10 Things You Learn As A WWE Creative Writer

What really goes on behind the curtain?

By George Rutherford /

Even in the post-Kayfabe, "Total Divas" era, much of what happens behind the scenes at World Wrestling Entertainment is still very much a mystery to the general populous. It's important for super fans to know that the "reality" of what we see is still very much controlled by the powers-that-be in Titan Tower. In 2007, a combination of tenacity, good timing and dumb luck landed this contributing author a job of which most could only dream. I had the nerve wracking pleasure of being interviewed (four times) and ultimately hired by Vince McMahon to be a creative writer for the SmackDown brand of the WWE. 

Advertisement

For those who are unfamiliar, the creative team at WWE is completely integrated into the production of television and pay-per-view events. We were on the road 300 days of the year, right alongside the talent. We are in the arenas, the planes and the hotels. We see the good, the bad and the sometimes very ugly. While the average tenure as a creative team member isn't typically very long (Mine certainly wasn't), there is a lot to be learned about the inner workings of one of the craziest businesses in the world.

Be advised: This isn't a "dirt sheet" about "Who hated who" or "Who was using performance enhancing substances". Those are out there if that's your thing. This is a list of what I think are interesting facts that you pick up in a day in the life of a proverbial fly on WWE's grandiose wall.


10. It's Scripted...But Not As Much As You Think.

Everyone over the age of 10 knows that, in professional wrestling, the match results are pre-determined. Contrary to popular belief, the writers don't actually write the matches. That is done by "producers" or "road agents". They work with the talent to create the best match possible based on the story lines developed by the creative team.

Advertisement

The best laid plans, however, often fall to ruin. Whether it's an unexpected injury, a delayed flight, personal issues or just good old backstage politics, the scripted plan would sometimes have to be changed at the zero hour! In one instance, due to a travel conflict, we had to completely change a match, rewrite the script, distribute it, get the talent together with a producer, and come up with a full match less than 90 minutes before going on live TV. What makes the guys in the ring professional is that they were able to pull it off as though it were the plan all along. 

Obviously not every match is a classic, but sometimes the wrestlers are asked to overcome some pretty serious hindrances and make it look natural like Butch Reed. It's for this reason that many lower and mid-card talent travel with the TV crew, even if they aren't scheduled to appear. You never know when you will get called in to take over a main event.

9. Vince Was Very Particular About His Snacks.

Before any TV or pay-per-view event, Vince and certain members of the production team would meet early in the day to have what is called a "Production Meeting". These meetings covered everything from script changes and talent issues to where we could find worms for "The Boogeyman" to eat in the ring. While it was likely that twelve things would change by showtime, the production meeting was important in establishing a baseline for the day.

Advertisement

One of the well-known rules of WWE production meetings was that there was to always be a Detour protein bar and a Diet Dr. Pepper at Vince's seat for the meeting. Oftentimes it would be the responsibility of Writer Assistants to procure these items and be sure they were in place before Vince's arrival. He didn't go crazy about it. The bar didn't have to be a specific flavor and the Diet Dr. Pepper didn't have to be exactly 47.2 degrees or anything. That's just what he liked to snack on.

Mr. McMahon is definitely one of those people who becomes so busy that he forgets to eat. When this happened, there would always be a spare Detour bar and Diet Dr. Pepper laying around that needed to be discarded after the meeting. Needless to say, I ended up consuming a few Detours and Peppers during that time.

8. Mark Henry Has A Great Sense Of Humor.

Once, before a TV taping, I was ringside watching match rehearsals. I was reviewing the script and observing how the guys in the ring were executing the plan for TV that night. My focus was snapped as I felt a giant man-paw clap onto my shoulder. When I turned my head, I was staring into the very intense face of “The World’s Strongest Man”, Mark Henry.

Advertisement

Mark gripped my shoulder and leaned in closer. Still not breaking eye contact, he growled:

“Who are you?”

“Um, hi Mark. I’m George. I’m the new writer for SmackDown”.

Leaning in even closer, he whispered:

“Do you like men, George?”

