10 Things You Didn't Know About The Four Horsemen

Everything you ever needed to know about the greatest wrestling faction of all time.

By John Bills /

Another year, another rumour of a revamped Four Horsemen. If you think 'CM Punk is returning' is a piece of wrestling gossip that won't go away, try being a long-time wrestling fan faced with another attempt to make a modern Horsemen, as rumours of the group's return do the rounds on the grapevine.

Advertisement

2021 is different though. Arn Anderson has dropped some serious hints in recent times, and The Enforcer is not the type of guy to blow smoke out of his proverbial. Can we expect to see a modern interpretation of wrestling's greatest faction of AEW Dynamite sooner rather than later?

Time will tell on that front, but there is never a bad time to get to know The Four Horsemen. The stable is a wrestling Mount Rushmore all in itself, a legendary faction that is never far from any discussion about 'wrestling's best'. The gritty realism of elite athletes banded together and living lives that fans dreamt of was the NWA's main point of difference against the glitz and glamour of Vince McMahon's WWE. In the history of professional wrestling, The Four Horsemen are a chapter by themselves.

What does that have to do with the Minnesota Wrecking Crew? Maybe nothing, maybe everything...

10. Before The Horsemen, There Was The Anderson Family

The origins of The Four Horsemen can be traced back to another wrestling team with a tremendous name; The Minnesota Wrecking Crew. It all started, coincidentally enough, in Minnesota in the late '60s with a tag team made up of 'brothers' Lars and Gene Anderson. The years passed and Lars and Gene were replaced by another pair of Anderson 'brothers' that might be more familiar to modern wrestling fans; Ole and Arn.

Advertisement

Arn had been a cousin from time to time (wrestling lineage can be quite malleable), but the duo soon became a trio when they aligned with a third Anderson cousin, albeit one with a different surname. I'm talking, of course, about 'The Nature Boy' himself, Ric Flair. The trio initially came together over a shared hatred of Dusty Rhodes, a common theme throughout the history of The Four Horsemen.

Ric Flair obviously isn't related to the Andersons, none of whom are actually related to each other. Pro wrestling families, everybody! The Anderson wrestling legacy is continued to this very day by current tag team icon Karl Anderson. Basically, if you're double tough and can hit a sweet spinebuster, chances are that you are a wrestling Anderson.

9. The Name Came About By Chance

It might just be the coolest stable name in the history of pro wrestling factions. The Four Horsemen? Undeniably cool. Is there a better use of Christian imagery in pro wrestling? The answer is no.

Advertisement

With that in mind, is it surprising that the name came about somewhat by chance? The group was formed almost by mistake, when time constraints forced three interviews to be jammed into one segment. Ric Flair was world champion, the Andersons were tag champions and Tully was US champion, and the four (along with J.J. Dillon) took over an interview segment to brag about their success. Ever the wordsmith, Arn then uttered the words that changed wrestling forever;

"Never in the history of wrestling have so few wreaked so much havoc over everyone else – that you’d have to go back in history books to the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse." The Enforcer held up four fingers as he made his claim, and the rest is history.

This is a point that cannot be understated, and it gives a good indication of why WWE will never create a stable fit to lace the Horsemen's boots. The coolest stable name in wrestling history came about thanks to a throwaway line in an unscripted promo. What would the group be called in WWE today? I dread to think.

8. Ground Zero For Wrestling Stables

The Four Horsemen are widely considered to be one of the best stables in the history of professional wrestling, maybe even the best. When the group was at its strongest it is difficult to disagree; all four members were top-level talents, while the stable continually made babyfaces and sold masses of tickets along the way. When it comes to wrestling factions, The Four Horsemen are the gold standard.

Advertisement

Groups of wrestlers banding together for a common goal wasn't invented by the Horsemen but the group were the first major faction to become established in the mainstream, the first to make factions cool, so to speak. Ever since Flair, Tully and the Andersons made it cool, wrestling promotions have been desperately trying to capture that lightning. They have rarely succeeded.

The Undisputed Era and Evolution are the two major success stories but the set-up of the Horsemen has been replicated time and time again, all the way down to the components that make up the stable. You'll have the centrepiece, the heir apparent, the enforcer and the muscle, guaranteed. The Inner Circle is another excellent modern example.

Who will play those roles in AEW? Time will tell, but there are plenty of contenders for each spot. Either way, the legacy of The Four Horsemen seems set to get a new branch.

