10 Terrible Booking Decisions From WWE Survivor Series 2016

A fun show with some horrible decision-making behind it.

By Brad Hamilton /

If the job of a wrestling company is to create memorable moments that leave your jaw on the floor, then WWE did just that with the 2016 edition of Survivor Series. What was once considered one of the promotion’s “Big Four” has fallen to the wayside in years past, eclipsed in importance by shows such as TLC and Money in the Bank. Not so this time round.

Advertisement

This year’s show featured the gimmick of having the two competing rosters of Raw and SmackDown facing off against each other for brand supremacy. Three elimination matches between the best each show had to offer would decide who came out on top in the first year of the brand split.

Raw won the night 2-1, with both the tag team and women’s matches going their way while the men’s singles bout saw the SD competitors come out on top. But the real main event of the night was Brock Lesnar vs. Goldberg in a rematch from WrestleMania XX.

While last year’s Survivor Series was one of the worst WWE shows in recent memory, this one was better on many levels but ended with one of the most bizarre booking decisions the company has EVER made. In fact, the entire night was littered with many such questionable choices. Let’s dive into those right now.

10. Goldberg Squashing Brock Lesnar

We’ve got to get this one out of the way because it is the biggest WTF moment in wrestling since… actually there may not be a bigger one. In the lead up to the match fans had braced for the inevitable bout that was to come. Goldberg hadn’t wrestled in nearly two decades, Brock isn’t exactly a performer capable of carrying someone, and their styles are far too similar to create a visual contrast.

Advertisement

We expected WWE to work some magic and try to get around the obvious limitations, but no one single observer on the planet believed WWE would have Goldberg squash The Beast in a minute flat without allowing him to get any offence in.

There are rumors of a rematch and Goldberg has now been signed to appear at the Royal Rumble, but none of that matters. The visual of the unstoppable monster that WWE invested nearly years in has now been shattered. Presumably the goal was to have someone finally vanquish Lesnar and become a megastar in the process. I sincerely doubt the idea was for that rub to go to a 50-year old guy who hasn’t wrestled in years, who left the company on bad terms and won’t be good for much more than a nostalgia pop.

So where do they go from here with Brock? The magic of having one of the younger guys – AJ Styles, Kevin Owens, Finn Bálor – come along and beat him is done. Over with. There’s no getting that back. And something tells me WWE is going to massively regret it. All for a brief “WTF” reaction at the end of an insignificant pay-per-view.

9. Roman Reigns Is The Last Man Standing For Raw

They just won’t learn, will they? There were five people on the Raw team, three of them heels, and every one of them was more popular with the crowd than Roman Reigns. Even Braun Strowman, who has done nothing more than squash matches up to this point, was getting a better reaction than The Big Dog.

Advertisement

Kevin Owens is the most despicable heel on the roster and was getting treated like a benevolent savior compared to Roman, not to mention how insanely over Chris Jericho was. So of course, rather than continue to build on the popularity of those stars and try to make some money, WWE once again had Roman Reigns booked the strongest out of everyone in the match.

At this point complaining about it seems as futile as yelling at walls, since WWE is no more aware of the fans’ feelings than a couch is aware that it’s being sat on, so all we can really do is shake our heads and chuckle.

Seth Rollins should have been the last one standing. His run since returning from injury has been booked horrendously and he needed that moment. But nope, instead we got the Survivor Series version of #LOLROMAN(ALMOST)WINS.

8. Keeping The Cruiserweights On Raw

Leading up to Survivor Series it was rumored that the entire cruiserweight division would be making the shift over to Tuesday nights, and the stipulation of the Survivor Series match between The Brian Kendrick and Kalisto was booked to facilitate that.

Advertisement

The high-flying division is floundering on the flagship show, and putting them on SD where they can hopefully be better utilized seemed like the obvious choice. The “pure wrestling” fans are gravitating toward the blue brand and the cruisers would likely be better served there.

All those rumors were either completely false or WWE changed its mind at the last minute because Baron Corbin interfered costing SmackDown the match and the entire division. It works for Corbin’s character but it hurts a division that was in desperate need of a shot in the arm, and also denies SmackDown some needed additional talent.

7. The Tag Team Elimination Order

WWE has some really great tag teams on the main roster, and the ones waiting in the wings down in NXT might be even better. So of course the best way to showcase all that new talent is by having them be the last teams standing in the elimination match, right?

Advertisement

Except that’s not what happened. I can understand eliminating New Day since they’ve been on top for so long, and Slater and Rhyno because, well, they’re Slater and Rhyno. And regardless of whether or not anyone wants to admit it, Gallows and Anderson are completely dead in the water. But there is absolutely no excuse for American Alpha not to be SmackDown’s final team in the ring in place of The Usos.

I love the Usos, and did even before their reinvigorating heel turn, but these guys have been in WWE for what feel like 34 years while American Alpha is a force to be reckoned with and new to most of the audience. Why not give them the rub of having them go down swinging for the SmackDown teams?