At this point, my brain flipped through every possible response to this question. For some inexplicable reason, my better sense settled on:

“Um, not in the romantic sense Mark”.

Letting out a long exhale, he replied:

“Oh, you will…”

Allowing a terribly awkward beat, he stood up, his face then pulling back into a perfectly pleasant smile as he said:

“Aw man, I’m just f*ck*in’ with you. Welcome to the show!”

In every encounter after that, Mark was awesome to talk with and had a great sense of humor. What else do you expect from the guy who convincingly pulled off the “Sexual Chocolate” persona?

7. John Cena Is A True Babyface.

One doesn’t have to look far to find an example of John Cena using his powers for good. Whether it’s a Make-A-Wish visit or a simple autograph signing, Cena has truly established himself as a face of the WWE.

Advertisement

If your skeptical side leads you to believe that it’s all just good PR for the company, I have a little slice of life story that suggest otherwise.

Being a native Pennsylvanian, I was thrilled when my father and sister were able to attend a show in State College. Backstage, they were taking in the controlled chaos that was life in the WWE. My sister timidly asked if she would be able to meet John Cena.

Now, nobody is busier behind the scenes than Cena. There is a large premium put upon his time. I managed to find him backstage (in an interview, naturally). As soon as there was a break, I asked him if he could take a second to meet my family. He immediately stopped what he was doing and followed me to them.

John spent several minutes chatting with my dad and sister. He didn’t come off as rushed or inconvenienced. He stayed longer than he needed to and made them feel like the most important people in the arena.

From what I saw, the guy was always a true babyface.

6. You Get Pitched A Ton Of Bad Ideas.

As a creative team member, it’s common for your phone to ring with pitches from wrestlers who either aren’t on the main roster or who are unhappy with their current character. In the interest of self-preservation, lower and mid-card talent will pitch a ton of ideas to the creative team in hopes of becoming the next breakout superstar. Some of these ideas are pretty good and can be developed into characters. Others, not so much.

Advertisement

Sometimes, ideas were pitched about storylines or specific match ideas. They weren’t all winners.

Keep in mind, ideas that made the cut at this time included Paul Birchall being both a pirate and ambiguously incestuous, Eugene being developmentally disabled and the somewhat racist “Cryme Tyme” gimmick.

That being said, imagine the pitched ideas that never made it further than a phone call. Here’s a couple:

Domino (Of the “Deuce and Domino” tag team) as a street-wise gangster rapper persona with a skinny white guy manager. From “Happy Days” to “Boyz n The Hood”? Nah.

Some may have read about this in interviews, but I remember when the idea was first floated of calling Mark Henry “The Silverback”. I recall shrinking in my chair at that one.

I did support Melina’s movie star gimmick though, because I got to be one of the paparazzi who followed her to the ring… Amazing.

5. Nobody Messes With The Undertaker.

889965

Behind the scenes, different Superstars have various levels of sway. “Curtain Jerkers” and mid-card talent were mostly at the mercy of the creative team when it came to character and storyline development. Main eventers were obviously given more consideration. Guys like Triple H and Shawn Michaels even participated in the production meetings. That being said, nobody on the roster had more political clout than the Deadman.

Advertisement

When Undertaker was involved in a storyline, we would be sure to call and consult with him before any decisions were made. Not because he demanded it, but because he just earned that level of credibility.

It wasn’t just with the creative team that Undertaker’s word was law. He served, and likely still serves, as an unofficial judge and jury when it came to backstage drama between talent. ‘Taker would hear all sides of an argument, and hand down his decision (which was always ultimately about the greater good, and everyone knew it).

By all accounts, Undertaker is a fair and just field General who never abuses his position. He keeps the peace and expects a certain level of respect and professionalism from everyone around him. While Vince is always the true final word, Undertaker is the man in the locker room.

4. There Is An Awesome "Merch Vault" In Titan Tower.

In WWE’s “Titan Tower” headquarters in Stamford, CT, there is a room. Available to employees only, this ordinary-looking office space is, in fact, an awesome merch vault. During my first week on the job, an HR guy took me for a tour of the building. There was a fantastic gym, a top-notch cafeteria and classic memorabilia (Like Andre the Giant’s boot) on display on every floor.