7. A Wretched Record In Their Signature Match

Dusty Rhodes is often credited as the brains behind the WarGames match, but it was the desire to vanquish the Four Horsemen that led to violent gimmick coming into play. The double-cage extravaganza was introduced as the Horsemen's signature match, the ultimate end to any feud between the group and whichever main event babyface happened to be in their crosshairs. 15 of the first 18 WarGames match included some form of The Four Horsemen.

Advertisement

Wrestling is weird, obviously, and the lack of success a wrestler (or in this case, faction) finds in their signature match is further proof of this. The Undertaker has a relatively poor Hell in a Cell record, for example, but even the Deadman's lack of dominance in the Cell doesn't come close to the wretched record of The Four Horsemen in WarGames.

1-15. That is The Four Horsemen's WarGames record. That sole victory came in 1991 at WrestleWar, and even that wasn't necessarily a true Horsemen quartet, as Larry Zbyszko teamed with Flair, Windham and Sid in defeating Sting, Brian Pillman and The Steiner Brothers. 14 defeats came before that single victory.

In pro wrestling, establishing a signature match is usually a time-honoured way to ensure frequent defeats. Not even The Four Horsemen were above this.

6. Ole Anderson Isn't A Fan

Despite being a founding member of the group and one of the most credible fourth Horsemen, Ole Anderson was nowhere to be seen when The Four Horsemen were inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2012. Why was that? Well, the notoriously cantankerous Ole hasn't exactly been quiet on his issues with seemingly everyone in wrestling, from Ric Flair to Vince McMahon via most of the key players in late '80s and early '90s NWA.

Advertisement

The Four Horsemen was the making of the men who were privileged to be a part of the group, yet Ole Anderson has been extremely vocal in the past about his hatred for the group and all it achieved. To quote the man himself;

“It was just !*$%. We were picking up a little bit of money in the Four Horsemen, but to me, that was the worst damn thing I ever did because that was really show-business. It was still dependent on us to draw money, but we were hampered in so many ways. After all, I couldn’t do what I wanted to do because I wasn’t the boss. But unfortunately, a lot of people, when they think about the Anderson’s – Ole Anderson and Gene Anderson – the only thing they can come up with is the Four Horsemen, and that’s unfortunate because that to me was just a piece of crap. It was garbage.”

Wow, Ole, tell us how you really feel.

In his book 'Inside Out', Ole also went to town on The Nature Boy, criticising Flair for wrestling the same match over and over again. I'm not about to disagree with the criticism (Ole isn't the only person to point such things out), but why fix something that isn't broken? The Four Horsement made its members, but Ole Anderson may well be the exception to the rule.

5. The Fifteen Horsemen

Most wrestling fans have an idea of who makes up the best version of the Four Horsemen and of the qualities needed to be given a spot in wrestling's most elite faction. Almost everyone agrees that Mongo McMichael and Paul Roma don't quite fit the bill.

Advertisement

There have been 15 official Horsemen overall, covering a surprisingly wide range of performers and standards. Flair and Arn have been ubiquitous and Tully was never far away, but the fourth spot has often been a bit of a merry-go-round featuring classic names and not quite so beloved stars of yesterday.

Along with the aforementioned core trio, not to forget Roma and Mongo, the following 10 have been lucky enough to ride as a Horseman; Ole Anderson, Lex Luger, Barry Windham, Sting, Sid, Brian Pillman, Chris Benoit, Jeff Jarrett, Curt Hennig and Dean Malenko. Quite the variety, right?

Some of those stints were forgettable, others memorable. Curt Hennig was a Horseman for all of three weeks, installed in the group simply to turn on his colleagues and join the nWo, while Jarrett lasted all of four months before Flair kicked him out. Benoit was arguably the most fitting of the modern Horsemen, but that is another bag of snakes entirely.

Throw in six associates and 12 managers/referees and you've got a less exclusive club than you might assume.

4. No Flair And Arn, No Horsemen

There have been plenty of incarnations of The Four Horsemen, but none have existed without the rambunctious charisma of Ric Flair and the dependable toughness of Arn Anderson. Founding members of the group, the duo have been ubiquitous throughout the history of The Four Horsemen, the tight nucleus around which professional wrestling folklore has been written.

