10 Times WWE Ruined Their Own Ideas IMMEDIATELY
Tables, ladders and...DISAPPOINTMENT.
They just can't help it.
One minute, WWE have an idea in mind that's so good they'd be forgiven for trading high-fives around the table during creative meetings. The next, such merriment has turned to knowing glances between the staff as they ponder how to rescue something they've just sh*t all over with stupid decision making and one wrong turn. Sometimes, that's all it takes to spoil something.
The unique pressures that come with being part of such a fast-paced world must explain some of this. WWE's minds have to come up with so many ideas every single week that even they probably couldn't tell you exactly what they first had in mind. That pressure does funny things to the creative system, and it can cause previously-fine ideas and pitches to turn sour almost overnight.
Signature matches for individual wrestlers? Ruined. Hot storylines that could carry the company's output for a good six months at least? Quickly trod on so that week's Raw had purpose. Bold new directions for once-proud match types that grow into their own thing? Totally spoiled by overkill.
No, they just can't help it...
10. ECW's TV Revival
Idea: WWE's decision to resurrect the ECW brand for two stunning One Night Stand shows in 2005 and 2006 was lucrative. Seeing yet more dollars, the company decided to bring E-C-Dub back for good as a standalone third brand TV show to complement Raw and SmackDown in '06.
How It Was Ruined: WWE didn't book the original ECW, Paul Heyman did. His mad scientist approach hid weaknesses aplenty and turned shows like Hardcore TV into a smorgasbord of pop culture, teen angst, testosterone and weapons-filled brawls.
WWE's ECW had goofy gimps like The Zombie and exactly none of the underground culture feel of Heyman's old promotion. In one night, the majestic vibrance of Extreme became more like some crummy indy than WWE would care to admit.
ECW on Sci-Fi (now SYFY) was less Hardcore TV and more Sunday Night Heat from the off.
9. WCW's Invasion
Idea: Once they'd purchased the fragments of their old competition, the WWF decided to finally pull the trigger on an 'Us vs. Them' rivalry for the ages. WCW stars would invade and set up endless amounts of box office success on pay-per-view. At the very least, they'd get one big Invasion show out of it.
How It Was Ruined: Vince McMahon couldn't sign all the star names fans closely identified with the WCW brand, and that ended up costing the Invasion big time. Rather than seei names such as the nWo, Goldberg, Sting and Diamond Dallas Page hit Raw and SmackDown, people watched as the likes of Lance Storm and Hugh Morrus invaded instead.
It was a flop from the start.
Storm and Morrus were talented workers, but they weren't main event players in WCW. By booking them as the first invaders to cross-promote his supposed war, McMahon shot himself in the foot and diluted the credibility of WCW's threat.
8. 2019's Draft
Idea: WWE moved SmackDown to FOX on 4 October 2019, then held the latest full-blown Draft on the 11 October episode and on the 14 October Raw. It was going to be an exciting inter-channel battle between FOX and USA Network execs for control of the best superstars available.
How It Was Ruined: It was boring, flatter than the recipient of a Vader Bomb and trundled along to the delight of almost nobody.
Skits that showed bogus FOX and USA executives reacting from respective "War Rooms" were crap, and Stephanie McMahon's dull delivery when announcing each pick only made things worse. Hilariously, WWE also gave the game away by listing each pick in order on their website beforehand.
That meant Steph was reading out something fans already knew, and it made organic surprise impossible. As if that wasn't enough, Brock Lesnar (who was touted as a major coup for the show) quit SmackDown on 1 November and jumped to Raw.
7. Vince McMahon's Wild Card Rule
Idea: Before reaching 2019's Draft, WWE head Vince McMahon decided to spruce his roster up by creating a "Wild Card Rule". It'd allow some creative leeway when it came to major stars cross-pollinating on brands they didn't belong to. Armed with his usual gusto, Vince announced that three wrestlers would be allowed to hop between brands each time.
How It Was Ruined: WWE couldn't stick to their own rules.
Soon after McMahon's claim that only three could jump, others began ignoring his pledge by showing up willy nilly as often as they liked. Before long, as many as six or seven wrestlers from rival brands were appearing without attempted explanation from the announcers or punishment from Vince for doing so.
The fact this happened the week after McMahon's big declaration shows how little thought was put into these Wild Cards; when the promotion itself has to upload a detailed description that tries to make sense of things, you know there's a problem.
6. The Punjabi Prison
Idea: The Undertaker has his Casket Match (possibly also Hell In A Cell and Buried Alive), Mankind had his Boiler Room Brawl, Ken Shamrock had the Lion's Den and even Henry O. Godwinn had that Hog Pen abomination. So, maybe it was a given that WWE would gift The Great Khali his own match by way of the Punjabi Prison.
How It Was Ruined: Right before he was set to tangle with 'Taker at Great American Bash 2006, Khali was struck down by injury and couldn't make the pay-per-view. That left WWE in a bit of a hole, but they decided to press on and replace one giant with another.
Big Show got the nod.