Advertisement

The gem of this tour, undoubtedly, was the merch vault. Rows and rows of every type of WWE merchandise one can imagine. DVDs, posters, championship belts, shirt, action figures and giant foam hands lined the walls and shelves. For a child of the ‘80s, I was thrilled to see how much classic merch was there. The vintage rubber action figures, trading cards and old championship belt replicas took me right back to being seven years old.

Like a kid in a candy store, I was given the opportunity to search the piles of treasure for anything I wanted to take with me. Fighting my initial instinct to stuff my pockets and run out with my arms loaded, I chose a few choice DVD sets, made a mental picture of the room, and exited with my professionalism intact.

3. JBL Isn't Easily Impressed.

To say the least, JBL has presence. When he walks into a room, or building, everyone knows it. He is a large man with a booming voice. He also has no qualms about letting people know what he thinks. This includes letting new writers know what he thinks of their chances for success in the company.

Advertisement

When new creative members, as I was, met JBL for the first time, there was apparently a customary ritual involved. When I introduced myself to Mr. Layfield and shook his hand, he immediately gave me the name “D*ckh**d #16” and took a picture of me with his phone. This name and picture were then put into his phone along with the names and pictures of D*ckh**ds number one through fifteen.

Once I was officially part of the menagerie, JBL informed me (and everyone) that the over/under on me lasting in the company was two weeks. I’m not sure if any real money was placed on these bets, or if it was just amusing to him, but at that moment it became my goal in life to last at least fifteen days.

Determined to show JBL that I had the grit to make it in the dog-eat-dog world of Sports Entertainment, I tracked him down after the two week mark and informed him that I had beaten his two-week prediction. JBL waited about half a beat, said “Good job D*ckh**d 16” and went on about his day.

2. There's A Reason SmackDown Isn't Live.

In 2007, RAW was shot live on Monday nights. It was the flagship show and, for the most part, touted the top talent in the company. SmackDown’s top talent consisted of more kid-friendly gimmicks and veterans who were being utilized to develop lower level wrestlers.

Advertisement

SmackDown was taped on Tuesdays, edited, and aired on Fridays. From what I observed, it was a good call to not have SmackDown go directly to the viewing audience. For one, some of the more high-flying talent were on the SmackDown roster. Even top guys like Rey Mysterio didn’t always look as smooth live as he did on edited TV. For this reason, many of these matches were “cleaned up” in post-production to make the televised product look as polished as possible.

Once, there was a match so…let’s say unpolished, that it was just eliminated from the show. It was Chavo Guerrero vs. Jimmy Wang Yang. Both very talented, high risk performers. For whatever reason, the choreography just wasn’t working that night. The crowd were quickly turning on them, and I was fortunate enough to be out on the floor to see the match. As I watched the bout, I tried to figure out how the editors were going to string together a tight show out of this display. As it came to be, they couldn’t figure it out either and cut it completely.

1. Dusty Rhodes Deserves His Legendary Status.

During my tenure, Dusty Rhodes was the head writer of ECW. This gave me the chance to sit with him in the writer’s room and pick his brain about all things wrestling. His decades of insight into programming, story building, and the art of “putting butts in seats” was invaluable to someone as green as me. In the creative process, I never once saw Dusty push his own agenda or insert himself into the spotlight for no reason. He was, however, always willing to jump in and do what was needed for the good of the show.

Advertisement

One day, I had the rare occasion to enjoy a lengthy one-on-one discussion with Dusty. When I asked him about the difference between the business now (now meaning 2007) and the old days, Dusty looked me in the eye and told me:

“Let me tell ya somethin’ young fella’. The difference is that ever since Vincent Mac-Mahon went on television and had to tell the world that wrasslin’ was scripted…there was no goin’ back afta’ that!”

Essentially, Dusty explained that matches couldn’t have long, low periods like they did pre-attitude era. They needed more excitement, but we still had to protect the talent from too much danger and focus on better storylines to build drama.

Always one to put the team first and take care of everyone, “The American Dream” was a real class act.

Advertisement