10 Things TNA Wants You To Forget About Abyss

TNA's long serving star has had a chequered history.

By Matt O'Connell /

Abyss is one of TNA's biggest, and longest-tenured stars; in fact, he and James Storm are the only wrestlers still on the roster that appeared on their very first show back in 2002. It€™s been a long, bumpy road since then, and most of the company€™s early stars like AJ Styles, Ron Killings, Alex Shelley, Petey Williams and even Jeff Jarrett have left for greener pastures, but the Monster appears to be in for the long haul. He€™s a real foundational figure, and his presence has been a constant, even as regime and roster changes have rocked the promotion. His loyalty is pretty puzzling, given some of the startlingly bad angles and matches TNA has stuck him in over the years. He€™s been both jilted lover and psychotic stalker, both innocent victim and malevolent beast. He€™s been through more contrived family drama than anyone in wrestling not named €œMcMahon€, and he€™s apparently TNA€™s go-to guy to introduce irredeemably goofy gimmick matches and regrettable characters. He€™s had about as many alignment changes as Kane, and even less luck in world title convention. In short, Abyss has been through a lot, and this list compiles some of the strangest, most nonsensical, and disappointing moments in his otherwise storied career.

10. Coming Up Short In Monster€™s Ball

Abyss has always been €œthe Monster€ of TNA, usually the largest and most physically imposing wrestler on the show. He towers over most of his competitors, leading to memorable size dynamics with classic opponents like Sting, AJ Styles, and Christian Cage. TNA bills him at 6€™8€ and 350 pounds, and that€™s normally pretty believable, but on at least one occasion the promotion accidentally proved that the big man isn't quite as big as they claim. At Bound For Glory 2007, Abyss faced off against Raven, Samoa Joe, and Brother Runt, in a Monsters' Ball match. He was the tallest participant in the match, but not in the ring; special guest referee Jake "the Snake" Roberts, squarely in his pre-DDP sad hunched old man phase, is still a few inches taller than Abyss. Roberts' billed height? 6'6". Oddly enough, TNA DID actually change Samoa Joe's billed height when he left the X-Division for the heavyweight ranks, dropping from 6'8" to 6'2", and he looks jusssst a bit smaller than Abyss here. It's almost like all wrestlers are lying about their heights and weights, but that can't be; the athletic commissions would be all over that.

9. The Magic Ring

TNA has seen fit to saddle Abyss with basically every cliched bad gimmick there is, so it's no surprise that they would eventually just start stringing them together. Abyss was stuck in a losing streak until he was given Hulk Hogan's WWE Hall of Fame Ring. Wearing this magically allowed him to access the "powers" of various wrestling legends, meaning that he countered the always productive "veteran on losing streak" gimmick with the definitely-not-ridiculous "imitating other guys" gimmick. Hulk was at his hyperbolic best, ranting and raving about how the ring would give Abyss the power of ten thousand Hogans and make him "the God of men." Apparently thrilled at the prospect of literal deification, Abyss made worrying Paul Bearer sounds the entire time. The payoff for all this was a match in which Hogan's ring was wagered against Ric Flair's, and yes, this means TNA promoted a match based on their wrestlers desperately fighting for WWE's props. Not that this would have been good had they used Sting's TNA Hall of Fame ring, but perhaps it wouldn't have broadcasted TNA's truly prodigious inferiority complex all over the world. Er, more than usual.

Advertisement

8. The Alleged Mystery of Joseph Park

Abyss had been missing from TNA for several months when a Penn Jillette-looking doofus named Joseph Park showed up claiming to his brother. In an attempt to learn more about his missing sibling, Joseph would become a wrestler himself, because of course that happened. He was normally clumsy, but he'd occasionally "snap" and wrestle exactly like his identical brother. Hmmmmm. The Joseph Park character itself was great, and Abyss did a fantastic job of portraying him, but TNA almost immediately began insulting the fans' intelligence by dropping "hints" about multiple personalities.Despite the reveal that Joseph and Abyss were ONE AND THE SAME being the exact opposite of shocking, TNA somehow saw fit to drag this "mystery" out for two full years. Miraculously, in that time, no one ever thought to pull off Park's trademark track suit jacket and see if he had Abyss' tattoos.

Advertisement

7. The James Mitchell Saga

For years, Abyss' career was closely intertwined with that of with Father James Mitchell. Mitchell, for the uninitiated, was basically a discount Paul Bearer that was even more cartoonishly evil; dude had curled-up eyebrows! Initially, he'd simply cackle ominously while Abyss beat guys up, but eventually it began to appear that he was the real monster, and Abyss himself was reluctant to destroy. And that's where the wheels fell off. It was revealed that Mitchell wasn't controlling Abyss with any kind of supernatural totem; rather, he was using blackmail. Blackmail involving gunplay, family drama, and amnesia. It turned out that Abyss' mother had shot his father and that Abyss had taken the blame. Mitchell would reveal this to the world if Abyss did not do his bidding, despite the fact that they had this conversation on national television. Mitchell would then reveal an additional secret: HE had been the father/gunshot victim all along! This was less high drama than the Family Guy gag about the man that was secretly a woman that was secretly a horse that was secretly a broom. It also lead directly to the next best-forgotten chapter of the Monster's life . . .

