10 Times WWE Royal Rumble Opened The Forbidden Door
From special guests to surprise substitutes - the rare times WWE dared to let the outsiders in.
AJ Styles' dramatic debut at the 2016 Royal Rumble sent shockwaves throughout the wrestling industry while simultaneously paying off something WWE themselves had teased just weeks earlier.
The company giddily teased the arrival of 'The Phenomenal One', Luke Gallows, Karl Anderson and Shinsuke Nakamura on January 5th 2016, just 24 hours removed from all four working NJPW's Wrestle Kingdom 10 at the Tokyo Dome. They were as good as signed, so Styles subsequently wasn't swaggering through the as-yet-unnamed Forbidden Door. But it certainly felt that way. And not even just from New Japan exclusively - AJ was considered a modern day version of Sting in that he'd worked for just about every promoter but Vince McMahon, and him arriving without an infamous name or gimmick change was yet another bizarre twist that foreshadowed a brave new world that ultimately never came to pass.
A two minute singles sequence with then-WWE Champion Roman Reigns was the icing on the cake. The organisation had somehow managed to manifest a good glimpse of a dream match without delivering the official version - this was reality booking while keeping the fantasy alive.
It was cool, it was different, and it was extremely un-WWE save for these equally strange rule-proving exceptions...
10. Mickie James (2022)
Standing aloft as one of the lone highlights of the entire Premium Live Event let alone actual Royal Rumble match, Mickie James' 11:40 stint in the 2022 Battle Royal was a slice of strange and unique company history.
Historically, WWE plays appallingly with others, and though the entries on this list will all serve as rule-proving exceptions, none shine as bright a light on some business opposition as Vince McMahon did here.
Former WWE Champion James was, by this point, the Impact Wrestling Knockouts Champion, and the company presented her as that entirely. Her self-penned "Hardcore Country" theme blared throughout The Dome At America's Center to one of the only pops of the entire show, and James wore her current gimmick as proudly as the heart permanently placed on her sleeve.
Eliminated by Lita but scalping longstanding rival Michelle McCool along the way, her bookending moments featuring women she'd wrestled during her original and fondly-remembered WWE run spoke volumes of how much thought had gone into her cameo.
9. Genichiro Tenryu & The Great Kabuki (1994)
Longstanding WWE fans had been introduced to Genichiro Tenryu as early as WrestleMania VII thanks to the company's working relationship with Japan's SWS (Super World of Sports) and yet another guest spot in the Royal Rumble in 1993.
But 1994's appearance alongside The Great Kabuki was an altogether different beast.
Storyline allies of Mr Fuji, Tenryu and Kabuki were drafted in for one night only as violent problem solvers for Yokozuna. The pair joined the gaggle of regular roster heels in destroying The Undertaker during his Casket Match with the WWE Champion, and were later spotted battering Lex Luger backstage to try and hamper his chances of winning the Rumble itself. As insurance policies, they were also entered in the match as well, but neither plan worked out all that well.
Luger tossed out both men, and in Tenryu's case used the help of co-winner Bret Hart to get it done. The duo were one and done in WWE, immediately returning to their regular roles in NJPW having failed as Fuji's henchmen.
8. Hiroki Sumi (Greatest Royal Rumble)
Arguably the strangest moment from an incredibly strange night, Hiroki Sumi's cameo in 2021's one-off Greatest Royal Rumble was totally in keeping with the grim tone of WWE's first Vision 2030 show in Saudi Arabia.
Everything had to be the biggest and best per the whims of the paymasters. The headlining battle royal had to be nearly double the size of the annual January tradition and burst at the seams with monsters, giants and anybody from bygone eras those pulling the strings within the Saudi Arabian Sports Authority particularly liked.
Up, then, stepped Hiroki Sumi.