It doesn't take a genius to work out why this sucked. Khali, the guy that bamboo cage was created for, was nowhere to be found. Instead, Show and The Undertaker worked for 21 looooooong minutes. Their match, the awkwardness of the structure and Khali's cancellation killed the gimmick immediately.
5. Giving Bobby Lashley Some Personality
Idea: Impressive physical specimen though he is, Bobby Lashley has always lacked a bit of personality. In 2018, WWE thought they'd remedy that by penning a fanciful backstory that mixed humour with a splash of John Cena's 'Never Give Up' flavour. Surely that'd help people identify with big Bob?
How It Was Ruined: The combination of WWE's horrendous writing (Saturday Night Live this wasn't), Lashley's uncomfortable performances and fan apathy created a contender for worst storyline of the year.
Renee Young's awkward sit-down interview with Lashley was a strange enough start, and things spiralled out of control when Sami Zayn introduced three dudes dressed up as "Bobby's sisters". Jessica, Cathy and Frances were tanking hard enough before Lashley wandered out to put a stop to things and tried to crack some jokes.
The silence coming from the stands was deafening, and it was obvious to everyone but WWE that any attempt to give Bob that much-needed personality was going to fail. He needed someone to talk for him, not some subpar Mad TV bullsh*t.
4. Royal Rumble's WrestleMania Importance
Idea: By 1993, Vince McMahon was seeking another way to shake up the Royal Rumble match and give fans a reason to care. '93's version needed something unique after Ric Flair's WWF Title heroics the prior year, and Vince had just the ticket. The Rumble winner, it was decreed, would bag himself a guaranteed slot in the main event of WrestleMania.
How It Was Ruined: Yes, Yokozuna did win the Rumble and work 'Mania IX's main event against WWF Champ Bret Hart. Yes, he did win the belt from Bret and look like a dominating monster in the process. No, Rumble winner Yoko didn't end the night as champion in Las Vegas.
Hulk Hogan did.
You'd have to go some to find a bigger Hogan mark than this writer (especially in the early-'90s), but he shouldn't have won at IX. A second title change in just a few minutes at 'Mania completely rubbished Yokozuna's herculean efforts at the Rumble and made a mockery of how important that win was.
3. Hell In A Cell
Idea: The first ever Hell In A Cell spectacle would see The Undertaker battle Shawn Michaels inside the new cage and give the WWF a new star to go along with it. Kane, 'Taker's kayfabe brother, would debut and spin off into a feud between supernatural siblings that could carry on into WrestleMania XIV.
How It Was Ruined: First and foremost, it's important to point out that The Undertaker vs. Shawn was great, and Kane's debut is one of the most memorable in WWE history. However, did the new masked menace really need to take a big chargrilled dump all over the gimmick by ripping HIAC's door clean off?
Fans were told repeatedly in the build up to 'Taker vs. Michaels that the cage would keep everybody out and lock only those two men in. The arrival of Kane changed that, and the booking made that brand new structure look like it was made of paper rather than cold, unforgiving steel.
A small gripe, maybe, but it's nonetheless true that Kane (memorable introduction or not) ruined the original purpose and selling point of HIAC.
2. TLC As A Pay-Per-View
Idea: A shade over nine years after the first TLC corker at SummerSlam 2000, WWE decided to turn the gimmick into a standalone pay-per-view in 2009. Fans, it was reasoned, would delight at the thought of multiple variants of the core idea, and that included spinoffs of the established multi-weapon formula.
How It Was Ruined: A Chairs Match? Seriously.
DX vs. Jeri-Show had the main TLC gimmick, Christian vs. Shelton Benjamin worked the Ladder one and Sheamus met John Cena in a WWE Title Tables Match. That left The Undertaker and Batista to make do with the lamest offshoot the writing team could think of. They had... chairs to fight with.
Hearing the announcers try to hype this as significant was almost sad, and both guys struggled to add any excitement to a weapon that was used on weekly TV anyway. Immediately, people started to realise that TLC might become a throwaway show rather than must-see.
Watch 2019's version for proof they were right.
1. CM Punk's WWE Title Walkout
Idea: At Money In The Bank 2011, CM Punk beat John Cena to become new WWE Champion and then blew a cheeky kiss towards Vince McMahon as he left through the crowd. Punk, ever the rebel, was going to depart WWE with the top prize, and there was nothing Vince or anyone else could do about it.
How It Was Ruined: Except crown a new WWE Champ and act like Punk's departure was irrelevant.
One sodding week after the most newsworthy title change in recent history, WWE booked a mini-tournament to crown Rey Mysterio as WWE Champion. Then, on the exact same night, Cena beat Rey to win the belt and claim he was the real champ, not Punk. This was every bit as messy and unnecessary as it sounds.
Punk's rebellion against WWE's corporate machine was nullified like it had never happened at all, and it's hard to see why anybody thought this was a good idea. If the company could just create a new title, call it the old one and move on with the snap of some fingers, then why were fans expected to give a damn about MITB?
As Randy Orton might say, that was "Stupid".
-
When else has WWE ruined their own ideas immediately? For more, check out 7 WWE Stars Who Can Never Be Babyface Again and 10 Things WWE Fans Need To Know About The XFL!