker who deserved much better. Much unlike Khali, at least McMahon didn't feel the need to put the World Title on Gonzalez. Departing in October, 1993, the giant made little impression on the company, and many fans wished he hadn't been there at all. Harsh, maybe, but wholly accurate at the same time.

3. Vladimir Kozlov

Newcomers to WWE should rejoice at the character of Rusev, played admirably by a man who gets how to piece together an exciting match. In 2008, wrestling fans were subjected to Vladimir Kozlov, who surely must stand as one of the most bewildering choices as a main eventer in recent memory. It's stunning to think, but Kozlov was actually handed a clean win over The Undertaker on an episode of Smackdown, mainly in a last-ditch attempt to get fans to care about the character. Unfortunately, not even a win over one of WWE's most-beloved stars could catapult Vladimir into the stratosphere - WWE were handing Kozlov everything they could, but he just wasn't cut out to be a top star. Confusing fans even more, Kozlov co-headlined Survivor Series 2008, taking part in a billed Triple Threat Match also featuring Triple H and Jeff Hardy. It was announced during the Pay-Per-View that Hardy had been found unconscious, a storyline which would later be revealed as a plot by Edge to win the World Heavyweight Title. Therefore, fans had to sit through a singles match between Triple H and Kozlov, which didn't really capture the imagination.

2. Hardcore Holly

A lifelong mid-carder, Bob Holly was renamed 'Hardcore' Holly in the late-90's, mainly so he'd slot nicely into the promotion's Hardcore Title division, something he did with great aplomb. Indeed, Holly had fun matches with everyone from Steve Blackman to Al Snow, and they were entirely fine for what they were. Going further, when in there with a great talent like Kurt Angle or Chris Jericho, Holly was capable of holding up his end of the bargain, providing much entertainment. Along the way, during a routine match on Smackdown in 2002, Holly suffered a broken neck at the hands of Brock Lesnar, who was clumsy with him during a powerbomb spot. Out for over a year, Hardcore returned in 2003, looking to gain revenge on Lesnar for what he had done to him. This resulted in a rather odd-feeling main event push for Holly, who challenged for the WWE Title at the Royal Rumble in 2004, losing in quick order to a man clearly higher up the pecking order than he. Fans did admittedly pop when Holly beat down Lesnar at Survivor Series, but there wasn't much mileage in a true main event run, and considering there were rising talents like Eddie Guerrero waiting in the wings, nobody believed Holly could feasibly win the belt.

1. Heidenreich

Appearing for the second time on this list being bogged down by an incapable opponent, The Undertaker just couldn't catch a break many times throughout his tenure. Thankfully, WWE had since rectified a lot of their mistakes, putting the man opposite great performers such as Shawn Michaels, Triple H and Edge over the years, instead of bum notes like Jon Heidenreich. Sometimes, a wrestler comes along who just doesn't really look like he grasps what the industry is all about - their matches are dull and awkward-looking, and they don't seem to show much aptitude for any aspect of the business. Heidenreich perhaps sums that up better than most, but that can't change the fact WWE had high hopes that he'd be a top heel. The company tried everything with the guy, even going so far as to make him a new member of the Legion Of Doom, which went down about as well as you'd imagine. Facing 'Taker in high profile bouts at the likes of the 2004 Survivor Series, as well as the subsequent month at Armageddon and then Royal Rumble (in a Casket Match), Heidenreich was given every opportunity to get over with fans, but he just couldn't really do it. What other strange pushes do you remember in WWE? Whether the fault of the wrestler or the company, are there any others which can match the ones on this list? Let us know in the comments section down below!