Advertisement

On the surface, Arn and Flair could not be more different. Even their nicknames are polar opposites. 'The Nature Boy' is all glitz and glamour, all hyperbole and bright lights, while 'The Enforcer' is a no-frills beatdown monger interested only in getting the job done. Arn went to great lengths in his promos to get across the prevalence of professionalism over glamourisation in his game, while Flair was busy waxing lyrical about his nightlife escapades and playboy lifestyle.

Polar opposites in some ways, but then there always has been weight to the yin and yang argument, while both men were more than capable of indulging in the other's specialities. Flair was as tough as they come, while Arn was known for his partying ability. Arn and Flair complimented each other, in the ring and out.

It is difficult to imagine a Four Horsemen without Flair or Anderson, because there hasn't been a Four Horsemen without the two of them.

3. The Midnight Express Almost Became Horsemen

Professional wrestling is chock-full of 'what could have beens', from dropped feuds to rumoured gimmicks and beyond. The Four Horsemen are not free of this trope, and the faction's great 'what if?' centres around what would of undoubtedly been the best in-ring version of The Four Horsemen possible.

Advertisement

As 1989 became 1990, the group had been reduced to just Ric Flair and Arn Anderson. Tully's personal demons had gotten the better of him, and all of a sudden there was space for two bodies in a revamped Horsemen. The Midnight Express (then made up of Bobby Eaton and Stan Lane) were rumoured to get the bump, a plan corroborated by Jim Cornette in 2020, but for some reason it never happened. Wrestling fans were robbed of what could have been the elite version of an already elite faction.

The Midnight Express-version of The Four Horsemen was agreed, but Jim Herd changed his mind and decided to move forward without the group. As the story goes, this was the straw that broke the camel's back, although in this case the 'camel' is 'Jim Cornette and Stan Lane'. They soon left WCW, Flair went off to WWE, leaving Arn and Bobby to have a pretty darn successful run as a duo and within the Dangerous Alliance.

2. WCW Continually Tried To Kill The Group

It shouldn't be a shock to hear that WCW tried time and time again to kill off one of the promotion's most popular acts. Self-sabotage really is a skill, after all.

Advertisement

When Arn and Tully left for WWE in 1988 the group found itself in limbo, a void that it struggled to recover from. This was when the group really began to cycle through members, so WCW's lack of enthusiasm towards the group can maybe be understood. When WCW tried to repackage Flair as a modern-day Spartacus, the proposal was made with the Four Horsemen well and truly in the rearview mirror. Jim Herd's obsession with modernising the timeless Flair and moving on from the Horsemen directly led to the Nature Boy turning up in WWE in 1991.

The most egregious example of WCW trying to bury its most credible group came in 1997. The Horsemen were feuding with the nWo, and Kevin Nash and company took to the ring for a memorable promo segment that parodied the Horsemen in a most offensive manner, poking run at Arn Anderson's recent retirement and battles with alcoholism, among other things. The Horsemen were made to look utterly toothless in the face of the poison that was eating WCW alive.

Did Flair and his men ever get revenge on Big Sexy? If you're even asking that question, you obviously aren't familiar with WCW. The segment led to a WarGames match at Fall Brawl, a match won by the nWo after Curt Hennig turned on the Horsemen. Truthfully, this was the final nail in the coffin.

1. Talking The Talk, Walking The Walk

On screen, The Four Horsemen were portrayed as elite athletes living the high life. No matter who made up the group at the time, not a promo passed without at least a cursory mention of limousines, all-night parties, a laundry list of female companions and all the rest. As the old saying goes; women wanted to be with them, and men wanted to be them. The Four Horsemen were superstars.

Advertisement

Off screen, the story wasn't too different. The Horsemen were legendary for their lavish ways and they have never been particularly shy in sharing the details. This quote from Flair is just one of countless examples of The Four Horsemen living the life they so-often claimed to enjoy;

"We had our own private jet. We were on the Great American Bash tour in 1985. We worked in Frisco, Seattle, Portland, L.A, Albuquerque, and Vegas. We stayed at the Tropicana for a five-day run. I got drunk and spent $40,000 on two fur coats. I still got one at home. Never worn it. We flew back to the hotel at midnight and partied until 8:00 am, worked out, and then laid in the sun all day. We did not go to bed for five days. It was phenomenal."

Limousine-ridin', jet-flyin', kiss-stealing, wheeling and dealing, indeed.

Advertisement