No, you're not supposed to know that name from his Cagematch profile or a long-forgotten WrestleMania classic. Sumi booked his place in WWE and Royal Rumble infamy for who he wasn't rather than who he was. Per Dave Meltzer's reporting, Crown Prince Mohammed Bin Salman wanted The Undertaker, Ultimate Warrior and Yokozuna. The latter two being dead naturally created an issue, which WWE elected to partially address with Sumi's otherwise-inexplicable 46 seconds in the match.
7. Doug Gilbert (1996)
Doug Gilbert doesn’t do all that much in the 1996 Royal Rumble beyond being one of several warm bodies for newcomer Vader to absolutely pulverise, and while there’s no shame in that, something of a pattern emerges when you revisit the build-up and execution of that year’s battle royal.
Gilbert was airlifted in from USWA, AJPW’s Takao Omari was one of the strangest one-shot deals in company history (more on him shortly), Dory Funk Jr flew in between his own All Japan tours (more on him too!) golden era stalwart Jake ‘The Snake’ Roberts made the most unlikely of returns, and Vader’s arrival from an on-fire WCW itself felt like a rare case of WWE taking something wholesale rather than cynically reimagining it for toy sales.
And on that - McMahon was deep in negotiations with The Ultimate Warrior at this point. He really wanted the bananas former WWE Champion for this one, even though the end result of a WrestleMania return fit the booking much better.
For all Gilbert was unremarkable in the contest, he fit the unpredictability and uncertainty of the era well. And that’s the other thing - the 1996 Royal Rumble wasn’t some unique experiment from a Vince McMahon in artisanal and idiosyncratic form. WWE was worryingly broke, increasingly desperate, and genuinely under threat as the United States’ number one wrestling promotion for the first time since McMahon’s aggressive national expansion over a decade earlier.
To that end…
6. Takao Omori (1996)
Takao Omori gets the first part of being a WWE Superstar right at least. “Big smiles out there, pal!” was presumably the well-trodden instruction from Vince McMahon to the man he referred to as "a wild man from Japan", and Omori bursts through those entrance doors like Zack Ryder hitting a Toys R Us Christmas sale.
But how and why was he there at all?
Reports were that Omori himself wanted to spread his wings on the other side of the Pacific, but his American adventure ended there for the time being. He did eventually work select dates in the US, including an NWA World Heavyweight Championship bout with Ken Shamrock on the fourth ever TNA show.
His Rumble appearance is sadly as unmemorable as you'd imagine - he goes just 2:48 before Jake Roberts and Triple H dump him out, and has no scalps to his name either. The brevity is almost in fitting contrast to his illustrious All Japan career - his CV boasts approximately 3000 matches over four decades.
And speaking of decorated All Japan runs...
5. Dory Funk Jr (1996)
Dory Funk Jr debuted in 1963, meaning he was 33 years deep into a fabled career when he made his one and only appearance in a Royal Rumble in 1996.
For multiple reasons - some more obvious than others - he was an imperfect fit.
It wasn't that Funk was a touch long in the tooth compared to a shallow roster full of mostly younger wrestlers, nor that in WWE canon he only really had a short spell as "Hoss" Funk a full decade earlier to lean on. It was simply that the match itself didn't exactly offer him the opportunity to prove exactly why he warranted a spot in the first place.
Funk was 55-and-looking-it in the match, but his age alone doesn't tell the whole story of where he was at in his career either side of the bout. Funk worked hundreds of matches for All Japan Pro Wrestling between 1986 and 1996, and went on to work hundreds more all over the world ahead of his (as-of-writing) last outing in 2018. To paraphrase another WWE Hall Of Famer, he had a lot left in the tank.
10 minutes with zero eliminations and mostly corner kicks and punches didn't really give him much chance to prove it.
4. Carlos Colon (1993)
Gorilla Monsoon remarking "a lot of fire in this youngster" as the 44-year-old Carlos Colon made his way into the 1993 Royal Rumble was a far funnier story when the company wasn't overflowing with wrestlers older than that only just hitting their creative prime and competitive peak.
