10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Carmella

James Ellsworth = the real Miss. Money In The Bank...

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE

Well, this is awkward.

Advertisement

Both Carmella and Corey Graves have been making headlines for all the wrong reasons over the past few days. It all stemmed from Graves' wife posting on Instagram that the announcer had been cheating on her with 'Mella behind her back, and she even went as far as to claim Carmella was a hero to their young children. Now, fresh reports suggest the couple have been going through a divorce for six months.

Whatever the truth is, it's rather embarrassing for WWE that social media has blown up over the situation. It's one of those modern-day negatives; Twitter is always going to go haywire whenever it so much as sniffs some controversy. That's just the way it is. Regardless, this is something the company would rather people moved on from, and quickly.

Advertisement

So, what else would WWE like fans to forget about Carmella's life and career? Much of this is wrestling-related, don't worry, and the blame often falls at the feet of the writers, but here's everything we think the promotion want you to ignore about the 'Princess Of Staten Island'...

10. Her Dad Was A WWE Jobber

WWE/E Online

There was nothing especially F.A.B.U.L.O.U.S about Paul Van Dale's WWE career.

Advertisement

According to old wrestling databases, Paul Van Dale last worked for the company on a 1995 episode of Superstars. There, he teamed with Tim McNeany as Paul McDale in a losing effort against mountain men The Blu Brothers. He'd worked as enhancement talent since the late-80s.

This is not something WWE mention, and they never have done throughout Carmella's entire run. Since joining the promotion in 2013, she's been cast as someone without wrestling lineage. That's not strictly true, though it is understandable that WWE don't want to admit daddy dearest was a boots n' tights journeyman.

Advertisement

Paul has appeared on Total Divas in the past, but he's never been a part of his daughter's WWE run on NXT or SmackDown. Dig a little deeper into some media interviews with Carmella and you'll find a few references to how she'd watch wrestling with him growing up.

9. She Used To Be A Third Wheel For Two WWE Cast-Offs

WWE.com

How you doin'?

Advertisement

Those words were once over like rover in WWE. Together, Enzo Amore and Big Cass were one of the most popular tags on the roster, and their witty banter and catchphrase combos made them babyface sensations. Before that, they were aligned with 'Mella in NXT, which is something WWE have conveniently forgotten.

No wonder. Both Enzo and Cass have been released from contract over the past year or so, and both left under a cloud of questionable circumstances. That's not something management would want people remembering; Carmella is very much her own woman now, not third-wheeling eye candy who was described by Amore as "hot as hell".

Advertisement

Back in the NXT days however, that was her gig. She was there solely to look good and act as the team's snapback-wearing hairdresser-turned-valet. It's funny how things change.

8. The Welcoming Committee

WWE.com

If you've forgotten about 'The Welcoming Committee', then this writer offers you the most sincere of apologies for bringing them up. Basically, Carmella (with James Ellsworth), Natalya and Tamina hated the thought of Charlotte Flair dominating SmackDown like she had Raw, and so they formed a unit to stop her.

Advertisement

Thrilling stuff, eh?

The short-lived faction was as lifeless as it sounds. It only existed for a brief spell after the 2017 Superstar Shake-Up, and it disappeared before anyone could wonder aloud what the hell the point was. We remember it though, and not fondly. This was a truly crap portion of Carmella's main roster run.

Advertisement

For an example of how instantly redundant the group was, check out their six-woman tag match against Becky Lynch, Charlotte and Naomi at Backlash that year. 10 minutes has never felt so long.

7. That Time She Found James Ellsworth "Uniquely Attractive"

WWE.com

James Ellsworth was there to act as a Vanilla Ice wannabe freakshow with no chin that Carmella could use to win matches, get some heat and treat like dirt, right? Sort of, but that's not the full story. There was a time, when the pair first hooked up on screen, that it looked like they might be romantically linked.

Advertisement

Score one for Jimmy.

During several promos, Carmella described Ellsworth as "uniquely attractive", and claimed he had a certain charm to him that other men lacked. It was as weird as you think, and became even more so when WWE continued such madness for a good few months. Apparently, 'Mella had the hots for the guy.

Advertisement

WWE eventually phased this plot point out and had Carmella use James as a verbal speedbag instead. The compliments dried up, but not before she'd given him a makeover, called him "cute" and flirted like she was auditioning for an American Pie flick.

6. How She Won Money In The Bank

WWE.com

No Chin Jim even helped her become Miss. Money In The Bank.

Advertisement

Well, technically, Ellsworth himself bagged that title. He was the one who actually hauled down the MITB briefcase before tossing it to his buddy, but WWE didn't let that fact get in the way of a good story. They also failed to grasp why fans were irked by a male comedy character sorta' ruining a female first.