6. Judas Mesias, the OTHER Long-Lost Brother

We've covered Joseph Parks, but that angle was actually the second time TNA decided to give Abyss a brother. Judas Mesias was the grand finale of James Mitchell's dramatic reveal marathon, a new monster brought in to destroy Abyss for betraying their father. At this point they were basically doing a community theater version of the Undertaker/Kane/Paul Bearer only with a second, more disappointing Kane. Judas was actually journeyman grappler Ricky Banderas, most famous at the time for being the top heel of MTV's short-lived Wrestling Society X. Although Judas would go on to have a stellar career in Mexico's AAA promotion, he fizzled hard in TNA. He lasted only a year, though he'd return in 2013 to battle . . . Joseph Park. Abyss' family tree should be cut down and the earth salted.

5. The Token Title Reign

Abyss is the Kane of TNA, and that's more than a facile comparison based upon their shared history of masks and convoluted backstories. They're also consummate long-term company men who have seen their loyalty rewarded with really disappointing world title runs. Kane famously won the WWE title from Stone Cold Steve Austin when he started bleeding lamely during a first blood match, and Austin regained the title 23 hours later. Abyss fared even worse when he defeated Sting by disqualification at Genesis 2006. Yes, TNA's resident psychotic monster won their world title when Sting shoved a referee. Yes, TNA's world title can change on a disqualification. Yes, it was dumb, and no, Abyss has never been champion again. Seriously, TNA, if you'd like your fans to take your monster heel seriously, maybe don't book him like he's "One More Match"-era Christian.

4. Slay Misty For Me

One of Abyss' more extended rivalries was with Black Reign, who was Goldust with black face paint instead of gold and a pet rat called Misty instead of gay panic. Armed with little more than ill-defined mental illness and a spooky theme song, Reign was paired with Abyss in a series of truly terrible street fights. Aside from foisting the dreaded Rellik -- which, as we know, Don, is "killer" spelled backwards -- on TNA fans, this rivalry also introduced one of the stupidest weapons in wrestling history. At Genesis 2007, in a "Shop of Horrors" match, Abyss produced a plywood board with mousetraps glued to it. He then attempted to chokeslam Misty, an actual, normal sized rat, onto the panel. Also, Shop of Horrors Match? Abyss really has copied Kane's entire career, right down to the tangential involvement of evil dentistry.

3. The Last Rites Match

In retrospect, almost all of Abyss' long-term storylines wound up being ridiculous. The big guy's rivalry with Sting would provide his sole world championship, but also such career lows as the Last Rites Match. In true TNA fashion, they took an existing gimmick match and made it pointlessly complicated. In this case, it was a casket match, except that you couldn't win until you put your opponent in the "DEATH BED" and wheeled them up to the ceiling with a pulley rig. TNA officials helpfully provided the competitors with dime store Halloween decorations as weapons, most notably a plastic candelabra that caused Sting's head to gush blood despite Abyss hitting him in the stomach with it. The match notoriously garnered angry chants of "Fire Russo", despite it actually being a Dutch Mantell brainchild. Still, it's probably telling that even TNA, innovators of such stipulation-lousy stinkers as the King of the Mountain Match and the Reverse Battle Royal, haven't dusted the cobwebs off of this one.

2. The Dr. Stevie Debacle

Did you know that ECW midcarder and Sunday Night Heat curtain-jerker Stevie Richards was a medical doctor? It's true! Stevie apparently pursued this degree in his spare time during his active wrestling career, which could perhaps explain why he was so bad at it. At first, saw the good doctor in his office, where he'd gently point out that participation in things like the "Doomsday Chamber of Blood" was not conducive to developing non non-violent coping mechanisms, but Abyss just wasn't getting it. Therefore, Stevie tried to cure Abyss' violent psychopathy using hardcore wrestling, which is, at best, of suspect clinical value. It eventually turned out that the clinic was simply a cover for a Stevie/Raven/Daffney stable, which was revealed as part of a Mick Foley heel turn, which was itself a master plan by Mick to teach Abyss something something THE MONSTER INSIDE. Abyss is the Ric Flair of obnoxious storyline twists.

1. The Cheese Grater

At Genesis 2012, Abyss faced off with Bully Ray in a Monsters' Ball, which is not regrettable in and of itself. Ray was one of the hottest heels in wrestling at the time, and Abyss, despite what you may surmise from reading this list, is usually very good in hardcore matches. No, one specific moment within this generally okay match stands as the dumbest thing Abyss was ever involved in. Midway through the match, Abyss brandished a cheese grater and placed it lightly between Bully Ray€™s thighs, causing him to bolt upright, his arms held out at his sides as if in shock. Abyss then, in clear defiance of how kitchen utensils, pants, and testicles work, somehow critically wounded Bully by gently moving the grater away from his pants. TNA€™s stellar announce team leapt into action to call this immortal moment. Taz quipped, €œHoly gorgonzolie€, while Mike Tenay asked €œThat€™ll grate the cheese, won€™t it?€, apparently confused at the intended purpose of a cheese grater. The two chuckled over their rapier wits as the match rolled on, only to be interrupted by Bully hitting a low blow on Abyss. He staggered to his feet, hobbling around the ring and shouting, "GAWD MY BAWLS," several minutes after the alleged injury took place. Ah yes; the legendary Delayed Reaction Over-the-Clothing Cheese Grater Bloodless Genital Mutilation Technique. Truly, TNA is where Wrestling Matters.