10 Superstar Returns That Could Save WWE Payback

By Marc Jobling /

With WWE€™s next pay-per-view (or €˜special event€™) happening on June 1st, the creative team find themselves in a delicate situation. The neck injury sustained by Daniel Bryan leaves them without a WWE World Heavyweight Champion and reduces the show€™s star power even more. Coming from Chicago for the second consecutive year, Payback only has rematches of Evolution vs The Shield and John Cena vs Bray Wyatt, along with an Intercontinental Championship match between Bad News Barrett and Rob Van Dam. Whilst the two main events will be interesting and should deliver in quality, these rematches won€™t convince non-Network subscribers to fork out $45. And with the WWE€™s stock plummeting recently, the corporate staff in Connecticut certainly doesn€™t want to miss out on money! In a rare move, a promo has been announced for Payback, where Bryan has to either surrender his title or his wife Brie gets fired. The lack of attention given to the secondary titles has backfired on WWE, as a well-built title defence for Sheamus or Bad News Barrett could have had some intrigue. Simply put, Payback needs a high profile return, someone to boost buy rates and get people talking afterwards. It€™s time to assess ten candidates who might generate that buzz.

10. The Miz

Ok, before you laugh, hear me out. The Miz has been away filming highly anticipated €˜The Marine 4€™ and, before then, had been steeply descending ever since winning in the main event of Wrestlemania XXVII. Recent years have seen the likes of Jack Swagger, The Great Khali, Christian, Dolph Ziggler and Rey Mysterio hold a world title, hence cheapening their worth, but Miz seems to be the poster boy for quickly being pushed down the card. But should he have been de-pushed? He can speak, has regular media appearances, has charisma and is passable in the ring. For all those that dislike The Miz, he has overcome the hostility encountered upon first arriving in WWE from reality TV. In 2013, he was €˜approved€™ by Ric Flair and started using the Figure Four Leglock as a finisher but that new credibility didn€™t get him anywhere. But maybe he€™s been away from TV just long enough to make fans forget the way his character has nosedived. A return at Payback, accompanied by a fresh heel gimmick, could give the momentum needed for The Miz to eventually return to the main event.

9. Christian

It€™s sad to see Christian€™s career stutter towards a halt, due to frequent injuries. His first reign as World Heavyweight Champion was mostly due to his best friend Edge€™s sudden retirement and fan€™s emotionally attaching their support onto Christian. But his lengthy career deserved a title reign at some point and he got another during his long feud with Randy Orton. Since then, his TV appearances have been sporadic thanks to persistent shoulder damage, but he still received mini pushes. 2013 saw him participate in The Shield€™s second ever WWE defeat and receive a World Heavyweight title shot against Alberto Del Rio at Summerslam. Even this year, he took part in the Elimination Chamber for the unified world title and pinned Sheamus, despite eventually coming up short. Before Wrestlemania, Christian turned heel and became number one contender to Big E€™s Intercontinental title, until a concussion took him off-screen again. A return at Payback could see him demand a match with the Barrett-RVD winner and reinforce his heel turn, something which is bound to entertain the WWE Universe.

8. Rey Mysterio

Another veteran dogged by injuries, Mysterio continues to sell loads of merchandise at WWE Live events. Therefore, the WWE would like to keep him away from retirement as long as they can, especially after the company€™s shocking shock tumble last week. Last month€™s eight month absence through a knee injury was followed by unspectacular cameos upon his return, coming in at #30 in the Royal Rumble and taking part in Wrestlemania XXX€™s Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal. He€™s done nothing since then and there€™s been speculation that his in-ring days are coming to an end. Whether Mysterio returns as a competitor or in an ambassadorial role, he still receives a child-dominated pop from crowds and would boost Payback. Perhaps he could be used to put over Cesaro, Rusev, Barrett and Bray Wyatt. Or he could face Alberto Del Rio for the millionth time!

7. Hulk Hogan

Returns at Payback don€™t have to be in-ring. Hulk Hogan could be used to make an announcement, be the host or put over some of the younger roster members. Even now, despite his stint in TNA, the 60-year-old gets eyes on the product and still has name value. Whilst the WWE have toured Europe lately, Hogan has been doing the media rounds €“ visiting newspapers and even ITV€™s €˜Loose Women€™! His 2014 return has been to mostly promote the WWE Network and the ability to now watch vintage matches, many including Hogan. But, ideally, he could be used to interact with the new generation coming through. Maybe he can shake Daniel Bryan€™s hand, talk about The Shield or arm-wrestle Cesaro. No matter what Hogan could do at Payback, it€™d be water cooler material for the Monday.

6. AJ Lee

Very much one of the roster€™s younger members, AJ has been on a break since the night after Wrestlemania. There, her 295-day Diva€™s title reign ended at the hands of newcomer Paige. Prior to that, she had beaten practically every other diva again and again, showing her clear superiority and domination. Maybe that€™s why the WWE granted her some time off €“ the Diva€™s division was even staler than normal and it enabled AJ to recharge her batteries. It€™s since emerged that she is to marry CM Punk very soon, despite only being together a matter of months. Considering Punk walked out on the WWE and seems to be persona non-grata, some of that heat may have attached itself to AJ. They mightn€™t be in any hurry to end her break. However, for the sake of the Diva€™s division, AJ needs to return at Payback and feud with Paige over the summer. Lee is arguably the only Diva with anywhere near an on-screen personality.