The audio/visual mix is at completely at odds too. Legendary WWC wrestler and promoter Colon had been at it since the 1960s and wore the literal bumps, bruises and scars of the industry with every weathered step he took. Monsoon's crack at his former business partner's advancing years was funnier for the fact that wrestlers ageing out of the trade simply didn't look like Sheamus, AJ Styles, CM Punk and others that have lived extremely different lives to those that came before them.
The line stands as the only memorable moment for Carlito's Dad in the match itself. He got seven minutes to strut his stuff and eliminated Damien Demento - himself a man more remembered for looking on from the outside as Giant Gonzalez destroyed The Undertaker rather than anything actually did inside the squared circle.
3. Dick Murdoch (1995)
There are a number of reasons why every door back into mainstream pro wrestling should have been forbidden for Dick Murdoch by 1995.
Known throughout the industry as one of the more openly racist and hate-filled men to ever enter the sport - more than one story exists of Murdoch being a Ku Klux Klan member - the big man’s bigotry was more than enough of a reason to keep him gone from screens years and years removed from his competitive and commercial peak.
Alas, wrestling is wrestling and he was brother brothered in for the night away from full time duties in NWA Dallas and extended tours for IWA and WAR in Japan.
Murdoch’s Rumble run went just 5:08 before he was dumped by Henry Godwinn. This interaction with a New Generation stalwart wasn’t an isolated incident either - he seconded Bob Backlund in TV spots against Razor Ramon, though nothing more permanent came from his Stamford sojourn.
2. Mil Máscaras, Pierroth, Cibernético, Latin Lover (1997)
The 1997 WWE Royal Rumble was a study in contrasts for a company in a state of flux.
The location itself was part of the paradox - the Alamo Dome in San Antonio, Texas drew 60,000+ to the show during a downtime, though so much of the building was papered even with hometown hero Shawn Michaels winning the WWE Championship in the main event.
Beyond 'HBK', the company were relying on a working relationship with AAA to spice up the undercard and Royal Rumble itself and results were...mixed.
Canek, Héctor Garza and Perro Aguayo defeating Fuerza Guerrera, Heavy Metal and Jerry Estrada in a botchy and boring six-man tag cursed the working relationship before the Rumble bell rang. When it did, Triple A regulars Pierroth, Cibernético and Latin Lover drew neither boos nor cheers and simply went in there to eventually be thrown back.
Mil Máscaras was a different prospect entirely, but unfortunately he knew that himself. The lucha icon earned a warm reception from the crowd thanks to a legacy as one of the greatest in the genre's history, but simply refused to be eliminated by any of the WWE wrestlers he deemed beneath him. To this end, the hero was booked like a pillock, hurling himself from the top rope to the floor as the announcers questioned if he'd bothered to learn the rules.
1. Haku (2001)
The highly-rated and fondly-remembered 2001 Royal Rumble was arguably an even bigger flex of WWE's global dominance than the iconic WrestleMania X-Seven that followed just months later.
Coming just days after the purchase of WCW and being used as the platform to conclude Steve Austin's iconic and industry-altering babyface run, the Dallas 'Show Of Shows' remains something of an inadvertent farewell to the Attitude Era. Meanwhile, with the opposition still technically in operation and WWE business showing no sign of slowdown, the Royal Rumble stands as a celebration of it.
Never was this more apparent than when Haku very randomly returned to WWE after nine years away. The comeback itself wasn't particularly newsworthy but the nature of it was - the former Meng was WCW Hardcore Champion as he entered the match. Working on a per-date deal in an Atlanta outfit just months away from being gone forever, Tonga Fifita was free to go where he pleased and did just that despite still holding gold.
Just over five years removed from Alundra Blayze going the other way, this was tellingly unceremonious by comparison. No belts went in bins, no burials were bothered with. A war that once raged between two sides had already been well and truly won.