10 Times WWE Totally Wasted Potential

Emma the latest in a long line.

By David Cambridge /

It was announced this week that Emma would be departing WWE after six years on its books.

Advertisement

All of the comments that traditionally follow the news that a wrestler has been released were there: some said good riddance, others expressed dismay, and Lio Rush made an off-colour Twitter joke that led to a dressing down from half the WWE roster.

Mostly, however, people are agreed that she wasn't really given a fair crack of the whip by her former employers. They never looked upon her as anything more than what Triple H would - and perhaps did - refer to as a "B-plus player". If that.

Given that she was attempting to make her name in arguably the most stiffly competitive women's division WWE has ever had, perhaps there's an element of truth to that. We'll never know for sure, though, because she simply didn't get the chance.

If there's comfort to be derived, it's from the fact that she now joins a whole host of WWE wrestlers past who - despite their obvious talent - for some reason never quite managed to smash through wrestling's glass ceiling.

10. Juventud Guerrera

WWE must have had the opportunity to pick up Juventud after the collapse of rivals WCW in 2001 - but for some reason it took a further four years for him to make his way north.

Advertisement

That, unfortunately, was a sign of things to come - and when the Lucha Libre legend finally did get back in the big time he was only there a couple of years - most of which spent as one-third of a stable named the "Mexicools".

That's not a terrible spot to be in if you're a young upstart, but Juventud already had a decade of mainstream experience under his belt. He was one of the leading lights in Eric Bischoff's thriving cruiserweight division, and could have occupied a similar role in WWE.

And though he did win the belt a couple of times he always felt like an after-thought, forever being snubbed in favour of more compelling "characters" like Chavo Guerrero and Gregory Helms (who, if anything, probably should have been going for the US Title).

9. Gail Kim

Gail Kim's WWE career will chiefly be remembered for the fact she was hired after JR introduced Vince McMahon to Asian-themed adult sites, and perhaps that she handed in her notice by deliberately eliminating herself from a battle royal.

Advertisement

In eras past, the company may have been able to get away with this without criticism, but we have evidence that Kim's undoubted talent went to waste. The Canadian star proved time and time again during a stellar career with TNA that she was one of the leading female stars of her generation.

What makes this particularly maddening is that WWE brought her back to the fold for a second time on the basis of her excursions in TNA. As with R-Truth and Bobby Roode, this was supposed to be their chance to right the wrongs of her disappointing first spell.

Alas, she just arrived a few years too early, never really given the opportunity to fight any meaningful matches as the likes of Kelly Kelly, Eve Torres, and Michelle McCool dominated the then-"Divas" division on Raw.

8. John Morrison

A combination of movie star good looks and some of the most innovative ring work WWE has ever seen looked at one point like it would be enough to take John Morrison to wrestling's peak.

Advertisement

Ultimately however, his career in the American mainstream is the familiar one of a deftly talented worker who - for whatever reason - was never quite considered a main event player.

And that is perhaps a little unfair given how many of his contemporaries - from Jack Swagger to Dolph Ziggler and Mark Henry - got their opportunity in the main event at one point or another around the time that he was entering his peak years.

As with many on this list, Morrison was harmed primarily by his perceived lack of ability on the microphone. This was true to some extent, but you only have to watch old clips from The Dirt Sheet to see he wasn't exactly Baron Corbin either.

7. Shelton Benjamin

It's the obvious answer, bound to be greeted by the charge that Shelton's mic skills ultimately just weren't good enough for a main event spot.

Advertisement

That's fair, but it ignores just how brilliant he was in the ring. From power moves to chain wrestling to high-flying, WWE's Gold Standard could do it all. He even had a nose for the truly spectacular, his daredevil spots being one of the highlights of the annual Money in the Bank match at WrestleMania.

Like Brock Lesnar, he probably could have used a mouthpiece. But where Brock Lesnar got one of wrestling's greatest ever talkers, Shelton settled instead for his momma, whose television debut was probably the exact moment that his world title aspirations died.

Now in his forties, it's perhaps too late for the former Team Angle member to realise all that untapped potential - but the fact that he's still on the WWE payroll speaks to what a terrific worker and consummate pro he's always been.

6. Ultimo Dragon

Ultimo Dragon is wrestling royalty in Japan, but his career Stateside - in the WWE at least - never quite managed to take off.

Advertisement

You can perhaps put this down to the fact that he was too similar to Rey Mysterio in terms of both look - both of them wearing masks - and style inside the ring. The Ultimate Underdog had already filled the role of Vince McMahon's favourite high-flyer, leaving Dragon to play second-fiddle, alongside Billy Kidman and Tajiri.