5. Ric Flair

After retiring from in-ring matches at Wrestlemania XXIV, Flair has spent time with anyone who€™d have him €“ TNA, Ring of Honor and Hogan€™s €˜Hulkamania€™ tour of Australia. He finally returned to the WWE in 2012 to be inducted into the Hall of Fame as part of the Four Horsemen. Occasional appearances came to a halt last August when, at Summerslam Axxess, he was accused of being intoxicated and going off-script in a public chat with Jim Ross. Yet Flair returned to the WWE again at this year€™s €˜Old School RAW€™ and recently endorsed The Shield, turning his back on Evolution. With those teams main eventing Payback in a No Holds Barred six-man elimination tag match, it makes storyline sense for Flair to make an appearance, whether that be backing The Shield or showing he remained Evolution all along. With the feud set to continue for at least another month, Flair can then stick around to remind folks why he€™s €˜The Dirtiest Player in the Game€™.

4. Chris Jericho

Known recently for his long breaks to take care of other commitments, Jericho doesn€™t hide the fact that he€™s open to returning once again for another stint. With 2007 and 2012 returns, it€™s only a matter of time until Y2J comes back to save the WWE Universe. He sings, he acts, he€™s a presenter €“ Jericho is a multi-talented man but still finds time for WWE. He put over Fandango at Wrestlemania 29, Dolph Ziggler in his first weeks as World Heavyweight Champion and actively enjoys making newer superstars even better. As suggested with Rey, you can put Jericho with Cesaro, Barrett or Rusev. Maybe he can be put higher up the card, feuding with Bray Wyatt or turning heel to face Daniel Bryan. Either way, Payback needs saving and maybe Jericho is the man to do so.

3. Daniel Bryan

Despite doubts that WWE would treat Bryan as a serious main eventer (based on countless other wasted opportunities to others), it seems like the bosses finally see what they have in Bryan. An underdog, an excellent wrestler, someone who is incredibly over with all age groups and a man who makes them lots of money in merchandise. The €˜Yes!€™ chant is fully integrated into the mainstream and is the new €˜What?€™ amongst the WWE Universe. He even married a Diva! 2013 and 2014 are all about Daniel Bryan, as he attempts to put himself amongst the upper echelon of all-time superstars. Typically, his WWE World Heavyweight Championship reign has hit an awful amount of bad luck. His father died soon after WrestleMania and now he has had neck surgery, expected to keep him out for two months. Normally, he would€™ve been stripped of his title by now but, in a pleasant surprise, WWE have decided to keep the belt on him until it€™s absolutely obvious that it must change. The lack of title match, especially now they€™re unified, seriously hampers the Payback card but hopefully it€™s just for one PPV. Also, to be honest, a fit Bryan would€™ve fought Kane again €“ another rematch and one that wouldn€™t exactly set hearts racing. That€™s why Bryan isn€™t higher on this list. But make no mistake, the WWE desperately needs Bryan back wrestling soon.

2. Brock Lesnar

The one in 21-1 caused one of the biggest legitimate shocks in wrestling history by ending The Undertaker€™s undefeated streak at WrestleMania XXX. Even now, it seems crazy. I€™ll never forget the reaction in the bar I watched Mania at €“ scenes of disbelief, shock and confusion. Surely the referee messed up the count? I stood pinching myself for a while minute, convinced that this couldn€™t ever possibly be real. Those feelings will go with me to the grave. And, in his following absence, manager Paul Heyman goes out of his way to find creative ways of bringing up the victory. It€™s truly marvellous to watch. If the WWE entrusted Lesnar with such a burden, you better believe that he€™s getting pushed to the moon. Expect an eventual WWE World Heavyweight Championship reign, as well as a path of carnage. So when do we see Brock next? It€™s almost certain that he€™ll feature in a Summerslam main event, so maybe Payback is where the seeds are sown. Who€™s his next target? There€™s a lot of mystery and there€™ll be much excitement when Lesnar returns and he€™d almost certainly be the headline coming out of Payback. Only one man would get more people talking....

1. CM Punk

In a shock to almost nobody, CM Punk tops the list as the one man who would undoubtedly save Payback. However, he€™s virtually guaranteed to not be there. There€™s even doubts as to whether he€™ll ever return, as photos show him well-slept and with a more relaxed figure, seemingly content in his retirement. The fact that he€™s from Chicago gets dreamers to convince themselves he€™s returning in his hometown arena €“ it would blow the roof off €“ but the chance for a better Chicago return was the March 3rd edition of RAW. A month before WrestleMania 30, CM Punk returning would€™ve been huge. He could feud with Bryan for the title, he could get involved with Evolution vs The Shield, he could do almost anything. At least his social media silence is now over. Punk left in January and barely made a noise on Twitter until recently. He announced at a Chicago Cubs game that he€™s marrying AJ Lee next month, so he€™s pre-occupied with living a happy life, off the road. For the first month, WWE were remaining nice to Punk in the hope that he€™d return but, since then, they€™ve chose to ignore his existence. They even put a post-it note over his face in the background whilst filming an Ultimate Warrior documentary. So, unfortunately, don€™t expect any pipebombs from the €˜Best in the World€™ anytime soon. And it€™s such a shame, because returning at Payback would be the biggest boost possible to the WWE right now.