Before the pay-per-view, WWE made a big deal out of how historic a women's Money In The Bank match was, and how it validated their female revolution. Then, they had some guy dress up like a 12-year old going to an Eminem concert, had him climb the ladder for the winner and do all the heavy lifting.

Advertisement

Later, WWE decided to do things properly and rebook another ladder-based bout on SmackDown so Carmella could win the match properly. That didn't really work either. Ellsworth helped her again, nullifying the point of the redo. Oops.

5. How Poorly Her Title Reign Ended

WWE.com

It's easy to forget that Carmella cashed in her MITB briefcase on Charlotte Flair in April 2018 and held the SmackDown Women's belt for a substantial 131 days. In that time, she came into her own as a heel, ditched Ellsworth and cut some super-strong promos on all comers. Finally, 'Mella was showing she was money.

Advertisement

Then, in the blink of an eye, it ended.

WWE's writers flashed their knickers at Charlotte and Becky Lynch instead. At SummerSlam, Carmella (the champion, don't forget) was a definite hanger-on in the Triple Threat match for her title. The real story was Becky's dream and Flair's willingness to intrude on it so she could become champ instead. That, dear reader, is when 'The Man' was born.

Advertisement

Meanwhile, Carmella was left looking like an absolute afterthought. She wasn't involved in the finish, failed to regain the title in an aimless rematch two weeks later and was moved aside so creative could focus on some former BFFs.

4. That Nip Slip

WWE.com

Carmella and Natalya vs. Naomi and Becky Lynch from Fastlane 2018 would've been an entirely forgettable match had 'Mella's nip not slipped and made TMZ some advertising dolla' (probably). Mid-match, her rather skimpy ring gear gave way and out came some boob.

Advertisement

Again, oops.

As you'd expect, the internet was all over this. It was an awkward moment for Carmella, as wardrobe malfunctions often are, and it proved her leotard wasn't quite fit for purpose. Either that or she just forgot to put on enough tape that'd keep everything in check.

Advertisement

Let's move on, 'cause these things are always a little salacious and embarrassing to mention. Despite the red faces we're get from even talking about this one, it is definitely something WWE would like everyone to move on from, and so it fits here.

3. The John Cena Rumours

WWE.com

So does this rather newsworthy rumour.

Advertisement

Carmella's only response to talk she'd been dating John Cena post-Nikki Bella was a quick post on Instagram that said, "I wonder how many calories y'all burn by jumping to conclusions". Witty, but still the media couldn't resist speculating on a little bit of juicy goss. For a short period last year, this was everywhere.

Some places finally put the rumours to bed by posting stories claiming they'd been had and that there was nothing to the story. That, it seemed, was that, but social media had a field day discussing whether or not both stars had been seeing one another behind the scenes after all for months afterwards.

Advertisement

This was another cringe for WWE bosses. Cena's relationship with Bella had been so high profile and accepted within company circles that any reports of a third party muscling in on Nikki's turf were always going to be met with gasps.

2. That Saudi Advert Appearance

WWE/@GSAKSA

WWE's decision to take wads of cash and run supershows in Saudi Arabia was one of 2018's most controversial hot topics. To some, it reeked of corporate money-grabbing, and others couldn't stomach the fact that women wouldn't be able to appear on the card.

Advertisement

Then, the Greatest Royal Rumble happened, and Carmella popped up in a mid-show ad wearing her leopard-print one-piece. Cue an angry outburst from the event's organisers and the General Sport Authority (said organisers) publicly apologising for some "indecent" content.

Sasha Banks, Naomi, Alexa Bliss, Becky Lynch and others were shown in the commercial too, and it was hardly racy stuff.

Advertisement

Indeed, 'Mella could be seen sipping from a water bottle in her ring gear, and that was it. Somehow, due to cultural differences, Saudi authorities deemed this wildly inappropriate and promised it'd never happen again so long as their relationship with WWE continued.

1. Her Initial Babyface Run Was A Flop

WWE.com

Carmella is (for now; we'll see what happens now her 'Fabulous Glow' tag-team with Naomi has seemingly come to an end) a dance-break-loving, all-smiling babyface. This is a massive departure from her spoiled brat character as a heel, but it's not actually the first time she's played goody-two-shoes on WWE's main roster.

Advertisement

Rewind nearly three years to the summer of 2016 for her initial try.

After landing on SmackDown that July, she went about the task of convincing people she was a female version of the uber-hip Enzo Amore and Big Cass duo over on Raw. It...didn't go well. Within a week or two, she was already hearing some jeers for her over-enthusiastic delivery, hammy 'street talk' and watered-down version of an already-successful act.

Advertisement

WWE acted swiftly and turned Carmella heel a month later in mid-August. It was a mercy killing for her dorky face character, and it rescued an otherwise-doomed solo bow on Tuesday nights before it was too late.

What else do you think WWE want fans to forget about Carmella? Let us know down in the comments section below!

Advertisement