In sidelining him, WWE sent out a clear signal that it had no real interest in recapturing the magic of the WCW cruiserweight division. Instead of a dream WrestleMania XX singles match between Dragon and Mysterio, we got a multi-man invitational, won by the less adventurous Chavo Guerrero.

Ironically, the Japanese star is exactly the kind of figure the ailing 205 Live ranks desperately needs if it is to be rescued from its current slump - and, honestly, he could probably still fill that role at the age of 50.

5. Emma

With most people reveling in the fallout of Lio Rush's Twitter storm, no-one really noticed that Emma greeted news of her release with a single heartbreak emoji.

Advertisement

The 28-year-old was perhaps mourning not only the fact that her WWE dream was over, but that it never really got started. The company just never had any solid plans for her that weren't doomed to failure due to problems not of her own making.

It's sad, especially given that we have evidence - albeit not much - that she really was a gifted wrestler, whose match with Asuka at TakeOver London was probably one of the best in NXT history.

Someone in the back, however, decided that her character was too vanilla to stand out on the main roster. The Emmalina experiment that followed was among the more bizarre debacles in recent memory, and made this news somewhat inevitable.

4. Damien Sandow

Damien Sandow is fondly remembered by WWE fans, but there's no getting away from it: the history books will show that he was the first man to unsuccessfully cash in the Money in the Bank briefcase.

Advertisement

And a man with the breadth of talent boasted by Sandow surely deserves more than that. Seriously, this guy had all of the raw tools, among them ability in the ring, mic skills, and a natural flair for connecting with and drawing impassioned responses from the audience.

To no-one's great surprise, The Miz's former stunt double is now looking to branch out into acting. Wrestling, it seems, will never truly see the best of him, his career having failed to recover from defeat to John Cena in October 2013.

There's a lesson somewhere in all of that for Baron Corbin, who faced his own humiliating loss when he tried to cash in a Money in the Bank title shot back in August. Don't let your dreams be dreams, Lone Wolf.

3. Carlito

Carlito apparently had a rotten attitude backstage (he was a "bad apple", if you will) but so did Shawn Michaels and he still made it to the very top of the WWE pyramid.

Advertisement

True: the ex-United States Champion was no HBK, but take a look at some of the wrestlers headlining shows around the time of his peak and you can't help but feel he was unfortunate to have spent a career languishing in the mid-card.

What's really difficult to figure out is how Carlito was never really given any meaningful feuds, his career highlight perhaps coming in 2005 when he was paired up with a 50-something Ric Flair, with whom he shared arguably his best singles match.

Although he was talented, the WWE hierarchy clearly had reservations that were too difficult for him to overcome - evidenced in the end by the brutal way in which he was fed to a recently-returned Triple H at Unforgiven 2007.

2. Cody Rhodes

The man they now call Cody is currently having a whale of time performing on wrestling's independent circuit, but there's no getting away from the fact that he has unfinished business in the big time.

Advertisement

This is largely the consequence of the fact that they took too long dragging their heels over a potential main event push. He became synonymous with the mid-card as a result, with a slew of rookies getting their big break before he did, despite not spending nearly the same amount of time "paying their dues" at the bottom of the show.

You look at Cody's WWE career and - between tagging with Dustin Rhodes and playing Randy Orton's second-generation protege - the only thing that's missing was a run with the world title (or at the very least the chance to compete for one).

Still only 32, there's every possibility Cody could now "do a Drew McIntyre" and return reborn and reinvigorated, but as Gail Kim found out two runs can be equally fruitless unless someone is pulling for you backstage.

1. Neville

The 205 Live run Neville enjoyed this year produced some stellar matches, but you could never quite shake the feeling that it was beneath someone of his talent.

Advertisement

The Man That Gravity Forgot is genuinely one of the world's best workers, something the WWE Universe may never get to see now that he's (quite understandably) grown frustrated with his lowly place on the Monday Night Raw card.

The tragic thing in all of this is that, unlike Shelton Benjamin and co, Neville was beginning to cultivate a wrestling persona to match his ability between the ropes, making measurable improvements with his promos despite the popular perception that he wasn't a natural talker.

WWE wasted the opportunity to take him to the next level, however, by having him abruptly drop his Cruiserweight Championship to Enzo, in the process undoing all the ground work he had laid during the first half the year. Given all of that, you can't really blame him feeling his future may lie elsewhere.

Advertisement