And while we’re on the subject of that match…

6. Sheamus & Cesaro Winning The Tag Match

We get that you want Sheamus and Cesaro to be a thing, WWE. We really do. But it isn’t happening. All we can see when they’re in the ring together is how badly Cesaro is being wasted in this lame “reluctant tag partners” gimmick when he should be in the world title picture on either show.

Advertisement

It’s even more infuriating when you have a tag team elimination match to decide which brand has the better tag scene and the last team standing to decide the match for their roster isn’t even actually a tag team. It could’ve been any one of the actual tag teams but instead they gave that push to a duo that won’t be together a few months from now.

What does that say about how WWE views their tag team division when they took a look at all the talented squads that comprised that match – from serious wrestlers to genuinely entertaining comedy acts – and decided that the two singles guys, one of whom is as stale as he can possibly be, should be the sole survivors?

5. Shane McMahon's Near-Death Experience

One of the reasons why wrestling fans have always reacted so positively to Shane McMahon is because he’s always busted his hump to be viewed as “one of the boys". Never one to shy away from a risk Vince’s son has made his name with some of the scariest stunts the sports entertainment world has ever seen. The Kurt Angle suplex through the glass, the Titantron falls; Shane-O-Mac is the Matt Murdock of the WWE.

Advertisement

That being said, the dude is 46-years old. There’s no reason why he should be actively attempting suicide at this stage of his life. The WrestleMania match with Undertaker was entertaining ONLY because we all expected some spectacle of a stunt – and we got it. But Shane is trying to shorten his life and that’s not smart.

The force of the coast-to-coast into the mid-air spear was enough to knock him senseless, and as he lay on the mat in a crumpled heap staring into blank space, Randy Orton had to break character to reassure his family that he was okay.

Credit where it’s due, it was a hell of a spot, but not something WWE should be doing with guys his age. Especially non-wrestlers.

Which brings me to my next point…

4. Why Was Shane Even In The Match?

If the bout between the Raw and SmackDown male singles stars was a battle to prove brand supremacy, what does it say about the SD roster that their own commissioner has so little faith in his talent that he inserted himself into the match rather than rely on one of his contracted wrestlers to fill that spot?

Advertisement

Dolph Ziggler, Baron Corbin, and Apollo Creed are guys who could have easily made the team, and for Corbin especially he could have gotten the rub that Braun Strowman came out of the match with. Instead, we’re supposed to view them as lesser competitors to the 46-year old McMahon who has only had one match in a decade, and that doesn’t speak well of the brand itself.

I’m not taking anything away from his ability in the ring – in fact he’s always entertaining – but from a kayfabe perspective, Shane being part of the team should be incredibly insulting to everyone on the SmackDown roster.

3. Kane? Really?

The Big Red Machine is an awesome character and has stood the test of time alongside his “brother” as a performer who has been able to adapt to several different eras while maintaining his relevance and popularity. I’m a big fan of the character and the man behind the work, but I just don’t understand why he’s still decisively beating promising talents like Luke Harper in late-2016.

Advertisement

If I were WWE I would have gone with another Raw vs. SmackDown match in this spot and rather than have Harper – someone who BADLY needs some momentum – lose to Kane, I’d pit the Wyatt Family member against Raw’s representative of Rusev.

That would have given us a match that added to the brand vs. brand stakes while matching up two competitors that we haven’t seen wrestle a thousand times. Plus it gives us the benefit of adding to the brand superiority stakes while also blessing us with more Rusev, which is always good thing.

2. Charlotte Vs. Bayley: Too Soon?

WWE has definitely exhausted the Charlotte/Sasha Banks program – at least for a while – so it was time to build up a credible contender for the women’s champion. With Charlotte knocking it out of the park as a heel, she needs a strong babyface to oppose her.

Advertisement

Unfortunately for Raw there aren’t many options and they decided to pull the trigger on making Bayley the challenger. While that feud has the potential to be excellent, it just feels a bit too soon. Bayley and Charlotte should be something that they hold off on until WrestleMania, with Bayley getting her big win on the grandest stage of them all.

She either has to beat Charlotte and face Sasha at 'Mania, in which case her title win won’t have the same impact, or she has to continuously lose until someone else takes the belt off Flair and then beat that person on the big show. Regardless, it would have made more sense to give Charlotte a placeholder feud to fill the time until 'Mania season kicks off.

1. Teasing The Undertaker

This final entry is less about what happened on Survivor Series as it is about the go-home SmackDown show that aired a few nights prior. The Undertaker made his return on the 900th episode and declared his loyalty to the blue brand, then followed that up by saying that if anyone caused the SD team to lose to Raw they would have hell to pay.

Advertisement

This had fans expecting that The Deadman would come into play somehow at the event, with speculation that he might even set up his WrestleMania program at some point. As the night progressed and there was no sign of 'Taker, it became apparent that we had been swerved. Which is fine, but I can't help but feel like WWE used his looming presence to help draw interest in the elimination match and then pulled a bait and switch when he played no role.

He did state that he will no longer allow WrestleMania to define him so maybe this means he'll be showing up more often, but the lack of Undertaker at Survivor Series felt a little bit cheap.

-

What did you think of the decisions made at Survivor Series 2016? Let us know in the comments below!

Advertisement